r/CFB • Tennessee • Third Saturday… • 7h ago

Discussion After the conclusion of today’s games CFP #3 Alabama best wins will be 7-4 Kentucky, 6-5 South Carolina, 6-5 LSU, and a 5-6 Miss State where Kamario was already banged up

CFP #3 Alabama’s quality wins^TM took some hits today. Their best win, Kentucky, is now a four-loss team and should be unranked. Their next-ranked win, South Carolina is now a 5-loss team and definitely should be unranked. Where are their quality wins now to justify their ranking?

1.4k Upvotes

982 comments sorted by

454

u/heranitback109yards Auburn Tigers • Team Chaos 6h ago

I think the team with the season’s best win should get a CFP auto-bid… whoever that is, idk 🤷‍♂️

132

u/xylicmagnus75 Tennessee • Third Saturday… 6h ago

At the moment I think that's Auburn..

We'll allow it.

42

u/FapFapkins BYU Cougars • Arizona State Sun Devils 5h ago

If they win the Iron Bowl give it to em idc

53

u/silverhk Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Bold choice to pick BYU.

21

u/nihilism_or_bust BYU Cougars 5h ago

I think you mean UCF

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Misinformed_user Illinois • Virginia Tech 4h ago

Wake forest beat SMU by more so therefore Wake Forest > Notre Dame

943

u/mbe8819 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago edited 6h ago

It’s not about our wins

It’s our quality losses

/s

161

u/Forsaken-Sale7672 Utah Utes 6h ago

Goddamnit, of course this is the year where quality losses mean the most.

25

u/FaceglazerSSBU Oklahoma Sooners 5h ago

I like that idea. The quality wins vs quality losses rotates from year to year and sometimes you end up on the good side and sometimes you don’t. Who doesn’t love a little bit of RNG in year long seasons that people have poured their everything into?

37

u/cdillon42 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Tell us about it

31

u/MarchMadnessisMe Louisiana Ragin' Cajuns • LSU Tigers 5h ago

Can I offer you a Pop Tart during this trying time?

→ More replies (6)

123

u/Arkehn Longhorn Network • Team Chaos 6h ago

Losing just means more.

75

u/ShowCivil Alabama Crimson Tide • WKU Hilltoppers 6h ago

Committee is absolutely just going “how da fuq do we…..alright nevermind the procedure. Who do we think is good?”

12

u/Oblivion2104 Iowa Hawkeyes • Oklahoma Sooners 5h ago

I mean at this point they really should just say hey we are wiping the slate clean and reevaluating everyone.

→ More replies (6)

35

u/Knicks-in-7 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Multiple quality losses. More=better

24

u/mbe8819 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

way more gooder

21

u/Big_Somewhere9230 Indiana Hoosiers 6h ago

Your grasp of the English language is terrible. It’s much more gooder.

17

u/Desperate_Gift_9366 Indiana Hoosiers • Ball State Cardinals 6h ago

It just means more

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

172

u/LightningDusty Florida Gators • Orange Bowl 6h ago

They'll still be #3.

44

u/BoNnnnfhir Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Oregon Ducks 6h ago

Nah they moving up to 2

47

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 6h ago

Probably. A 2 loss team with zero ranked wins. Committee might just be trolling us at this point

11

u/IrishMosaic Notre Dame • Michigan State 5h ago

Why wouldn’t Missouri be ranked? They won today.

41

u/miboyl Indiana Hoosiers • Sickos 5h ago

Missouri's sole purpose is to be ranked 21-25 and serve as a ranked win for SEC teams come playoff selection time

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/taleofbenji Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

They consistently have wins over no one in particular week in and week out. 

27

u/Mantergeistmann Vanderbilt • Penn State 6h ago

Hey, their win over Vandy looks even better now that Vandy's taken a ranked team down to the wire!

→ More replies (2)

40

u/Pinus_grandiflora Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

I for one found their game against Chattanooga to be convincing

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (22)

68

u/nihilism_or_bust BYU Cougars 6h ago

Georgia didn’t look good in their win, so Bama takes #1

34

u/laxintx Texas A&M Aggies • Paper Bag 6h ago

"They scored 47 and didn't allow any points, what else can we ask them to do?"

-Yurachek on Tuesday night

→ More replies (3)

372

u/Zingggbot5000 Tennessee • Indiana State 6h ago • Bravo

They’re gonna keep them high so people keep watching that stupid ass fucking show on Tuesday nights

108

u/SnooOpinions9048 Iowa Hawkeyes 6h ago

Why watch show, when I can just see the poll posted on reddit?

11

u/MightyCaseyStruckOut Texas Tech Red Raiders 4h ago

And then rightfully bitch about it

→ More replies (1)

74

u/cdillon42 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

I refuse to watch it based on that fact.

27

u/nnhumn Texas Tech • UT Arlington 6h ago

Im too busy watching maction during that time. I just see the rankings at halftime usually

10

u/cdillon42 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Same or ive been playing the oot remake and get my news from fox sports it CBS just so espn doesn't get the views

→ More replies (3)

5

u/nihilism_or_bust BYU Cougars 5h ago

I’m literally just now learning there’s a show associated with the rankings.

After 20+ years of watching college football.

How do people find time to watching shows about the games after watching the games?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

278

u/metabolic_chaos Nebraska Cornhuskers • Wisconsin Badgers 6h ago

WAKE FOREST TO #3

39

u/FootballAndPornAcct Georgia Bulldogs • College Football Playoff 6h ago

Wake is fucking scary

26

u/PointlessUnicorn337 Georgia Bulldogs 5h ago

My husband hasn’t been paying attention to Wake at all this season and was kinda dismissing them so I started reading off some of their scores to him and he was like, “Oh…shit.”

→ More replies (1)

74

u/Mammoth_Impress_3108 Nebraska • Kansas State 6h ago

I believe they are playing like the #3 team right now. Maybe don't deserve it due to their schedule and lack of ranked wins, but they are peaking right when everybody is stumbling.

84

u/pattymacnd311 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

"Maybe dont deserve it due to their schedule and ranked wins"

Ah good....hes talking about Bama who has a shite schedule and no ranked wins

33

u/Mammoth_Impress_3108 Nebraska • Kansas State 6h ago

Yeah, Wake Forest definitely deserves to be ranked ahead of Bama. The CFP will still keep Bama a solid 3-4 spots ahead of Wake for rea$on$, though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

21

u/Mayfect SMU Mustangs • TCU Horned Frogs 6h ago

Bruh look at how they have outscored opponents the last 7 games.

They aren’t peaking. They are fucking good.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SpiritFingersKitty Wake Forest • Georgia 6h ago

We will have the same number of ranked wins as Alabama after today unless the committee gets even more crazy with their rankings...

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Kasen_Ibara Texas A&M Aggies • Montana Grizzlies 5h ago

I hope /u/WAKEISGREAT is watching with glee somewhere

→ More replies (1)

181

u/Redrubytheofficial Louisville Cardinals 6h ago

The story of Kentucky is genuinely depressing why did they cancel their playoff chances.

Also looks like this is just gonna end with another Georgia national championship

74

u/Wasteland_Rang3r Texas Longhorns 6h ago

Kentucky had a very promising year for having a first year head coach.

56

u/Atlanta-Anomaly Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

We’ve won the last 2 sec titles and still didn’t win a playoff game. Definitely not a foregone conclusion at all. We gotta make it past the quarterfinals first

→ More replies (5)

39

u/Aidanj927 Texas Tech Red Raiders • UTSA Roadrunners 6h ago

Kentucky was always overrated, they got railed by Bama then beat A&M before people knew they were terrible. They beat SC and LSU by 1 point each, they honestly aren’t far from missing a bowl

→ More replies (3)

69

u/Ilovemyangelsomuch Clemson Tigers 6h ago

Wake Forest natty is inevitable

57

u/Dangerous-Tip-9046 6h ago

If Indiana and Wake Forest win titles-- 2 of the 5 losingest programs in the sport-- I don't think any fanbase will ever be able to be reasonable and tolerable ever again. It would be so glorious

7

u/CuriousCrawler1 Indiana Hoosiers 6h ago

Would love this

7

u/Mike_with_Wings Florida • North Carolina 5h ago

Honestly it’s what I’m rooting for now

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Fletch71011 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

We are going to be tied with them in the metrics again and we are getting a lot of our best players back, but also unfortunately lost one today. I just hope we are on the other side of the bracket as them. As of now, implied odds are a pick em if Georgia plays ND.

8

u/IDontTortureChickens Notre Dame • Ball State 5h ago

I think Georgia is likely better than us, but I do think ND/Georgia would be the most likely playoff game to be an absolute banger right now. Hopefully if it happens it's not before Jan. 25.

12

u/Penetratorofflanks Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

Some say they never recovered from spooky Neyland.

30

u/terdferguson74 Georgia Bulldogs • Montana Grizzlies 6h ago

Inshallah brother

7

u/StartupDino Georgia Bulldogs • Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

Rat poison 🐀

2

u/34payton07 Louisville Cardinals 5h ago

We were so close to having the first top 25 showdown in the history of the rivalry

2

u/Odd_Show573 Tennessee Volunteers 4h ago

Anyone who legitimately believed in Kentucky as a real playoff team is either too zonked out on coal dust or completely oblivious to the tried and true pecking order of the SEC

→ More replies (7)

195

u/UT49-0U Texas Longhorns • Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago

Both Texas and Tennessee should jump them (as should a couple of other teams)

→ More replies (37)

25

u/Beefcliffe Miami Hurricanes 6h ago

You convinced me…#2 it is

→ More replies (1)

97

u/Runningart1978 6h ago

If it makes you feel any better the BIG10 Championship Game is trending to be.....Oregon vs Iowa....

No one is good.

Everyone is bad.

But everyone is also good!

25

u/Kh3hhdds343 6h ago

LOL. Don't try to muck it up. This is about Alabama which is the only top 12 team that hasn't beaten an opponent with more than seven wins.

11

u/livefreeordont James Madison Dukes 6h ago

I think Tennessee is better than Bama and has a better resume than Bama. Come at me bro

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Designer_B Iowa Hawkeyes 4h ago

Usc still has to pull the upset for that to happen.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Eastern_Ingenuity507 6h ago

Welcome to the CFP Rankings, the rankings where everything’s made up and who you beat don’t matter

33

u/tigernike1 Illinois • Music City Bowl 6h ago

The committee is such an unserious organization.

144

u/AUCE05 Auburn Tigers 6h ago

We are about to knock them out.

69

u/krigo97 Georgia Bulldogs 5h ago

From your lips to God’s ears

13

u/ninjas_in_my_pants Notre Dame • Missouri 5h ago

Allah said "Knock you OUT!"

8

u/IrishMosaic Notre Dame • Michigan State 5h ago

If Auburn wins, they knock them out of a bye, but in no way would they be knocked out of a home game in the first round. But I’m here for it.

30

u/Alexcox95 Florida Gators • Keiser Seahawks 5h ago

AUBURN’S GONNA WIN THE FOOTBALL GAME!

36

u/Fletch71011 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Please God

15

u/Just_Breathe85 Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

Please. It would be so funny.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lookieherehere Alabama Crimson Tide 4h ago

It's a very real possibility. We are a very inconsistent team and can absolutely lose to anyone on any given day. I feel like we are obviously ranked too high and will probably get exposed of we get in.

15

u/Atlas_B170 Tennessee • ETSU 6h ago

🙏

5

u/Ok-Professional9373 Tennessee Volunteers 5h ago

Do it auburn. Please

→ More replies (21)

57

u/CROBBY2 Wisconsin Badgers 6h ago

This whole year is about who you lose to, wins dont matter.

10

u/Pyro1934 Georgia Bulldogs • College Football Playoff 6h ago

Looks around nervously

10

u/Crayoneater47 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 5h ago

I mean come on they have such a good loss to Tennessee. How could they not be above Tennessee?

28

u/DanTheMan14331 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

I don't think that's true. Texas is being rewarded for a strong slate of wins despite two losses to teams in the 20's

13

u/Adventurous_Arm_5586 Chicago Maroons • Texas Longhorns 4h ago

Not as rewarded as Bama tho. There’s literally zero excuse for Texas to NOT be ranked above Alabama without bringing up losses. Which like fine, if that’s what you want your criteria to be, then fine. But then don’t try to pretend this is anything about wins if we’re gonna have Bama above Texas, it’s unserious

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Just_Breathe85 Tennessee Volunteers 5h ago

Quality losses, so hot right now.

9

u/Ok-Professional9373 Tennessee Volunteers 5h ago

Beat them. Beat every team they beat. Not in the same pod tho

8

u/TouchdownTerry Alabama Crimson Tide • Alabama Crimson Tide 4h ago

South Carolina?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

63

u/fhqwhgads_football Carnegie Mellon • Pittsburgh 6h ago

Don't people ever get tired of this? I sure am

15

u/hitokirizac Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Texas Longhorns 6h ago

c'mon fhqwhgads. I know I'm tired of it.

4

u/majoravatar Clemson • Florida State 5h ago

Everybody to the limit.

11

u/OmegaClifton Alabama Crimson Tide • Team Chaos 6h ago

We don't know why we're so high either. But yes, it's gotten old af being the villain of a regular ass team. I could see if we were Almighty Bama (TM) again, but we're plenty vulnerable now.

13

u/AV-8723 6h ago

The top 12 is gonna be a mess on Tuesday and I’m here for the chaos!!! As long as Utah holds on they will stay put, now with the rest of the field, YIKES!!!! UCLA (lost their backup) and Indiana (QB issues). Everybody else won besides Ohio State, who isn’t in the top 12 but the committee loves them( I put them on upset alert). It might just be an SEC love fest since the Big Ten shot themselves in the foot today. Three big 12 teams being in the top 12 is a great possibility. I’ve loved Wake all year so maybe they could move up a spot or two by handling business in run-away fashion against Georgia Tech.

8

u/SpiritFingersKitty Wake Forest • Georgia 6h ago

I think we move up over BYU after today's games, I also think it's possible UCLA drops below us, and we should move up over Indiana with their loss so I could see us being #8. 

6

u/AV-8723 6h ago

Will they pull a Florida State on UCLA is the real question. I’m all for Wake being in the top 10. I think they have a real shot at beating Miami in the ACC Championship game. I know Toney will be back, but Wake is cooking right now!!!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/S3Plan71 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

They have no reason being 3rd but the biggest joke of it all is having a Tennessee team that bullied them and stole their lunch money ranked below them. Matter of fact as overrated as Texas and Bama are Tennessee is the one two loss team i could accept being ranked higher than Miami and ND. They along with WF are the most underrated team in the country…. By the rigged committee

38

u/duplicated-rs Texas Longhorns 6h ago

Texas literally beat Tennessee at THEIR PLACE.

Holy fuck yall see Texas and throw your critical thinking out of the window

34

u/Euphoric_Inspiration Tennessee • Third Saturday… 6h ago

Texas, Tennessee, Bama. It’s not that hard folks

→ More replies (18)

7

u/Blaine1111 Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

Texas is also in the sec championship at the moment id argue they deserve the 2nd highest sec team right now

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Extreme_Rice_8867 Boise State Broncos 6h ago

I actually think Tennessee finally hops them this week. They’re close enough in the same “pod” or whatever the hell that explanation was. They’ll probably just come up with another reason to keep Tennessee back though.

15

u/Icy-Lecture-224 6h ago

But Texas beat them….at their house, and also has two losses?

And while it’s not as impressive as it once was, a much much better OOC win?

7

u/ItsTimetoLANK Texas Longhorns • Paper Bag 6h ago

You do know Texas beat Tennessee in Knoxville, right?

2

u/Ok-Professional9373 Tennessee Volunteers 5h ago

Texas, Tennessee, Bama.

4

u/Cheeziest_Puffs 6h ago

I mean, what goes against Alabama also goes against Tennessee. Tennessee beat Alabama by two scores but also lost to South Carolina. Alabama pantsed South Carolina. It’s just a massive circle of suck.

→ More replies (110)

17

u/tc100292 Vanderbilt Commodores 6h ago

This was pretty much their exact argument against us last year and I can’t imagine why we got treated differently than Alabama

6

u/Several-Vanilla-8503 6h ago

The only thing we can do is............. expand the cfp to 24 teams!

6

u/i_love_bubble_butts 3h ago

Ive heard enough....put them #1

32

u/TVxStrange Auburn Tigers • Michigan Wolverines 6h ago

If Auburn wins the Iron Bowl, should they make the playoffs?

/s

It should however, keep Bama out at the least.

17

u/Just_Breathe85 Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

You would have undoubtedly the 2 best wins in cfb 🤔

3

u/SwissForeignPolicy Michigan Wolverines • Marching Band 5h ago

With the amount of chaos we've had, 9-3 Bama probably still gets in.

→ More replies (6)

27

u/StruggleEither6772 South Alabama Jaguars • Army Black Knights 6h ago

Guess they should move Indiana and UCLA up….

21

u/agk927 Iowa Hawkeyes 6h ago

Iowa belongs in the top 12

→ More replies (1)

27

u/TimelyBodybuilder637 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • UMass Minutemen 6h ago

I really hope Wake Forest annihilates Bama in the playoffs. It would be poetic.

4

u/Milton__Obote LSU Tigers • Northwestern Wildcats 5h ago

I’d be there for that

→ More replies (31)

58

u/amstrumpet Alabama Crimson Tide • Yale Bulldogs 6h ago

Bama deserves to be in the playoffs as of now. they don’t deserve a bye. they also wont get a bye if they don’t get into the sec Championship and win, so who cares?

52

u/OneVast3433 6h ago

Because what else will r/CFB whine about?

12

u/DanTheMan14331 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

they also wont get a bye if they don’t get into the sec Championship and win

How do you figure? Alabama's probably not going to play in the SEC championship. Unless the committee changes their mind (which they should), Alabama probably gets a bye if Georgia beats Texas in the SEC championship game.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 5h ago

That's the issue, they are absolutely on track to get a bye. Especially after UCLA and Indiana losses today.

If one of Miami or Utah does not win their conference championship, Alabama is almost definitely getting a bye

6

u/ModsEmbezzleMoney Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

If Wake beats Miami I guarantee they vault up the last poll. The last poll is the one where the committee actually postures and placates the conferences. Just look at Miami finally jumping up last year after the ACC would have been left out otherwise.

Byes are probably gonna shake out to be SEC Champ, Big 12 Champ, ACC Champ, and UCLA if they win out or SEC championship game loser if score is close, or Notre Dame. They'll bump us down and say our resume isn't as strong after championship weekend having not played.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

22

u/Swing-Too-Hard 6h ago

At this point there is 0 reason for the Tide to be ranked ahead of Tennessee.

5

u/Gingeronimoooo 5h ago

Yeah I'm an Alabama fan but you're probably right. We both deserve to be in the playoffs and it will shake out there. The obsession with Bama is wild though, blame the committee. People acting like Alabama is awful are worse than the committee.

→ More replies (8)

34

u/swagasaurus-r3x Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

If they are #3 next week it is malpractice by the committee

→ More replies (24)

21

u/OnVisOch Alabama • Mississippi State 6h ago

According to Curt Cignetti, we’re supposed to get credit for being part of the reason those teams fell off. Apparently we’re supposed to also … brag(?) … about being part of the “we helped get Kamario injured” club à la IU “ripping the heart out” of OSU by injuring Sayin.

So, uhhhh, if we’re gonna go this path, can we also stop sucking Cig off for a moment?

5

u/qotsabama Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

Indiana got clowned today.

→ More replies (3)

61

u/stickn_n_movn Clemson Tigers 6h ago

This might be a hot take but who really gives a shit

Rubber will meet the road in the playoff

109

u/Wasteland_Rang3r Texas Longhorns 6h ago

Well four teams get byes so seeding matters

48

u/CommodoreIrish Notre Dame • Vanderbilt 6h ago

IIRC, the bye seeding has lead to a loss for every team except IU.

28

u/tc100292 Vanderbilt Commodores 6h ago

I don’t think Boise and ASU lost because of the bye though

13

u/Big_Lawfulness_8143 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

And basically all of them have been vegas underdogs

The real tell for who will win a playoff game

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/Rnorman3 Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

Seeding affects byes and home field advantage. It very much matters

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SwissForeignPolicy Michigan Wolverines • Marching Band 5h ago

This is a flaming hot take but who really gives a shit

Just beat your rivals and win your conference, and to hell with the ESPN Invitational

→ More replies (1)

17

u/RoutineSad2633 6h ago

Bama is ranked several spots too high. It’s silly to willfully ignore that they lost by three scores to TN. That said, at 10-2 they are obviously a playoff team so I can’t get all that worked up about it.

WF is a freaking juggernaut. I think they are going to pound a pretty good Duke team next week, and should move into the top 10. I also think Miami should be worried about them in the ACC CCG. If WF wins that game …. no idea what the committee will do but they will be forced to slot them in the top 6.

9

u/DubiousAdviceGiver Boise State Broncos 5h ago

Wake vs Utah is the people’s natty!!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Flaggstaff Florida State Seminoles • Utah Utes 2h ago

The first round bye is what people are worked up about

9

u/qotsabama Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

Hey! We lost by two scores to Tennessee!!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Tricky_Big_8774 Virginia Tech Hokies 3h ago

Wake is a playground bully, not a juggernaut.

3

u/TempAcct724 Utah Utes 4h ago

They’re definitely still a CFP team, but there’s zero reason they should be in position for a first round bye.

→ More replies (24)

8

u/HookEm_Tide Alabama Crimson Tide • Texas Longhorns 5h ago

Finally, someone in r/CFB is paying attention to Bama!

3

u/JackintheBox333 Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

Kentucky will still be ranked because 4 loss SEC team equals quality apparently. Look for Missouri to replace South Carolina in the CFB Playoff Top 25 because SEC.

3

u/gilbygamer Oklahoma • Illinois College 3h ago

"Okay. You've convinced me. Rank 'em number one." -The Committee, probably

9

u/Kh3hhdds343 6h ago

Alabama is treated like an undefeated power-conference team or a 2-loss squad with an unbelievable resume — neither of which comes close to describing its situation.

5

u/finaderiva Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

I wish they’d put Tennessee above bama so you guys would shut the fuck up about it

5

u/terribliz Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

On the other hand, Alabama's quality loss to Tennessee got even better 😅 tbf, I never thought UK was the team the media seemed to want them to be in the first half of the season. Bama's best performance was almost undoubtedly against UGA and everyone who watched it knows how it easily could have ended without the missed PI call. I don't really care where they get seeded - never thought they deserved the 3 spot, just seems obvious they deserve to be somewhere in the top 12.

5

u/GotSomeUpdogOnUrFace 5h ago

Don't worry guys they'll move up to #2 anyway

8

u/VolleyballSchool Nebraska • Nebraska 6h ago

In the BIG10 anybody can beat anyone. We proved it this weekend. This conference has so much depth!

2

u/-we-win-those Oregon Ducks • Cornell Big Red 6h ago

If the name was SEC, yes depth. It’s not, so instead everyone is mid

24

u/Main_Opposite_6661 Michigan Wolverines 6h ago

Alabama will get body bagged in the postseason so who cares. They are irrelevant.

14

u/deerhuntingdude Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

u/RemindMeBot 2 months

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Coverlesss Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

If they’re irrelevant why is this subreddit so obsessed with them?

12

u/Mike_with_Wings Florida • North Carolina 5h ago

Can’t let a good dead horse go to waste

11

u/MichelNey2 Oregon State Beavers • Texas Longhorns 5h ago

His team needed to cheat to win their chip 3 years ago and beat directional Michigan lol

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ActuaryFeeling6043 Vanderbilt Commodores 6h ago

Well I’m salty because they have a shockingly similar resume to Vanderbilt last year who didn’t even sniff the playoffs.

3

u/WaltSneezy Alabama • Georgia Tech 3h ago

Well the context of last year was a lot different than the chaos this year. There is significantly more room for 2 loss teams in the playoff this year than last, on track for even more losses too. If you were in this position last year, you would likely be sitting with where BYU is right now.

9

u/stevo887 Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

This just in, preseason polls matter.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/stevo887 Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago

The irony in that flair!

→ More replies (45)

12

u/entitledfanman Auburn Tigers 5h ago

Which is specifically why they're so high up at number 3, and why that's such a problem. 

At 2 losses I have no problem with Bama in the playoffs, and I say that as a committed Bama hater. The problem with them being 3 is it means they get a bye on the first round and preferential matchups past that. The record will show they at least got past the first round and being rested means they will probably win their first game, and in a few years most people will completely  forget it was complete bullshit they were ever ranked 3rd. 

9

u/Smoochie_Gucci47 Ole Miss Rebels 5h ago

if i remember correctly, most teams that get the first round bye surprisingly don’t play as well as the teams who start the gauntlet early

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/Old-Pomegranate-9225 Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

Yall almost went 12 months without a national scandal so you guys really did outdo yourselves this year.

6

u/Undying470 Alabama Crimson Tide • Oregon Ducks 4h ago

Not the Michigan fan talking shit now that his team is back to being irrelevant again. 

→ More replies (8)

4

u/SilveryDeath Notre Dame Fighting Irish • FAU Owls 6h ago

To be fair they also beat ECU, who is 7-4. So that was their second biggest win this year. /s

→ More replies (1)

4

u/PlaymakersPoint88 Alabama • Old Dominion 5h ago

All Bama, All the time.

8

u/FreightTrainJim Texas Tech Red Raiders 6h ago

They'll rank Auburn so that Bama can get another "top 25 at the time" win over a 5-loss team.

3

u/war_damn_eagle Auburn Tigers • UAB Blazers 5h ago

1000%

Expect to see us at #25 this week at 7-4

7

u/Competitive-Rise-789 Georgia Bulldogs • Oklahoma Sooners 6h ago

Shocked it wasn’t a BYU flair tbh

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TobiasFunke69420 6h ago

Yeah I get it, everyone hates bama.

Yall know how this is though. Some teams start off hot, others end hot, some start off weak, have a great week, then end up shifting the bed.

The idea that a teams strength at any given week is strictly driven by their record at the end of the year is silly.

That being said, I don’t really care. It is what it is at this point

→ More replies (3)

16

u/KeegCorp Jacksonville State • Syracuse 6h ago

Beat that dead horse. Every week y’all keep saying the same thing about Alabama. Nothings gonna change. Y’all might be obsessed with them atp.

Maybe complain about who voted them as 3 instead of every week acting like it’s Alabamas fault lmfao.

20

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 6h ago

Maybe complain about who voted them as 3 

What do you think people are complaining about???

→ More replies (6)

10

u/ill_cago Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

They definitely are obsessed and pathetic

2

u/randomwalktoFI Oregon Ducks 5h ago

Sure, 4 of the top 5 is SEC teams. I guess Bama can be 5

reddit: no, not like that!

→ More replies (7)

2

u/LarryPhillipsHeisman 6h ago

Probably move up to 2

2

u/JSkel13 Alabama Crimson Tide 2h ago

And who should be ranked ahead of Bama? Please enlighten me

2

u/workaholic828 Weber State Wildcats 2h ago

Tennessee lost to that 5 loss South Carolina team so that’s why you’re not gonna be ahead of them

2

u/Glittering-War-8360 1h ago

If those are the best wins on the resume, #3 needs a better defense than "well, it's Alabama." There's a difference between thinking a team would beat everyone below them and rewarding them like they already did.

13

u/SpreaditOnnn33 Louisville • Ohio State 6h ago

No ranked wins means Bama has a worse resume than every CFP team besides Boise State

10

u/mcwilly Alabama Crimson Tide • FAU Owls 5h ago

Yet Alabama is #6 in strength of record.

6

u/Qybrid Alabama • Penn State 6h ago

I believe you’re missing a shutout 47 point win against a 7-5 team on the playoff bubble Week 12.

4

u/RDR350Z Texas Longhorns 5h ago

They’re the 2025 aggy

4

u/TheyreRocksHank2 BYU Cougars 3h ago

None of this will be pointed out by Reece Davis when he interviews the Committee chair.

3

u/charlesgarland42 6h ago

So you’re saying they’ll move up to #1? Can the committee move them up beyond #1? 0? Negative 2?

10

u/MyPlace70 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago

You know what Bama didn’t do, lose to 6-5 SC.

9

u/MidlandsBraves Clemson • Wake Forest 6h ago

That’s true. But if only there were some other way people could compare bamas resume vs Tennessees.

Like what would happen if they played a game against one another.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/glo363 Alabama Crimson Tide • Ole Miss Rebels 5h ago

Rent free lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SPCsooprlolz BYU Cougars • Fresno State Bulldogs 6h ago

They're Just Meaning More so hard this year

→ More replies (2)

4

u/West-Ad2726 6h ago

So what you're saying is - they should be ranked above Utah, who has zero quality losses.

4

u/Dangerous-Meal8303 6h ago

You dumb or something? It’s not about who you beat, it’s those quality losses that show everyone just how quality you are. Indiana and UCLA will finally get the respect they deserve now that they got an extra loss. How are we supposed to know how good wake forest is when all they do is beat teams into submission, we need to learn what they do when they lose by 20, because you gotta absolutely suck to be the best!!!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/biggerbytheday19 Texas A&M Aggies 6h ago

Let’s not forget they were kinda robbed at uga

16

u/restless_vagabond /r/CFB 6h ago

This is actually the reason they are #3, but the committee can't say "We think Bama actually won that game" even if they are essentially giving them credit for a win/draw.

I don't agree with it, but it's clear as day.

13

u/OnVisOch Alabama • Mississippi State 6h ago

Can’t publicly bash the refs. Union too strong. But this has to be the reason behind the scenes.

8

u/Jalkenri Alabama Crimson Tide • UAB Blazers 6h ago

Not only robbed, but robbed in a game against a QB who almost played a PERFECT GAME. Gunner only has FOUR incompletions on the night. I'd have to go and check but I remember THREE of those being drops by the receivers, and the 4th was a self tipped pass to be intercepted.

If he makes a single additional mistake that game can swing wildly the other way.

4

u/Pyro1934 Georgia Bulldogs • College Football Playoff 6h ago

Guess they better get to the SECCG or find us in the playoffs for revenge then.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/MikeMacBlu Notre Dame • Missouri State 6h ago

Any other team would be fighting for their lives next week.

3

u/N8_the_worst Kentucky Wildcats 6h ago

Now do Texas.

8

u/The__Vern Texas Longhorns • Team Chaos 6h ago

Tennessee (9-2)

Ole Miss (7-4)

Missouri (7-4)

6

u/gollumaniac Boston University • Buffalo 6h ago

And Ohio State. Alabama is getting credit for their Mississippi St win because they were good before Taylor got hurt. Same logic should apply to the Ohio State win: they were a top team before Saiyin got hurt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/R0b1NH0oD Oklahoma • Red River Shootout 6h ago

Ive heard enough make them #1 /s

2

u/Marciano_il_Mario 6h ago

What were the records when Alabama played them?

2

u/Relative_One_2441 Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

Alabama’s “quality” wins:
7-4 Kentucky (Away) 45-17
6-5 South Carolina (Home) 49-18
6-5 LSU (Away) 31-13
5-6 MSU (Away) 56-23

Alabama’s losses:
9-2 Tennessee (Away) 10-26
10-1 Georgia (Home) 17-20

Tennessee’s “quality” wins:
9-2 Alabama (Home) 26-10
7-4 Kentucky (Home) 34-6
6-5 LSU (Home) 27-13

Tennessee’s losses:
9-2 Texas (Home) 17-20
6-5 South Carolina (Away) 24-27

Common Opponents:

Texas A&M:
Tennessee W: 22-7 (Away)
Alabama W: 31-10 (Home)
Net Differential: +4 Tennessee

LSU
Tennessee W: 27-13 (Home)
Alabama W: 31-13 (Away)
Net Differential: +4 Alabama

South Carolina
Tennessee L: 24-27 (Away)
Alabama W: 49-18 (Home)
Net Differential: +34 Alabama

Kentucky
Tennessee W: 34-6 (Home)
Alabama W: 45-17 (Away)
Net Differential: 0

Vanderbilt
Tennessee TBD
Alabama W: 21-6

Auburn
Tennessee W: 24-14
Alabama TBD

Both Tennessee and Alabama played ACC opponents in OOC play. They’ve each also played one FBS and one FCS opponent.

ACC
Tennessee W over (3-8) Georgia Tech 45-24 (Away)
Alabama W over (5-6) Florida State 50-36 (Home)

FBS
Tennessee W over (5-6) Kennesaw State 42-9
Alabama W over (7-4) Eastern Carolina 48-10

FCS
Tennessee W over (4-8) Furman 56-9
Alabama W over (7–5) Chattanooga 47-0

Summary: These teams are mirror images from a conference scheduling and performance standpoint. Weird that we played the same schedule outside of (Texas/Arkansas)/(Georgia/MSU)

Tennessee has one better win and one worse loss. Alabama has more “good” wins and multiple ranked wins on the road, while all of Tennessee’s ranked SEC opponents have come to them in Neyland. Tennessee, of course has the head to head over Alabama in Neyland.

My takeaway is that these teams should, at the very least, be ranked right next to one another. Nothing about schedule difficulty or point differential indicates a 6 spot gap. Perfectly reasonable for Tennessee to be in front, given the H2H and many similarities almost everywhere else. I can also see a reasonable and measured case for Alabama in front as well. Regardless, Tennessee needs to move up.

I could also see rivalry week being a differentiator between the two, as we get the final data point, which could conceivably change things in the eyes of the committee.

2

u/MakesInappropriate Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago edited 6h ago

Guys. Bama fans also are confused why we are number 3. We will not end the season top 4 i promise you. As entertaining as r/cfb’s obsession over alabama football is, im just ready for the final rankings to be here so you guys can get back to talking and thinking about anything other than alabama football

5

u/SpiritFingersKitty Wake Forest • Georgia 6h ago

Maybe you are, but there are PLENTY of bama fans on here that are defending that ranking like their lives depend on it

3

u/Gingeronimoooo 5h ago

Not really, regardless we should be in the playoffs. People have a raging hat boner for Bama but we are clearly a good team. Probably not #3 but the obsesssion with Bama is wild. Rage at the committe if you want not the team

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Atlas_B170 Tennessee • ETSU 6h ago

Don't look at my flair, I am completely unbiased. When anyone even says "Alabama" I start hearing the siren tone from Kill Bill in my head

2

u/Adventurous_Arm_5586 Chicago Maroons • Texas Longhorns 4h ago

At this point if they’re ranked above Texas it’s malpractice

3

u/lukaeber BYU Cougars • Virginia Cavaliers 4h ago

We were well past malpractice weeks ago.