(Reproduced in full from CDN Guest Commentary 9/11/26)
By CHARLOTTE SATHER Guest Writer
Bellingham Public Schools recently hosted two listening sessions for feedback on the proposed school closures of Columbia and Carl Cozier elementaries. (I’m an employee of BPS but am not representing them in this piece.)
The two nights of public comment had different tones, and some common themes. The Nov. 3 Carl Cozier session had many speakers showing concern for the well-being of others in their school community. How will this affect Carl Cozier families that are already furthest from resources? What about the Family Resource Center? Speakers on both sides of the issue cautioned that adults will set the tone for how any upcoming transitions go for the kids.
These sessions were not designed for debate or dialogue. The format enabled community feedback, and the school board and superintendent absorbed it. A side effect of this format was that fact-checking didn’t occur, and within some basic guidelines like “no profanity” and a three-minute time limit, people could, and did, say anything at all.
Monday’s protests and feedback session regarding Columbia had a frenzied quality. It was great to see the large gathering of teens: civic engagement of kids and teens is invaluable.
But then it turned a bit. As workers finished their shifts and exited through an alternate door (the main entrance was blocked by protesters), they were met with shouts of “shame” and “you’re disgusting.” These are the workers whose jobs are making sure students and staff have computers that work, supporting schools with information and systems, etc., and most of us who work in that building earn less than teachers.
This led to a turbulent evening, containing calls for resignation of the school board and superintendent.
As I looked around the room that night, I saw people who can afford to send their kids to private school talking about the injustice of putting their kids on school buses. I heard accusations and weaponized empathy hurled toward our extremely hard-working board. (This is the same school board who, over the course of the last decade plus, has continuously worked to level the playing field for marginalized families and students.)
Some people said the quiet part out loud. One parent had already sent their students to private school, partially because our district “put too many resources towards the lowest-performing students.” Another asked incredulously how we could justify hiring a mental health specialist. One speaker offered a solution of busing kids from other schools to Columbia to increase enrollment, though most felt that a disruption to their own children’s school location was unacceptable. Several people expressed, “I hear the budget’s an issue, but there has to be another way,” which indicated they probably aren’t having to choose between a full cart of groceries or a full tank of gas.
In the long 90 minutes before I was called on to speak, the following thoughts swirled through my head. These are folks with a lot of education, skills, resources and anger. If I oppose their point of view, are they going to come after my job, too? I make less than teachers, but I work in this building they seem pretty angry about. I’m a single mom; can I afford to step into their line of fire? These questions persist.
My comments focused on the inequitable distribution of resources, and how keeping Columbia open would concentrate resources in our smallest school. Here’s the part I didn’t say out loud. It would be a disproportionate concentration of resources at our smallest, richest, whitest school. Most new families will not have access to a neighborhood where the median housing price is $665,000.
One of the most troubling moments that night came in the conflation of the recent arrest of a former school district employeewith other issues on which people were demanding accountability. Because they want someone to blame. Same here.
Let me assure you. We’re all angry. It’s horrifying.
Here’s the problem. In the absence of criminal behavior on the mandatory school employment background check, and when abuse has not been disclosed or reported, we cannot know what we don’t yet know. This is a gut-wrenching reality shared by all supporters of survivors of sexual violence. Let’s put our focus on support and gratitude for the survivors who bravely come forward, whose courage helps us to take community-wide measures increasing safety. Leaning into divisiveness is not the path to a safer community.
Our community has much in common, whatever our stance on school closure. Together, we may breathe easier after the mid-term elections. We all wish every child in our district could walk to a neighborhood school. And I bet we all wish that predators had that title emblazoned on their foreheads, to help us keep kids safe. But we can only work with what we have, and what we know.
Let’s shift the tone.
Charlotte Sather is a Bellingham Public Schools employee. The opinions expressed are her own and not of Bellingham Public Schools or members of the Bellingham school board.