r/CFB • Oregon Ducks • Michigan Wolverines • 13h ago

News [Brett McMurphy] Ohio State's loss guarantees preseason No. 1 team in @AP_Top25 poll will not win the national title for 21st time in last 23 years

https://x.com/Brett_McMurphy/status/2124241438959702453?a=zu-ARV0goy5LVPvD_R8&s=20
2.7k Upvotes

233 comments sorted by

853

u/prismatic_lights Ohio State • Pittsburgh 13h ago

And even the last one to do it (2017 Alabama) didn't go wire-to-wire as #1.

417

u/Kinks4Kelly Holy Cross Crusaders 13h ago

Only 1999 FSU and 2004 USC have gone wire-to-wire IIRC.

164

u/FunkoPopDude 13h ago

coincidentally college football got way more entertaining after 2004

117

u/Flameosaurus Texas Longhorns • Sickos 13h ago

Yeah the 2005 season was pretty cool

7

u/JayMerlyn Notre Dame Fighting Irish • FBS Independents 9h ago

I preferred 2006

→ More replies (4)

3

u/itsabearcannon Vanderbilt • Georgia Tech 5h ago

Really? UGA part two a few years back didn’t go wire to wire?

Could have sworn they did.

5

u/ImmNottCurious Georgia • Illinois 5h ago

they dropped (well technically it was the first CFP rankings of the year) us after Tennessee beat Alabama. We then reclaimed it after destroying Tennessee at home.

3

u/itsabearcannon Vanderbilt • Georgia Tech 5h ago

What horseshit. I’m sorry, I’m of the opinion that you leave the defending champ at 1 until they lose

2

u/ImmNottCurious Georgia • Illinois 5h ago

it's whatever, didn't matter at the end anyways. People remember b2b nattys more than wire-to-wire #1

70

u/Paulbegalia Wake Forest • Georgia 13h ago

2016 Bama was painstakingly close until Renfrow’s TD

27

u/RogueHippie Alabama Crimson Tide • Team Chaos 12h ago • Heartwarming

Literal last second, man. It was a fucking pick, I'll say it 'til the day I day.

13

u/jdk2087 Clemson Tigers • Oklahoma Sooners 11h ago

I swear to god Bama fans will hold on to that until the day they die. I loved our series and competitive games. But, the play was fine or it would have been called. The amount of pick plays that are actual pick plays that get called is virtually 0%. Plus, pretty sure our guy was just running his route and the defender happened to run into him. Not his fault the defender fucked up.

All that aside. All of our natty games against each other have been spectacular aside from 2018. I loved our match ups when we were both top tier.

9

u/RogueHippie Alabama Crimson Tide • Team Chaos 8h ago

Of course I'm gonna hold onto it forever, it's cfb. We're supposed to be petty.

They were such good fucking games, man.

2

u/jdk2087 Clemson Tigers • Oklahoma Sooners 8h ago

Very true. 100% agree with you.

1

u/dankenascend Auburn Tigers • North Alabama Lions 8h ago

It was supposed to be a pick, but the defender engaged him to jam before he had the chance.

1

u/JohnnieTightLips Wake Forest • Ohio State 12h ago

Your playoffs is about to be fun

1

u/OnionFutureWolfGang Notre Dame Fighting Irish 5h ago

That team was insane through the regular season. Dominated a really tough schedule. They were getting a defensive TD basically every single game.

229

u/Zloggt Illinois Fighting Illini • Missouri Tigers 13h ago

The Buckeyes can still win the national championship if, uh, whoever’s pulling the strings these days has the courage to do what it takes…

46

u/Kapono24 Michigan • Central Michigan 12h ago

Serious question, because we may as well start now, but this team still makes the 24-team playoff, right?

22

u/LilBushyVert Miami Hurricanes 12h ago

Absolutely

17

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

Not after they lose next week

6

u/Kapono24 Michigan • Central Michigan 12h ago

I think they do though.

3

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 11h ago

At 7-5 slumping so hard after losing sayin with a clear SEC committee ranking bias?

Na

→ More replies (4)

4

u/transuranic807 Ohio State Buckeyes • UAB Blazers 10h ago

Ya that so totally doesn’t feel right to me… probably an unpopular opinion, but having eeked into playoff a couple times we did not belong there and ended up getting a housed, I really don’t want to be in unless we really earn it.

4

u/Kapono24 Michigan • Central Michigan 9h ago

I appreciate the assessment but even with the four team playoff there's been teams getting fucking smashed. Realistically there's like six great teams any given year, usually fewer. But that's how silly the 24-team playoff is where OSU would still likely make it.

79

u/Original_Profile8600 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

If we were Alabama the committee would rank Nebraska top 20 and bump us up a spot

22

u/Fletch71011 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 12h ago

Just one? You're being too nice.

Nebraska is 18th in FPI and you lost by 3. They get 3 for being home. Technically this is a tie in the metrics lol.

You shouldn't be punished that badly but you sure will be.

7

u/somehype Nebraska • Sacramento State 11h ago

Someone had to be the ranked team to get that fucking monkey off our back

51

u/comradewilson Alabama Crimson Tide • Florida Gators 12h ago

Poor little OSU never catching a break

47

u/JohnnieTightLips Wake Forest • Ohio State 12h ago

I dare you to name one time the committee favo….i dare you to name two…..I dare you to name 6 times the committees favored osu in their final rankings

10

u/AlphaH4wk Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 10h ago

They're easily the second-most coddled team in the nation

Still quite a bit behind Alabama though

1

u/yureadmahpost Nebraska Cornhuskers • Doane Tigers 12h ago

You know what, I'll allow it.

5

u/cyberchaox Rutgers Scarlet Knights • Landmark 9h ago

The Buckeyes' chances literally aren't zero yet; there's still a scenario where they can make the CCG to get the autobid.

7

u/Stags304 West Virginia Mountaineers • Paper Bag 12h ago

Yeah I don’t get this tweet. The playoff is selected by a committee. Every team is still eligible for a natty

4

u/InitialYoghurt5138 12h ago

Well the VP did go there, but I think he's on the outs with the president because he mentioned things might not be all winning

1

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

How many tattoos will that cost?

673

u/Miserable_Jacket_129 Nebraska Cornhuskers 13h ago • Bravo

You’re welcome.

105

u/it-is-just-a-game Miami Hurricanes • UNLV Rebels 13h ago

I hope you guys right the ship soon and we play each other more often.

97

u/Orion14159 Kentucky Wildcats • Sickos 13h ago

Miami/Nebraska would turn out so many "what year is it?!" memes

24

u/Miserable_Jacket_129 Nebraska Cornhuskers 12h ago

What’s old is new again. The 90’s are BACK!!!

6

u/LightningDusty Florida Gators • Orange Bowl 12h ago

Consistent 10 win seasons and being a serious SEC contender? Fuck yeah!

11

u/Miserable_Jacket_129 Nebraska Cornhuskers 11h ago

Let’s roll Gator bro.

3

u/LightningDusty Florida Gators • Orange Bowl 11h ago

I'm actually a pretty young fan who unfortunately didn't get to enjoy Florida football in the 90s. What's funny is that I have a 1996 Fiesta Bowl hat that I randomly got around a decade or so ago. I don't remember exactly where or why I got it, but I just figured that a hat about Florida being in the Fiesta Bowl was cool. I guess at the time I didn't know about the absolute ass whooping we received in that game.

3

u/goldhbk10 Miami Hurricanes • Washington Huskies 11h ago

This sub would meltdown at the 90’s U 💯

4

u/Miserable_Jacket_129 Nebraska Cornhuskers 10h ago

Imagine running back the 94 NCG.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Miserable_Jacket_129 Nebraska Cornhuskers 13h ago

I love some Cane/Husker action!!

1

u/Quikstar Nebraska Cornhuskers • Miami Hurricanes 11h ago

Same!

6

u/CowboyMustacheFace Ohio State Buckeyes 13h ago

Extend Matt Rhule!

2

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

Please! Then give Ryan day a longer extension!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Quikstar Nebraska Cornhuskers • Miami Hurricanes 11h ago

I'm conflicted but also want this!

14

u/javascript Tennessee Volunteers 13h ago

🫡

7

u/bigstu_89 Ohio State Buckeyes • Dayton Flyers 7h ago

Thanks for making sure I don’t have to watch this garbage team in the playoffs

1

u/justsumjackass Kansas State Wildcats • Kansas Jayhawks 5h ago

This is the first time you've won that I'm mildly happy about.

1

u/not_here_nor_ther Ohio State Buckeyes 5h ago

Ohio state guaranteed this weeks ago

1

u/FunkoPopDude 13h ago

first big Nbraska win since 1997

3

u/Bartman383 Nebraska Cornhuskers • /r/CFB Brickmason 8h ago

This is Eric Crouch Black 41 Reverse erasure.

→ More replies (10)

140

u/NaaNbox Georgia Bulldogs • Indiana Hoosiers 12h ago

I’m genuinely not hating, can someone more familiar with the program please explain to me how OSU has just folded after losing Sayin? Like, they are just about the last team I would expect to roll over after losing a starting QB since they are so loaded everywhere and more importantly, the most consistent program year to year since Saban’s retirement. Is it just because this is the chaotic everyone sucks year? My flabbers are gasted.

116

u/Noobtastic14 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

My opinion is that we held out pretty well in the NIL era but destiny comes for us all. Talent isn’t getting hoarded by a handful of blue bloods anymore. Kids would rather get paid to start at a smaller school than sit on the bench at a big school. There just isn’t any “depth” that we were used too in the good’ol days. That’s also why this year is so chaotic, NIL brought parity back to CFB.

12

u/Spencer1K Alabama • Florida State 8h ago edited 8h ago

No team in the nation has a deep bench like what the top used to have. Injuries will majorly fuck any program now. Its increased the parity at the very top because of it. Im sure many fans like that.

The negative side effect is the g6 schools get all there talent siphoned away. Thats one major reason they were a combined 3-76 to p4 schooled before this week. All that talent just gets absorbed upwards. This is good for the players, really bad for the g6 schools exposure in the FBS.

2

u/Bartman383 Nebraska Cornhuskers • /r/CFB Brickmason 8h ago

Were G6 schools winning against P4 at a higher rate pre-NIL?

8

u/Spencer1K Alabama • Florida State 8h ago edited 8h ago

pre nil modern era they hovered around a 20% winrate. They are less then 4% winrate this season, and we have seen a slow decline in winrate since NIL era started.

32

u/Unhappy-List-2354 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Georgia and Notre Dame are doing great. 

UNLV and Utah are loving life. 

23

u/ClaudeLemieux Michigan Wolverines • NC State Wolfpack 11h ago

UNLV…loving life

They’re 6-4

10

u/Unhappy-List-2354 Ohio State Buckeyes 11h ago

That should be UCLA!

But they’re down now! 

1

u/ClaudeLemieux Michigan Wolverines • NC State Wolfpack 10h ago

ahh yeah makes more sense

2

u/Adams5thaccount Boise State Broncos • UNLV Rebels 9h ago

No the typo also makes sense. Very happy to be 6-4. Very happy to actually think we should really be like 8-2 but we blew it a couple times.

I think you and those who agreed with you have already forgotten that we've only dragged ourselves out of the bottom 5 all time win percentages over the last 5 years. This only marks the 6th bowl eligible season in the current century. And the 4th in a row.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Far-Veterinarian104 Florida State • Tennessee 9h ago

Kirby Smart and Marcus Freeman are unfathomably good at retaining players.

4

u/JoeVonHoff 4h ago

The type of player that wants to go to ND in the first place and can meet the academic requirements probably cares about more than NIL money. Freeman is also a player’s coach. It’s not that big a mystery.

6

u/Unhappy-List-2354 Ohio State Buckeyes 8h ago

Kirby Smart is unfathomably good at winning games. 

Marcus Freeman is unfathomably good at counting to 10 but not anything higher. 

4

u/Flioxan Notre Dame • Jeweled Shillelagh 7h ago

Uh what?

5

u/Unhappy-List-2354 Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

The 10-man play vs Ohio State. 

5

u/Flioxan Notre Dame • Jeweled Shillelagh 7h ago

Oh lol yea thats rough.

I thought you meant wins and was confused

9

u/smpennst16 12h ago

I mean you could say the same about Ohio state until this year lol…

They have been more consistent but could easily have 3-4 loss season in the next few seasons. It’s much more likely for a great program with a great staff to have a “down” season now than before.

You guys also just won a natty more recently than the teams you mentioned.

-15

u/ThreeLeggedMarmot Michigan Wolverines 12h ago

Thank God.

Now that everyone can pay, who the fuck would CHOOSE to live and attend classes in Columbus Ohio.

23

u/Fedoras-Forever-Mom Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Columbus is actually a great city lol. I don’t live there anymore but never got why folks talk about it like it’s some po dunk town.

4

u/FunRich1804 Florida Gators 8h ago

You've gotta love Michigan fans who still think Rashaan Gary went there for free after turning down $300k from Clemson.

5

u/Lpeer Michigan Wolverines 11h ago

Honestly, it's probably the best city in Ohio... I hate to say it, but Columbus is pretty wonderful.

1

u/NoBreadsticks Ohio State • Cincinnati 7h ago

The absolute disrespect to Cincinnati

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sylli17 Washington Huskies 9h ago

Everyone thinks something like that. But everyone has a different style, flavor, taste, background, etc. Ultimately, though, a lot of these kids are going to be going where they get paid best.

72

u/bringbacksweatervest Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

We weren’t that good of a team anyway. The offense was all Jeremiah Smith before Sayin went down and we haven’t found anything after either. Offensive line cost us a shot at a championship last year and we didn’t get anyone in the portal and we didn’t get a new line coach.

The defense wasn’t fantastic before either, turnovers and Arch’s indecisiveness made them look good for 3 quarters against Texas. Otherwise they’ve been average at best all year.

That shit was gonna catch up to us at some point with or without Sayin.

22

u/justjoshingu Texas Longhorns • Texas Tech Red Raiders 11h ago

The thing that helped texas the most was making ohio state look amazing before coming back and beating them. Lol

7

u/Jepordee Ohio State Buckeyes • Ohio Bobcats 8h ago

The answer is Arthur Smith and Matt Patricia. Idk if you could dream up a worse coordinator duo lol

1

u/OnionFutureWolfGang Notre Dame Fighting Irish 5h ago

How was Patricia's defense so good last season and then so bad this year though? Was it all Downs/Styles/Reese?

2

u/Naive-Elephant-9305 Georgia Bulldogs 2h ago

The talent they had last year was ridiculous, even by Ohio State standards. Any decent defensive coordinator would have absolutely cooked with those guys.

8

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 11h ago

Finally an honest take by someone with that flair. It's appreciated.

I am a massive fanboy of #4 too but what you said is so true. He might be one of the best players i have ever seen.

14

u/tronovich Hawai'i Rainbow Warriors 10h ago edited 10h ago

I think OSU fans are being realistic with their criticisms - people just aren’t buying it, almost as if they think it’s self-deprecating analysis.

Everyone’s wants the fans to focus their hate on Fahey, when he’s far from the issue.

7

u/transuranic807 Ohio State Buckeyes • UAB Blazers 10h ago

Ya, Fahey held up his end of the bargain, at least certainly as much as you could ask for from a true freshman unexpectedly thrown into those games

3

u/Geno0wl Ohio State • Cincinnati 8h ago

He isn't winning games, but he hasn't really been the reason they are losing either

31

u/Original_Profile8600 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Because the problem was never our quarterback, it was our defense. Texas had a wild drop that led to a pick in the first quarter before scoring 20 in the fourth. Josh Hoover overthrew many recievers, and Buckeye that watched that game saw it. We've given up over 120 points in the last four games, what changed is our defense finally stopped getting lucky

10

u/Fedoras-Forever-Mom Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Honestly I think the offense being more consistent just hid more of the flaws with our defense. When teams aren’t worried about having to keep up with our offense they can scheme better calls without worrying about how many times they’ll get the ball

16

u/spankboy21 12h ago

My understanding is that their intended second string qb is a bust, and losing sayin just killed the teams motivation

27

u/leave_no_crumb Missouri Tigers 12h ago

That’s a 30 million dollar roster. If they quit, then they deserve the hate from the fan base.

18

u/Borrominion Ohio State Buckeyes • Penn Quakers 12h ago

Fahey has been 2nd string since fall camp and he’s played fine, imo. At least he’s not been the main reason for the regression.

11

u/lkn240 Illinois Fighting Illini • Sickos 12h ago

Main reason is the defense being the worst OSU defense I can remember in a long time

2

u/Safe-Show-7299 Ohio State Buckeyes 5h ago

Definitely the worst since that one year where Purdue scored like 60 points on us during prime time

-5

u/Busy_Appearance4982 Tulane Green Wave 12h ago

Is your standard of QB play just being better than literally handing the other team the ball?

I mean sure there is worse out there and today was on the D, but Fahey has not looked like a guy that should get snaps ever at a high level school.

12

u/Borrominion Ohio State Buckeyes • Penn Quakers 12h ago

He completed 60% for 260 yards, 2 TDs and one pick that should have been caught (and also called incomplete). We have much bigger problems.

2

u/OhYa2021 Ohio State Buckeyes • Ohio Bobcats 10h ago

Fahey has made less “why did he do that?” turnovers than Julian. Not even sure if Fahey has any of those? Julian was good for about per game.

15

u/StreetReporter Clemson Tigers • Cheez-It Bowl 12h ago

I thought it was because they hired a bad OC and Matt Patricia is a bad DC

3

u/ToothPickLegs Ohio State • Bowling Green 11h ago

Arthur Smith still rides the one good year of being an OC with Derek Henry and a good offensive line

1

u/Mottled_Paws Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

Just say you understand noth6

11

u/MidlandsBraves Clemson • Wake Forest 11h ago

NFL fans tried to tell the world Patricia and Arthur are football terrorists but Ohio state fans refused to listen.

10

u/TheFAKEcampbell Ohio State Buckeyes 10h ago

Our defense was really really good last year, and before injuries it was looking good this year. The second we lost a few guys the floor fell out though.

9

u/Mottled_Paws Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

We had 4 1st rounders. I wondered back then if that wasn't the real reason for the success.

2

u/Decent-Recognition98 Ohio State Buckeyes 5h ago

I don't think OSU fans have that kind of say in hiring decisions

2

u/TheRoyalJuke Ohio State • Kent State 8h ago

Tbf a large portion of the fanbase was saying the exact same thing when they were hired, but post 2024’s surprise championship, there was a big “Trust Day” push. Then we looked pretty good last year and it seemed to shut the naysayers up for a while. But they’ve always been there.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/decodezilla 12h ago

Sayin’s injury crippled the offense and put too much pressure on a mediocre defense that couldn’t handle it

2

u/Britton120 Ohio State Buckeyes • The Game 10h ago

The osu team from a couple years ago had an incredible amount of talent that has moved on over the last two seasons. Especially on defense. Add to it that osu has been struggling in both trenches and it becomes difficult to control games. This is before considering injuries.

2

u/dirty_old_priest_4 Virginia Tech Hokies 7h ago

You're right. My old mom could just throw every time to those receivers.

1

u/Excellent-Gur-8547 Vanderbilt Commodores • Penn Quakers 13m ago

What about your new mom?

3

u/SocialRemedial Ohio State Buckeyes • Arizona Wildcats 12h ago

OSU had a historically great defense last year which resulted in an obvious exodus of talent to the NFL. This team was always going to rely on its offense more than its defense against a gauntlet of @Texas, @Indiana, @USC, Oregon. 9-3 seemed like a real possibility. Cut to: losing both QB1 Sayin and RB Ja'Kobi Jackson. Now OSU is wet-behind-the-ears on both sides of the ball.

However, despite the defense starting anew, giving up as many points as they have to USC, Oregon, and Nebraska is inexcusable to most fans.

5

u/ThreeLeggedMarmot Michigan Wolverines 12h ago

The real answer is they were never that good to begin with, and it didn't have a lot to do with the QB. Indiana is not that good either. Look at what's going on in Washington right now, and they almost lost to us if we simply made a few chip shot field goals. The Big Ten is not very good this year, sadly.

3

u/JohnnieTightLips Wake Forest • Ohio State 12h ago

The Texas game should have been a warning sign. Everything went wrong for Texas and right for osu for 3 quarters and they lost

2

u/smpennst16 12h ago

Top is very down but you could easily say the same about every team aside from Georgia in the sec. All these teams are losing to the middling to bad conference teams that 3-4 years ago they handled.

Also struggling in a game is normal. I’ve seen so many future title teams lose to “lesser” teams before that it really doesn’t mean much.

I do agree that Indiana doesn’t look the same but are still easily a top 10 team. Winning games matters and win you take almost all of them it’s impressive.

1

u/Ironredhornet Michigan State • Saginaw V… 10h ago

Their defense isn't good this year. Rough offensive performances by IU and Texas masked it for a bit. Lpsing Sayin means they have a harder time getting it to Smith, and they also lost RB1. Also Matt Patricia defenses have difficulty with mobile qbs at times which are very common in college.

1

u/transuranic807 Ohio State Buckeyes • UAB Blazers 10h ago

Agree. There is something underneath the hood. It was evident to me in watching facets outside of quarterback just start folding. Mindset, team cohesion, coaching or all the above. It is deeper than a qb issue for sure. Fahey held his end of the bargain IMHO

1

u/OhYa2021 Ohio State Buckeyes • Ohio Bobcats 10h ago

Ive watched all the games. Fahey has made a few errors. Id say no more than Julian this year tbh. I think this mostly falls on Arthur Smith and he will really have to sell Day on keeping his job next year. Something about Arthur Smith’s offense just feels off. Playcalls are mostly conservative. The team just seems like theyre not cohesive as a unit. Maybe someone with more football knowledge can speak to that.

The talent and aggressiveness of our defense has declined too. For all of Igbinosuns PI’s and holding calls he got on defense, he always seemed to be a leader at his position, and always played with a chip on his shoulder. Just not seeing anyone with that tenacity on D this year. That said, I think Patricia has done fine with what he has to work with. It’s mostly been the offense putting the defense in really tough situations.

1

u/ORdeadhead2 9h ago

My take is the team wants a different QB and are playing like shit in protest.

1

u/StopScreamingItsFine Georgia Bulldogs • Billable Hours 7h ago

NIL.

Backups aren’t exactly getting paid a lot to be at a school and if they are they’re not a backup.

1

u/Jaded_Platypus_6576 Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

I don't know, go ask Curt Cignetti

1

u/thatoneguyD13 Ohio State • Rutgers 7h ago
  1. Injuries. Not just Sayin, we've lost a lot of players this year.
  2. Inexperience from a lot of our starters. Especially on defense.
  3. Offensive coaching staff shit the bed after the loss of Hartline.
  4. Defense has been bad. Early in the year i chalked that up to #2 but it's not improved.
  5. Several offensive future stars have not panned out yet.

Maybe with Sayin we're 9-2 and still have a shot at playoffs but we're not winning any playoff games.

36

u/WhaleQuail2 Pittsburgh Panthers 13h ago

“Gaurantees” - the committee now sees this as a challenge

3

u/cyberchaox Rutgers Scarlet Knights • Landmark 9h ago

It's literally not a guarantee yet. They haven't been eliminated from Big Ten title contention.

635

u/allisthepriceofall Oregon Ducks 13h ago

*THE Ohio State’s loss

122

u/Source0fAllThings Michigan Wolverines • Chicago Maroons 13h ago

*anOSU

39

u/QueefSniffin Oregon State • California 13h ago

Welcome to the other OSUs, Ohio State

-32

u/FunkoPopDude 13h ago

this is like a championship season for mishitigan fans

20

u/Classic_Owl3711 Kansas State • Highland CC 12h ago

I get the rivalry but Michigan is 5-5 so don’t think this is the “championship season” as you call it that they had in mind

13

u/Pad_TyTy Michigan Wolverines 13h ago

Ohio residents go to Michigan to vacation because it's actually nice

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

62

u/Frostfire26 Texas Longhorns • Texas A&M Aggies 13h ago

Back in my day, OSU was a quality win

19

u/Michiganman1225 Team Chaos • Sickos 13h ago

Anytime OSU loses it's a quality win.

9

u/Flimsy-Space-8724 Georgia Bulldogs 13h ago

Breaking all kinds of records today

134

u/a1umn1 Michigan Wolverines • USF Bulls 13h ago

So we finally will stop pre-ranking teams right.. RIGHT??!?!?

72

u/PenguinPapayaThor 13h ago

Right, Michigan had no buisness being ranked

8

u/britishmetric144 Washington Huskies • Pac-12 13h ago

What about Oregon? They are certainly top ten, but I doubt they are number two.

5

u/Vocen Oregon Ducks 12h ago

What about Washington? They are certainly top 50, but I doubt they are number 17.

-3

u/a1umn1 Michigan Wolverines • USF Bulls 13h ago

Flair up or shut up.

16

u/Dangerous_Golf_7417 Texas A&M Aggies 13h ago

Lol he's an OU fan

2

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

He's a loser aOSU

7

u/Competitive_Goat4250 13h ago

Yall little kids on your message boards are so sensitive 😂😂

7

u/a1umn1 Michigan Wolverines • USF Bulls 12h ago

We’re all online arguing over teams that dont gaf about either of us, shit was sensitive to begin with ¯_(ツ)_/¯

7

u/PenguinPapayaThor 13h ago

Nah bih

0

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

HAHAHA

-1

u/bluntsonthereg_ Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

Neither did Ohio state

5

u/ThisIsOurGoodTimes Ohio State • Ohio Northern 12h ago

lol how’d that game go again when sayin wasn’t hurt?

→ More replies (2)

21

u/VanDenIzzle Mississippi State Bulldogs • LSU Tigers 13h ago

Rankings week 0-5 just shouldn't exist.

1

u/citrus1330 Alabama Crimson Tide • Michigan Wolverines 11h ago

🙄

1

u/transuranic807 Ohio State Buckeyes • UAB Blazers 10h ago

ESPN probs good with getting rid of preseason rankings so long as they can still rank the SEC early tho

8

u/prfsr_moriarty 11h ago

Breaking news: “NCAA announces last minute decision to expand playoffs to whatever place OSU finishes in.”

25

u/MediumRareNation Texas Longhorns 13h ago

Who were the 2?

Edit: nevermind found it

30

u/MoreThanAFeeling1976 UCF Knights • FAU Owls 13h ago

2004 USC and 2017 Alabama

-1

u/FunkoPopDude 13h ago

Roll Tide, central florida fan!

13

u/prismatic_lights Ohio State • Pittsburgh 13h ago

2017 Alabama (didn't stay #1 the whole time) and 2004 USC.

11

u/mukduk1994 Utah Utes • Army Black Knights 13h ago

2017 Bama and 2004 USC

11

u/eagledog Fresno State • Michigan 13h ago

2017 Bama and 04 USC

6

u/JBurton90 Florida Gators 8h ago

Technically nothing is stopping the clown committee from ranking them.

5

u/BigHersh14 Alabama Crimson Tide 7h ago

Its almost like preseason ap polls are dumb

20

u/tripleM_20 Michigan Wolverines • Michigan Wolverines 13h ago

AP IS WASHED

9

u/androosh Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Don't worry, playoff format changes next year, and we all saw what happened the last two times they did that, right guys?

This is all I have left, and you guys can't take it from me until we fail to win next year.

4

u/JasonVorhehees Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Well at least we did something noteworthy this season

3

u/ech01_ Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Won’t be preseason 1 next year at least

3

u/cyberchaox Rutgers Scarlet Knights • Landmark 9h ago edited 9h ago

Not guaranteed yet, especially with Maryland leading USC.

If Ohio State wins and Indiana/Iowa/Oregon all lose, the Buckeyes still can make the CCG on the conference SOS tiebreaker. But it's pretty much all on the Terps--the Buckeyes do need the Trojans to lose one of these games and not be in the tiebreaker (their SOS is too strong), and they need Wisconsin to win to be part of the tie, but they need at least two of (Terps win tonight, Terps beat Penn State next week, Rutgers beats Michigan State next week).

Edit: Wait, Maryland winning tonight would add another wrinkle. If USC wins tonight, the Buckeyes would need UCLA to beat USC just to get the Trojans out of the tie, so they'd need both the Maryland win and the Michigan State loss to get the superior SOS. But while USC is a common opponent for Ohio State and Oregon, UCLA is an Oregon opponent but not an Ohio State opponent. Thus, if Maryland beats USC tonight, any of USC/Maryland/Rutgers winning next week is enough to swing the tiebreaker in Ohio State's favor.

TLDR: If Maryland wins tonight, Ohio State can make the CCG with a win, a Wisconsin win, an Iowa loss, an Oregon loss, an Indiana loss, and any of USC/Rutgers/Maryland wins. If USC wins tonight, they instead need both Maryland and Rutgers to win while USC loses.

1

u/RukiMotomiya 2h ago

How much do you think people will implode if Ohio State gets in this way after all the Duke ACC memes last year?

5

u/Amonamission Michigan State Spartans 10h ago

And now Michigan could end their season with a better record than OSU with a win this next weekend 😂

11

u/AnotherDimwit Michigan Wolverines 12h ago

More proof that we shouldn’t have any polls until a month or two into the reason.

5

u/djsassan Ohio State Buckeyes • Salad Bowl 12h ago

Holy shit, we agree on something

3

u/AnotherDimwit Michigan Wolverines 12h ago

I think by rule that makes it law…or at least it should.

2

u/jzeffer 12h ago

Takes at least 5 games to know if teams are mostly as good as they look on paper. Ranking teams before a single snap is just setting up the entire seasons rankings to be skewed

1

u/impy695 Ohio State Buckeyes 4h ago

Fuck you. Also, I agree.

0

u/citrus1330 Alabama Crimson Tide • Michigan Wolverines 11h ago

many people enjoy seeing and discussing who is expected to be good that year. no one expects anyone to consistently predict the national champion before the season starts.

1

u/AnotherDimwit Michigan Wolverines 10h ago

I think you can enjoy discussing whose going to be good without building in bias that ultimately warps the season.

2

u/Bartman383 Nebraska Cornhuskers • /r/CFB Brickmason 7h ago

ESPN is very mad reading this comment.

4

u/Unhappy-List-2354 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

1 in the AP Preseason Poll (min 20 teams ranked) who didn’t finish the season ranked

1950 Notre Dame

2012 USC

2026 Ohio State???

7

u/RoyalEngine2885 12h ago

I'm sure they'll be ranked pre-season #1 again tho. 🙄

7

u/Original_Profile8600 Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

We will not be. We'll be ranked, but it'll be an SEC team that probably didn't deserve it either

2

u/stimulation Georgia Bulldogs • /r/CFB Brickmason 11h ago

Was trying to remember why we weren’t pre season #1 in 2022 but I forgot we had 5 first rounders and 15 NFL draft picks after we won the first one. And Stetson was still overlooked even by our fan base. We were actually #3 pre season that year.

It is interesting that Bama won so many under Saban when they were in full Death Star program mode and yet it only happened once for them. Felt like Bama was pre season #1 from 2008 to 2023.

3

u/_token_black Ohio State Buckeyes • Temple Owls 10h ago

Brett McMurphy needs to call his doctor because his hate boner for Ohio State never goes down

That being said he’s not wrong

2

u/fritzg1988 13h ago

Thank you, Big Red.

2

u/raimuuu Ohio State • Youngstown State 12h ago

First team in ever to do everything you never want to hear about a football team. Literally never on the right side of history lol

1

u/hardindapaint12 Georgia Bulldogs 12h ago

Can't wait for next year when they'll be safely in !

1

u/solomonrooney UC Davis Aggies 12h ago

Ohio State looks really bad, not sure what happened to them.

1

u/AntSmith777 Washington Huskies 12h ago

If this was next year they could still win it all…

1

u/B1GFanOSU Ohio State Buckeyes • Big Ten 12h ago

Nothing good ever comes from us being ranked #1.

1

u/pinetreesrule South Dakota State • Minnesota 11h ago

Quality losses everyone! Thats how Alabama will get in!

1

u/ATXBeermaker Texas Longhorns • Stanford Cardinal 11h ago

Gotta be embarrassing starting the season as AP #1 and not even making the playoffs.

1

u/Designer_B Iowa Hawkeyes 10h ago

When's the last time they beat a team that finished in the top 25? Because Ohio State is not going to.

1

u/ORdeadhead2 9h ago

So can we all agree no more pre-season ranking BS.

1

u/Mottled_Paws Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

It was always dumb for us to be preseason #1 anyway. I never understood that

1

u/TheWallsHaveNostrils Washington Huskies • Wisconsin Badgers 5h ago

The Committee is going to move Ohio State up now out of spite. No one tells them what they will and won't do.

1

u/lukaeber BYU Cougars • Virginia Cavaliers 4h ago

The A.P. needs to just rank Alabama No. 1 every preseason ... can't go wrong with that one.

1

u/Lane8323 Sam Houston Bearkats • Texas Longhorns 3h ago

It’s almost like preseason rankings don’t matter

1

u/Bad_Karma19 Alabama Crimson Tide • Army Black Knights 13h ago

Ummm, okay.

1

u/BananaNutBlister Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

McMurphy’s an idiot. I could’ve told you OSU wasn’t winning a title 3 weeks ago.

-1

u/giggitybuck Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

Imma be real with you. I forgot we were ever ranked 1. I thought it was Indiana since they were defending champs

0

u/Trumpburnerforlibs Texas Longhorns 12h ago

At least Texas ended up being ranked last year

-4

u/EffectiveGreen3174 12h ago

For the last few years OSU has played a cupcake schedule with an inflated ranking. The Big Ten as a whole has grown weaker. Once again another year Ohio State gets exposed as just an average team. 

0

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/heyheyitsandre Michigan Wolverines • Miami (OH) RedHawks 12h ago

That was my exact thought, I was like …we don’t know that yet lol. They’ll sneak them in and then they’ll go on a miracle run and end up winning somehow

0

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Quick-Difference3267 Notre Dame • Purdue 12h ago

Yeah!!