r/CFB • /r/CFB • 27d ago

Discussion 2026 Coaching Carousel I: Showing 'Em The Doeren

I'm trying to free your mind, Wolfpack. But I can only show you the Doeren. You're the one that has to walk through it.

-Morpheus, The Non-Colley Matrix

That's right, it's time to get the ol' coaching carousel spinning again! We've got two head coaches down already but no reports of Grumors. Whose seat is the hottest? Who's taking their place?

58 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

38

u/RedditRedux Florida Gators 27d ago

NC State and Maryland need to work fast before Manchester United enter the carousel

9

u/tdatcher Navy Midshipmen • Sickos 27d ago

Marylands soccer coach may be poached lol

23

u/immoralsupport_ Michigan • Oregon State 27d ago

I understand why Doeren was fired but there’s like a 70% chance the next coach is the same or worse (90% if it’s Philip Rivers)

17

u/xkq227 Ohio State • Virginia Tech 27d ago

He can just fill all of the coordinator positions with his kids

9

u/HoBamaMo Alabama Crimson Tide • Sickos 27d ago

He could field both teams with just his kids.

4

u/ReachFor24 West Virginia Mountaineers • Team Chaos 27d ago

He could pack the stands with just his kids

9

u/jwb101 Georgia Tech • Kennesaw State 27d ago

Idk, how many of those coaches would get beat by Vanderbilt like Doeren did?

22

u/Capital-Flow-1501 27d ago

I'm sure everyone loves Philip Rivers but he can't be considered a serious candidate

8

u/tolvin55 /r/CFB 27d ago

(looks to Colorado).....I think you might be right

3

u/treegrowsinbrooklyn1 Florida Gators • Louisville Cardinals 27d ago

If you believe message board rumors (lmao) not only is he a serious candidate, he’s the guy

2

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

It’s driving me mad and I can’t read any of our media. You want to make it more likely you win 10 games and learn how to actually coach in-game…so you hire an alum because “he interviewed with the Bills, so obviously that means he’s ready even if his experience is all in HS.”

17

u/Status-Ad-7335 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 27d ago

Brent Key should start being in these conversations. Haynes King merchant

9

u/jthomas694 South Carolina • Ohio State 27d ago

He really lost a lot losing Faulkner, King and Philo.

4

u/jgtengineer68 Georgia Tech • Georgia Southern 27d ago

Eh not sure on Philo he's played the same for Florida he played for us in limited. The big issue is king and ol depth

2

u/Lefthook16 Alabama Crimson Tide 27d ago

You guys went hard after Pribula didn't you? From the outside it felt like after you didn't get him you didn't really have a Plan B.

1

u/jgtengineer68 Georgia Tech • Georgia Southern 27d ago

Not exaclty, we explored him but the biggest issaue we have is apparnely one of our boosters told key that he was willing to pay for justice haynes... and no one else.

4

u/jwb101 Georgia Tech • Kennesaw State 27d ago

Unfortunately our fan base is roughly split between money doomers(we can absolutely come up with the money to buy Key out when they start having the “oh shit the stadium is empty” moments) and the Key is a “Tech Man” and we need a tech man as coach. The rest are just at the stage of firing the coordinators again(our best DC left to the NFL to be a position coach) and having someone other than Key make the hiring decisions. Alpert needs to give Key a list or 2-3 coaches and say here are you options, they’ll work for me and work with you.

2

u/cmanonurshirt Georgia Tech • Arkansas 27d ago

If only the Panthers didn’t trust Kenny Pickett on the depth chart so we could see Haynes in the NFL…sigh

16

u/sneakypenguin94 Appalachian State • Wake Forest 27d ago

Long overdue for State fans. Did Shane Beamer buy himself a little more time yesterday?

18

u/jthomas694 South Carolina • Ohio State 27d ago

Between Florida, Tennessee, his buyout, the fact that they just bought out Manieri, and that they might have to buy out Paris - probably.

The final 5 games are - @OU, A&M, @Arkansas, UGA, @Clemson. 8-4 really isn’t out of the picture even if 7-5 is most likely. We’re not firing a HC with that buyout for going 7-5 IMO

4

u/ThompsonCreekTiger Clemson Tigers • Army Black Knights 27d ago

Yall are gonna beat Clemson like a drum this year

2

u/Better-Temporary-146 Clemson Tigers 27d ago

Only chance is our D stifling Sellers. 

But our D is great at man coverage, but we’ll need a spy or two on him. That will be the difference, and how beat up USC will be after Georgia (why are they playing UGa before Clemson? That makes no sense).

2

u/outthawazoo South Carolina • 日本大学 (Nihon) 27d ago

Y'alls front 7 is filthy, I wouldn't be surprised if our game vs. y'all looked a lot like our game vs. Tennessee yesterday, maybe lower scoring

1

u/ThompsonCreekTiger Clemson Tigers • Army Black Knights 27d ago

But our OL & offense in general is atrocious. Honestly some Clemson fan might as well do the uno reverse of the whole dogshit thing & eat 1 if Clemson manages to win.

15

u/jthomas694 South Carolina • Ohio State 27d ago

I really hope State doesn’t go after Rivers legitimately. It’s a good fanbase that deserves an actual coach, not someone who has never coached above the HS level

1

u/treegrowsinbrooklyn1 Florida Gators • Louisville Cardinals 27d ago

It’s what the fanbase wants though, at least based on social media

1

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

No, you see, his love for the university and “drive” will produce endless $$$ and overcome every single disadvantage even a good ACC school has and we will break college football.

Like, what non-Big Ten/SEC coordinators do people even have in mind when they say “he will raise the money to bring in the best assistants”?

I’m not trying to derail but I’ve not been this annoyed with our fanbase since Chuck Amato. Guess this is his revenge in death.

14

u/gogglesup859 Kentucky Wildcats 27d ago

North Carolina quietly produces a lot of 4/5 star recruits. The only states with more players in the 2027 Rivals Top 300 are Texas, Georgia, California, Florida, Ohio, Tennessee, and Illinois. There's really no excuse for one of UNC or NC State to not be consistently winning a minimum of 8 or 9 games and regularly making a 24 team playoff once that becomes a thing

9

u/Better-Temporary-146 Clemson Tigers 27d ago

Seven FCS teams, four in the ACC spreads the home talent around. Especially if schools from neighboring states recruit NC well too.

Clemson historically recruits the Charlotte metro area well, for instance 

8

u/lil_geesey NC State Wolfpack 27d ago

Those 4/5 star recruits are consistently getting recruited heavily by teams like Tennessee, Clemson, South Carolina, Georgia, Bama, etc. The hometown hero card only gets you so far when both programs have been equally mid for their entire existence

9

u/crackers780 NC State Wolfpack • Team Chaos 27d ago

Will Shipley is the player that comes to mind. Had almost an entire family that rooted for NC State but he chose Clemson in the end.

11

u/tolvin55 /r/CFB 27d ago

Neat but your missing a lot of context. For example big schools steal the top talent first. Nc state isn't convincing kids to stay over Bama, Ohio State, Penn State, etc.

Then UNC, Virginia, Duke, and WF come in with way more 💰 and can outbid the Wolfpack. Truthfully most of ACC can outbid the Pack. NC State is likely 8th or 9th in the pecking order.

And I say that having lived in raleigh for the past 20 years and married a state girl. I used to walk to the stadium to watch games. State has just not set themselves up to take advantage of that talent and when they do get some to develop....a bigger school can take them away

12

u/johndelvec3 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 27d ago

On paper Philip Rivers is genuinely an awful idea

6

u/Normal-Hornet8548 Air Force Falcons 27d ago

Trent Dilfer 2.0

Why hire Harry HighSchool as coach? Having played in the NFL doesn’t make one ready to be a P4 head coach with no college coaching experience.

I could see Rivers as GM, but head coach?

5

u/Long-Structure-6453 Oklahoma Sooners 27d ago

On paper...

0

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

The only argument for him as coach anyone seems to have that’s not subjective homerism like “no one is as committed to NC State” is that apparently the Bills gave him an interview. That’s it.

Amato passing this week plus this has very strongly reminded me that I don’t understand our fans and 75% annoy the crap out of me. Back then the argument to keep Amato after 2004 was all presumed unquantifiable intangibles, like “he clearly has passion and fire and loves this school!” Now the argument for Rivers is the same. And this is an ENGINEERING school…you’d think data would come up, even once.

8

u/CptCheese Tulsa • Washington State 27d ago

Welcome to the show, Baylor!

4

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 26d ago

I’ve posted these in the firing threads, but I’ll add them here.

Aranda is out at Baylor. This may be difficult times ahead for Baylor. Their head coach salary and (allegedly) their NIL spending ranks on the low end of the P4. They’ve got to get this coaching hire right. Here are some options.

Jeff Traylor (HC UTSA): given the limitations of the program, having a strong Texas recruiter with plenty of high school connections can pick up some of the slack. Traylor fits this mold. Plenty of high school success and a 70-27 career record has attracted plenty of attention. But he’s sitting on a nearly $10million buyout. He’s the ideal candidate, but he’s possibly out of reach.

G. J. Kinne (HC Texas State): a more attainable but higher risk option. Kinne has gone 27-19 turning around the Bobcats and has done so by running one of the most prolific offenses in the country. There’s still questions of whether he can win big games, but he will be a name to watch this cycle. He’s also got ties to Baylor: his dad Gary Joe was once a star linebacker for the Bears.

Shannon Dawson (OC/QB Miami): I’m truly lost as to how little attention Dawson has got over the past two carousels. He’s done some truly phenomenal work over the past few seasons. And he’s coached all over the state of Texas.

Brian Newberry (HC Navy): Newberry is having a down season this year, but still two 10-win seasons in four years at a service academy is a great record. His OC Drew Cronic’s wing T offense should be more transferable to other programs like Baylor (see Northwestern this season)- if of course he doesn’t get poached himself. Newberry seems comfortable at Navy, but he is a Baylor alum.

Maurice Linguist (Co-DC/DB Alabama): there are a lot of assistant coaches in the FBS who are Baylor alums. The one I will highlight is Linguist. A former safety for the Bears, Linguist has served under a ton of very good coaches: P. J. Fleck, Jimbo Fisher, Dan Mullen, Mike McCarthy, Kalen DeBoer, Jim Harbaugh, and has head coach experience as well (a 14-23 spell at Buffalo). Most insiders say he’s a top talent and potential P4 head coach in the making.

Other contenders include: Zach Kittley (HC Florida Atlantic), Blake Baker (DC LSU), Buster Faulkner (OC Florida), Jason Eck (HV New Mexico), Brent Vigen (HC Montana State), Charles Huff (HC Memphis), Mack Leftwich (OC/QB Texas Tech), Slade Nagle (OC Houston), Joe Klanderman (IHC/DC/S), Colby Carthel (HC Stephen F. Austin), Blake Anderson (HC Southern Miss), Kendall Briles (OC/QB South Carolina), Shiel Wood (DC Texas Tech), Spencer Danielson (HC Boise State), Shawn Bell (QB Houston), Josh McCown (OPGC/QB Minnesota Vikings), Trooper Taylor (AHC/RB Texas A&M), Mike Gundy, Garrett Riley (QB Missouri), and Glenn Thomas (Co-OC/QB Nebraska).

I expect a long search here, because… if USC pulls the trigger and fires Lincoln Riley, this would be a great landing place for him.

2

u/MuhMuhManRay Tennessee Volunteers 26d ago

What do we think about Gary Patterson for Baylor? He has plenty of experience coaching in the Big 12 and in Texas. He did wonders for TCU and sure his last few years there were subpar but looking back it kinda feels like one of those things where both parties involved just needed a fresh start. I still think he's a hell of a coach. I believe my main concern if I was Baylor would be how he'd navigate the current landscape of CFB because it's so drastically different than it was 5 years ago when he last was a HC.

1

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 26d ago

I don’t think Patterson will be a contender for three reasons. First, he’ll be 67 when the next season starts. That would make him the third oldest head coach in the FBS (after Belichick and Ferentz). Second, I don’t think he’s really cut out for this era. He wasn’t an exceptional recruiter in his day and focused on developing players over multiple years. That will struggle today, particularly at a program that doesn’t rank high on NIL (and Patterson himself has been openly anti-NIL). His recruitment strategy was being called outdated in 2020. And three, he’s making $2mil a year at USC where he gets to watch film and call plays and worry very little about recruiting, NIL, or player retention. From his perspective, I’m not sure if you want to give up that.

2

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago

I feel like Kinne still has the inside track here while they also bide their time a bit and see what bigger name who on the market becomes available… although the interim incumbent is making an interesting push.

1

u/Weird-Revolution2079 Florida Gators 25d ago

Keep my OC’s name out ya effin’ mouth!

4

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 24d ago

Sam Houston need a new coach. Longo is gone, and his replacement will have to manage a major rebuild. Here are some candidates.

Josh McCown (QB/PPGC Minnesota Vikings): probably a dream candidate, McCown is one of the most prominent Sam Houston alums in coaching. He’s considered a bit of a rising star, so I’m not sure if he would step down to college for what will probably be a hard job. But he could certainly give the program a boost.

Colby Carthel (HC Stephen F. Austin): Sam Houston likely can’t poach an FBS coach. If they want to bring in someone with head coaching experience, they will have to hire from the FCS ranks. Carthel is a good option. Only 50, the Texas native has over a decade of head coach experience with a 111-56 record, plus a DII National Championship. He shown an ability to win games despite considerable player and staff turnover- perfect for this new era of college football. His turnaround at SFA took a while though.

Matt Powledge (DC North Texas): another alum in coaching and a Huntsville native, don’t be misled by his current role. Powledge has P4 experience and a lot of Texas connections. It’s not uncommon for programs in the doldrums to hire a native son and hope success follows, but he maybe just a little too green for this role.

Chris Hampton (DC Oregon): two interconnected and vast coaching trees run through Huntsville: Willie Fritz’s and Ron Randleman’s. Plucking from this tree might be a smart move to harken back to previous successes. There are a lot of promising fruits on that tree, Slade Nagle, Shiel Wood, Rob Greene, Shawn Bell, but I’ll highlight Chris Hampton. Though he doesn’t have ties to Texas or Sam Houston, he is considered to be a rising star in the college ranks.

Shawn Bell (QB Houston): my outsider pick is Shawn Bell. A name probably not a ton of people have heard of, Bell is doing a great job this season improving both the yardage and efficiency of Conner Weigman. A native of Waco, Bell is a former high school coach who moved over to the college ranks in 2017. He might not be ready for an FBS job, but this could be a high risk, high reward option.

Other candidates include Slade Nagle (OC Houston), Shiel Wood (DC Texas Tech), Cody Hawkins (HC Idaho State), Seth Doege (OC/QB Arizona), Skyler Cassity (DC Oklahoma State), Brian Wright (HC Northern Arizona), Brent Vigen (HC Montana State), Patrick Toney (DPGC Atlanta Falcons), Mike Gundy, Garin Justice (AHC/Co-OC/OL SMU), Hugh Freeze, Bobby Discher (ST Ohio State), Mack Leftwich (OC Texas Tech), Tom Herman (AHC Florida State), Barry Lunney Jr. (OC/QB Illinois), Austin Armstrong (DC Houston), and Blake Gideon (DB/DPGC Texas).

1

u/Francis_X_Hummel Colorado Mines • Wyoming 22d ago

Todd Whitten HC Tarleton

4

u/I_am_the_darkness_99 South Carolina Gamecocks 11d ago

Shane Beamer has performed one of the most amazing hot seat disappearing acts of all time. If he wins 2 of the next 3 that's a pretty respectable season for a Gamecock team. And we got one of the best offenses in the SEC and one of the best at SC ever. So I am definitely hoping he has more success so that not only Beamer will stay and we don't have to start all over again but that Briles will stay for a while and build us up an offensive identity and attract top prospects.

4

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 5d ago

So what would a potential Phillip Rivers staff look like?? If the rumors are true and NC State are looking to hire the Pro Bowler, he’s going to have to build up a staff. So what would the staff of a man who’s never coached anything beyond Alabama Class 4A football? I am connecting Rivers’ entire network: people he has played with and played under, to see if there are enough people Rivers have worked with to form a staff. TLDR: yes, and- if NC State can land the targets- a pretty good one.

Priority number 1 for this hypothetical staff should be Rivers’ NC State teammate Clayton White (DC/ILB South Carolina), but he may not be attainable. A compromise could be some of White’s understudies, such as Travian Robertson (DL South Carolina) or Torrian Gray (CB South Carolina). Another possible coup could be Daronte Jones (DC Washington Commanders), who has extensive college experience and worked under one of Rivers’ mentors Norm Chow.

I’d expect another teammate, Jerricho Cotchery (AHC/PGC North Greenville) to be part of the staff in some capacity. Dovonte Edwards (S Sam Houston) could be an analyst.

We’ll start using college coach connections. Rivers played under some college coaches with big networks: Chuck Amato, Norm Chow, Doc Holliday. So we’ll start digging through these first. Brad Lambert (DC Marshall) could be an LB coach, as could Jordon Hankins (DC/LB East Carolina) or J. J. Clark (Asst. LB Dallas Cowboys), Geep Wade (OL Nebraska),Brett Ekkens (QC lol Arizona Cardinals) or Greg Adkins (Analyst South Carolina) could be OL coach. Pepe Pearson (AHC/RB Tarleton State) could coach RBs. Dallas Baker (WR Baylor) could coach receivers. Terrell Buckley (HC Mississippi Valley State), a close Amato protégée, could coach DBs.

Todd Stroud (Advisor Miami) will probably be hired in an off-field role. He’s held numerous roles at NC State.

But here’s the interesting part. Rivers’ QB coach during his acclaimed senior year was none other than Curt Cignetti. The two have remained close and allegedly Cig convinced Rivers to go into coaching. Rivers will likely look to Cig for suggestions. Names like Rod Ojong (DPGC/CB Indiana), Ben Harakel (Asst. DB Indiana), Jerrick Hall (DL Navy- an NC State alum), Alex Higgins (QC Indiana), Francis Meehan (QC Indiana), Cam Haney (CB Tulsa), Warren Messer (Nickels SMU), Marcus Hall-Oliver (Edge Fresno State), Matt Birkett (CB South Florida), Damien Wroblewski (Asst. OL Maryland), Anthony Leonard (DL Marshall), and Jim Chapin (OC/QB Central Michigan).

Adam Fuller (S Los Angeles Chargers) might be called back to college to be DC, but that’s a big ask.

Interim head coach Todd Goebbel will probably be retained as ST coach.

Having a seemingly ancient NFL career means Rivers also interacted with a ton of coaches and players who are now coaches. Brian Stewart (DC Middle Tennessee State) spent several years coaching the Chargers when Rivers was there. Former teammate and coach John McNulty (QB Michigan State) should be a favorite to join the staff in some capacity,

Nick Hardwick (Asst. OL Los Angeles Chargers), James Cregg (run game specialist LSU), or Chris Watt (Asst. OL Indianapolis Colts) could be an OL coach. Michael Spurlock (Asst. WR Ole Miss) and Kashif Moore (WR Penn State) could coach receivers. Carlos Polk (Asst. ST Dallas Cowboys) or Alex Bayer (ST Syracuse) could be special teams coordinator. Teammate Roger Cooper (ILB Illinois) could coach linebackers, as could Brandon Moore (HC San Diego) or Bobby King (ILB Philadelphia Eagles). Other teammates include Steve Gregory (DC Vanderbilt), Gabe Franklin (S West Virginia), Chuka Ndulue (Asst. DL Miami Dolphins), Dave DeGuglielmo (Analyst Stanford), Dexter McCoil (S Louisiana Tech), Brian Baker (DL Dallas Renegades), and Dan Shamash (Asst. TE Los Angeles Rams).

Expect recent Colts and Eagles staffers too given Rivers’ connections with those two head coaches. David Overstreet II (CB UCF) is a contender. Former Eagles OC Mike Groh is a possibility for OC or WR coach. There aren’t a ton of other coaches from this side of the network willing to drop (or have dropped) to college, but I’ll float Cato June (Asst. LB Indianapolis Colts), Brent Stockstill (OQC Indianapolis Colts), Tom Manning (TE Indianapolis Colts), Brian Bratton (WR Stanford), Tyler Scudder (Asst. LB Philadelphia Eagles), Allen Smith (Asst. Philadelphia Eagles), and Tyler Yelk (S Nebraska).

An off-field addition will likely be his brother Stephen, who serves as Philip’s assistant coach at St. Michael Catholic High School in Alabama.

Pther possibilities include Chris Wisehan (Asst. Eastern Michigan), J. C. Price (DL East Tennessee State), Scott Turner, Cornell Brown (DT Eastern Michigan), Will Burnham (Asst. ST Houston Texans), Brett Arkelian (Analyst Utah State), Shane Montgomery (OC Dartmouth), Tyler Haines (HC Catawba), John Hughes (Co-OC/OL Idaho State), Steve Shimko (QB Dallas Cowboys), Mike Goff (OL Birmingham Stallions), Mike Scifres (Specialists Arizona State), Steve Wilks, Andrew Dees (TE Cornell), Kavell Conner (DC/LB West Florida), Adrian McDonald (S/PGC UTRGV), Trovon Reed (CB USC), Addison Lynch (DB New York Giants), Phillips McGeoghan (HC Berlin Thunder), Jason Michael, Brent Jackson (DQC Arizona Cardinals), Chris Watt (Asst. OL Indianapolis Colts), Jeremy Bruce (QC Indianapolis Colts), Montgomery VanGorder (Asst. QB Philadelphia Eagles), Sean Desai (Asst. Cincinnati Bengals), D. J. Eliot, D. K. McDonald (DC/CB Kansas), and Roy Istvan (Analyst Florida).

Former teammate Byron Jerideau (Asst. S&T Georgia Tech) could be a favorite for S&T coach. Otherwise, S&C coaches will likely come from the NFL, with someone like Jonathan Brooks (Asst. S&C Los Angeles Rams).

4

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 5d ago

Who replaces Scotty Walden at UTEP?

Walden is put after going 6-28 with the Miners. UTEP’s football program seems to decline further and further, at this point testing near complete irrelevance. The Miners have achieved a winning season just once this decade, and stunningly haven’t won a bowl game since 1967.

I’m going to look for coaches with ties to Texas, high school links, and a, preferably, a link to the school. Here’s some names to know.

Colby Carthel (HC Stephen F. Austin): Walden was a FCS head coach originally from Texas. Usually ADs don’t try the same strategy after a coach gets fired, but I like selecting from the FCS here. Carthel is leading a top FCS program at Stephen F. Austin and has a DII national championship to his name. One difference between Walden and Carthel? Carthel is from *West* Texas. That can mean a big difference.

Todd Whitten (HC Tarleton State): a coach with over 150 career wins who coached two spells at UTEP, that’s going to get a phone call. Whitten is going to get several calls this season leading the Texans to an undefeated (so far) season. But he’s been head coach at Tarleton State for 17 years across three separate periods. And he’ll be 62 at the end of the season.

Mack Leftwich (OC/QB Texas Tech): on the opposite end of the spectrum is a coach half Whitten’s age. Leftwich played at UTEP during the Kugler years. He’s quickly worked up the ranks, currently leading the offense at Texas Tech. This could be a starting point for his head coaching career.

Kenny Perry (AHC/ST/RB Texas Tech): Perry has been a key part in Texas Tech’s resurgence under Joey McGuire. And, like McGuire, Perry has well over a decade of experience coaching high school football in Texas. He’s never called plays at the college level, but could serve as a CEO type coach similar to McGuire.

Jeff Grimes (OC Wisconsin): Given this individual’s… we’ll say “testy” reputation among many P4 fan bases, this is a good time to say that this list is candidates that I think will be considered for the job, not necessarily ones who would do well. We’ve seen in the past historically weak programs like Kent State, Akron, New Mexico State, and UL Monroe struggle to find head coaches, and it’s not often for their first few choices to turn them down. At a basement dweller like this, it might just be a case of who says “yes”. Former UTEP offensive tackle Jeff Grimes could be that person. He’s got ties to the program, he’s been an OC at four different P4 programs. He probably can raise the floor for a place like UTEP.

Other names to consider: Peter Rossomando (HC Lamar), Cody Hawkins (HC Idaho State), Brennan Marion (OC/QB Colorado), Jeff Banks (AHC/ST/TE Texas), Emmett Jones (WR/PGC Oklahoma), Clint Killough (HC UIW), Brian Wright (HC Northern Arizona), Kendal Briles (OC South Carolina), Garrett Riley (QB Missouri), Joe Lorig (ST/Nickels Oregon), Mike Bloesch (TE/RGC North Texas), Justin Johnson (AHC/WR/PGC Texas Tech), Jeff Nixon (OC/RB Syracuse), Shawn Bell (QB Houston), Philip Montgomery (AHC/WR Mississippi State), Tremaine Jackson (HC Prairie View A&M), Tony White, Todd Graham, Seth Littrell (Analyst Tennessee), Payton Pardee (ST/TE UTEP).

7

u/mayonkonijeti0876 Rose-Hulman • Louisville 27d ago

Is this finally the year Jeff Traylor makes the jump to a P4 Texas job? I have to imagine he's one of the top candidates for Baylor or TCU if it opens. I also think Texas Tech is a stealth candidate to be open this year if they dont make the playoff. Maguire has consistently had undisciplined teams and their red zone struggles are concerning

5

u/Young-Viiperr Texas Tech • Iowa State 27d ago

McGuire isn't the problem, dude has nailed every hire except OC and OL. Mostly a no-nonsense HC with occasional gaffs (like losing the last game in October every season). His teams improve significantly towards the end of the season.

Hire one even decent OC, and Oregon, Cincy/ASU would've been beaten these past 2 seasons. Mack Leftwich is in over his head, I'd take Lincoln Logs Brisket if LR is fired

1

u/mayonkonijeti0876 Rose-Hulman • Louisville 27d ago

That is fair. Maybe I am being to impatient, but they should definitely fire the oc if they dont make the playoffs

6

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

I am baffled as to how the alumni of an engineering school can be so in favor of a coaching hire backed up by zero data. Glenn Schumann would be my first call. You’d think “let’s bring some of what UGA has to NC” would also inspire donations, and it’s actually backed by results.

I don’t have high hopes that that’ll work out though, so my second call is to steal Jake Dickert.

4

u/nosoup4ncsu NC State Wolfpack 27d ago

$$$$ is extremely important also.

If a hire can attract more funding, that will carry weight. 

2

u/Pluff_Mudder 27d ago

Then hire him as the "GM" ala Andrew Luck at Stanford, don't make him your HC.

1

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

No shit. But the people pushing this act like that’s all you need.

Never mind that there’s a definite ceiling on whatever State can get. Where’s the proof that any of his prior NIL fundraising was at such a level that the potential talent would make quality coaching experience unnecessary? Has ANY school shown any version of this “maxx out spending on everything that’s not a HC” working? Bc if we’re going off vibes here like so many seem like they are, then the historical vibe around us doesn’t make me think we’re going to break college football and become the pioneer of this model (cause it sure isn’t working at CO).

1

u/nosoup4ncsu NC State Wolfpack 27d ago

I'm not advocating for Rivers , for or against. 

It could be great, or it could be a disaster. 

3

u/Phil_S2S Washington Huskies 23d ago

The NC State discussion has a wrinkle I find interesting: identifying talent and keeping talent aren't always the same skill.

If a staff recruits a lightly regarded player, develops him for two years, then he transfers and breaks out elsewhere, how do we judge that staff?

I'd want to look at both the development and the roster-building decisions, rather than giving all the credit or blame to one coach.

6

u/mayonkonijeti0876 Rose-Hulman • Louisville 27d ago

Calling my shot here, I think Rivers is the next head coach at NC State. NC State needs to excite their donors to get some more money, and he would do it. His son is also legitimately very good. People keep saying that NC State is the best opening available, but if they spend the same they did with Doeren, Baylor and Maryland are better jobs. They need something to get money into the program, and Rivers could take a lower salary so more money could be put towards NIL. I dont necessary think the Rivers hire would work, but this is the sell at least.

5

u/DeNomoloss NC State Wolfpack • Roanoke Maroons 27d ago

I find it maddening that we went from wanting a coach fired due to poor game prep and in-game adjustments…to wanting to hire a coach with no coaching experience because only NIL money matters and you need a big NFL name (how’s that working out in Colorado with a guy who’d actually coached an FCS team first?).

Talent, at least at an ACC level, has not been such an issue. Execution has sucked.

I’d rather not risk it on someone who once interviewed for a job in the NFL and that’s supposed to be enough to qualify him.

The obvious answer is making Rivers GM and hiring a good SEC coordinator.

7

u/Young-Viiperr Texas Tech • Iowa State 27d ago

Doeren has always been really good at identifying and developing players, especially in the portal era. NCST practically has become a talent pipeline for other P4 programs.

X's-and-O's have been underwhelming and prep, which is most infuriating.

6

u/nosoup4ncsu NC State Wolfpack 27d ago

Too good at developing.

Numerous guys that State recruited around 2020 particularly on the defense, played for 2-3 years, got coached up, and ran to the B1G and SEC for $$$

1

u/Phil_S2S Washington Huskies 23d ago

That's a good distinction. If State helped turn players into valuable transfers, that says something about identification and development—even if retaining them was another challenge.

I'd separate those questions when evaluating the next staff.

1

u/wallstreetbeatmeat3 27d ago

In no universe or timeline is Maryland a better job than NC State. Just having to live in MD makes it a worse job than just about anywhere. If they bring Philip in then I believe it’s going to be as a GM type role, I don’t believe Gunner is going anywhere else but if his dad ends up here helping in some capacity there’s no way he up elsewhere

0

u/mayonkonijeti0876 Rose-Hulman • Louisville 27d ago

Maryland is a Big 10 job, and once the 24 team playoff comes into play, you can go 8-4 and make the playoff

5

u/Benjilikethedog2 Lander • South Carolina 27d ago

So NC state has to be the best P4 job that has opened up so far.

Like just because they are in a good state to recruit and they get to play an ACC schedule is probably a lot easier to get into the playoffs than the Big 12 or B10

2

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 25d ago

Let’s talk replacements at NC State. This is going to be a bit tricky. NC State aren’t a huge power, but Doeren was decently paid. The Pack probably won’t have the first choice of the G6 and top coordinators, but there’s a bunch of possibilities to choose from.

Shannon Dawson (OC/QB Miami): Dawson has put up video game numbers in the ACC over the past few seasons. He has no ties to North Carolina, but knows the conference well. He’ll be a head coach soon. Why not here?

Zach Kittley (HC Florida Atlantic): NC State historically has not hired people with ties to North Carolina, so we should cast a wide net here. I’ll add the Texas native Kittley. He hasn’t quite done the turnaround yet at FAU, with a 9-10 career record so far, but he’s running a fun offense and got the Owls on track for a bowl season or better.

Phillip Rivers: his name has been floated for a potential NC State coaching job for several years now, and there does appear to be a vocal minority of fans pushing for this. Will it work? Probably not, but maybe it can be a Deion-like program boost for the program.

Scott Satterfield (HC Cincinnati): Cincinnati is 5-2 this year, and Satterfield is from North Carolina. In terms of both salary and buyout, Satterfield ranks near the bottom of the G4. He’s attainable, but in many ways he seems similar to Doeren.

Glenn Schumann (DC/ILB Georgia): Schumann’s stock has fallen a bit from his previous reputation as one of the best assistants in CFB. He was allegedly the favored head coach candidate at North Carolina before a certain former NFL head coach was hired. He could be a solid fit for NC State.

Joe Cox (Co-OC/TE LSU): here’s a non-Rivers wild card. Cox is a Charlotte native and a solid recruiter in the region. He’s never called plays at the college level, but he’s worked on a ton of staffs and could probably build a decent crew. But it may be too early for him.

Other possibilities include Buster Faulkner (OC Florida), Jamey Chadwell (HC Liberty), Clayton White (DC/ILB South Carolina), Billy Napier (HC James Madison), Mike Shanahan (OC/WR Indiana), Blake Baker (DC LSU), Tre Lamb (HC Tulsa), Tony Gibson (HC Marshall), Bryant Haines (DC/LB Indiana), Brian Hartline (HC South Florida), Lance Taylor (HC Western Michigan), Arthur Smith (OC NC State), Todd Goebbel (IHC/ST NC State), Jake Dickert (HC Wake Forest), Charlie Weis Jr. (OC LSU), JaMarcus Shephard (HC Oregon State), George McDonald (WR/PGC LSU), Matt House (OLB Kansas City Chiefs), Charles Huff (HC Memphis), and Jason Eck (HC New Mexico).

2

u/madmaley Cincinnati Bearcats • /r/CFB Dead Pool 20d ago

I think you meant to be put P4 instead of G4 for Satterfield

2

u/MinMadChi Rutgers Scarlet Knights 25d ago

I think that Rutgers is resisting the buyout for the time being and is looking to lock up a good reason by letting him play out the season before firing him. Rutgers has spent shit ton of money since joining the Big Ten, so any big expenses need to be handled carefully at this point.

2

u/PunishedLeBoymoder Stanford Cardinal • /r/CFB Promoter 23d ago

People are currently overlooking the NIU opening, are there any ideas on who they're going with

7

u/notebart 23d ago

Former NIU head coach Dave Doeren

2

u/Weird-Revolution2079 Florida Gators 23d ago

Napier to Baylor

2

u/Weird-Revolution2079 Florida Gators 20d ago

Actually, Napier to FSU now😂

2

u/PunishedLeBoymoder Stanford Cardinal • /r/CFB Promoter 18d ago

Rumors are swirling that Tosh Lupoi is done. I'd laugh so fucking hard if this was true

2

u/MuhMuhManRay Tennessee Volunteers 17d ago

I'll be very surprised if they fire him after 1 year

2

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago edited 12d ago

Baylor and GJ Kinne are in a very interesting dance. Part of a legendary Baylor family, he’s clearly at a level of candidate where he appears worthy of the Baylor job, but to Baylor’s defense, he’s not been good enough to be absolutely overwhelming to shut down the interview process, and the interim candidate might be stealing the support of those who didn’t want to wait to see what bigger names are going to become available.

What I will say, is if GJ gets passed by Baylor, I think this will for sure end the dalliance. I think GJ is getting hired this year regardless, and while it might not be by a job that’s Baylor’s level, he might sign a buyout that is prohibitive to anyone outside of the top 20 budgets in CFB.

I think that assuming someone is smart and poaches Dickert, Wake will be looking at GJ. I think that Tulane will definitely be firing Hall and looking at GJ.

2

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago

On the latest Phantom Island pod, Godfrey freely speculated that if Yurachek goes from Arkansas, Silverfield is likely to go after him (by little fault of his own).

Arkansas is probably the toughest scenario of any P4 except for the 3 true Northeastern schools (Syracuse, Rutgers, BC). They need a foundation, they need recruiting, they need regional emphasis, and it’s probably the most obvious case of “the fast way won’t work here” in the nation.

I think Glen Schumann is just the hyper-obvious fit here. He offers a knowledge from the best program builder in the country, who’s 2nd generation of the best program builder in history, all of his experience his SEC, and he’s got a Dallas background to get even closer to Arkansas. He’s only ever coached on teams with dominant trench play so you’ll assume he’ll disproportionally prioritize it, which is arguably important to the Arkansas culture of how the team is supposed to play. And he’s probably gonna bring no one with him, so he’s gonna have to do it the slow way.

Many ppl might push back on if Schumann should take this job, but the reality is that hasn’t happened already for Schumann. He’s been passed over several times and the way the industry is going is HC experience is everything. Arkansas is still an SEC job, and its location of being in his region of expertise might be more beneficial to his success than looking at an ACC or Big 10 job. He could see if TCU opens and has any interest, but if not, it’s probably time to pull the trigger.

1

u/LasixSteroidsAbx Georgia Bulldogs • Virginia Cavaliers 1d ago

Lanning and Brown both took HC positions outside the SEC and I assume Schumann would take the same path. And he doesnt appear to have 'the spot' he has his eye on like Kirby. He has been around a while so its clear he is waiting for a soft landing spot- a school that is not cash poor, has donor potential, good recruiting base, not alot of politics, reasonable expectations/sane fans, and a path to success. I am not sure any of the jobs open are this- Arkansas and FSU included. (UNC would have been great) But it seems that teams are favoring those with HC experience and not seeing alot of coordinator hires as of late.

1

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 13h ago

On Godfrey’s subscriber only podcast he said Schumman is seen frankly as a budget option by most major coaching searches in this cycle

1

u/LasixSteroidsAbx Georgia Bulldogs • Virginia Cavaliers 13h ago

He has it pretty good at UGA and we are happy to keep him.

2

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago

Also in Godfrey’s episode today for potential Michigan HCs, only the big game names, DeBoer and Chesney. DeBoer already a reach just flatly doesn’t seem possible while Russell is there.

If you’re gonna go Chesney, I’m curious if Will Stein is also a candidate they’d go all in on.

2

u/ShweatyPalmsh Tulsa Golden Hurricane • Oklahoma Sooners 6d ago

Do we think that Will Muschamp is going to get another shot at a HC gig this cycle? I think he’s grown a lot since his stint at Florida and SC and could put something together. I think we’ve figured out that Florida for one reason or another is a tough job and the South Carolina job is even harder. 

3

u/B1GTOBACC0 Oklahoma State • Arkansas 27d ago edited 27d ago

Who's next? It's gotta be one of Dykes, Aranda, or Lupoi, right?

Edit: It was Aranda

15

u/mcflymcdoofus Notre Dame Fighting Irish 27d ago

Lupoi? He isn't getting fired after 1 season. Aranda is dead man walking. Dykes is probably gone.

4

u/Set-Admirable West Virginia • Backyard Brawl 27d ago

Baylor or TCU needs to make the move quick. They are going to be competing from a similar pool of coaches. Whichever goes first is going to be in a better position.

4

u/usffan USF Bulls • Miami Hurricanes 27d ago

Moving quickly hasn't necessarily proven to be a path to success - see State, Penn. It's not like there's a giant pool of successful G6 candidates that are out there (Eck and... I guess Huff or JaMarcus Shephard? Only the former's on his 3rd school in as many years and the latter's only 7 games into his career). You could try to poach a sitting P4 coach (Dickert) or a coordinator (Indiana or Miami), but the Hoosiers haven't exactly looked stunning this year (maybe Bryant Haines - that defense has looked pretty legit) and is Miami more a product of having the most high priced talent or having good coordinators?

1

u/Young-Viiperr Texas Tech • Iowa State 27d ago

Cal never finished the signing or Lupoi's contract, so he could absolutely be canned year 1.

1

u/WHSRWizard Notre Dame • Virginia 27d ago

It's time!

1

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 18d ago

An update to any Last Chance U fans, Holmes County CC head coach Marcus Wood has retired from coaching. He took over Holmes in 2021, achieving three straight winning seasons, culminating with an 8-2 2024 that included a win over Buddy Stephens. But the Bulldogs went 3-6 in 2025 and 1-9 this season.

1

u/tdatcher Navy Midshipmen • Sickos 13d ago

I'm offering Dan Quinn any takers

1

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago

Wanted to just use this sound board some different thoughts here.

NCState: context I am in NC, so very familiar with the State fanbase. Look, I do not want to sound like a broken record of criticism, but I definitely am of what I think is the majority perspective that this is a deeply unserious choice. I get that Rivers has an aptitude that is a totally different level than Dilfer, and Dilfer’s biggest value add with elite 11 was a paper tiger. But still, there’s just so much to learn, there’s too much gimmick and athlete reliance at the HS level.

I just don’t understand, why if you really wanted to do this, you didn’t hire him as OC. Hire an upcoming and playcalling HC, and mandate Rivers as the OC as a key to the boosters. Is it a bad look for a coaching candidate? Sure, but it’s still better than the alternative of just taking the plunge. I honestly thought Buster Faulkner was going to be the NCState coach, and Rivers would have been a great right hand man. NCState is a good job, maybe even a better job than how they perceive themselves. And if Rivers is going to be insulted or not take the OC job, you could easily sleep at night knowing that he frankly would not be able to make the jump from HS coach to P4 OC at any other school either, you’re still offering him a massive inside track for a career jump ahead of schedule, and he’d still get to work with his kid.

1

u/LasixSteroidsAbx Georgia Bulldogs • Virginia Cavaliers 1d ago

I really dont get this either. All the benefits Rivers has as HC he has as OC. And you get time to learn to ropes and the program to learn his needs/strengths.

1

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago edited 12d ago

I think it’s interesting that Jeff Traylor’s value-add of deep ties to Texas high school football is probably way more valuable to an out-of-state school, maybe even a far away non-border state, that needs to rely on Texas recruiting, as a way to stay relevant and jump ahead of the Baylor, TCUs, Oklahoma State’s of the world.

This screams Colorado to me. Maybe a Big 10 school if like Minnesota or Purdue if their sitting head coach leaves. Arkansas could be an option, but I still think Arkansas priority will be to lock up their own state’s high schools first and foremost.

1

u/jalexjsmithj Oklahoma State • Wake Forest 12d ago edited 12d ago

2 interesting old heads and one less interesting old head. Dan Mullen, Jimbo Fisher, and Brian Kelly.

When I think about candidates, I always like to try and list out what that individual’s true value adds are and how big of a plus those are.

Mullen: Next level, truly great schematics. Probably closer to some of the other great schematic minds in the game but doesn’t get the pub because he’s not young or handsome. Obviously, recruiting / program building is a bit of a weakness.

Jimbo: Schematics is a plus, but inconsistent, and overall he’s got intensity issues. However, recruiting, talent evaluation, and fanbase & donor engagement is a big plus.

Jimbo’s gotta be getting a bit worried. This is probably the 2nd to last year he has outside of the game before he’s officially too far gone and too old where to get back in he’s have to be looking at mid-level Sun Belt jobs. If I was him, I’d be taking all in on this Maryland job. It gives him so much of what he needs to succeed, he’s going to be playing tons of opponents who are bigger deals with thr Big 10 schedule, it’s got that base of talent he can really use, it’s a regional fit, and Maryland could use a figurehead and public relations figure that would value making football fun again.

Now, if I’m Maryland, is Jimbo my first choice? Absolutely not, I’m going in on Dickert like everyone else is. Sell him untapped monetary potential, he wins at all on a Wake like budget, and all of a sudden untapped resources that have been apathetic for years and years become available.

But if I’m Dickert, am I loving Maryland? The budgetary differences between Maryland the rest of the Big 10 is about the same as what he’s facing Wake and the ACC, and there’s way less competency in the ACC. You’re already recruiting similar areas, and you know enough that Maryland doesn’t really have any brand presence at home anymore. It might be worth it to stay instead of rebuild. Hell, If Cal came open, assuming they match pay or get within 95%, isn’t that a better job than Maryland? The budget is way closer to your competitors, it’s maybe the most untapped potential donor market in the country, you get to stay in the incompetent ACC, and by way you (Dickert) already have West Coast experience. You might prefer it a as a place to live.

So now Maryland, is onto it’s 2nd choices. Jason Eck is gotta be interesting, but an energy and tone in common between Jimbo and Eck, and with Jimbo you get the name, and experience with high level talent & recruiting. Could be a fit.

Dan Mullen is a tough natural fit because I think he’s by far the best candidate to take over a functioning situation where they need a boost of upside. I think him and Michigan both missed each other last year where he would have been a fantastic bridge coach, but Michigan won’t hire 2 of those archetypes back to back. The best fired or potentially fired situation is definitely Baylor and Mullen doesn’t seem on that radar at all or a culture fit. I think the question becomes is Tulane a fit? Is it a big enough upgrade where it’s worth it for the move for Mullen? And is Mullen a name Tulane would be happy with, which frankly I think they should be.

Now… Brian Kelly. I understand that BK is a winner and honestly won everywhere he’s been. But, I gotta ask, if we assume that winning is an output, what are his value-add inputs that make you confident in him? Is he schematically excellent on the defensive side of the ball? Hard to say yes when Freeman has gotten so much of the credit for ND defenses at the end of the Kelly era. It feels like it’s Rutgers or bust for BK, and if I’m Rutgers, I get going for a floor raiser, but we saw with Schiano that a floor raiser will deteriorate with time without a ceiling season. I think I’d want to go with a younger guy with more upside just to break the malaise.

1

u/CFBCoachGuy Georgia Bulldogs 10d ago

Furman seems to be closing in on a candidate for next season’s head coach: former East Carolina coach Mike Houston. Houston, a current volunteer assistant at Clemson, has a 51-17 record as an FCS head coach, and won a national championship with James Madison.

1

u/roguebandit1 Duke Blue Devils • Florida State Seminoles 10d ago

Lots of buzz now about Willie Fritz being the next FSU head coach. What do y'all think? I think it could be a good stability hire, especially if he brings Keishawn Henderson with him.

1

u/justintrenell Michigan • Bethune-Cookman 6d ago

So we've just fired Woodie and have brought back Alvin Wyatt to finish out the season.

I would advise y'all to watch just for the fits.