r/CFB • u/supertruck97 • 6d ago
Analysis [Analysis] How bad is Marcel Reed? Historically. A look at 30 years of A&M starting QBs
Through 10 games, Marcel Reed has 8 TD, 9 INT and a 45.1 QBR, which was 16th of 16 qualified SEC QBs going into the Tennessee game. I wanted to see where that sits in A&M history.
**Method**
I looked at every A&M QB season from 1996 to 2025 in which the QB held the starting job through at least the first 10 games. I left out seasons where the starter was benched or replaced, or the job was shared:
- Jerrod Johnson 2010 (benched in game 7)
- Trevor Knight 2016 (shared with Hubenak)
- Zach Calzada 2021 (didn't start the first two games)
- The 2022 and 2023 seasons, when the job was split
I used full-season lines for the historical QBs, since game logs weren't available for most of the older seasons. QBR only goes back to 2004, so passer rating is the common yardstick.
**Reed through 10 games:** 160/287 (55.7%), 1,712 yards (171 per game), 8 TD, 9 INT, passer rating around 109.
**Results (bottom of the group, sorted by rating)**
| QB / Year | Cmp% | Yds/G | TD-INT | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stewart 1996 | 48.8 | 159 | 9-7 | 107.6 |
| Reed 2026 (10 G) | 55.7 | 171 | 8-9 | ~109 |
| Farris 2001 | 58.5 | 190 | 8-9 | 111.6 |
| McGee 2007 | 58.0 | 178 | 12-8 | ~118 |
| McCown 1999 | 51.5 | 216 | 14-10 | 128.0 |
| McNeal 2005 | 53.2 | 196 | 16-9 | 128.6 |
(~ = my own calculation.) The other nine seasons in the sample all rate 126 or higher: Farris 2000, McNeal 2004, McGee 2006, Johnson 2009, Tannehill 2011, Manziel 2012 and 2013, and Mond 2018-20. Manziel's 2013 is the top at 172.9.
**What the data shows**
- Reed has the second-lowest passer rating of the 16 seasons in the sample.
- Only two seasons in the group have more INTs than TDs: Reed 2026 and Farris 2001. Both are 8-9.
- Stewart 1996 is the only season that's clearly worse. His completion rate and yards per game were lower, but he had more TDs than INTs. That offense also ran about 47 times and passed about 27 times per game, so the yardage isn't comparable to a modern passing attack.
- Reed's 171 yards per game is second-lowest in the group, ahead of only Stewart.
- His INT rate (about 3.1%) is high but not the worst. McCown in 1999 and McNeal in 2005 were both around 3.4%.