r/Balkans • u/Delicious_Process815 • 2h ago
Culture/Lifestyle Opinion on balkan identity politics?
This is a response i made to one post, but that post was 15 days ago, and i would like to see what other people think about this:
"Now the whole idea of "balkan collective" only exists with some people on the internet, the wast majority of people within the balkan region (whatever you think its boundaries are) dont really have any strong affiliation toward the balkan region or identity, or even care about it. The balkan was at first a geographical term (and an incorrect one at that) and later became a way to describe a region in soutern europe where ottomans uses to have significant cultural and political influence (which is why the term is so confusing). I am not sure how much "balkan unity" ideas there were in past 100 years but they were never all that impactful, except for maybe yugoslavia, but that was about unifying only south slavs. Truth be told, in bosnia (where i come from) nobody really thinks about "the balkan" as a meanigful or useful concept (they might say "proud to be balkan" as a meme or for laugh though), and dont care about what is going in bulgaria, greece, romania etc. They might care what is happening in serbia and croatia, but thats because they are neighboring countries and they were in yugoslavia and also speak the same language. Actually, 10-15 years ago, people in ex yu thoigh of the balkan as only consisting of former yugoslavia and albania, because there was a cultural and political connection there. Now, about the first option (macedonians supporting n. macedonia), that doesnt happend because within countries/groups in many ex yu states (i am only taljing about them as thats the only context i can give) "greater collective" is a very complex topic. Now being a "serb", "croat", "bosniak" seems like a strong identity today (especially from an outside perspective) but in reality they are very abstract a superficial. These identities in recent history were rapidly adopted in 1980s when yugoslavia was collapsing and people did not feel safe. In a country/region like bosnia, rule has been aggressive and changed so much that people just dont have a tight affiliation and trust in the state. People first and foremost had (and still kind of have) primary affiliation with either their family, village, town, municipality, local region instead of a state or a region of states. So from their diaspora bosnians primarly finance their family and then maybe their town (but even that is rare)."