r/CIVILWAR • u/MCWoodWork74 • 15m ago
Robert E. Lee opposed Confederate monuments in writing in 1869. How did we end up with hundreds of them anyway?
I write a small history newsletter as a hobby. I mostly do it because I like digging into the details that get lost when a topic turns into a talking point. I just finished a piece on the Lost Cause and wanted to share a few things that surprised me while researching it:
Lee said no to monuments. In 1869 he declined an invitation to help mark positions at Gettysburg, writing that it was wiser "not to keep open the sores of war."
The Confederates' own documents say slavery. Mississippi's 1861 secession declaration said its position was "thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery." Twenty years later, Jefferson Davis's memoir had a chapter heading calling slavery "not the Cause, but an Incident."
Longstreet got blamed for Gettysburg, but not until 1872. Jubal Early made the "dawn attack" accusation after Longstreet had become a Republican and led a mixed-race police force against the White League in New Orleans. Lee's own former staff officer searched Lee's papers for evidence against Longstreet and found nothing.
The textbook rules were written down. In 1919, the UDC's historian general published a pamphlet listing which school books to reject, including any that said the South fought to keep its slaves.
Most monuments came in two waves. One was roughly 1900–1920, and the other was during the civil rights era, not right after the war.
Full piece is here if anyone wants it: [link]
I'm curious what people here think about the North's role. Reconciliation needed white Northerners to accept a lot of this, and the 1913 Gettysburg reunion is a pretty striking example.