I've been out of a four-year relationship with my diagnosed BPD ex for about nine months.
Yesterday I was cleaning out old notes on my phone and found one I'd completely forgotten about.
The title was "Compliments that are safe to give."
I wish I was joking.
It was basically a list of things I could say to my ex without accidentally starting an argument.
"Ask how she feels about her hair before saying anything positive."
"Don't say she looks happy. She might think you're suggesting she usually looks miserable."
"Don't compliment an outfit unless she specifically asks."
"Never say something was better than last time."
I sat there reading it and remembered exactly why I'd written it.
Early in our relationship, I used to compliment her constantly. I thought she was beautiful, loved her sense of humor, and was genuinely proud of things she accomplished.
But somewhere along the way, compliments became another thing I could get wrong.
I'd say she looked beautiful and she'd ask why I hadn't said anything about her appearance the day before.
I'd tell her I was proud of something she'd done and she'd say I was talking down to her.
Once I told her I loved seeing her excited about a new hobby. She got upset because apparently that meant I found her boring when she wasn't excited.
And I never knew which interpretation I was going to get.
Sometimes she'd smile and hug me. Other times the exact same kind of comment would turn into an hour of explaining what I really meant.
Eventually I started saying less.
Then she'd ask why I never complimented her anymore.
That's when I made the note.
I genuinely thought I could figure out the correct way to be affectionate if I just paid enough attention.
The part that really got me yesterday was remembering how much time I spent editing ordinary text messages.
I'd type something nice, reread it, remove a word that might sound wrong, replace another word, and sometimes just delete the whole thing.
I wasn't trying to manipulate her or say things I didn't mean.
I was trying to tell someone I loved her without having to defend the sentence afterward.
A few weeks ago a coworker showed me pictures of a painting she'd finished.
I thought it was really good.
And I caught myself mentally rehearsing how to say that without sounding patronizing or accidentally implying something negative about her earlier work.
Then I said, "That looks amazing."
She smiled and said, "Thanks!"
That was the entire interaction.
No questions about what I meant. No discussion about my tone. No need to explain why I'd chosen that particular adjective.
I remember feeling weirdly relieved, and at the time I couldn't quite understand why.
Finding that note yesterday made it click.
I used to be someone who said nice things to people without thinking twice. I didn't realize I'd started treating kindness like a statement that needed legal review.
I know this isn't a trait of everyone with BPD. I'm talking about what happened in my relationship.
But I wonder how many people here have found themselves doing something similar.
Not just walking on eggshells when things were bad, but becoming afraid of saying the wrong thing even when you were genuinely trying to be loving.
I deleted the note yesterday.
I wish deleting the habit was as easy.