r/CCW • u/thechriskarel • 16h ago
r/CCW • u/RTADefenseTechInc • 22h ago
Guns & Ammo 9mm Critical Defense is Not Good.
SUMMARY: While many have complained about setback problems, the 115gr Hornady Critical Defense has 2 other major problems:
- It possesses objectively worse terminal performance than many 9mm JHP cartridges—including a 40+ year old, heavily criticized design: the 115gr Winchester Silvertip.
- It's insultingly everpriced for the performance.
INTRO:
Unfortunately, the prevalence of Youtuber tests with petroleum-based clear ballistic gel (to include sub favorites like Lucky Gunner) have severely misled people as to the performance of certain ammunition.
I can't even begin to count the number of people who have insisted a cartridge is "GTG" and “meets the FBI minimum” because it penetrates 12-13” in a Clearballistics block.
Despite the manufacturer's claims to the contrary, Clearballistics 10% gel does not produce results actually equivalent to 10% organic gelatin (the stuff the FBI actually uses).
Hornady's own testing¹ found that handgun projectiles penetrated 35-48% further in the Clearballistics product than in real 10% gelatin.
¹(https://static.hornady.media/site/hornadyle/files/ballistic-gelatin-comparisons-1-3.pdf)
12” WHY?:
So why is there a 12 inch minimum recommended penetration depth for handgun projectiles from the FBI and IWBA?
To summarize in short, it is was a response to the 1986 Miami shootout, where a shallow-penetrating 115gr Silvertip provided less than satisfactory penetration (after penetrating only soft tissue and cloth) on Michael Platt’s body, possibly/likely resulting in the death of 2 FBI agents, and the severe wounding of 2 more, after the shot failed to perforate Platt's heart.
The belief was that a deeper penetrating projectile would be less likely to result in repeat incidents of this type.
How much does it matter that a projectile penetrates, at least 12 inches? That's up to you.
But if your reasoning for being confident in a particular cartridge is “it penetrates more than the FBI minimum” I'm going to assume it means something to you.
PROBLEM 1: THE PERFORMANCE
Despite Clearballistics gel tests that show 13 inches of penetration from the Hornady cartridge², testing in FBI calibrated organic 10% gel and heavy clothing shows the 115 grain Hornady projectile actually performs worse than much-derided 115 grain Silvertip that was used during the 1986 Miami shootout.
115gr Hornady Critical Defense in calibrated, 10% organic gel and heavy clothing³:
-11.25” penetration.
-0.57” recovered diameter.
-115gr retained weight.
115gr Silvertip in calibrated, 10% organic gel and heavy clothing⁴:
-11.60” penetration
-.57” recovered diameter.
-115gr retained weight.
Both projectiles expanded exactly the same diameter, retained exactly the same weight, and the Silvertip penetrated marginally further.
²(https://www.luckygunner.com/labs/self-defense-ammo-ballistic-tests/)
³(https://www.hornadyle.com/handgun-ammunition/9mm-luger-115-gr-ftx#!/)
⁴(IWBA 1996 Volume 2 Number 3.)
PROBLEM 2: THE PRICE
Despite performing slightly worse than 40-year-old technology, Hornady viciously overprices their product over both old-tech and new(ish)-tech JHP's.
Going by today's prices for cheapest shipped on Ammoseek:
115gr Hornady Critical Defense: 96 CPR
115gr +P+ Federal 9BPLE: 49 CPR.
115gr Speer Gold Dot: 55 CPR.
115gr Winchester Silvertip: 74 CPR
124gr +P Federal HST: 69 CPR
147gr Federal 9MS: 50 CPR
147gr Federal HST: 64 CPR
THE OBJECTION:
Of course, those taken in by Hornady's marketing department may have an objection:
“But the Hornaday has the patented flex-lock tip! A normal hollow point will clog and act like a FMJ!!”
Well, not only did the Silvertip not clog in IWBA heavy clothing testing, and it didn't show signs of clogging in real life shootings, either.
In 1986 Miami shootout, there were 4 wounds known or suspected to be caused by the 115gr Silvertip, all of which strongly suggest good expansion:⁵
- Platt Arm/Chest Wound B (Known, projectile recovered fully expanded)
- Platt Arm/Chest Wound C (Known, projectile recovered fully expanded)
- Matix Wrist Wound E (Strongly suspected, 1.5” x 0.5” diameter exit wound)
- Platt Leg Wound L (Unclear if 115gr Silvertip or 158gr LSWCHP. 0.5” diameter exit wound)
Projectile clogging is likely significantly overstated as an actual problem.
The perception of “unreliable” conventional JHP expansion is made worse by the prevalence of Clearballistics tests; projectiles expand significantly less⁶ in this test medium, even when they are known to expand well in 10% organic gel or tissue.
⁵(Forensic Analysis of the April 11, 1986, FBI Firefight Anderson, French).
⁶(https://static.hornady.media/site/hornadyle/files/ballistic-gelatin-comparisons-1-3.pdf)
CONCLUSIONS:
- Hornady 115gr Critical Defense is a step 40-years backwards in cartridge performance.
The bullet does not expand very large, and underpenetrates worse than the much derided 115gr Silvertip.
The performance is no better than, if not slightly worse than, the 115gr JHP designs of the 1980's and 1990's, yet costs more than some of today's best performing projectiles.
2. I'm not suggesting you carry antiquated 115gr JHP's like the Silvertip, Hi-Shok, or Hydra-Shok. But if you did, you'd save a lot of money, and likely wind up with better terminal performance to boot as opposed to Critical Defense.
If you're dead set on Hornady, the picture for this post is from gel testing of my last remaining 135gr +P Critical Duty. I no longer use it, but it is far superior to Critical Defense.
Or, you could just buy HST or Gold Dot, and it would still be cheaper than Hornady. I suggest that option.
r/CCW • u/Wind1nthePines • 18h ago
Getting Started CCW Day One
I’ve been shooting regularly for a few years and finally made the jump. IWB at 3 o’clock and it all but disappeared after the first couple hours. Felt good having that thang on me cause shit’s crazy out there.
HK CC9, Guerrilla Tactical Low Pro
r/CCW • u/slaylosh • 15h ago
Pocket Dump / EDC Wedding edc
Went to a wedding today this is what I carried how'd I do
r/CCW • u/AdequateMedia • 12h ago
Training Went 7 months only dry firing. 43x & eps carry
Just trying to motivate myself to get back into shooting regularly. I also I avoid it because it makes me want to own things I don’t need 🤣
r/CCW • u/Tropical_Tardigrade • 16h ago
Training Cold heat drill with full hands and some thoughts on pocket draws.
Figured I’d give another go at this drill and see how I’d fail. Ruger LCP against a cream cheese box sized target.
u/bigjerm616 asked me about how to get a quick draw regardless of hand placement in this post.
TLDW:
Consider your pocket shape, pocket holster shape, and any barriers blocking your access to your pocket opening.
Slanted/chino style pockets are tubes built for speed and aren’t as affected by long flannel shirt tails as jeans pockets are.
Put your whole body and mind into it: be target focused and envision your draw and presentation prior to enacting it.
Variables: I don’t have large hands, I wear my pants about 4” below my navel, and I like using super deep pockets (Duluth FTW!).
YMMV. Be safe and mind your booker hooker!
PS: maybe don’t use that OEM pocket holster for too long if you’re carrying with one in the pipe.
And yes, I know it’s time to rebuild my target stand.
r/CCW • u/whycantwehaveboth • 17h ago
Guns & Ammo I've been carrying a BG 2 off and on for a few months, I put 1K of WWB and exactly 50 rds of Critical Defense through it with absolutely zero issues before carrying. Now I put 100 rds of whatever's cheap every month, no failures. I am aware of the issues others have had.
Do y'all let the negative experiences of others effect your set up that's proven reliable?
r/CCW • u/KoreanworkerTX • 12h ago
Guns & Ammo I took the Texas LTC class and shooting qualification test today
I'm a Korean worker who arrived here in May this year, currently working as a welder at the Samsung construction site.
I really wanted to get the physical plastic LTC card as a personal trophy, so I took the class and test today!
I used S&W Equalizer 9mm
Since October 1, 2026, online LTC applications are only available through RSD, and I ran into an issue where I couldn't create a TxT account. When I reached out to RSD to ask for an alternative way to apply, it took two weeks to get a reply, and they told me I can apply by mail.
I really hope to get that card in my hands
r/CCW • u/Global-Olive625 • 3h ago
Other Equipment Vaultek Safes
Looking for reviews and or recommendations on a good nightstand gun safe. Just need something to keep the little one’s paws away. Currently looking at the vaultek smart station ds2i
r/CCW • u/Stantheman7409 • 5h ago
Guns & Ammo Failure to feed
Hello All,
I had three failures to feed when running federal Punch 124 grain. How do I tell if it's me or the Glock? I'm still a little inexperienced I've only shot 1k rounds thru my Glock so I'm relatively new.
r/CCW • u/dudeonhiscouch • 17h ago
Guns & Ammo HST 124 Grain vs 147 Grain?
I have a mix of both in my possession but I’m wondering which is actually better so when I cycle my current batch out which one should i replace it all with or does it even matter?
r/CCW • u/SpaceKaydet1941 • 7h ago
Guns & Ammo Bersa vs Taurus
Hi all! Wanted to hear from people who own/shot both brands. Recently i became very interested in the bersa thunder .380 simply because i like the way it looks, but i heard mixed things about them. I would like to know how they compare against taurus pistols, since i do have some experience with taurus, being brazilian. IMO taurus is the minimum baseline for fit/finish/reliability (not saying they are good, just saying that to me, they represent the floor of what i consider acceptable), so if bersa=taurus that should give me a good general picture about them. Hope everyone has a great day!
r/CCW • u/Routine_Business3409 • 13h ago
Holsters & Belts Guard her belt & Dene Adam’s thigh shorts
Has anyone tried the guard her belt by sticky holsters yet? It’s supposed to be the main replacement for the can-can concealment thigh garter holster. And I wanted to see what people thought of it in real life.
As for an older product, does anyone like the dene Adam’s thigh holster shorts where it’s on the inner thigh? Can you share your experience because, oddly enough, and as old as this product is, it doesn’t actually have many reviews which I think is kinda odd.
I’m getting into wearing more skirts and dresses and want to be able to conceal on body since that’s the safest.
r/CCW • u/Aethelric78924 • 11h ago
Holsters & Belts Which holster for a Beretta 92 and TLR1HL?
Hey everyone, I’ve had a Beretta LTT 92G Elite for a few years now and I finally picked up a wml. I used to carry it AIWB with a T1C Axis Elite, but discovered I don’t care for appendix carry.
Since I need a new holster to accommodate the light, I figured I’d see what your suggestions are for IWB strong side/4 o clock carry.
I’ve seen a few options and recommendations like the Phlster Floodlight 2, T1C Echo, JMCK, Odin Holsters Valknut.
Anyone have experience with any of these or holster recommendations for my setup?
Thanks in advance.
Legal I dont know what to do anymore and dont know if this subject even belongs here
So i went to a store today thinking itll be a normal day for me again, nope!
Im leaving the store...lets call it Bal-mart....and i have my grand daughter with me. A guy randomly starts following me to my vehicle. I know this because between my vehicle i went left 2 parking lanes, right one lane, left 2 lanes again then started towards the front of the store and moved a lane to get to my vehicle. My grand daughter, i love her....but she doesnt listen for anything. Im freaking out this entire time and instead of listening to my commands, she decides to play around. She is infront of me by 10 feet, running circles around me, behind me by 15 feet, decides to argue with me about the direction we are headed and in general doesnt listen at all. I told her this is serious and she needs to pay 100% attention to me.....like i said, she didnt. I finally get to my vehicle and toss her in the back seat as she is slow as heck doing absolutely anything you want her to. I climb in the front seat and lock the doors and start the car. The guy took a picture of my license plate and walked away, i had my firearm drawn but thankfully didnt have to use it. I called 911 but was told they had no officers who could respond and if i wanted to wait 2 hours for an officer to make a report i could, i declined and drove away.
How can i get it through a 5 year olds brain that when i say something is important and she needs to pay attention to do it. Of course i said a bad man was following us and her reply was "he doesnt look like a bad man". She thinks someone needs to look like a Disney villian to be a bad person.
I was excessively stressed and worried the entire time this situation was happening. What didnt help was her not listening. While i have been robbed in the past and have discharged my weapon during a confrontation in the past, i want to do everything i can not to do it again and i dont want my grand daughter seeing something like that.
I am thinking i cannot take her anywhere myself again and ill need to be with my husband who also conceal carries if i do go anywhere as 2 of us are less likely to encounter something like this than just myself and my grand daughter.
Would anyone know why the person following me took a pic of my cars license plate? Can they find my home address or other information from that?
Right now i dont know what the heck to do. She is 5, 100lbs so i cant lift her that easily and she doesn't listen to anyone.
Did i do anything wrong during this encounter? Anything i can do to prevent this kind of thing in the future?