r/BetaReaders • • 21d ago

Discussion [Discussion] r/BetaReaders check-in series! Share how your WIP is going, or how your beta reading is going, ask questions, and connect with more writers and readers!

4 Upvotes

Hello r/BetaReaders!

Who else can’t believe it’s November already? It’s basically 2027 now

Here’s this month’s prompt in the spirit of voting season: what happens/happened when you have/had split beta reader reactions? Do you ask for their reasonings before going with your gut decision or do you wait before implementing things? Or do you see if each beta view has a point and revise accordingly?


Welcome to our 11th monthly check-in thread!

These monthly pinned post aims to help the community connect with other writers and betas!

Share how your WIP is going, or how your current beta read is going, or other relatable beta reading topics in this thread!

This is a great thread to talk about writing, updates, accountability, trends, vents, and more.

It is not the right thread to post first pages as there’s another pinned thread for that, but you can link to your beta post if you wish.

Do NOT advertise any beta/editor services here, and no free samples to later ask for payment are allowed. You can try r/hireaneditor or r/freelance_forhire instead.

We also ask that self promotion of completed works do not contain links. Mentioning success is completely fine!

And we’d like to take this opportunity to remind people that works generated with AI, and AI-generated feedback is not allowed here, either. r/writingwithAI or r/betareadersforAI are better subreddits for that.

And because scammers are now targeting GDocs: please DM them and not leave them up on the sub publicly to avoid harassment

I’d also like to note that we have additional flairs available to help people know what specialty you have: traditional publishing, self-publishing, and fanfic. Please consider using them to help people match with you.

Also, it’s best to subscribe to our sub before commenting or posting to help avoid Reddit’s filters sending your content into the spam queue

Please ensure you comment in good faith and do not break any other r/betareaders rules.

Thank you, and happy writing/reading/editing/beta matching!


r/BetaReaders • • Oct 07 '26

Meta [Meta] Please review our subreddit’s resources on the sidebar and wiki to help with your posts here

14 Upvotes

For extra accessibility and convenience, r/betareaders is pinning this post with a link to the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/wiki/index/

Additionally, you may find these comprehensive resources helpful in creating your own blurb or synopsis

If you are aiming for traditional publishing or self publishing, writing a query letter blurb will not only help tell potential betas what they can expect, but they also show you the core components of your story upfront and often helps with DIY revision

Many people prefer detailed information to help them decide on taking on a beta read, but the subreddit currently strictly enforces 2 key pieces of information in posts as some people want more privacy and will DM them to respondents

Please do take note of r/betareaders rules, which are found on the sidebar to the right, and are also expanded on in the wiki. The sidebar also has clickable links to templates that give suggestions for information beta readers would like to know before responding. The less you provide, the less enticing your post is. Conversely, extremely long posts also reduce likelihood in responses

And again, this is a fully free subreddit that does not permit services or requests for money in any form. It is also anti-AI generated works and pro-human

The wiki will have minor updates in future, and so will the comprehensive resources linked

Best wishes for your writing, revising, and beta reading!


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

80k [In Progress] [80k] [Contemporary Romance] Risk Management: A Novel

2 Upvotes

Hello writers! I’m looking for a critique partner to swap first draft chapters with as we’re still writing. My WIP is a first-person, contemporary romance with spice, but I’m happy to provide a censored version if spice isn’t your thing. I just have the first 20% (Act 1) done so far. I’d be happy to swap 2-3 chapters at a time, voice chat, or even do an introductory phone call/video chat if you’d like! I’m disabled and home bound, so I’m hoping to find community with fellow writers online ☺️ Also, should go without saying, but I’m vehemently against AI use in any stage of the creative writing process.

A little about me. I’m a 32-year-old former psychotherapist-turned-writer. This will be my second manuscript but my first one that’s ever going to see the light of day (iykyk). I’m hoping to eventually pursue trad publishing with this WIP once it’s ready. And I’m located in the Pacific Northwest.

I’m a fairly experienced reader in contemporary romance and romantasy with some interest in upmarket/book club too. I also read some nonfiction/memoir just to keep things fresh.

Book Blurb:

Melanie is all about risk management. After all, it’s her day job. As risk manager for an elite financial consulting firm, she helps global banks avoid catastrophic financial loss and legal ruin before lunch. But can Melanie manage the same level of risk in her love life? When an impulsive one-night stand (OK, a one-night three-way) at her company’s weekend retreat goes awry, Melanie scrambles to fix it before her bosses find out. But growing feelings threaten to foil her plans before the Sunday shuttle back to the airport.

This debut novel features a workaholic girlboss, jet setting, a hidden chronic illness with authentic representation, and a happily ever after.


r/BetaReaders • • 37m ago

>100k [complete][100k][Upper YA High Fantasy] Threader's Ascent. Looking to do a manuscript trade

1 Upvotes

I am looking to do a manuscript trade with anyone who has a similar or lower word count (i.e less than 150k words). I am looking for a critique partner that can help me find the errors I know are hiding somewhere in my manuscript and won't mind me being critical for the sake of improving the book. If you are willing to comment throughout the text that would also be great.

The book itself is upper YA meant for crossover appeal, it is about a boy loosing his family and joining a rebellion to get them back putting him in the center of a deadly seige and eventually pitting him against people he thought he could trust.

I would prefer not to do a trade for a manuscript with 18+ content as I probably won't be able to give good advice for manuscripts if I haven't read similar books and I usually avoid that kind of story. If you have a clean adult book you want me to beta read, that could also work.


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

80k [Complete] [80k] [Fantasy] Anchor Point (Mermaids, pirates, seaside fantasy)

1 Upvotes

Looking for beta readers!!!

Completed second draft of my would-be-debut novel. Hoping to query, but need reader feedback to start on changes/refining 3rd draft.

BLURB:
As a child, mermaid Ell washed up on the shore of an orphanage with a baby dragon in her cradle. Years later, both girl and dragon have grown, but are relentlessly pursued by a cult of priests who want to take her dragon away. The key to their salvation lies in the hometown Ell has never been to, the hidden Mer civilization of Tsurilan.

To find it, Ell and her dragon team up with an enigmatic ex-pirate, a former professor, and a mysterious child. But even if Ell finds Tsurilan, she has to choose between the Mer and human worlds, protect Glim as the priests grow bolder, and grapple with her growing feelings for Maren, the ex-pirate whose motivations are not so noble as they seem.

[No spice, sapphic romance sublot (main couple), and mostly lighthearted with the tiniest bit of slightly violent action scenes and suspense]

FEEDBACK NEEDED:

Reader reactions, whether character choices/relationships are believable, pacing. Not looking for line level edits/grammar. I have a few documents you can fill out as you read for guidance!

Open to manuscript swapping. If so, would prefer to trade 1-2 chapters to see if good fit.

Timeline: 2-3 months (sooner rather than later, if possible!)

Please please please don't feed any part of the work to AI or use it for feedback (I know it's a rule already, just reiterating this is the most important requirement).


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

80k [In Progress] [80k] [Literary Fiction / Magical Realism / Metafiction / Experimental] Title Undecided: While I Burn / As I Burn / Burn With Me / Among the Flames

2 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a writer looking for a few additional beta readers for my interconnected short-story collection about fire.

The collection is approximately 80,000 words and is divided into three sections: Spark, Blaze and Coal. It consists of interconnected stories, all narrated by a flame in a fireplace, to ‘you’, the one enjoying its warmth. The stories jump between your experience by the glow and the various lives fire has led throughout its long relationship with humans (jumping through history, mythology and the many ways flame is used).

I'm particularly interested in feedback about:

The narrator and voice: Is Flame an engaging and distinctive narrator? Does its voice remain compelling throughout the collection?

Individual stories: Which stories work particularly well? Are there any that feel weaker, incomplete or out of place?

Structure and progression: Do the three sections work together? Does the progression from Spark to Blaze to Coal feel meaningful? How does it feel as a single piece?

Prose style: How does the writing itself come across? I'd be interested in reflections on the language, sentence structures, rhythm, repetition, imagery and overall style. Does the prose feel distinctive and appropriate to the stories?

Tone and atmosphere: Does the balance between humour, the everyday, strangeness, mythology, philosophy and melancholy work?

Emotional engagement: Are there moments that genuinely interest, surprise or move you?

Overall experience: Does the collection feel like a coherent literary work? What impression does it leave once finished? Most importantly, did you enjoy it?

I'd particularly appreciate some thoughts on individual stories as well as an overall impression after reading. I'm interested in honest, considered responses. I'm perfectly happy to hear what doesn't work, what becomes tiresome, or where the collection loses your attention. I'd also love to know which moments and stories stay with you, and if you enjoy the style.

I'm also very happy to have readers review just one section of the collection, rather than the entire 80,000 words. The three sections can be read independently, although they are intended to form a larger progression. So if you'd prefer to take on Spark, Blaze or Coal individually, that would be equally welcome. Of course, if you'd like to read the whole collection, I'd be delighted!

The Collection

A collection of stories narrated by Flame, whose relationship with humanity stretches back further than anyone can remember. It has been present for a great many things, in one form or another, and has a lot to tell you.

But enough description; we could describe things all day. You're here now, and the coals are glowing. So settle in, make yourself comfortable, and perhaps put another log on. There's no particular hurry.

If this sounds like something you'd enjoy reading, I'd be very happy to hear from you! Feel free to contact me.


r/BetaReaders • • 3h ago

90k [Complete] [93k] [Fantasy/Romance] Through the Confluence

1 Upvotes

I've done as much self-editing as I can, and now I'm seeking beta-readers for my 93,000 word (345pp paperback format) fantasy-romance.

Blurb: Gregory finds himself stuck in a fantasy realm after stepping through a magic portal. Now, he must navigate this strange new world, and figure out how to get home. Think "Wizard of Oz," but Dorothy is a college guy from Minnesota, there's a Lion who's anything but cowardly, and there's a woman with horns and a tail that might slit your throat if you call her a demon.

This is fairly standard fantasy stuff, with a heavy dose of romance, and enough adventure and action to keep things interesting. Expect a small bit of humor as well. It's not a dungeon-crawler, and not litRPG. The romance is medium-burn, with a Black-cat FMC, and golden-retriever MMC. It's the 1st book in a series, and ends on a sort-of cliffhanger...the book's main plot is resolved, but a new can of worms is opened.

POV: 3rd person limited, split evenly between MMC and FMC.

What I'm looking for: general commentary on pace, plot, and character development, and overall enjoyment. Let me know what's working and what isn't. Does the main couple have chemistry? Is the action easy to follow?

What I'm not looking for: line-editing and/or proofreading (but if you find something egregious, feel free to let me know)

Warnings: naughty language, graphic violence, graphic sex (3/5 on the spice scale), drugs/alcohol use.

Available formats: epub, pdf (formatted for 5.5x8 book size), exchanged through Google drive or email.

Timeline: a month or two? I'm not super worried about timeframe.

Swaps: Unlikely. I feel too bad being critical of someone's work, so I'm kind of a terrible beta-reader.

Excerpt (opening):

When he looked back and saw a plain brick wall instead of the door he’d just stepped though, Gregory knew he’d made a mistake. He gripped his backpack straps and took a step, but stumbled when his hiking boot caught on an uneven cobblestone. Looking down the street, he saw buildings of exposed timber and plaster rising on either side; their upper floors and balconies jettying out over the road, creating a claustrophobic tunnel effect.

Where am I?

People, talking, grumbling, and the general murmur of a crowded city street filled his ears. What was that smell? He looked down just in time to avoid stepping in a fresh pile of manure. A man on a horse clopped past. The rider was wearing metal plate armor, and… was that a fucking sword strapped to him?

WHEN am I?

Where did the door go?

Confusion. Panic. His stomach rose to his chest, pushing his pounding pulse into his throat. 
Holy shit. Breathe, Greg. There’s a logical explanation for this.

Angry shouting directed his attention to a scuffle across the street. Two big, brutish looking guys with green skin—wait, what?—were accosting a woman in front of a shop.

“Your medicine is garbage!” One of the green men shouted at her, shattering a glass vial at her feet. “Ghorza still sick!”

“Maybe your sister should stop drinking so much!” She stood her ground, standing tall, even in the face of two huge green dudes that looked like powerlifting champions one injection away from a steroid overdose. “It’s not my fault you’re too stupid to follow instructions.”

One of the green monster-men… things, shoved her shoulder, causing her to stumble back and fall on her rear. Despite feeling like he was in some sort of fever dream, an instinctual need to deescalate took over.

Running across the narrow street and getting involved was his second mistake.


r/BetaReaders • • 4h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Would requesting a specific type of reader be a bad idea?

0 Upvotes

I'm still in my beta reading process, and altho I have some "normal" beta readers who have finished and enjoyed my book, I feel like I need to get the feedback from a very specific type of people to see if i'm doing things correctly or not.

The issue is that, so far, I havent seen anyone doing that before (exclusing sensivity readers), so idk if it's a good idea to even try. For example, I want someone who is physically similar to my MC to read the novel to see if she has ever experienced something like that (in terms of how my MC is treated, or her expectations about people and so on), or both a heterosexual woman around 23yo, and a lesbian to see what they have to say about it... stuff like that.

I dont even know how could I search for those kinds of readers either.


r/BetaReaders • • 4h ago

90k [Complete] [92k] [Fantast] The Golden Hammer

1 Upvotes

Hello there!

Just finished initial revisions on my debut novel. Looking for feedback with the plotline (including holes), pacing, characterisation and general feel of the story. Hoping to move to the next stage in the new year. To give you an idea of the book;

As magic drains from a desperate, unraveling world, quiet antiquarian Arnold has his peaceful life shattered when a night ambush robs him of a newly found relic. Teaming up with unlikely allies, he discovers the stolen trinket is actually one of the legendary Three Hammers—a massive reserve of dwindling magic. Uncovering a dangerous conspiracy, Arnold reclaims the weapon, only for the thief to vanish and leave him a prime target.

An excerpt from the first chapter;

His eyes darted back and forth along the edge of the valley as he moved north-eastward along its curve. Behind him, there was another call of the horn, and when he turned he could see figures atop horses descending rapidly down the side of the valley. Even at distance, Arnold could hear their clamour; wailing and shouting in a revelry. He took a breath and broke into a run. He did not dare to turn and see if they were gaining on him. He continued to run as fast as his legs could carry him, hoping desperately that they would not be able to make up the distance between them. Gasping for breath he hugged the inside wall of the valley as it grew steeper, hoping it would provide some cover. He ran until his body began to scream, forcing him to slow.

Happy to DM early chapters. Also happy to swap critique, if that would help others as well.
Thanks!


r/BetaReaders • • 5h ago

>100k [Complete][133k][Epic Fantasy / Medieval Fantasy] The Pallid Aeon

0 Upvotes

Hello! I finished my third draft of my epic fantasy novel, The Pallid Aeon. The story is written in 3rd person limited POV. It has two parallel storylines, which go as follows:

An entertainer named Kala investigates a being with mind magic called the 'Pallid Lord' in order to free her lover, Walter, from a curse. However, as Kala learns more about the Pallid Lord, she questions who the real enemy is. The Pallid Lord, or the people that had put her up to this task in the first place?

Meanwhile, Walter seeks to save a mutual friend of theirs, named Victor, whose life is withering away. Walter would stop at nothing to see Victor's vitality restored. He promised Kala that he would stay safe till she returned from her investigation. But Walter finds that promise tested as his efforts lead him to dangerous people that would manipulate and exploit him.

I'm happy to provide of a sample of the first 1 to 3 chapters in DMs via Google Docs, and if you'd like to continue reading from there, I could send the rest. I'm mainly looking for initial impressions as you're reading, and what you liked, as well as what you're not keen on.

Thank you, and I hope to hear from you,

Daisy


r/BetaReaders • • 5h ago

>100k [Complete] [102k] [Adult Historical Fiction] Alas, Dreamland

1 Upvotes

Coney Island, 1909. Dreamland is the brightest place on earth, a park of a million electric lamps, and in one building on its promenade premature babies are kept alive in incubators in front of a paying crowd.

Minnie Thompson is the nurse who keeps them breathing. She's engaged to George Stadler, the park's lion tamer, a big charming German showman who drinks more than he lets on. When his best lion takes his arm, she marries him at his bedside because it's the right thing to do. Then there's James Rowe, the quiet electrician who keeps the park lit and is living under a name that isn't his.

For two years Minnie weighs her promise against the man she actually loves, until the night in May 1911 when the whole park burns and both men go into the fire.

The park, the incubators and the fire are real. The people are invented. It's a love story with stakes, no explicit content.

Looking for: whether the three points of view feel distinct, who you're rooting for and when that changes, and anywhere you got bored or lost. Full manuscript, about four weeks if that works for you.

Swap: happy to read yours back. I like historical, thrillers, literary horror and most things with a strong voice.

Content warnings: a lion mauling and an amputation, drinking, sick and premature infants, and a large fire.


r/BetaReaders • • 8h ago

Novelette [In Progress] [10k] [Urban Fantasy/Progression Fantasy] Blue Mage's Bestiary

1 Upvotes

Looking for Beta-readers. Willing to swap~

What I'm Looking For: Got an extended prologue ready and I'd like people to look at it before proceeding further.

Content Warnings: Few, but if you're scared of those fungi that take over insect bodies there's one of those in this sample.

Timeline/Format: I'd like turnaround by month's end, or two weeks if need be. Per subreddit instructions, just DM me for the link

Critique Swap: I'd be open for anything of comparable length or content!

Excerpt:

A call goes out at some ungodly hour. Something like two-fifteen in the morning. It’s the emergency on-call line, and of course Vic’s covering this week. There’s a winged serpent wrapped around the power couplings! All contractors on deck. This will take all night to sort out; creature disposal is just the beginning. Elaborate cleanup crew, mountains of paperwork. Whole nine yards.  Vic’s just put his head down to sleep, but apparently that’s not happening tonight.
Of course there’s a Dread Quetzalcoatl wrapped around the power couplings. Just had to be tonight. Just had to be at Vic’s plant. The greatest engineers in history planted the seeds for these facilities and just let ‘em rip. Nobody knows how they work. It’s always some new B.S. And that’s the industry-official jargon. Imagine what the average layperson thinks of the emerging field of paracausal mana generation? Might as well be magic. Well, in ways beyond the obvious.
Vic pulls himself out of the bunk—the work phone won’t stop blaring incident coordination alerts even if he ignores it all night—and tries to get dressed in a rough approximation of a Tower-appropriate, regulation-compliant work uniform. He’s got robes with a wide range of resistances to various terrestrial elements. Rubber-soled boots for electricity resistance; those always come in handy when dealing with the power couplings. Bracers like those black Kevlar things police dog handlers use provide more straightforward physical protection. Those likely won’t help against a problem of this size, but it’s an important psychological boost to be wearing some kind of armor, y’know?

Random Note: It's in third-person present tense. I was intentionally aiming for 'what if the entire narrative were like the first 50-odd pages of Snow Crash', if you have experience with that.

Beyond that, here are my major questions (they're in the doc too):

  1. Any point where you stop or skim? 
  2. Were there any points where you were confused or the meaning of something was unclear? Try to point it out in the comments!
  3. These opening chapters mostly just follow Vic, but are there any points of characterization that worked (or did not work) for you? 
  4. For a web serial, what do you think of chapter transitions? Do they make you want to continue? Could they be punchier? Would you keep reading?
  5. I do believe chapter 1 is too long and chapter 2, too slight. What do you think? Would you suggest a place to split ch 1, or anything to expand on ch 2? 
  6. Lastly, what do you think of tense, tone, style, etc?

r/BetaReaders • • 9h ago

40k [in progress][40k][fantasy/mystery] The Pale Clock Society

1 Upvotes

Hello! My name is Violet Crow and I am an aspiring indie author actively searching for beta readers! My manuscript is in it's final stages of editing and I would like to receive a feedback which includes;

- Character development and consistency

- Dialogue and character interactions

- Pacing and narrative flow

- Plot consistency and continuity

- Worldbuilding and immersion

- Emotional depth and reader engagement

- Overall reading experience

If possible, I would love to get a general impression of each individual chapter, so that I know what is working well and what could be improved. Finally, after reading the whole manuscript, I would love to get a full review and an overall opinion.

The Blurb

Beyond space and time lies a hidden mansion where the imaginary is ordinary. Furniture talks, ghosts wander the halls, and children marked by a mysterious symbol attend lessons before going on missions through paintings to retrieve lost artifacts from the past, all under the guidance of their ageless mentor.

Averie and Christopher have known no other life. To them, this strange mansion is home.

Until a girl walks out of a painting.

That is not supposed to happen.

She arrives with no mission, no explanation, and something even stranger: memories of a world beyond the mansion. Among them is the image of a woman who brought her there, and a secret she was never meant to carry.

As those memories begin to surface, the mansion’s carefully guarded truths start to unravel.

And whatever brought the girl here may be coming back for her.


r/BetaReaders • • 18h ago

80k [Complete] [86k] [Magic Realism] Saint Onofrio the Wanderer

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am looking for readers for my completed novel manuscript titled "Saint Onofrio the Wanderer". It's a magic realist odyssey across a fabled Italy, wherein a guilt-ridden Sicilian financier residing in Milan walks the length of the country to reconcile with his estranged mother, as the ghosts of Italy's historical past rise up to meet him and a malevolent figure hunts at his heels.

I am providing a short excerpt of the opening below:

"I.                Καιρός – Milan l’è on gran Milan

Yesterday, I received a letter from mamma. I did not open it at once; rather I decided to leave it on my nightstand so that I could keep it close. I fixed on it and looked to penetrate the envelope with my gaze in order to discover its contents, but this being too much for me, I left my center-city apartment today to wander the fog-dusted streets with some other fabricated urgency that I forced upon myself. As the main door of my building slammed shut behind me with a resounding boom, I felt another door of perspective open up before me: I knew then that I had to visit the Blessed and Nascent Virgin Maria in the Domus of this metropolis of Meneghino, so that I might clear my mind before addressing my mother’s unexpected communication.

Now I stand before the work of God in this piazza bustling with throngs of tourists clicking their camera shutters, as students idle in packs, cackling and smoking their Nazionale cigarettes. The mischievous maranza of our times, the pickpockets on the prowl, let their cacophonous tunes blare from large speakers to the visible disdain of the passing patrol of the Carabinieri; I disregard the rabble to focus my attention on the Duomo.

The Cathedral astounds me, its impressiveness reduces me to rubble, and I cannot help but turn inwards as I search for the same majesty within myself. I am not a proud man, but I am well educated, and I must assert that I am not without feeling. My love of the Duomo must prove this in the greatest measure simply because the Duomo has no rival, and any love that is great for it must come from a great man. [...]"

(There is some adult content in the text, moments of ribaldry and satire.)

I would be interested in beta readers who can comment on story structure, pacing, and also give any general reader reactions. Someone who enjoys picaresque novels might be interested in this one, as each chapter explores a different Italian city. Of course, I would love to know if there are willing beta readers out there who are knowledgeable in Italian history, culture, and language; comments from this perspective will help me see if I landed the immersive aspect well. My Italian is strong, but I feel a native speaker would have a vital perspective. Of course, I am open to other interested readers who are not Italian speakers or Italianists, but who may be passionate about history and interested in fabulism.

I can also do a critique swap!

Thanks for your attention.


r/BetaReaders • • 16h ago

Novella [In progress] [20k] [Fantasy Isekai] A Soul Forged in Two Worlds

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been working on an original fantasy isekai story called A Soul Forged in Two Worlds, and I wanted to share it here to see if anyone would be interested in giving it a read.

The story follows a young man named Cassian Vaeloren, who gets reincarnated into another world after his death on Earth. He gets a second chance at life in a world filled with magic, different races, kingdoms, and things he's never experienced before.

As he grows up, he also discovers a mysterious ability called the Mind Forge, which has the potential to change not only his life but the world around him.

I'm aiming for a mix of fantasy adventure, action, comedy, worldbuilding, kingdom building, politics, mysteries, and character development.

I'm still learning and improving as a writer, so I'd really appreciate anyone willing to give it a chance. If you do read it, I'd love to get a comment or two about what you think of the story. Any feedback, thoughts, or criticism would mean a lot!

Story: A Soul Forged in Two Worlds

i can dm where i have it posted and if you can please leave a comment when i send the link


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [Complete] [92k] [Adult contemporary sapphic fantasy] THE HUM

4 Upvotes

Hi beta reader community!
 
Hoping to find more readers for my book, The Hum. It has gone through extensive revisions already. I want to do one final round of beta reading before I decide what to do next.
 
Genre: Adult contemporary sapphic fantasy
 
Length: 92,000 words (3 parts, ~30,000 each)  
 
Audience: LGBTQ+ adults and adult fantasy/romantasy readers
 
Spice Level: mild-to-moderate sapphic intimacy
 
Content Warnings: Emotional manipulation, loss of a loved one, mental health facility themes, mild language
 
General Synopsis: Skye, a 22-year-old witch descended from survivors of the Salem Witch Trials, is tired of letting her coven down with her mediocre magical powers and inability to conform to coven norms. That is, until she meets a witch from another coven who inspires her to stop trying to change herself to fit the mold. Skye’s journey of self-acceptance, both in terms of her magical abilities and sexuality, leads to the discovery of generations of coven secrets. Skye must decide if she will stay small to keep the peace, or claim the magic she was taught to fear, even if it means losing the only life she’s ever known.
 
I welcome any type of feedback, especially on timeline consistency and making sure the magic system makes sense! I would also love to connect with LGBTQ+ readers. I’m a lesbian and wrote this story based loosely on my own lived experience, and since my previous readers haven’t necessarily related to the comphet experience, I’d really appreciate thoughts on that specifically.

If you’d like to read it, please send me a DM! If it seems like a good fit, I’ll send you Part 1, and if you enjoy that, I’ll send Parts 2 and 3. No pressure if you decide it’s not for you! I’m hoping to wrap up feedback in the next 3–4 weeks.

Also, one of the main characters is a rescue dog named Jupiter. In case you love a good dog sidekick!

Thank you :)


r/BetaReaders • • 20h ago

70k [Complete] [72,300] [Dystopian Romance] CREATURES OF SOUL AND MIST

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Searching for another round of readers for my current project. I’m currently querying this project with one request out, but since I haven’t had much success other than that I figure more eyes won’t hurt! Particularly I would love some eyes on my first chapter, first fifty pages, and potentially entire manuscript if anyone has time! Also, if anyone would like to take a look at my full query letter and provide feedback, that’s welcome as well!

Here’s the working query blurb! (undergoing some revisions)

A decade after the government ushered the remaining population of their country into protective walls, an infectious mist ravages the landscape, turning a large percentage of citizens into memory-consuming vampiric creatures. Delilah, an immune soldier, is tasked with hunting these creatures that have taken over society. Her first love is out there as a creature himself, and every kill she completes is an act of revenge against his betrayal. He stole pieces of her memories, leaving her empty and unable to love her new partner, Malikh, in the way he deserves. 

When the government reveals that her ex is feeding on members of their population in search of her, she seizes the opportunity to eliminate him. The government proposes that if she does this, her memories will potentially be restored. Malikh wants to leave the past behind and continue their search for rumored escape tunnels, but Delilah is trapped within the smoky claws of her disrupted memories.

As they traverse the ruins in search of their target, they learn the tunnel system they have been searching for is orchestrated by those they hunt. As Delilah prepares to risk her relationship with her partner to finalize her revenge, she discovers an active rebellion against the government and information that exposes the source of the mist, leaving her view of the world shaken. Worse still,  the man she is determined to eliminate is at the center of it all– and may be their only hope at escape.

Small excerpt from the beginning:

Bodies were strewn across the muddled floor of the dilapidated district. Delilah stepped over the discarded carcasses. The leftover husks of a Kolvik’s meal. Desolation choked its way down her throat, coating her mouth with its bitter flavor. She cut her eyes to Malikh, her gaze traveling down his features as he studied the body of a woman on the ground. The woman’s gaze was turned upward toward the sky, eyes searching for something to fill her with a soul once more. Malikh kneeled and gently pushed her lids closed before clearing his throat.

“What a mess,” he forced out. Delilah was silent in response, the words not finding an escape from her clogged throat. He stood from the woman’s body and brushed his fingers lightly against Delilah’s, the woman’s death passing between them. As he walked forward, Malikh made a motion to close another victims eyes. Delilah shivered, the reek of the swollen bodies churning her gut.

“There’s not enough time to acknowledge them all,” Delilah cut in as she pushed her nausea away and forced her Hunters mind forward.

“We have to track it before it goes anywhere else.” Her voice sliced through the still air surrounding them. Her stomach clenched at the sudden halt to Malikh’s actions. She reminded herself of the target. The reason these people were dead in the first place. That was what was important right now. Her fingers itched with the need to collect vengeance. Her thoughts swirled, taunting her with the past that could have delivered her the same fate.

Malikh nodded and continued through the sea of hopelessness.

Delilah took extra care to avoid treading on their bodies as she navigated the space. Her eyes snared on the trail of Mist leading into the forest. The dirt beneath her feet pressed against her boots as she followed where her intuition had tugged her to go. Malikh fell into line behind her. The rhythm of their in sync steps calmed her rising nerves. A cold breeze rallied the goosebumps on her skin into a rise as she entered the tree line.

The Mist thickened before her, the trail becoming lost in swaths of gray. She scoffed. “Of course it would choose now to roll in, and not before the Kolvik devoured the entire town. These people could’ve been safer inside their homes if the alarm had been sounded.”

Leaves crunched beneath their boots as they travelled as carefully as they could through the trees. Delilah winced at the sound, worrying it would attract the Kolvik’s attention before she was ready. It was bad enough the rest of the creatures had scattered. But at least they knew one had stayed behind.

Please DM me if you’re interested!


r/BetaReaders • • 21h ago

Novelette [In Progress] [12K] [Thriller/Romance] Title TBD

1 Upvotes

Fifteen years ago, fifteen-year-old Lily Armella vanished from Mercy Creek, Pennsylvania.

Her face still hangs in the post office, the diner, and the sheriff's department. The town calls her disappearance its greatest tragedy. It never mentions that it's also its dirtiest secret.

Now her little sister is coming home.

At twenty, Vivian Armella has built a following as a true-crime writer, dissecting cold cases for thousands of readers. But she has never written about the one that matters most. The police called it an abduction. The town called it a tragedy. Her family learned to stop asking questions but Vivian never did.

The one person who might help her is Ashford Baker: twenty years old, son of the sheriff who led the original investigation. He grew up in the shadow of a missing girl's photograph and learned early that some questions can get a person hurt. By day he's the sheriff's charming, troubled son. By night, he makes his own money as a model, keeping that life carefully walled off from his family and the town.

Vivian needs his father's files. Ashford agrees to help because he knows something about the night Lily disappeared.

Neither of them expects to fall in love.

And neither is ready for what Vivian finds: her sister didn't die that night. She's still alive. And someone in Mercy Creek has spent fifteen years making sure no one finds her.

And someone in Mercy Creek has been making sure she stays that way.

Tropes:

- Childhood tragedy

- Forced proximity

- Forbidden romance

- Morally grey love interest

- Secrets and lies

- She uses him, he lets her

- Small-town corruption

- Lovers with conflicting loyalties


r/BetaReaders • • 23h ago

50k [Complete][50,068][Supernatural Thriller, Action]Hush, My Vampire

1 Upvotes

Hush, My Vampire

by Moe M Meadows

This is a query of a highly edited version of my manuscript. For my manuscript, I need beta readers. I hope you can check for plot holes, the clarity in writing, the action sequences, and finally the characterization. Please don't be afraid to be critical as it helps make my manuscript better. I hope you read this query over and ask to read my manuscript. Enjoy.

Description

Paragraph 1: 

Hush, My Vampire is about marginalized groups in the form of a gritty, paranormal thriller full of action. This is a world where paranormal creatures exist but the rest is like our world.
Paulo, a middle aged man from Atlanta is part Goblin which are creatures that have small spikes on their heads that can be hidden by clothes, hats or similar things, and have a bit darker skin. Some of them have supernatural abilities who are even rarer. Paulo is one of those. Paulo hides his spiky head with a hat. Besides their head and skin, Goblins look human like everyone else. The set up is two cops from two very different backgrounds, Paulo and Webney de Court, looking for a serial killer.

Paragraph 2:

Stephan, the villain, brutally kills someone and the FBI agents, who now work with Interpol, are called to Saudi Arabia. Paulo must find the killer with the few clues he left behind only to learn that Stephan is more unique than any killer he has encountered before—the killer is a vampire. This world is about 10% Goblin and 1% vampire, making vampires quite rare.

Paragraph 3:

The heart of the story is Paulo and Webney argue over how to find their “Amalia”, a codename for a future wife.

Cliff hanger:

 
Paulo is deaf in one ear, brave, and has something significant over the vampire serial killer, …Superpowers. The action sequences are reminiscent of martial arts and action films in the 2000s and 2010s.

Comparable titles:

The Comparable Titles are: Black Boy by Richard Wright, RazorBlade Tears by S.A. Cosby, When No One is Watching: a Thriller by Alyssa Cole and, Your House Will Pay by Steph Cha. All are about gentrification and racism similar to how Goblins and gentrified settings are included into this story. Racism is a major theme in this novel. This novel has many action sequences similar to John Wick films and the Lies of Lock Lamora novels.
Author Bio: 

The author has been attempting to write 500 words 5-6x a week for about 3 years now. He wrote his third fiction novel but is working on publishing his first, all are not published yet. Although he has written a trilogy on another topic, this novel is a standalone.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [In Progress] [12k] [Upmarket Speculative Fiction] Senior Player One – Seeking Alpha Readers for Dark Comedy About Aging, Memory, and Second Chances

4 Upvotes

Hi friends!

I'd love a few readers to share honest thoughts on the first ten chapters of my work-in-progress novel, Senior Player One. 100% transparency: this is the best thing I've ever written. Also, 100% transparency: I'm not a reliable narrator. 

This is where you come in. 

I'd love some fresh perspectives on whether the premise, characters, humor, and storytelling are landing with you.

About me: I'm a lifelong writer who actually went to school for creative writing. That was a while ago (think quill, candlelight, and parchment). I had a milestone birthday two years ago and decided to finally use those college credits for something, so I wrote a book.

It was awful. 1/10, don't recommend.

But I learned a lot, and in January I started writing Senior Player One and… tbd.

Genre: Upmarket Speculative Fiction / Dark Comedy

Length: I'm sharing the first 10 chapters (approximately 12,000 words). The full manuscript is still in progress.

About the book: What happens when your family volunteers you for an experimental immersive clinical trial for people living with dementia?

A retired Las Vegas magician named Harold Cho is about to find out.

Imagine if Richard Osman wrote Dungeon Crawler Carl.  Fewer explosions. More paperwork. And a surprisingly large amount of heart.

Feedback I'd love: I'm mainly interested in honest, big-picture feedback rather than proofreading or line editing. This is a first draft, so there are plenty of typos waiting for future me to tackle.

I'd especially appreciate your thoughts on pacing and engagement, characters and dialogue, humor, tone, premise, and clarity. Most of all: did finishing one page make you want to read the next?

You'll probably enjoy it if you like character-driven speculative fiction, unconventional protagonists, dark humor, and stories that explore serious subjects without taking themselves too seriously. And since this is a work in progress, if you'd like to stick around while I finish the manuscript, that would be a big bonus.

How to get involved: If you're interested, comment or DM me and I'll send over the Google Doc link. No hard deadline, but feedback within 2–3 weeks would be ideal.

Content warnings: Dementia and cognitive decline, aging, grief, death, strong language, and racist remarks by a character.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [COMPLETE] [92K] [FANTASY ROMANCE] Bound by Shadow and Veil

0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m looking for a few readers for Bound by Shadow and Veil, the first book in my Veilborn Trilogy. It is an unpublished fantasy romance with strange dreams, a world hidden behind the Veil and a slow burn romance.

When Emma’s dreams start bleeding into her waking life, the stranger she keeps seeing in them might know why. But getting answers means trusting him before she knows what he is keeping from her.

I’m sending the original draft because I’d love to know how the story lands before I revise it again. Where did you want to keep reading? Where did you get confused or lose interest? Did Emma and Caelan’s romance feel earned and real? Also, does it feel like YA or New Adult to you? I am looking for honest reader reactions, not line edits.

If this sounds like something you’d enjoy, message me and I can send the first 6 chapters. No pressure to read the whole book if it’s not for you.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [Complete] [90k] [Dark/Urban Fantasy] Celestial Exchange

1 Upvotes

Hello everybody! I recently pitched this novel at an writers/agents convention, and one agent suggested getting a few beta readers before going to query again. For a little bit of context, I started this project in 2024, and I was deeply inspired by Jujutsu Kaisen and wanted to write something that played with a critique on gender roles in fantasy. This project has been through three (and a half) major revisions since then. I'm really open to any general critique or notes on the story, as I think the most important thing for me now is to gauge people's reaction to the story and learn it's strong and weak points. I'll post my query letter below for a brief description of the novel. Note: I'm also open to a critique swap.

Kota is sick of being saved. Being born both mentally and physically weaker than his peers, Kota has spent his life hiding behind the strength of an overbearing aunt in order to survive the many monsters lurking in the shadows of Janjiro City. When Kota gets attacked by a malformed hybrid beast while trying to live a normal life, an innocent bystander is killed, finally giving him the push he needs to beg a group called the Astral Society for sanctuary. In the process, however, he discovers that he has the potential to join their ranks and become an aster.

But asters aren’t heroes. In a society where strong convictions power one-of-a-kind ‘techniques’, arrogance is a sign of status, and Kota’s gentle demeanor is treated like a threat. He soon finds himself being harassed and beaten by somebody far stronger and more experienced than him, until he’s rescued by a fellow trainee, a girl named Sae. 

 Sae is the star of a generation, the prodigal heiress to an influential family with a long and powerful history. She’s everything Kota has ever wanted to be: extroverted, kind, and most importantly, strong. She even offers to become his tutor and guardian as he develops the skills necessary to defend himself. After she saves his life twice in the span of a week, Kota swears to pay back this debt and become her equal – by any means necessary. 

To do so, he must confront deep rooted insecurities over being more of a caretaker than a warrior, and find a way to fight without traditional means. As Kota confronts not only the nightmarish monsters he’s spent years running away from, but also the hypocrisy of the Astral Society’s leadership and its consequences, he comes to understand that relying on others isn’t always a weakness, and may even be exactly what the society needs to survive.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [119k] [Gothic Coming-of-Age] The Last Autumn of Arti Usher

1 Upvotes

This book is rumored to contain:

- A 16-year-old girl in a tuxedo (and sunglasses)

- An enormous, decaying costal city

- An ancient, hereditary society that reveres an ink-producing organism trapped beneath a well

- A ruined labyrinth containing said well

- A Gothic Revival mansion with a vaulted atrium

- A corrupt, self-serving government determined to fill its empty Death Row

- A mechanical execution machine put to use only once a year, on the last day of October

If I could perform such a trick, I would gladly snap my fingers and send generative AI on a one-way trip to Tartarus. Don't accuse me of using it. I scratch.

If you wish to become a beta reader for THE LAST AUTUMN OF ARTI USHER, please DM me.

THANK YOU!