r/CFB • u/Euphoric_Inspiration Tennessee • Third Saturday… • 7h ago
Discussion After the conclusion of today’s games CFP #3 Alabama best wins will be 7-4 Kentucky, 6-5 South Carolina, 6-5 LSU, and a 5-6 Miss State where Kamario was already banged up
CFP #3 Alabama’s quality wins^TM took some hits today. Their best win, Kentucky, is now a four-loss team and should be unranked. Their next-ranked win, South Carolina is now a 5-loss team and definitely should be unranked. Where are their quality wins now to justify their ranking?
1.4k
Upvotes
454
u/heranitback109yards Auburn Tigers • Team Chaos 6h ago
I think the team with the season’s best win should get a CFP auto-bid… whoever that is, idk 🤷♂️
943
u/mbe8819 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago edited 6h ago
It’s not about our wins
It’s our quality losses
/s
172
u/LightningDusty Florida Gators • Orange Bowl 6h ago
They'll still be #3.
372
u/Zingggbot5000 Tennessee • Indiana State 6h ago •
They’re gonna keep them high so people keep watching that stupid ass fucking show on Tuesday nights
278
u/metabolic_chaos Nebraska Cornhuskers • Wisconsin Badgers 6h ago
WAKE FOREST TO #3
181
u/Redrubytheofficial Louisville Cardinals 6h ago
The story of Kentucky is genuinely depressing why did they cancel their playoff chances.
Also looks like this is just gonna end with another Georgia national championship
195
u/UT49-0U Texas Longhorns • Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago
Both Texas and Tennessee should jump them (as should a couple of other teams)
25
u/Beefcliffe Miami Hurricanes 6h ago
You convinced me…#2 it is
97
u/Runningart1978 6h ago
If it makes you feel any better the BIG10 Championship Game is trending to be.....Oregon vs Iowa....
No one is good.
Everyone is bad.
But everyone is also good!
27
u/Eastern_Ingenuity507 6h ago
Welcome to the CFP Rankings, the rankings where everything’s made up and who you beat don’t matter
33
u/tigernike1 Illinois • Music City Bowl 6h ago
The committee is such an unserious organization.
144
u/AUCE05 Auburn Tigers 6h ago
We are about to knock them out.
57
u/CROBBY2 Wisconsin Badgers 6h ago
This whole year is about who you lose to, wins dont matter.
63
u/fhqwhgads_football Carnegie Mellon • Pittsburgh 6h ago
Don't people ever get tired of this? I sure am
13
u/AV-8723 6h ago
The top 12 is gonna be a mess on Tuesday and I’m here for the chaos!!! As long as Utah holds on they will stay put, now with the rest of the field, YIKES!!!! UCLA (lost their backup) and Indiana (QB issues). Everybody else won besides Ohio State, who isn’t in the top 12 but the committee loves them( I put them on upset alert). It might just be an SEC love fest since the Big Ten shot themselves in the foot today. Three big 12 teams being in the top 12 is a great possibility. I’ve loved Wake all year so maybe they could move up a spot or two by handling business in run-away fashion against Georgia Tech.
11
u/S3Plan71 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago
They have no reason being 3rd but the biggest joke of it all is having a Tennessee team that bullied them and stole their lunch money ranked below them. Matter of fact as overrated as Texas and Bama are Tennessee is the one two loss team i could accept being ranked higher than Miami and ND. They along with WF are the most underrated team in the country…. By the rigged committee
17
u/tc100292 Vanderbilt Commodores 6h ago
This was pretty much their exact argument against us last year and I can’t imagine why we got treated differently than Alabama
6
u/Several-Vanilla-8503 6h ago
The only thing we can do is............. expand the cfp to 24 teams!
6
u/i_love_bubble_butts 3h ago
Ive heard enough....put them #1
32
u/TVxStrange Auburn Tigers • Michigan Wolverines 6h ago
If Auburn wins the Iron Bowl, should they make the playoffs?
/s
It should however, keep Bama out at the least.
27
u/StruggleEither6772 South Alabama Jaguars • Army Black Knights 6h ago
Guess they should move Indiana and UCLA up….
27
u/TimelyBodybuilder637 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • UMass Minutemen 6h ago
I really hope Wake Forest annihilates Bama in the playoffs. It would be poetic.
58
u/amstrumpet Alabama Crimson Tide • Yale Bulldogs 6h ago
Bama deserves to be in the playoffs as of now. they don’t deserve a bye. they also wont get a bye if they don’t get into the sec Championship and win, so who cares?
22
u/Swing-Too-Hard 6h ago
At this point there is 0 reason for the Tide to be ranked ahead of Tennessee.
34
u/swagasaurus-r3x Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago
If they are #3 next week it is malpractice by the committee
21
u/OnVisOch Alabama • Mississippi State 6h ago
According to Curt Cignetti, we’re supposed to get credit for being part of the reason those teams fell off. Apparently we’re supposed to also … brag(?) … about being part of the “we helped get Kamario injured” club à la IU “ripping the heart out” of OSU by injuring Sayin.
So, uhhhh, if we’re gonna go this path, can we also stop sucking Cig off for a moment?
61
u/stickn_n_movn Clemson Tigers 6h ago
This might be a hot take but who really gives a shit
Rubber will meet the road in the playoff
17
u/RoutineSad2633 6h ago
Bama is ranked several spots too high. It’s silly to willfully ignore that they lost by three scores to TN. That said, at 10-2 they are obviously a playoff team so I can’t get all that worked up about it.
WF is a freaking juggernaut. I think they are going to pound a pretty good Duke team next week, and should move into the top 10. I also think Miami should be worried about them in the ACC CCG. If WF wins that game …. no idea what the committee will do but they will be forced to slot them in the top 6.
8
u/HookEm_Tide Alabama Crimson Tide • Texas Longhorns 5h ago
Finally, someone in r/CFB is paying attention to Bama!
3
u/JackintheBox333 Georgia Bulldogs 6h ago
Kentucky will still be ranked because 4 loss SEC team equals quality apparently. Look for Missouri to replace South Carolina in the CFB Playoff Top 25 because SEC.
3
u/gilbygamer Oklahoma • Illinois College 3h ago
"Okay. You've convinced me. Rank 'em number one." -The Committee, probably
9
u/Kh3hhdds343 6h ago
Alabama is treated like an undefeated power-conference team or a 2-loss squad with an unbelievable resume — neither of which comes close to describing its situation.
5
u/finaderiva Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago
I wish they’d put Tennessee above bama so you guys would shut the fuck up about it
5
u/terribliz Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago
On the other hand, Alabama's quality loss to Tennessee got even better 😅 tbf, I never thought UK was the team the media seemed to want them to be in the first half of the season. Bama's best performance was almost undoubtedly against UGA and everyone who watched it knows how it easily could have ended without the missed PI call. I don't really care where they get seeded - never thought they deserved the 3 spot, just seems obvious they deserve to be somewhere in the top 12.
5
u/GotSomeUpdogOnUrFace 5h ago
Don't worry guys they'll move up to #2 anyway
8
u/VolleyballSchool Nebraska • Nebraska 6h ago
In the BIG10 anybody can beat anyone. We proved it this weekend. This conference has so much depth!
24
u/Main_Opposite_6661 Michigan Wolverines 6h ago
Alabama will get body bagged in the postseason so who cares. They are irrelevant.
4
u/SilveryDeath Notre Dame Fighting Irish • FAU Owls 6h ago
To be fair they also beat ECU, who is 7-4. So that was their second biggest win this year. /s
4
u/PlaymakersPoint88 Alabama • Old Dominion 5h ago
All Bama, All the time.
8
u/FreightTrainJim Texas Tech Red Raiders 6h ago
They'll rank Auburn so that Bama can get another "top 25 at the time" win over a 5-loss team.
7
u/Competitive-Rise-789 Georgia Bulldogs • Oklahoma Sooners 6h ago
Shocked it wasn’t a BYU flair tbh
7
u/TobiasFunke69420 6h ago
Yeah I get it, everyone hates bama.
Yall know how this is though. Some teams start off hot, others end hot, some start off weak, have a great week, then end up shifting the bed.
The idea that a teams strength at any given week is strictly driven by their record at the end of the year is silly.
That being said, I don’t really care. It is what it is at this point
16
u/KeegCorp Jacksonville State • Syracuse 6h ago
Beat that dead horse. Every week y’all keep saying the same thing about Alabama. Nothings gonna change. Y’all might be obsessed with them atp.
Maybe complain about who voted them as 3 instead of every week acting like it’s Alabamas fault lmfao.
2
u/LarryPhillipsHeisman 6h ago
Probably move up to 2
2
u/JSkel13 Alabama Crimson Tide 2h ago
And who should be ranked ahead of Bama? Please enlighten me
2
u/workaholic828 Weber State Wildcats 2h ago
Tennessee lost to that 5 loss South Carolina team so that’s why you’re not gonna be ahead of them
2
u/Glittering-War-8360 1h ago
If those are the best wins on the resume, #3 needs a better defense than "well, it's Alabama." There's a difference between thinking a team would beat everyone below them and rewarding them like they already did.
13
u/SpreaditOnnn33 Louisville • Ohio State 6h ago
No ranked wins means Bama has a worse resume than every CFP team besides Boise State
6
u/Qybrid Alabama • Penn State 6h ago
I believe you’re missing a shutout 47 point win against a 7-5 team on the playoff bubble Week 12.
4
u/RDR350Z Texas Longhorns 5h ago
They’re the 2025 aggy
4
u/TheyreRocksHank2 BYU Cougars 3h ago
None of this will be pointed out by Reece Davis when he interviews the Committee chair.
3
u/charlesgarland42 6h ago
So you’re saying they’ll move up to #1? Can the committee move them up beyond #1? 0? Negative 2?
10
u/MyPlace70 Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago
You know what Bama didn’t do, lose to 6-5 SC.
5
u/glo363 Alabama Crimson Tide • Ole Miss Rebels 5h ago
Rent free lol
4
u/SPCsooprlolz BYU Cougars • Fresno State Bulldogs 6h ago
They're Just Meaning More so hard this year
4
u/West-Ad2726 6h ago
So what you're saying is - they should be ranked above Utah, who has zero quality losses.
4
u/Dangerous-Meal8303 6h ago
You dumb or something? It’s not about who you beat, it’s those quality losses that show everyone just how quality you are. Indiana and UCLA will finally get the respect they deserve now that they got an extra loss. How are we supposed to know how good wake forest is when all they do is beat teams into submission, we need to learn what they do when they lose by 20, because you gotta absolutely suck to be the best!!!
4
u/biggerbytheday19 Texas A&M Aggies 6h ago
Let’s not forget they were kinda robbed at uga
3
u/MikeMacBlu Notre Dame • Missouri State 6h ago
Any other team would be fighting for their lives next week.
3
u/N8_the_worst Kentucky Wildcats 6h ago
Now do Texas.
2
u/R0b1NH0oD Oklahoma • Red River Shootout 6h ago
Ive heard enough make them #1 /s
2
u/Marciano_il_Mario 6h ago
What were the records when Alabama played them?
2
u/Relative_One_2441 Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago
Alabama’s “quality” wins:
7-4 Kentucky (Away) 45-17
6-5 South Carolina (Home) 49-18
6-5 LSU (Away) 31-13
5-6 MSU (Away) 56-23
Alabama’s losses:
9-2 Tennessee (Away) 10-26
10-1 Georgia (Home) 17-20
Tennessee’s “quality” wins:
9-2 Alabama (Home) 26-10
7-4 Kentucky (Home) 34-6
6-5 LSU (Home) 27-13
Tennessee’s losses:
9-2 Texas (Home) 17-20
6-5 South Carolina (Away) 24-27
Common Opponents:
Texas A&M:
Tennessee W: 22-7 (Away)
Alabama W: 31-10 (Home)
Net Differential: +4 Tennessee
LSU
Tennessee W: 27-13 (Home)
Alabama W: 31-13 (Away)
Net Differential: +4 Alabama
South Carolina
Tennessee L: 24-27 (Away)
Alabama W: 49-18 (Home)
Net Differential: +34 Alabama
Kentucky
Tennessee W: 34-6 (Home)
Alabama W: 45-17 (Away)
Net Differential: 0
Vanderbilt
Tennessee TBD
Alabama W: 21-6
Auburn
Tennessee W: 24-14
Alabama TBD
Both Tennessee and Alabama played ACC opponents in OOC play. They’ve each also played one FBS and one FCS opponent.
ACC
Tennessee W over (3-8) Georgia Tech 45-24 (Away)
Alabama W over (5-6) Florida State 50-36 (Home)
FBS
Tennessee W over (5-6) Kennesaw State 42-9
Alabama W over (7-4) Eastern Carolina 48-10
FCS
Tennessee W over (4-8) Furman 56-9
Alabama W over (7–5) Chattanooga 47-0
Summary: These teams are mirror images from a conference scheduling and performance standpoint. Weird that we played the same schedule outside of (Texas/Arkansas)/(Georgia/MSU)
Tennessee has one better win and one worse loss. Alabama has more “good” wins and multiple ranked wins on the road, while all of Tennessee’s ranked SEC opponents have come to them in Neyland. Tennessee, of course has the head to head over Alabama in Neyland.
My takeaway is that these teams should, at the very least, be ranked right next to one another. Nothing about schedule difficulty or point differential indicates a 6 spot gap. Perfectly reasonable for Tennessee to be in front, given the H2H and many similarities almost everywhere else. I can also see a reasonable and measured case for Alabama in front as well. Regardless, Tennessee needs to move up.
I could also see rivalry week being a differentiator between the two, as we get the final data point, which could conceivably change things in the eyes of the committee.
2
u/MakesInappropriate Alabama Crimson Tide 6h ago edited 6h ago
Guys. Bama fans also are confused why we are number 3. We will not end the season top 4 i promise you. As entertaining as r/cfb’s obsession over alabama football is, im just ready for the final rankings to be here so you guys can get back to talking and thinking about anything other than alabama football
2
u/Atlas_B170 Tennessee • ETSU 6h ago
Don't look at my flair, I am completely unbiased. When anyone even says "Alabama" I start hearing the siren tone from Kill Bill in my head
2
u/Adventurous_Arm_5586 Chicago Maroons • Texas Longhorns 4h ago
At this point if they’re ranked above Texas it’s malpractice