I tried Bread Dad’s Bread Machine White Bread – Soft & Buttery recipe in my Neretva bread machine, and honestly, the bread turned out really good!
I made a 1 lb loaf, used bread flour and bread machine yeast, and followed the recipe exactly. The bread rose beautifully, and the inside was nice and soft.
The only thing I’m trying to figure out is the crust. I used the lightest crust setting and took the bread out immediately after baking. Brushed some butter on it while it was still hot and covered it with a thin cloth for about 2–3 hours before slicing.
The crust wasn’t hard or thick, just slightly crispy, almost like toast, especially on the sides. I was hoping for that really soft sandwich bread crust.
I’ve now sliced it and stored it in a plastic bread bag, so I’m curious to see if that softens it overnight.
For those who regularly make milk or white bread in a bread machine, is this just how fresh homemade bread is supposed to be? Does the crust soften after sitting in a bread bag overnight?
Or is there something else I could do to get a softer crust without changing a recipe that otherwise worked so well?