r/AvoidantAttachment • u/sasha_michael • 17h ago
Seeking Support - Advice is OK✅ How to distinguish avoidance vs incompatibility?
I’m in my early forties and have a long history of ending relationships. A lot of my relationships have been on and off, including my longest relationships: two five-ish year relationships, the first of which included two break-ups and a short marriage, and the second of which included FIVE break-ups before one of them stuck. I can point to things that weren’t right in all of my past relationships, I guess, but I also recognize that I am the common denominator. I thought for a long time that I was just a serial monogamist, but I think I have to admit that I have intimacy issues. I’m also not really even a monogamist anymore as my past few relationships have been, at least in theory, polyamorous (tho honestly pretty functionally monogamous).
I have been dating someone for a little over a year. She is very nice to me and we have similar values and a similar sense of humor. We enjoy a lot of the same things. In theory this relationship should be great, and I definitely felt I was in love for the first six months or more. More recently I feel so guilty for not really feeling that way anymore. We haven’t had sex in months because I haven’t really been pursuing it. She’s a bit of a people-pleaser and has told me she’s stayed in past relationships longer than she should have, when they were no longer that great for her. I fear I am making our relationship into one of those, kinda. So I feel guilty for staying and also guilty for thinking of leaving. Because if this is just my own baggage I gotta figure out, maybe I’m throwing away something really good, and I’ll regret it for a long time, or worse, end up in another back-and-forth situation slowly destroying her love and regard for me over time, lol.
But, like, there are some things I can point to that might be incompatibilities. We don’t really connect on an intellectual level — not that she isn’t smart, but she just doesn’t like to talk about things critically the same way I do. I have friends I can connect with that way, though, and I don’t really know whether that’s something I need in a partner. We’re in very different career stages despite being of similar age, and our financial situations are pretty different, which has sometimes been challenging to navigate. And for several months I haven’t been very attracted to her, but again, it’s not like anything about her changed, so is that really just a me problem I need to figure out?
For a while my approach has been to push through, to try to be honest about things and at least talk to her about the things that feel less potentially hurtful to talk about (including my relationship history and difficulty with intimacy), and hope that eventually I will arrive at some place of feeling closer to her and in love again, if I can somehow hang out through whatever is going on now. I’m in therapy and all that. But what if we’re incompatible? What does that even mean, and how do I know?
I realized recently this is literally the first relationship I’ve been in where I’ve met someone and dated them for a solid year without breaking up. I was with my ex-spouse for stretches of longer than a year, but we did break up within the first year. So like it makes a certain amount of sense to me that some part of my subconscious sorta freaked out when we hit like 8-10 months or whatever, when I typically would have broken up with someone. And I don’t want to be like this forever. But again… how can I know whether this is the person to try to get through this with? Am I just going to make both of us miserable trying to fake it till I (we) make it?
Sorry for the length — I guess the TL;DR is “how do you tell if you want to leave a relationship because you’re a bad match or because you’re avoidant?”