r/CanadianConservative • • Sep 09 '26

Meta State of the Subreddit - September 2026

Post image
191 Upvotes

State of the Subreddit: Brigading, Disagreement, and the Big Tent

Over the past several weeks, the mod team has received an increasing number of comments, reports, and mod mail over the past several weeks complaining about the brigading of r/CanadianConservative.

That said , we've also seen comments saying that the subreddit is effectively unmoderated because of said brigading being allowed.

We want to clarify what brigading actually means, as well as the moderation philosophy that began with the creation of this subreddit and continues to this day.

What is brigading?

Brigading, or community interference, is when users coordinate or organize activity intended to interfere with another community.

Examples can include:

  • A group being directed here from somewhere else specifically to disrupt discussion.
  • Coordinated mass voting intended to manipulate which opinions are visible.
  • Coordinated commenting, trolling, reporting, or harassment.
  • Organized attempts to overwhelm a community or manipulate its discussions.

Brigading is against Reddit's rules and against ours. When we have evidence of genuine community interference, we will take action. This includes an automated bot that sends a report everytime r/CanadianConservative is linked to from outside the subreddit.

But there is an important distinction:

Disagreement is not brigading.

Someone criticizing Donald Trump is not, by itself evidence that they are a brigader.

Someone supporting closer relations with the United States is not evidence that they are a brigader.

Someone opposing closer relations with the United States is not evidence that they are a brigader.

Someone criticizing Pierre Poilievre, supporting him, disagreeing with CPC policy, supporting the PPC, disliking the PPC, identifying as a Red Tory, libertarian, populist, social conservative, fiscal conservative, moderate, or something else does not make them a brigader.

And an opinion receiving more upvotes or downvotes than you expected is not, by itself, evidence of vote manipulation.

This is a big-tent conservative subreddit

Canadian conservatism has never been a single ideology.

There are significant disagreements within the right over trade, foreign policy, immigration, social issues, provincial autonomy, economic policy, populism, the role of government, the Conservative Party itself, and as of right now, Canada's relationship with the United States.

Those disagreements are allowed here.

I'll use myself as an example.

I'm a Wexit enjoyer. I believe everything west of Ontario would be better off as a separate country.

Does that automatically make me right? No.

Do I remove people who think otherwise? No.

Is it a meme-ideology? Likely (but I tell myself it isn't).

I don't remove comments from people who think Wexit is ridiculous, who strongly support Canadian federalism, or who think Western separation would be a disaster.

I'm a moderator, not the arbiter of what every conservative in this subreddit is required to believe.

I can argue my position. You can tell me I'm completely wrong. Someone else can argue something entirely different. That's the point of our community. If you're looking for a circle jerk of confirmation bias, there are many other subreddits tailored to that exact thing.

The same principle applies to the current debate surrounding the United States. Some conservatives strongly support the current US administration. Some agree with parts of its agenda but disagree with others. Some strongly dislike it. Some want a much closer relationship with the US, while others are deeply opposed to that.

None of those positions, by itself, establishes whether somebody belongs here.

"This subreddit is unmoderated"

We've also seen the accusation that r/CanadianConservative is "unmoderated" or that the moderators aren't doing anything.

The numbers simply don't support that.

There have been more than 14,000 individual moderator actions on this subreddit in the last 12 months, as well as 835 modmail messages sent.

"But you didn't answer my modmail!!1!11!", probably because you're A) complaining about a filter that isn't going to change or B) Complaining about brigaders when, on review, you got into an argument with another long-time member of the subreddit over the nuances of geopolitics.

Posts and comments are removed. Reports are reviewed. Spam is dealt with. Users are banned when necessary. Reddit's sitewide rules are enforced. Our article and submission standards are enforced.

A subreddit being actively moderated does not mean every comment you dislike will be removed.

Our goal is to enforce Reddit's Terms of Service/sitewide rules and the subreddit's article and submission standards, not to turn r/CanadianConservative into a police state where everyone has to tippy-toe around what they say because they're worried that one poorly worded sentence will get them banned.

There is a difference between passive moderation and active curation.

Moderation means enforcing the rules necessary to keep the community functional and compliant with Reddit's requirements, not to have an overbearing rule list on top of an over-the-top TOS where the mod team arbirarily decides what is and isn't allowed on the subreddit.

Curation would mean moderators deciding which opinions are acceptable, which flavours of conservatism are legitimate, which political positions should receive visibility, and removing otherwise rule-abiding users because we don't like what they're saying.

We're interested in the former, not the latter.

That inevitably means you're going to encounter comments here that annoy you, offend you, seem stupid to you, or directly contradict your own beliefs.

That's not evidence that the subreddit is unmoderated. In many cases, it's evidence that the moderators aren't using their powers to decide arguments for you. If you can't handle that, there are other subreddits that actively curate content in order to fit your particular flavour of conservatism.

What we don't want to become

We don't want users treating every unpopular opinion as evidence of infiltration.

If the response to disagreement becomes “brigader,” “Liberal pretending to be a conservative,” “bot,” or “you're not a real conservative,” we eventually stop debating ideas and start debating whether the person expressing them is allowed to be here.

That creates an echo chamber, and that isn't the purpose of this subreddit.

At the same time, being a big tent does not mean anything goes.

Users who come here solely to troll, antagonize the community, derail discussions, repeatedly violate the rules, or participate in actual coordinated interference will continue to be moderated. Downvote them into the ground and our filters take care of them pretty quickly.

A request to the community

Debate the argument instead of trying to disqualify the person making it.

If someone says something you strongly disagree with, challenge it. Ask them to defend it. Provide evidence. Downvote it if you think it contributes nothing.

But please don't report someone for brigading simply because their politics don't perfectly match yours.

Likewise, please don't assume that because a comment you reported remains up, the moderators "aren't doing anything." A report brings something to our attention; it does not automatically mean that content violates the rules. The report button is not a button to request moderators to silence an opinion you don't like.

If you genuinely suspect coordinated interference, report it and let the moderators investigate it. Evidence of users being directed here, coordinated voting/commenting, organized disruption, or similar behaviour is considerably more useful than “this person doesn't sound conservative to me.”

We will continue watching for genuine brigading and taking action when warranted. We will continue enforcing Reddit's rules and our own standards.

But we're also going to continue protecting people's ability to disagree.

- r/CanadianConservative Mod Team


r/CanadianConservative • • Feb 26 '26

Meta Reminder About Reddit's Terms of Service & Community Standards

0 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

Given recent events in the country, the Reddit Admin team has reached out to remind us that all subreddits on the platform, including r/CanadianConservative, must comply with Reddit’s Sitewide Rules. As your mod team, we are responsible for ensuring that content posted here follows Reddit’s policies, whether or not it breaks our own subreddit rules. It's 2026, and that means we all share responsibility in making sure r/CanadianConservative is an inclusive, welcoming safe space so that nobody gets offended. Failure to do so will result in this community getting shut down.

Going forward, we will be more actively enforcing Reddit's Content policy, specifically, policies related to harassment, hate speech, threats (or encouragement of violence), and abusive behaviour. Going forward, if you're a repeat offender: sorry, it's going to be an automatic ban, with very little room for appeal. We've been pretty relaxed on bans up to this point but if you can't play by Reddit's rules, you're gone.

Expect some updates to r/CanadianConservative's rules in the coming days to better reflect what Reddit expects of the community and to ensure we're all on the same page.

A quick brush up on the issues we face as a subreddit:

Harrassment

What it is:
Targeting a person or group with repeated, hostile, or degrading behaviour meant to intimidate, shame, or drive them away.

Examples:

  • Intentionally misgendering
  • Following a user across posts to harass/insult
  • Posting comments like, “You people are mentally ill and shouldn’t exist.”
  • Creating threads specifically to ridicule a particular individual.
  • Repeatedly tagging someone just to provoke a reaction.

Discussion of general policy is allowed. However Reddit says that the targeting of someone based on their identity crosses into harassment.

Hate Speech

What it is:
Content that attacks, dehumanizes, or promotes exclusion of people based on protected characteristics.

Examples:

  • Claiming a group of people is inherently dangerous, predatory, or immoral.
  • Saying a certain identity group should lose civil rights.
  • Using slurs directed at a protected group.
  • Arguing that a specific community is “a threat to society.”
  • Using a violent incident to claim that an entire identity group is responsible or dangerous.
  • Saying women, religious minorities, or LGBTQ+ people should not participate in public life.

Discussion of general policy is allowed. Attacking identity is not. Generalizing criminal behaviour or moral failings to an entire group is considered hateful conduct under Reddit’s TOS

Threats or Encouragement of Violence

What it is:
Direct or indirect statements that endorse, encourage, or fantasize about violence toward a person or group.

Examples:

  • “Someone should deal with these people permanently.”
  • “They deserve what’s coming to them.”
  • Expressing approval of violence against a group.
  • Saying a group should be “eliminated” or “removed.”
  • “I hope someone hurts them.”
  • Joking about killing someone in a way that implies real harm.

Even if phrased as “jokes” or sarcasm, statements that normalize or celebrate violence are considered genuine threats under Reddit's TOS.

Abusive Behaviour

What it is:
Personal attacks, degrading language, or conduct meant to demean or humiliate others.

Examples:

  • Calling someone slurs or derogatory names.
  • Saying a person is “disgusting” because of who they are.
  • Posting edited images or memes meant to humiliate a protected group.
  • Telling someone to harm themselves.
  • Attacking someone’s identity instead of engaging with their argument.
  • Mocking someone’s appearance, disability, or transition.

Even when framed as humour, frustration, or “just being honest”, abusive behaviour is abusive behaviour and is covered under Reddit's TOS.

I wish I didn't have to make this communication, but welcome to Reddit. It's their sandbox, we just get to shit in it. If you can't follow these rules, go to another platform that allows genuine debate like X or other Reddit alternatives.

Thanks.


r/CanadianConservative • • 9h ago

Article Pierre Poilievre calls no jail sentence for child rapist ‘abhorrent’

Thumbnail
ctvnews.ca
63 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 10h ago

Satire Chat is this true

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 11h ago

Discussion Did the Ontario Liberals just hand Doug Ford another Majority?

Post image
77 Upvotes

With the Ontario Liberals electing Navdeep Bains as their leader, I can't help but think Doug Ford is probably laughing at the thought of winning yet another election.


r/CanadianConservative • • 16h ago

Social Media Post And They Want To Bring More Immigrants

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 18h ago

Discussion It doesn't matter what we do or who we vote for as we will be demographically replaced in 20-30 years

96 Upvotes

I've kind of stopped caring about what the government does, initially more for my own mental health but now it's more because Indon't think we cna do anything to correct course. By Statcan's own reports even a few years ago before Carney's immigration hikes they posited that by 2041 ablut 46-51% of people in Canada will be first generation immigrants or the children of those immigrants. By 2050 it's supposed to be the majority and by 2100 it's posited to be upwards of 80%.

This will have major implications and create massive change in our society as the people immigrating come from places with starkly different values structures and institutions that are at times diametrically opposed to those in Canadian society. As these people grow to become the majority they will (as in any represenative democracy) begin to constitute a major part of the electirate, they will enter snd take over the institutions and when they do our values of things like civic government, a western interpretation of jurisprudence and the foundation if our laws and moral systems (that being built upon earlier Christian frameworks) will begin to subside or be replaced by new ones. Canada will change drastically as a result and I feel dejected. We're at a point where I don't believe we can vote our way out if it, reversing course would likely mean a remigration program that would deport literal millions of people from even the last few hears alongside tighter immigration restrictions and likely pro-natalist policies to instead stimulate fertility rates. The government will howoever never do this since they are beholdened to corporate lobbying from businesses who have a vested interest in keeping immigration high.

I think about this often and it creates an existential depression. On one side of my family we are habitants, we have been living in Canada since before Canada even existed and now hundreds of years later we are slated to he pushed out of our homes and swept away.


r/CanadianConservative • • 9h ago

Article Mark Carney and Canada’s no-question period - The Globe and Mail

Thumbnail theglobeandmail.com
15 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 17h ago

Social Media Post And who is footing the bill?

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 9h ago

Article Taiwan warns Canada’s Carney that deeper ties with China come with risks

Thumbnail
apnews.com
11 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 14h ago

News Navdeep Bains elected as Ontario Liberal Leader

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 20h ago

Video, podcast, etc. Doug Ford admits that it’s the federal industrial carbon tax that is killing the Ontario auto industry

57 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 16h ago

Article Tenants in Madrid say Toronto-based Brookfield is pricing them out of formerly public housing | CBC News

Thumbnail
cbc.ca
21 Upvotes

"They are pushing us out of our houses," said Rafael Cuadrado, who has lived in the complex for 20 years.

The main target of the residents' wrath is Toronto-based Brookfield Corporation.


r/CanadianConservative • • 21h ago

News Canada's crumbling healthcare system is 'owed half a billion dollars by visitors who left unpaid hospital bills'... as wait times for residents rocket

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
36 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 14h ago

News Doug Ford on Carbon Taxes

Thumbnail x.com
9 Upvotes

Ontario’s Ford and Fedeli after the Stellantis meeting: Canada’s GHG costs are a self-own that makes our auto industry uncompetitive against the US They said Canadian producers are “competing against the rest of the world, especially down to the US with both hands tied behind our back.”

US plants don’t face the same emissions expenses, so Canadian operations lose money on every car. Stellantis kept pointing to the GHG costs (plus ZEV mandates in BC and Quebec) as the core problem—two different playing fields.

Their bottom line: scrap the unnecessary GHG penalties that are costing billions if you want jobs and plants kept “warm.”

In other words, the federal emissions regime Carney and the Liberals defend is the binding constraint on competitiveness against our biggest customer. Ontario’s own Conservatives just called it out


r/CanadianConservative • • 21h ago

Discussion Liberal Voters and Liberal Party Does Not Adhere To It's Own Liberal Ideology

30 Upvotes

Liberalism is a political and moral philosophy centered on individual liberty, consent of the governed, political equality, and equality before the law.

The Liberal voters and the party no longer adhere to last two principles and haven't been adhering to them for a long time.

1. Political equality - For liberals it's completely acceptable to pander to ethnic minorities or women, but when it's white people or men, then it's bigotry or dog whistles. Another example is how certain groups in our society have a lot more political capital and importance than the rest. The two main groups are French speaking Canadians and Indigenous people. Another example is free speech and what kind of speech needs to be silenced while ignoring actual hate speech from certain groups. A good example are annual May Day riots which are referred as protests by the media. These riots never provoke any mass media or government reaction. However when it's white nationalists, police literally call businesses to prevent them from getting a venue at which they can speak at. An example of this is Hamilton Police this year.

2. Equality before the law- You can get discounted sentences for being racialized minority. Our own Charter allows this in subsection 1 of section 15 equality rights meaning ever since Pierre Elliot Trudeau, our country was never equal before the law. Discrimination is still allowed in terms of DEI policies that hire and promote based on race, gender and/or religion.

Liberal party and their voters are not Liberal. They are all hateful scum that don't even adhere to their own ideology. Instead of having principles, "Liberals" have groups they deem important - racialized minorities, women, Muslims, First Nations people and groups that they deem unimportant or a threat - White people, men, Christians, Conservatives.


r/CanadianConservative • • 17h ago

Video, podcast, etc. Is Canadian money making Spain's housing crisis worse?

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

Discussion Did Carney compensate Brazil with $560 million of Canadian taxpayers' money, so Brookfield wouldn't have to? Deforestation, slave labour...

72 Upvotes

2025 - Carney's former firm Brookfield has been accused of breaching Indigenous rights in 4 countries

Under Mark Carney's leadership, global investment firm Brookfield was accused of breaching Indigenous rights or harming the environment in at least four countries, CBC Indigenous has found.

Carney, who is running for prime minister as Liberal leader, spent more than four years as vice chair and then chair at Brookfield Asset Management, where he focused on green investing and renewable energy.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/brookfield-carney-indigenous-rights-1.7498967


r/CanadianConservative • • 19h ago

News An ‘urgent’ power crisis emerged after Cohere joined this Ontario data centre. Now electricity bills are rising

Thumbnail
thestar.com
7 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

News We need Canadian ICE

Thumbnail
globalnews.ca
113 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

Discussion Carney has 4 critical weak points: Immigration, Deficit budget, Bill C-22, Bill C-34. Most mainstream centrists and swing voters are against Carney on this when they hear.

20 Upvotes

If the Conservatives want to narrow the polling and bring back all the voters they lost to Carney, they need to focus on these 4 weak points centrists agree on. They can't get distracted on things that centrist swing voters don't care for, like trans people in bathrooms.


r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

Satire Canadian vs American vs British Healthcare

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/CanadianConservative • • 11h ago

Discussion How To Make Canadians Have Kids And Make Canada's Economy Productive Again With Single Legislation

0 Upvotes

Why don't Canadians have kids? This phenomenon is not unique to Canada and United States. They are not having enough children in UK, France, Italy, Germany, South Korea, Japan and almost every developed nation. Meanwhile, if you take a look at every poor nation, they are growing their population through birth not immigration. Now now. I know what you're thinking and no I'm not suggesting we make Canada poor. But just think about it. Why is that the case? Most people in Canada, including the sub here say they don't want kids or are not ready to have kids because it's too expensive. It's also too expensive in Colombia, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, etc etc. But their people are having kids. Why? It's very simple. Because those nations are poor, they don't have a lot of services that we do in Canada and other developed nations. Which is good for us. But one of those services has single handedly destroyed our birth rates. It's Old Age Security. The answer is simple. In poorer nations, they don't have old age security hence having kids is a necessity as kids are the ones that take care of you when you're elderly. In the West, the government takes care of you. We don't just have a nanny state. We have a nanny state built specifically for our elderly. Canadians aged 65+, 45 years ago, had one of the best and easiest capitalist economies in history. Young people today, while the standards of living have improved for everyone worldwide, face worse prospects and standards than they would of had 45 years ago.

Let's go over the numbers. We spend $90 billion annually on Old Age Security. We could build 400,000 new homes annually with that money. We could end homelessness nation wide in Canada and United States with that money. We could build massive nation building projects that Carney keeps talking about and not doing. Instead, we spend it on people that are least productive members of our society. What would happen if we end OAS?

You create an incentive for people to have kids instead of financial incentives we provide that are not working. Having kids will no longer be a want but a need if you want financial security at your old age. I know I know what retractors are thinking - I'm evil for hating old people? Well, if we cut OAS and any elderly person ends up homeless because of this change, we could end homelessness not just for elderly people but for all Canadians. We could also heavily subsidize early child care for young Canadians to have kids earlier. We will invest those $90 billion each year we are spending to instead make our country more productive by investing into many different industries.

But we won't do it. Because each country that even tries to claw back OAS even a little bit, gets kicked out of government next election. What does that say about the elderly? They're going to die soon and they're going to take the countries down with them.


r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

Discussion It actually really impressive utterly incompetent the Alberta ndp is after Rachael notley

8 Upvotes

One year until a election and the ucp are leasing by ten points in newest poll


r/CanadianConservative • • 1d ago

Social Media Post Christian music ❌ Terrorism conference ✅

Post image
72 Upvotes