r/Barry • u/maximusasinus • 13h ago
I just finished binge watching Barry (first time viewing). Just wanted to vent. Spoiler
First off I want to say this was one of the most captivating shows I've ever watched, worthy of the praise it received, while also being undersold. I appreciate how the story unfolded, my expectations were constantly subverted. Also high praise for the actors who did an excellent job bringing their characters to life.
But it isn't all praise. I felt the show ended weak. They just couldn't stick the landing. I feel a lot of great television fall into this trap. It wasn't so bad that it will make the show unwatchable on repeat viewings thankfully.
I felt Fuchs was the least redeemable character in the entire show. He pulled connections to get Barry discharged from the marines to then groom him as a hitman-for-hire. And when Barry tried to leave his employ Fuches used psychological manipulation, coercion, and then eventually direct sabotage to drag him back in. -- and no this isn't a justification for the things Barry did, nor is it an argument for why he should have lived. On the surface Barry is deeply conflicted, but through the entire run of the show he is outed as a self-deluded, selfish, cowardly, manipulative, psychopath. He deserved to die, but in my eyes so did Fuchs. I felt that trading John for forgiveness and freedom was one of the few moments of weak writing.
I also disagreed with how they handled Cousineau. While Gene is a flawed, narcissistic, and often selfish person, framing him for murder is a massive injustice. He loved Janice. His flaws don't match the punishment. He is a deeply imperfect person whose ego gets him trapped, arguably making him one of Barry's most tragic collateral victims.
And to end on a positive note I want to just comment on the evolution of NoHo Hank through the series. Personally I felt it was the highest point for the series on the whole. He wasn't a static comic relief character throughout, the events of the series shaped him into a completely different person in the end (which given his experiences that was going to happen). That tiger scene was so dark (Carrigan acted out the desperation and hopelessness perfectly). I appreciate that it ended up hardening his character.