r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Design Critique Readability

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just making rough draft concepts for a thing I'm working on based on a game I quite like.

Which of the two reads easier and seems more attractive at face value? Thank you, nice people.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Design Critique Sell Sheet Feedback - Kithora

Post image
10 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I've been working on this game, Kithora, for the better part of 2026. I've got some conventions lined up for early next year where ideally I'd like to have it pitch-ready.

As of now, the mechanics and rule book are basically finalised, but the actual board itself is not (and the title is kind of a working title as well.) So the image isn't exactly final or anything. It is pretty heavily 3d-printed and I'm working to make it more manufacturable.

I'd love to know if you feel like it has a good draw and interesting highlights. This is the first game I've developed, so any and all feedback is appreciated!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

I need draft rulebooks to critique for an article. Would anyone like me to review their rulebook?

5 Upvotes

I'm writing an article on board game rulebooks and I need some prototype drafts to critique. Who has a rulebook that they'd be willing to let me review in an article? It will go up on https://rossongames.com/

Some notes:

  1. I won't post the whole PDF in full but I am going to be posting screenshots and quotes.
  2. It will be critical, but not "this person is an idiot" critical. I'm just going to be pointing out things that I think could be done differently.
  3. The article will refer to several rule books, including several published rule books. Not just one draft.
  4. I'll type up extra feedback for you as well. Not everything will make it into the article, but if I notice something extra I'll let you know.

I'm currently writing the rule book for my own co-design https://psykidsboardgame.com/ which is why I'm digging into this. I studied technical writing in college and have done professional technical writing (by which I mean I wrote one article, but it was paid). I've noticed some common problems that I want to talk about.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Design Critique Please critique my sell sheet!

Post image
9 Upvotes

Any thoughts or feedback would be welcome.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Game Mechanics Feedback on a card game about primates for an educational program

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hello! I hope this is the right place to ask. I work at a library and I designed this little card game about primates for an educational program I'm doing about Jane Goodall. I've playtested it against myself and it seems to work fine, but I wanted to ask if there are any glaring issues before I let the children try. The kids are 9-12 years old.

Extra details:

The more endagered the primate the lower their frequency in the deck (minus humans who are in at the frequency of "vulnerable")

Their abilities are based on how the animal lives in the wild, I tried not to make any too "OP"

I am not a game designer or primatologist

Based on this resource from the New England Primate conservancy and game mechanics loosely inspired by Wingspan


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

Design Critique Feedback for map artwork

Post image
4 Upvotes

Hi all. I have been tinkering with this game for a couple of years now. I am not posting it to promote the game, but to get feedback on the map artwork.

For context, this is a personal project with 0 budget. I am not going to commission an artist for this. I just used free stock images. At most I am going to give this game for free for PnP.

At the moment I am stuck at the map design. It is supposed to be a laboratory complex. Please tell me how to improve the look of this map.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Design Critique Pikmin: The Board Game

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I posted this a couple weeks ago, but I’m reposting it because I’ve made substantial changes and additions, including new game modes and a possible expansion.
This is a board game that I am designing for my fiancee, to combine her interest in Pikmin and my interest in board games and game design. I am not super familiar with Pikmin, and this is the first time I’m designing a game myself. I’d love to have more eyes on this to refine my wording, layout, and clarity.
I know it’s a bit long, but please give this a look and leave a couple comments over any concerns or anything. Thank you all so much!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

News Its here!

Post image
56 Upvotes

We finally got a boxed prototype of The Zookeeping Game made! I'll have to get some better photos later, but the small design changes we made to the cards feel a lot better.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Production & Manufacturing For anyone curious about tools built specifically for board game prototyping: free live session next week

1 Upvotes

Hey all,

Sharing this for anyone who’s been looking into tools made for how we actually prototype: lots of card variations, stats and text that change every playtest, print-and-play exports. Not general design software we end up bending to fit.

We’re hosting a free live session with Tabletop Creator (I’m on the team) where we take a simple game from idea to playable prototype and show how the workflow fits together: components, layouts, data and variables, export.

It’s pretty beginner-friendly, and there’s open Q&A.

📅 Tue, Nov 24 · 4:30–6:00 PM CET

https://luma.com/j6qrbuc8

If it’s useful to anyone, great. If not, carry on 🙂


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

Design Critique Lucky Guest guest artwork - Which is your fave?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

For a recent prototype convention, I pushed myself to make art for all the guests of my drafting game, Lucky Guest! These are the "flat" versions - next to no shading - and some may yet get their artwork revised, but the personal deadline was satisfying to meet.
Here are my personal, prototype print sheets for those cards. Which guest is your favourite?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

General Question Would you remove cubes on these slots from left to right or from right to left?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I need you to do a little study and find out the more common opinion about this because my girlfriend and I have differing oppinions about this :) I'm thinking about a system in my board game were you put little cubes on a card and at the beginning of every turn you remove one and carry out the effect that is under the cube. The removal need to happen in a fixed order. I want to know from you just based on your gutfeeling which of these 6 cubeslots you would remove first if you would have no further instructions. Thanks


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

Playtesting & Demos Seeking Playtesters for Bloomworks by Karma Games

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm the designer for Bloomworks, an upcoming game by Karma Games (publishers of Clans of Caledonia and Wildscape). We're in the last stages of balancing as we finalize components and get ready to launch. To that end, we've made the game available early on TTS for playtesting. Click here to get the Bloomworks module. Then, please fill out our online playtest tracker.

I hope you'll enjoy the early sneak peek into Karma's next mid-heavy Euro strategy game, and I appreciate any and all feedback you're able to contribute in the process. If you're curious about the game itself, Bloomworks is a contract fulfillment engine builder where players are aspiring florists in a cramped city apartment. A unique bloom scheduling mechanism and player-defined contracts make the game much crunchier than its floral theme may suggest, as you plant flowers, engage with a dynamic market, and dream about quitting your day jobs (variable player powers) because don't we all. Art by Mico, game design by me!

If you have any questions, let me know. Thanks for taking a look!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

Ideas & Inspiration Looking for feedback & comparable games

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am designing FIRST DOWN SNAP, a Card game with Würfeln, Würfelplatzierung, Push your luck, risk, goodies, bluffing. Target players: Party-groups.

Games I have already compared:

1st & Goal

What I like: The combination of tactical play selection and dice rolls conveys the feeling of a real American football game. The direct showdown between offense and defense is particularly interesting, as both players try to anticipate their opponent’s decision.; What I like less: The extensive game components and various dice can make it difficult to get started. The plays require more evaluation, which occasionally interrupts the flow of the game.; How my idea differs: FIRST DOWN SNAP focuses on fast-paced, tactical duels with just 22 cards and two dice. Plays are resolved directly based on card values, without additional reference tables. Weather effects alter the tactical conditions of each drive. In PRIME TIME mode, elements of skill are added for touchdowns and field goals.; Mechanics: Hidden play selection, card comparison, and dice mechanics.

Football Highlights: 2052

What I like: The ability to improve your team with new cards adds strategic depth and high replay value. The combination of the football theme and deckbuilding leads to interesting long-term decisions.; What I like less: At times, the deckbuilding aspect takes precedence over the immediate decisions on the field. Those who prefer fast-paced football showdowns will first need to get the hang of card management.; Difference from my idea: FIRST DOWN SNAP uses a fixed set of offense and defense cards instead of a deck-building system. Both players choose their plays face-down, putting the focus on reading and assessing the opponent. Weather cards further alter the conditions. With a playing time of 20–40 minutes and two different game modes, SNAP offers a compact football experience without team building.; Mechanics: card management, tactical card selection, and deckbuilding.

Breakaway Football

What I like: I especially enjoy the direct tactical battle between offense and defense. Both players must anticipate their opponent’s possible plays and adjust their decisions accordingly. This creates suspense without the plays being entirely determined by chance.; What I like less: The various card values and special rules may require additional explanation. Additionally, it lacks the physical dexterity component that adds variety to FIRST DOWN SNAP in PRIME-TIME mode.; Difference from my idea: FIRST DOWN SNAP uses direct card matchups and two tactics dice, supplemented by changing weather conditions and a bonus for a selected offensive position. Breakaway Football uses play cards, strength values, and additional Game Day cards. SNAP doesn’t require a separate game board and, in PRIME-TIME mode, uses the box itself as a ramp and end zone.; Mechanics: Face-down card selection, card comparison, and tactical play resolution.

What other games or mechanics should I look into? I’m particularly interested in strengths, weaknesses, and specific differences.

Thank you very much for your suggestions.

Which other comparable games or mechanisms should I research? I would appreciate concrete examples, strengths and weaknesses.

Thanks for your feedback.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

Ideas & Inspiration How do you make projectiles satisfying?

3 Upvotes

I've been stumped. I have these ideas for a military-style game, but I'm struggling with how to make the troops shoot at each other in a satisfying way. Simply pointing at someone and saying, "You got shot," is really boring. So, how can someone make physical, analog pieces shoot at each other in a way that feels engaging and satisfying?

as an example a soldier can shott 2 tiles in fron of him , just saing it got shoot seems realy boring , any ideas?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Playtesting & Demos Second playtest of Ultimatum!

Post image
37 Upvotes

I ran my second major playtest of Ultimatum, my board game I'm making! 

It was a lot of fun but the biggest issue is that it took far too long - the game finished after 5 hours, and it is possible for the game to go even longer than that, which is no good. My goal is a 2-3 hour long game, maybe up to 4 if it can really really justify it. 

I'm hoping (and iterating on design will reveal!) that the reason for the length of the game is the information, and the way it's presented. My players often weren't sure exactly what their cards did, and needed to ask me how things worked frequently, so I need to remake the player board and cards so that it's much more obvious how everything works. 

The rest of the time was spent arguing, negotiating, pleading with, and threatening each other - and that's the whole point of the game, so I don't mind that! 

Any ideas on how to speed things up, questions about the game, or anything else at all would be very welcome. 


r/BoardgameDesign • • 5d ago

Ideas & Inspiration AMA: 55 year old, dad of 2, full time worker, with first board game in pre-launch on crowdfunding. Here to help as much as my limited knowledge will allow.

39 Upvotes

Hey all.

First up, I think this is my second post ever. I lurk and read (generally the front page) as I lay in bed.
The reason I decided to make to huuuuuuge leap to a 2nd post was, basically, to see if I could offer any help to other board game designers.

I'm by no means any kind of expert or established pro, but the fact I started with just an idea for a game and had no bloody notion of where to start, who to contact or how to get it produced, means I may be able to offer some insight into the - at times - scary, overwhelming, journey from a place of complete ignorance to having a game set to launch.

My game is big in scope (minis, loads of components, etc.; think Scythe/Nemesis/Jaws of the Lion level of production), so I'll try to also answer any questions regarding creation, prototypes, manufacture, pricing, etc. of such games. Man, the amount of times I wish I'd created a little trick-taker or the like, but I simply couldn't think of one... no, no, I had to think of a big bloody epic beast of a thing, didn't I?

I will answer every question posted and be as transparent and informative as I can (withstanding divulging confidential client/artist/manufacturer information) but I may not be super quick doing so as I estimate the ratio of replies to naps to be 3 to 1.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Game Mechanics How much strategy is too much for a funny party game?

4 Upvotes

Hey, all! New here and new to this world (I primarily work as a screenwriter)!

So-- me and my good buddy have been developing a few games over the past years, and one of the things we’ve been going back and forth on is how much actual strategy belongs in a party game.

Our first game is called Secret Santa.

The basic idea is that players combine funny characters and personalities, and then everyone competes to give that person the funniest (or most awful) gift.

But we didn’t want it to just be about the best joke. We wanted players to have agency and other ways to score points. So we added a mechanic where you can also score if people choose your gift. And ways to try to double your points for round or even change out new cards.

Anyway, I’m curious how other designers approach this.

At what point in a party game does strategy get in the way of just having fun,

Would love to hear your thoughts.

Thnx!

Dave


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Rules & Rulebook Morphiblock Rulebook – Revised Version After Your Feedback. Would Love Your Thoughts!

Post image
8 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently introduced Morphiblock, a 3D spatial logic game I've developed myself. I was looking for people who enjoy abstract strategy games and have the interest and time to carefully read through the rulebook.

You provided some really valuable feedback, including constructive criticism, editorial suggestions, and other comments on how to improve and refine the text.

After several rounds of revisions, I've now completed an updated version of the rulebook.

Whether you've already read the previous version or are reading it for the first time, I would be very grateful if you could take the time to read the revised version and share your thoughts and opinions.

Thank you all in advance!

https://www.morphiblock.com/MORPHIBLOCK_RULEBOOK_16_PAGES_2026.pdf


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Publishing & Publishers First-time board game publishers: how did you approach international distribution and legal requirements?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m based in Europe and working towards launching my own small board game publishing business. I’d like to reach some of the larger European markets and potentially sell outside Europe as well. I’d love to hear from other independent publishers about how they approached those first steps, particularly international distribution.

I have a strong background in international logistics, so I’m comfortable with that side of things. What I’m less familiar with is the legal and administrative side of selling games in different countries: how to identify the requirements that apply and make sure everything is in place before putting a game on sale.

How did you decide which countries to sell in initially? How did you find out what you needed to do to sell legally in each market? Did you involve a lawyer or a compliance consultant? If so, at what stage?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Rules & Rulebook Hunter x Hunter Passionate Project

Thumbnail greedisland-masterofthebook.edgeone.dev
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently rewatched my childhood favourite anime Hunter x Hunter and got inspired to create a board game version of Greed Island!

I'm not planning to have it published and this is just a passionate project of mine. I spent the past two months working on the draft of the rulebook and am planning to start making the cards soon for playtesting.

Just want to share my rulebook and get some feedback on it (especially from Hunter x Hunter fans!). I just like the anime a lot and want to create a fun game for fans to enjoy. I'm planning to share the rulebook and print and play cards after playtesting (given it feels fun and engaging).

Any feedback would be great, thanks!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Production & Manufacturing Website for print cards for custom game with double side?

3 Upvotes

Good morning. I would like to create a board game. Aside from the various plastic components, need only to build 5–6 plastic spaceships, each capable of holding up to 5 small plastic cubes (which I should be able to handle easily with a 3D printer), I was wondering how to go about printing double-sided cards. I currently use the software NanDeck for the cards, but I am open to switching if necessary.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Playtesting & Demos Battle Pikmin! A Pikmin re-theme I made for Battle Sheep!

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

The original board game is called Battle Sheep:

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/54137/battle-sheep

Basically you send out your Pikmin to try to conquer (occupy) as many spaces as possible. Whoever has the most visible Pikmin on the board at the end of the game wins!

I also made a variant/version with special tiles on the board such as the Pikmin Flower (8), if you move a stack of at least 8 Pikmin onto the tile, you gain a bonus Pikmin on your stack, Treasure (10), you gain 1 bonus point at the end of the game (like an additional Pikmin on the field), and Nectar, movingo onto this tile makes your stack stop at that tile. All extra tiles are placed randomly and not edge spaces.

Let me know what you think, it was a lot of fun to make and play with my friends!

You can check out my other re-themes here:

[One Piece Legendary](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/10p0q0j/i\\_made\\_a\\_one\\_piece\\_version\\_of\\_marvel\\_legendary/)

[Pax Westeros \(Game of Thrones Pax Pamir 2nd Edition\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1fmseex/i\\_made\\_pax\\_westeros\\_game\\_of\\_thrones\\_retheme\\_of/)

[Runeterra Reforged \(League of Legends Tyrants of the Underdark\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1eew974/i\\_made\\_a\\_league\\_of\\_legends\\_themed\\_tyrants\\_of\\_the/)

[Pokemon Ark Nova](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1hdby4p/i\\_made\\_a\\_pokemon\\_retheme\\_of\\_ark\\_nova/)

[Pokemon Splendor & Pokemon Splendor Duel](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1mn9h3i/i\\_made\\_pokemon\\_splendor\\_again\\_updated\\_the\\_cards/)

[NBA Innovation](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nua3z1/with\\_the\\_nba\\_preseason\\_coming\\_in\\_a\\_few\\_days\\_i/)

[Zelda Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert/Forbidden Jungle](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nnjeaa/i\\_made\\_a\\_legend\\_of\\_zelda\\_retheme\\_of\\_forbidden/)

[Spy x Family Agent Avenue](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qh1sfq/i\\_made\\_a\\_spy\\_x\\_family\\_retheme\\_of\\_agent\\_avenue/)

[Lord of the Rings Clank Catacombs](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qndolc/i\\_rethemed\\_clank\\_catacombs\\_into\\_lord\\_of\\_the\\_rings/)

[Disney Legends of the Void](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1r02rba/i_rethemed_legends_of_void_into_a_disney_themed/)

[Genshin Impact Knarr]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s7n8ey/i_made_a_genshin_impact_retheme_of_knarr/

[Pokemon Harmonies]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s8kib9/i_made_a_pokemon_retheme_of_harmonies/

[Avatar the Last Airbender Duel for Cardia]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1sdvycf/i_made_an_avatar_the_last_airbender_retheme_of/

[One Piece Smash Up]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1v3hv70/made_a_custom_one_piece_smash_up_faction_as_a/

[Toy Story Battle] https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1wg0585/i_rethemed_toy_battle_into_toy_story_battle_and/


r/BoardgameDesign • • 5d ago

Design Critique Transplantica Characters

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Here are my artists latest iterations of the patient cards!

I'm very happy with them. The vibe is just how I want it to be, invoking that retro Food Chain Magnate vibe I strive for with some googie elements.

Some obvious issues I'm aware of - the font for the numbers is too unclear and the numbers themselves are too small. Also, the lung might need another lung to be more clear.

Do you have any other critique or thoughts? Which are your favourites? How is the contrast between colours? Is the quality adequate for an indie production?

I might need to change the tint of green and blue, maybe red, to make it more distinct in low and warm lighting. Sorry for the glares!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 5d ago

General Question First-time board game publishers: how did you approach international distribution and legal requirements?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m based in Europe and working towards launching my own small board game publishing business. I’d like to reach some of the larger European markets and potentially sell outside Europe as well. I’d love to hear from other independent publishers about how they approached those first steps, particularly international distribution.

I have a strong background in international logistics, so I’m comfortable with that side of things. What I’m less familiar with is the legal and administrative side of selling games in different countries: how to identify the requirements that apply and make sure everything is in place before putting a game on sale.

How did you decide which countries to sell in initially? How did you find out what you needed to do to sell legally in each market? Did you involve a lawyer or a compliance consultant? If so, at what stage?