r/Bogleheads • • Jun 08 '25

Articles & Resources New to /r/Bogleheads? Read this first!

347 Upvotes

Welcome! Please consider exploring these resources to help you get started on your passive investing journey:

  1. Bogleheads wiki
  2. r/Bogleheads resources / featured links (below sub rules)
  3. r/personalfinance wiki
  4. If You Can: How Young People Can Get Rich Slowly (PDF booklet)
  5. Bogleheads University (introductory presentations from past Bogleheads conferences)

Prepare to invest

Before you start investing, ensure you're ready to do so by following the early steps of this guide or the personal finance planning start-up kit. Save up an emergency fund, then take full advantage of any employer matching of contributions to any employer retirement plan available to you (this match amount is additional income that's part of your compensation/benefits package), then pay off any high-interest debt like credit card debt or high-interest student loans.

When you're ready to start investing beyond enough to get any employer match, follow the subsequent steps of this guide or the investing start-up kit. Take full advantage of tax-sheltered accounts available to you before investing in a taxable brokerage account: this is the most predictable way to improve your after-tax investment returns. (In the US, per Prioritizing investments: 401(k)/403(b) up to any match, then HSA if available due to high-deductible health plan coverage, then Roth or Traditional IRA or 401(k)/403(b) up to max which may be higher if the mega-backdoor Roth process is available, then a 529 to the extent you'd like to pay for future education expenses. Note that IRA contributions are subject to income limits around tax-deductibility of contributions or eligibility to make direct Roth IRA contributions; the backdoor Roth procedure is a workaround.)

There is often some potential tension between saving/investing toward retirement vs saving toward potential nearer-term goals like a down payment on a home purchase. Carefully consider the various tradeoffs involved in owning vs renting a home, keeping in mind that which may be a better financial decision is highly situational, and that opportunity costs of owning (less available to invest in higher-expected-returns assets instead) should be considered alongside non-financial lifestyle tradeoffs. If saving toward a near-term goal, note that funds holding stocks are inappropriate for money you'll need in 5-10 years, unless you're willing to take on significant risk of losing money in the meantime & delaying that goal. Instead, consider CDs, Treasury bonds, or target-maturity-date Treasury bond funds maturing before you'll need the money (then a high-yielding cash equivalent like an HYSA, government money-market fund, or ultra-short Treasury Bill ETF like VBIL between maturity & spending the money).

Save/invest enough

Your savings rate is the most important factor determining your ability to enjoy a comfortable retirement later in life, particularly early in your career / investing journey. Aim to save/invest at least 15% of your after-tax income if you're in the US & not covered by a pension beyond Social Security. In some cases, such as a shorter time to expected retirement (e.g. starting to seriously save/invest from a significant income later than your mid-20s and/or planning to retire earlier than your mid-60s) and/or a high income (which will not be partially replaced by Social Security to the same degree as a lower income), it may be appropriate to target a higher savings rate (e.g. at least 20% of after-tax income, or perhaps higher if multiple such factors apply to you and/or one factor applies to an unusual degree).

When calculating savings rate, remember to include 401(k) contributions in both the numerator (savings) and denominator (after-tax income). Any employer matching contributions may also be included in the numerator (savings).

Investing is 'solved'

Don't worry too much about trying to find the optimal set of funds to invest in. That can only be known with the benefit of future hindsight, and investment returns are far less important than your savings rate until your portfolio size grows large enough relative to new contributions. Aim to diversify broadly (for robustness to the uncertain future) and seek low fees (fund expense ratios charged annually) & simplicity (hands-off automation); see discussion of these & other principles in Bogleheads investment philosophy.

A target-date fund designed for investing toward retiring around a year closest to when you expect to retire is often a reasonable option, particularly in tax-advantaged accounts like a US employer retirement plan or an IRA. These all-in-one funds intended to be held alone are very broadly diversified, automatically rebalance to their then-target asset allocation, and gradually become more conservative with less expected volatility as you near retirement.

If the target-date fund available in an account/plan with limited fund options has significantly higher fees than suitable alternative individual funds, consider the tradeoffs of lower fees vs automatic rebalancing and asset allocation management. I.e. consider the lowest-expense-ratio funds available that provide exposure to US stocks (the fund name will typically contain 'S&P 500', 'Russell [1000|3000]', or 'US Large Cap'; ensure no 'Growth'/'Value' suffix, or pair that with the other), ex-US stocks (the fund name will typically contain 'International' or 'Intl' or 'Ex-US'; same caveat re: 'Growth'/'Value'), and US bonds (the fund name will typically contain 'Total Bond' or 'Aggregate Bond'). Take the weighted average of those funds' expense ratios, with weights based on the current asset allocation of the target-date fund you'd use instead. The difference between that weighted average expense ratio for individual funds vs the target-date fund expense ratio, multiplied by your portfolio value, would represent the current annual convenience fee for automated, hands-off investing via the target-date fund. Whether that's worth it to you depends on your personal preferences around paying higher ongoing fees (by sacrificing some investment returns) in exchange for set-it-and-forget-it features.

In a taxable account, target-date ETFs (available at least in the US) avoid some of the tax efficiency downsides of holding a target-date mutual fund. Tax efficiency may be further improved by holding a three-fund portfolio of index ETFs in a taxable account, but this also involves tradeoffs against automatic rebalancing and asset allocation management. Tax efficiency may be even further improved by keeping bond funds in tax-deferred accounts, though this involves additional tradeoffs against simplicity and some other potential benefits described here.

If you're a non-US investor, take care to thoroughly understand the tax implications of investing in a US-domiciled fund as a "nonresident alien" (which may include high tax rates on dividends and assets passing through an estate); in many cases this is best avoided, instead favoring an Ireland-domiciled fund.

Be mindful of fees

If your portfolio were to average a 5% annualized real (after-inflation) return after a low annual fee, paying an additional annual 1%-of-assets-under-management fee to a financial advisor and/or an actively-managed fund's expense ratio would forgo 20% of your portfolio's investment returns. An initial investment in a portolio averaging a 5% annual real return after a low annual fee would be worth about 47% more after 40 years than it would be after a 1% additional annual fee.

Some employer retirement plans offer only funds with high expense ratios. If that's the case for your employer's plan, it is often still ideal to get the tax advantages of contributing unmatched dollars to that plan before investing in a lower-fee fund in a taxable account (but only after maxing out IRA contributions); details here.

Automate & stay the course

Set up automatic contributions & purchases of fund shares wherever possible, otherwise set periodic reminders to manually contribute/invest (or try to find an alternative that allows automation), then maintain discipline through thick & thin. Keep in mind that market prices for funds should only really matter whenever you sell some shares to fund your retirement, and that lower prices in the meantime provide opportunities to buy more shares with a given contribution dollar amount and to rebalance from asset classes with higher recent returns towards those with lower recent returns (but possibly higher expected returns).

Tune out the noise: prognosticators of doom and gloom have no reliable ability to predict the future, and often have some conflicts of interest (e.g. selling ads, books or investment services, and/or trying to justify their investment positioning or encourage others to adopt that). The same goes for promotion of strategies promising market-beating returns by investing in a more-concentrated fashion (betting on some sector / theme / alternative asset beating the broad stock market).

Consider writing an Investment Policy Statement to document your plan when you're calm & clear-headed; this may be helpful to refer to later if you find yourself anxious & considering changes in response to market volatility & negative sentiment. Consider including a pointer there to this guided meditation video for later reference to help calm your nerves / regulate your emotions if needed when it seems like the sky is falling (this is arguably the most challenging part of investing).

Per Jack Bogle: "Do not let false hope, fear and greed crowd out good investment judgment. If you focus on the long term and stick with your plan, success should be yours."

Additional resources

Some additional resources that might be of interest for a deeper dive later:

  1. Taylor Larimore's Investment Gems (a collection of highlighted quotes from books related to investing; follow the links under the 'Gem post' column)
  2. The Bogle Archive (a collection of Jack Bogle's publications and speeches)
  3. Bogleheads Conference Proceedings (follow per-year 'Conference Proceedings' links to access slides/videos)

Please read our community rules here and follow those when posting or commenting in this community. If you encounter content here that breaks those rules, please report it (... > Report > Breaks r/Bogleheads rules).


r/Bogleheads • • Dec 28 '25

Why do Bogleheads discourage use of AI search for investing information? Because it is too often wrong or misleading.

368 Upvotes

I see a lot of surprised and angry responses from Redditors whose posts and comments are removed from this sub either for use of LLM search engine and other generative AI responses, or for recommending people use them to answer their questions. This facet of the Substantive Rule on this sub has a parallel in a similar rule on the Boglheads forum: "AI-generated content is not a dependable substitute for first-hand knowledge or reference to authoritative sources. Its use is therefore discouraged."

Many folks, especially on the younger side, are so accustomed to using ChatGPT or Gemini that it may be their default way to get any question answered. This is problematic in the field of investing for several reasons that are worth noting:

  1. LLMs are not firsthand sources with organic knowledge of the subject matter. They are aggregating reference sources and popular opinion and thus prone to both composition mistakes and sourcing material mistakes or biases.
  2. LLMs remain susceptible to "hallucinations" (made-up ideas) and can be not just false, but confidently false which is highly misleading.
  3. LLMs' response quality is very sensitive to the quality of the prompt. Users who are somewhat knowledgeable about a subject and also skilled at crafting good queries for AI searches are far more likely to get accurate and useful results - especially for research purposes or for reference to stored personal data - while the uninformed are more likely to get wrong or misleading answers to basic questions.

Policies excluding AI-generated content are not meant to be a referendum on the overall current or future value of AI as a tool for personal finance and investing, which is obviously enormous and transformative, especially for those who know how to best utilize it. It is a question of whether AI responses make for substantive content on this sub, and whether it is an appropriate resource to direct strangers and novices to. At the moment, the answer to both is a resounding no. On the one hand, people come to Reddit primarily for human interaction and original content, so posting AI responses or directing people to AI search engines is of minimal contributive value - folks can go chat with bots themselves if that's what they want. But as to whether AI search engines are appropriate references for finance and investing info, here are some articles from the past year that support their exclusion as a default response:

  • AI Tools Are Getting Better, but They Still Struggle With Money Advice (Money 2/13/25): "ChatGPT was correct 65% of the time, "incomplete and/or misleading" 29% of the time and wrong 6% of the time."
  • Is Talking to ChatGPT About Finance Ever a Good Idea? (White Coat Investor 6/22/25): "LLM responses had multiple arithmetic mistakes that made them unreliable. More fundamental than arithmetic errors, the LLM responses demonstrated that they do not have the common sense needed to recognize when their answers are obviously wrong."
  • Financial advice from AI comes with risks (University of St. Gallen, 1/7/25): "LLMs consistently suggested portfolios with higher risks than the benchmark index fund. They suggested: [more U.S. stocks; tech and consumer bias; chasing hot stocks; more stock picking and actively managed investments; higher costs.]"

Note: the views expressed here are largely my own, and I am not affiliated in any way with the Bogleheads forum nor the Bogleheads Center for Financial Literacy, but I invite others (including the mods on this sub) to weigh in with their own opinions.


r/Bogleheads • • 21h ago Heartwarming

A Case for Diversification: Watching Life Savings Evaporate in Weeks on r/NvidiaStock

433 Upvotes

A brutal reminder unfolding in real time of what happens when you bet the farm on one stock.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NvidiaStock/s/Ng2dtr4wAv


r/Bogleheads • • 10h ago

Negatives of Tax Loss Harvesting

34 Upvotes

The benefit of TLH is that it reduces current year capital gains (good!)

But since this lowers your cost basis, doesn't this mean you'll face a larger capital gains tax bill in the future? In other words, kicking the can down the road?

Starting to wonder if the juice isn't worth the squeeze.


r/Bogleheads • • 16h ago

Investing Questions Sold stock for house last week, offer fell through, re-buy VTI?

76 Upvotes

I assume the answer is just going to be “yes”, but curious on opinions. I sold about 500k in VTI/VXUS last week for a house downpayment, the offer fell through, and we decided to stop looking for the time being.

I know this sounds like a silly question considering the amount, but we’ve been investing for years and this is the first time I’ve actually pulled from our brokerage.

I sold when VTI was at $365, which funny enough I was SAD about at the time haha. Now I’m trying to decide if I fully rebuy, or keep it in a money market fund until the market starts to stabilize.

Looking to early retire in about 10 years. We still have a good bit invested I’m not pulling out.

EDIT: sorry to clarify I should I have mentioned we are NOT looking for a house anymore for the time being. The house we wanted was an outlier, we are really happy with our apartment and it’s rent controlled so just going to stick it out here.


r/Bogleheads • • 12h ago

Vanguard’s 40/60 recommendation

36 Upvotes

Given the correction we’re in, I thought it was interesting to look back at the 40/60 allocation Vanguard was talking about heading into 2026, for those with a midterm outlook:

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/vanguard-flips-the-script-on-6040-investment-strategy-110026190.html

I believe they had an older 30/70 recommendation prior to this. As someone who is nearing retirement, it caught my attention.

Thoughts? Is it too conservative for a midterm outlook?


r/Bogleheads • • 22h ago

Don’t think in $

118 Upvotes

I love seeing my portfolio lose value.
Every share of VT I can pick up for less $ is a good share.

Just think of you buying a tiny slice of the cake, which is the global economy. Nothing changed just the price of the slice. So as long as you are actively buying and saving, be happy for red days.


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Investment Theory Anyone else not even aware there was a downturn until checking Reddit?

191 Upvotes

I don’t even look at my portfolio. There’s an automatic DCA monthly from my checking into a diversified world index fund. I literally don’t care about a downturn as I’m not accessing my investments for an indeterminate period. Surely this is the point of being a Boglehead, you don’t have to worry about all this stuff.

Edit: ok I had some vague idea, but there’s so many headlines about stocks falling that I tend to just ignore them these days. Doesn’t make any difference to my strategy.


r/Bogleheads • • 21h ago

Glad to be diversified

44 Upvotes

I’d been feeling some fomo as I watched tech stocks like Nvidia grow massively while VOO and VTI increased only modestly.

Well recently with all the volatility in individual stocks I am so glad to be diversified. I’ll take having my modest gain wiped out over having a huge windfall suddenly disappear.

I’m in it for the long haul, ups and downs, so just gonna keep buying monthly, same as always.


r/Bogleheads • • 6h ago

Question about selling VOO?

3 Upvotes

I'll preface this by saying I am a newbie when it comes to investing and prefer to just VOO and chill

I had originally invested approximately 115K into VOO in my brokerage account over the past couple of years with the thought that I might need it in the short term for a down payment on a house. Ultimately the time has come and while I am still up, I am wondering if there is any specific strategy I should be doing to minimize capital gains.

My shares are currently valued at $131,00 and am looking to sell approximately 30-50k to increase my liquidity for closing costs and down payment.

I also had bought SMH earlier this year for 20k but with the market being what it is am now down about 6k.

My question is and please correct me if I'm wrong, if I sell SMH to realize those losses and rebuy VOO with that money, while selling approximately 50k worth of my shares in VOO, would that help to offset the capital gains tax? Is there any specific manner or order that I should do things or does it not matter?

Thank you for your help in advance!


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Do not worry

1.9k Upvotes

Remember, if you have your emergency fund, DO NOT WORRY ABOUT THE DOWNTURN!

We are crewmembers of the SS Vanguard. We have procedures in place, we have training. When the fire alarm on the SS Vanguard goes off, as it is today, we:

  1. Stay invested
  2. Throw a bit more in if you have the ability to.
  3. Do not check the price frequently.

VTI and chill, let's make Captain Jack proud.

He may be the laziest investor you've ever heard of, but you have heard of him.


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Seeing a lot of panic or worrisome posts, what's going on?

385 Upvotes

Isn't the sub about setting your allocation and chilling?

Whether it's VT/VTWAX and chill or your preferred VTI/VXUS allocation, shouldn't Bogleheads just keep investing and ignore market noise?


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago Regret

Baby's first market downtown

378 Upvotes

Just posting to vent for emotional relief :(

I'm pretty young (still in college) and made a decent amount of money at a summer internship. I did what I understood as the responsible thing and basically put it all into an index fund since I'm lucky enough to not really need the money right now. Unfortunately that was in August so I'm down like 10% lifetime :(

I feel pretty stupid right now esp since I've been skeptical of all the AI stuff in general. I understand that I should just think about it as little as possible but it's hard to ignore that if I was slightly more patient I would have basically saved the equivalent of 2 "normal" years, and who knows how many more if things keep looking bad. And yeah people say things like "oh but this year was up overall" but I didn't get to take advantage of the good part of the year 😭

Oh well I'm stuck with it now


r/Bogleheads • • 19h ago

Investing Questions Choosing VTI/VXUS allocation

5 Upvotes

I'm invested 100% in VTI/VXUS in my taxable brokerage. I'm trying to find the right split. Currently it's at 75% VTI and 25% VXUS. It sounds like this might be good for this current climate and the suggestions by Vamguard and Fidelity on how the US market will behave over the next 10 years?

Or are they wrong and I should do 80/20 or even 90/10 split?

I'm nearing 40. The majority of my portfolio is in target date funds so i let vanguard choose that split. This brokerage will maybe fund a house in 10-15 years but I need it to grow a lot more (to at least $500k but ideally more). It's only around 100k in it. I contribute around $3.5k every month.


r/Bogleheads • • 21h ago

Investing Questions Advice for structuring an HSA account

7 Upvotes

A couple years ago my company switched to a high deductible plan with an HSA. The obvious advantage is I get to invest the money I don’t spend. To date I have been putting extra funds into a vanguard money market fund. Low returns but my philosophy was cash preservation until I saved to a point where I could cover a year of deductible and max out of pocket. Now that I’m there I want to invest in something that will generate better returns knowing I’ve got ~20 years to retirement. I’m thinking andS&P 500 index or total market return fund. But curious in anyone has any advice or strategies they would recommend.


r/Bogleheads • • 21h ago

How to Tax Loss Harvest Index Funds with Recent Buying?

7 Upvotes

I started a boglehead style brikerage account mid year and have been unwinding my individual stocks to buy index funds (VTSAX and VTIAX). As a result, I've put substantial funds in the account this year and have continued buying as recently as yesterday.

If I want to TLH, I know I need to avoid the wash sale rule, so no buying within 30 days. This means I have to stop buying those funds until late December.

So would this plan make sense:

-direct all new purchases to VTWAX

-after 31 days, exchange VTSAX and VTIAX for VTWAX

This of course assumes the market is still down in 31 days. If it's not, then I would keep VTSAX and VTIAX, but also now have VTWAX, which muddies things a bit.

How do I know if the funds are considered substantially identical? What about 401k investments?


r/Bogleheads • • 20h ago

Career with front-loaded income

3 Upvotes

Hello Boglers,

I've seen the 100/0 - 90/10 stock:bond allocation recommended for young people. How does this change if your present income is higher on average than future income?

For example, take an 18 year old NBA player signed to a 3 year 5M$ contract with a clause that if they don't score an average of 15pts/game, they only take home 1M of their 5M. They probably shouldn't emergency fund + 100%(VTI/VXUS), right?


r/Bogleheads • • 17h ago

What allocation should I use for savings that doesn't have a purpose/goal to fund?

2 Upvotes

Hi all, here's some details before my question.

  • Single, 28 years old.
  • $7,000 monthly income after taxes. Extremely stable and reliable income.
  • I max out my IRA accounts every year.
  • I have a fully funded emergency fund.
  • 100% debt free.
  • My car is paid off, and I am actively saving $250 per month in a separate brokerage account for my next car (estimated to be 10 years away)
  • I currently don't have access to a 401k/403b/TSP style account, only my IRAs and taxables.
  • I am a renter (I like it this way, I prefer smaller places and flexibility).
  • Am currently able to save about 35% of my monthly net income (not a spendthrift and I got a sweet deal on my apartment lease).

Before I get to my allocations, here's how I personally determine the allocation for a goal/account. I have a spreadsheet I created that determines allocation of stocks/bonds/bills based on two factors: Quarters/years until the money is used/starts being used, and how long the money will be used for. For example, 30 years away from a 30 year retirement. Another example is my car fund being 11 years away from a single lump sum use. The amount of years/quarters that the money will be used for determines how many buckets the account is divided into. The buckets that are closer to being used get more dollars and are less volatile. The buckets much further out get fewer dollars and take on more equities. Buckets only hit 100% equities roughly 20 years away from estimated use. I only use VT, BNDW, and VBIL.

It's a bit more complicated than that, but I don't want to drone on forever. If you have questions on my process, let me know. My formula leads my 2037 car fund to be currently 59% VT, 40% BNDW, and 1% VBIL. It will scale down to 100% VBIL eventually.

Current Allocations:

  • Retirement accounts: 100% VT
  • Emergency fund account: 100% VBIL
  • Next car savings account (2037 target): Roughly 60% stocks, 40% bonds.
  • Checking: 1-2 months expenses.
  • Separate taxable brokerage: Can't decide.

My Actual Question!

After monthly expenses, saving for my retirement and next car, I am still able to save a few hundred dollars a month extra. It's been going into a taxable brokerage account, since I'm not able to put more into my IRA's. I am sure that in the future, there will be some purchase that I will want money for. Maybe a house, massive multi month trip, a big gift, or something else. But I don't know if that will be next year, or in 30 years. How should I allocate my extra savings? I've been going back and forth between just doing a 50/50 portfolio and 100% stocks and having it as taxable/flexible extra retirement savings. But that seems boring and not necessary.

Is there any way to tell what a solid allocation is for an unknown date of use?


r/Bogleheads • • 2d ago

Surprised how heavily loss aversion weighs on peeps

528 Upvotes

Market is only down ~3% in 6 months, still up 4% YTD, but people are losing their minds. We studied Loss Aversion in college. When you give someone $50 and then take it back later, they will freak out; even though the $50 was a gift they only held for a few minutes.

Even with that knowledge, I’m still caught off guard by just how sensitive everyone is to the smallest amounts of red in their brokerage dashboard. I could never be an FA.


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Fighting Intrusive Thoughts

52 Upvotes

Hey

So I finally did my rescearch on investing and at 28 years old decided to put 75% of my life savings (100k) into VOO about a month ago…

Just now fighting the “you should have known” thoughts…

I did my rescearch and it said that DCA statistically is less likely to beat lump sum…

So i wanna tell myself i shouldnt beat myself up and regret


r/Bogleheads • • 15h ago

Employer Provided IUL

1 Upvotes

My employer has offered its executives an indexed universal life policy as an "extra retirement account." I have pursued every avenue of getting these funds in any other form, i.e. 401a contribution, 457f, or just a cash bonus. No bueno.

Given that I would never buy this policy for myself and I have and will continue to hold adequate term life policies. I would like input on what account option I should choose to most closely mirror the index fund approach to investing. The policy tracks the S&P 500 with dividends of course. I have tried to include as much info as possible related to caps, guaranteed caps, participation rates, etc.

  1. Capped 1-year, 1% floor

◦ Segment: 1 year

◦ Floor: 1%

◦ Current cap: 9.25%, with 100% participation

◦ Guaranteed minimum cap: 3%

2. Capped 1-year, 0% floor

◦ Segment: 1 year

◦ Floor: 0%

◦ Current cap: 10.25%, with 100% participation

◦ Guaranteed minimum cap: 4%

3. Capped 1-year, 0% floor, 3% spread

◦ Segment: 1 year

◦ Floor: 0%

◦ Current cap: 14.5%, with 100% participation (3% is deducted from the index return before the cap applies)

◦ Guaranteed minimum: 5% cap, 3% spread

4. Uncapped 1-year, 1% floor

◦ Segment: 1 year

◦ Floor: 1%

◦ Current participation: 55%, no cap

◦ Guaranteed minimum participation: 15%

5. Uncapped 1-year, 0% floor

◦ Segment: 1 year

◦ Floor: 0%

◦ Current participation: 63%, no cap

◦ Guaranteed minimum participation: 20%

6. Uncapped 2-year, 0% floor

◦ Segment: 2 years

◦ Floor: 0%

◦ Current participation: 85%, no cap

◦ Guaranteed minimum participation: 25%

Other options

• Fixed account: declared rate set for 12 months, 1% guaranteed minimum.

• 12-month dollar-cost-averaging account: holds premium at a declared rate (4% currently, 1% minimum) and moves it monthly into the indexed accounts.

• Policy value enhancement: guaranteed extra 0.25% a year in years 1-10, and 0.50% from year 11.

Trying to make the best of the situation, though I'm grateful for the free money in any form.


r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Never bear too much or too little risk

Thumbnail bogleheads.org
60 Upvotes

Your risk tolerance is your ability to stick to an investment plan through difficult financial and market conditions. To know if an asset allocation matches your risk tolerance, ask yourself if you held it, would you sell during the next bear market? This is very hard to answer honestly before you have experienced one.

To give you enough money for retirement, you want assets with a decent expected return. This means you need to own stocks. Stocks return a share of the profits generated by publicly owned companies. But although they offer a chance of good returns, stocks are volatile and risky. In 2008, some markets fell 50% from their previous highs. Over time, stock prices roughly follow the trend of the economy, which is to grow. But prices can stagnate or decline for decade-long periods. This is why your asset allocation needs to include bonds as well as stocks.[1]

Bonds are a promise to pay back a loan of money on a set schedule. Bonds do not have the expected returns of stocks, but they are much less volatile. A mix of stocks and bonds will produce reasonable growth while limiting the size of the inevitable drops.

How much in bonds? This is the basic question of asset allocation. Before you decide, you first need to balance your ability, willingness, and need to take risk. The more risk you can handle, the less bonds you need. When you are young, your prime earning years lie ahead, and it will be decades before you need to access the money. So, higher stock allocations may be suitable, because big drops in stock prices will not hurt as long as you do not sell during the drop.

John Bogle wrote:[2]

[A]s we age, we usually have (1) more wealth to protect, (2) less time to recoup severe losses, (3) greater need for income, and (4) perhaps an increased nervousness as markets jump around. All four of these factors suggest more bonds as we age.

— Common Sense on Mutual Funds, John Bogle

Although your exact asset allocation should depend on your goals for the money, there are a few general guidelines that you can follow. These are based on practice rather than on theory, and are only a starting point for decision making, not the end.

For example, Benjamin Graham wrote:[3]

We have suggested as a fundamental guiding rule that the investor should never have less than 25% or more than 75% of his funds in common stocks, with a consequence inverse range of 75% to 25% in bonds. There is an implication here that the standard division should be an equal one, or 50-50, between the two major investment mediums.

— Quoted in The Intelligent Investor, Jason Zweig

Alternatively, John Bogle recommends "roughly your age in bonds". For instance, if you are 45, 45% of your portfolio should be in high-quality bonds. He describes the idea as just "a crude starting point" which "[c]learly ... must be adjusted to reflect an investor's objectives, risk tolerance, and overall financial position". He also suggests that you should treat any national or state retirement income you might receive as if it is a bond, setting its assumed value appropriately.[2]

This "age in bonds" and its variants, age minus ten years or age minus twenty years, are only approximate starting points. You will probably want to adjust them to fit your circumstances. For example, if you have a guaranteed state or other pension, this changes both your need and your willingness to take risk. Some investors do not add pensions and Social Security to their asset allocation of bond holdings.[4]

It is easy to underestimate risk and to overestimate your tolerance for risk. In 2008, many people learned too late that they should have been holding more bonds. Think carefully before choosing an asset allocation with high stock market allocations. If you have not been through a major market downturn before, your abstract logical thoughts about risk can quickly become emotional ones. The developing field of neuroeconomics explains how mental traits and emotional effects that work well in other areas undermine our ability to deal rationally with markets and investing.[note 1]

You should generally own bond funds instead of individual bonds, for convenience and diversification. Using individual corporate or municipal bonds require a very large holding to achieve the broad diversification and increased safety of a bond fund. The high number of different bonds in bond funds lets you ignore the risk of any one bond defaulting. You can manage Interest rate risk by choosing funds with short and intermediate-term duration, and default risk by choosing funds with high credit ratings. The idea here is for your bond holdings to reduce violent up and down swings in overall portfolio value. You want your risks on the equity side, not the bond side.

Aim to select an asset allocation that lets you sleep at night, and avoid the destructive urge to sell out in a panic the next time the market plummets, then having to worry over when is the time to get back in. This leads to selling low and buying high, the exact opposite of prudent investing.

You may be able to divide your bond allocations between just two categories: nominal bonds such as the Vanguard Total Bond Market Fund, and U.S. Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS) such as the Vanguard Inflation Protected Securities Fund. Inflation protected bonds provide both additional diversification and inflation protection.[note 2]

I-Bonds are also an attractive alternative to TIPS. You can buy them directly from the U.S. Treasury; you can buy them using your IRS tax refund; they do not need to be held in a tax-protected account; and they accrue interest tax-deferred for up to 30 years. There are annual limits on how much you can buy in I-bonds.


r/Bogleheads • • 17h ago

HSA allocation advice needed

1 Upvotes

41F, married with two children. We’re new to the HSA world and planning to use it as a long-term investment vehicle vs. relying it on for near term medical expenses.

Debating between:
Option 1: 100% FXAIX (S&P 500)
Option 2: 50% FSKAX (total U.S.), 30% FTIHX (international), 20% FXNAX (bonds)

For context, my 401(k) is in a Vanguard Target Date 2050 fund. My spouse’s and my Roth IRAs are invested in FXAIX. We also hold FXAIX in our taxable brokerage, where we DCA, so it feels like more international + bonds exposure for HSA is the right move.

Would you keep the HSA simple with FXAIX or use it to diversify a portfolio even more? Thanks in advance.


r/Bogleheads • • 18h ago

Looking for help with tax loss harvesting

1 Upvotes

I know, another tax loss harvesting post. But with the market down, I want to take advantage of the opportunity to tax loss harvest. And I am a noob that hasn't done it before.

I know there is no official guidance from the IRS but looking for verification based on what is considered best practices. I have a brokerage with VTI and VXUS that I want to harvest. A roth and HSA both with FSKAX and FTIHX. A 401k with a target date fund. A 529 for my child with NH TOTAL MARKET INDEX.

I plan to replace VTI/VXUS with ITOT/IXUS. Questions:

  • Do I need to worry about any of the other funds outside the brokerage for wash sale rules? If so, which ones? Or only VTI/VXUS in the brokerage? Again, to the best of people's knowledge.
  • Is there any risk to harvesting too much at once?
  • With dividends expected in December, how should I plan around that?

Any help is appreciated!