I'm a casual player and mostly just practice shooting in my own free time. For years, I never tracked what I actually do while shooting alone at the park. Just a general feeling "ah... I think my release was low", "maybe I didn't dip enough..." Didnt even count the make %. I know my form deteriorates as the session goes and stamina falling, but I couldn't tell what exactly is slipping away. I wanted an easy way to tell apart these "bad habits".
So I started building a small Apple Watch app for myself. You wear it on your shooting wrist, press Start and shoot. It finds every shot by itself, and you tap the screen after a make.
After each shot, the Watch shows how that shot compared with the previous shots or the average makes, not with a "correct" form:
- Angle: forearm's angle at the release
- Lean: how far the arm tilts sideways
- Legs: how much of the shot's upward push comes from my legs and body rather than my arm (the wrist's upward speed minus the arm's swing)
- Hold: how long the arm stays till after release
- And a surprising number of things that the watch can measure: dip distance, palm twist, travel path (gather-release), flick, if you shooting a pull-up or set shot, how still are you before the release, heart rate vs your makes, etc...
"How did I validate these metrics": Recorded about 2000+ shots from 5 players, with a phone and DJI camera at 120fps. Manually graded the moments of the shot sequence (lowest point of the gather, release, flick, ...) the makes, misses etc... Let AI analyze and match with the raw sensor data from the watch and build the scoring algorithm. To be honest, tuning the algo to work well at detecting both motion shots and set shots is quite difficult still.
"Why a Watch and not a camera app": I shoot at the park alone and sometimes just lazy to set things up for the cameras. Also privacy of other people can be a problem. Talking into a voice record on the watch about my own feedback and compare with the session analysis also shows some interesting insights. However, I do think combine both a footage and raw sensor data is still the best option. And of course, having a coach to help you!
"Does it count makes by itself": No. Shots are detected automatically. Tap anywhere on the screen to register a make. You can also ignore the makes/misses, focus on shooting and the phone app will still summarize the session at the end.
"How well does it find the shots": 34 of 34 in one session, 59 of 61 in another. Catching a pass, passing overhead, layups can sometimes be mistaken for a shot.
"Can it tell me why I missed": No (or not yet). What it can tell now is consistency and tendency. I compared my data to a D1 level player from Netherlands who tested the app and found that most of our makes and misses look almost the same. However some habits clearly show up: I hold my follow-through on only 15-55% of my shots. The D1 player held it on 54-91%. On curl drill, my numbers are shit (79% of the shots have two or more out of range numbers) vs his 16%. His dip is very consistent through out the session, mine is toward zero when legs are tired.
What the watch can't do:
- See the ball arc, spin, entry angle. Fingers are almost invisible, only the g-force by the flick is registered.
- Separate legs from core. "Legs" is everything that moves your elbow: legs, core and shoulder together. It also isn't jump height.
- Tell you what "good form" is. It only knows your own usual. If your usual has a flaw, it'll call that flaw "the same as last time." Fixing it is still a job for you or a coach.
If you are interested in trying this out, DM for the beta download. You will need at least an Apple Watch 8.