r/BehavioralEconomics • u/sndpedge • 15h ago
Ideas & Concepts Why do some leaders keep delaying decisions while calling it “evolving thought”?
I have noticed leaders reopening closed questions, asking for more data, or treating commitment as premature, all under the label of evolving thought. The stated reason is usually better quality. The result is often slower execution.
A useful comparison: biological evolution advanced from earlier primates to modern humans through imperfect steps. It didn’t wait for a finished version. Similarly, GPT-3.5 was released publicly in November 2022 well before AGI. Companies shipped something functional but incomplete, collected real use, and improved. Waiting for perfection would have delayed learning.
Research backs the pattern. Barry Staw’s work on escalation of commitment (1976, 1981) showed people can stick with earlier choices to justify past investments even when new evidence is weak. Barry Schwartz’s paradox-of-choice research (2004) found that more options and more information can increase anxiety and block decisions. Herbert Simon’s satisficing idea (1956) argued that with limited time and data, choosing something good enough is often more rational than chasing the optimal.
Most leadership programmes emphasise exploring options and challenging assumptions. Fewer emphasise knowing when to stop deliberating and commit. Decision Closure—mapping options, fixing a direction, and limiting further cycles unless material new information appears—seems like a missing piece. You can still adapt after you start; the adaptation just comes from actual results rather than endless discussion.
Has anyone else seen this pattern in their organisations?
#LeadershipDevelopment #DecisionMaking #HRStrategy #WorkplaceCulture