r/Capitalism • u/Epiphyte78 • 1h ago
do you understand how luxuries become commodities?
in this thread the op wrote about how he received a bunch of hate when he shared on a plant forum that he spent $2700 on a rare plant. he asked for explanations of the hate. there were many responses, but not a single one of them mentioned anything about how luxuries become commodities, except for mine...
**************
please link to the thread. i only have pachypodium lamerei and pachypodium geayi. oh yeah, i also have pachypodium succulentum.
the explanation of the hate is painfully simple. people weren't taught how luxuries become commodities. they don't know that when you and others spend small fortunes for a rare plant, that this greatly encourages and motivates the few people who have the rare plant to propagate it, which increases the supply and reduces the price.
the solution is also simple, in theory. at the top of every nursery homepage should be the question, "what should we carry?" below it would be a list of suggested plants, sorted by donations to the nursery.
**************
on fig forums i often see people complaining about high prices. they say economically absurd things like, "anyone who is willing to pay ridiculously high prices for these rare figs is seriously stupid, especially since the prices always quickly drop." the only reason that the prices quickly drop is because the supply quickly increases. and the only reason the supply quickly increases is because the high prices strongly motivate propagation. so the only economically coherent comment would be something like, "i sure hope that plenty of people pay the high prices for these rare figs, because this will greatly encourage their propagation, so they will quickly become more abundant and affordable."
in case you missed it, this is not a fig forum. this is "a place to discuss capitalism and capitalist interests on reddit." everyone on here should thoroughly understand how luxuries become commodities. sadly this is really not the case, based on everyone's responses to the thread i linked to.
initially i was hopeful that ai would help eliminate basic economic ignorance. for example...
**************
The economic arc of Philodendron spiritus-sancti is a classic case study in extreme scarcity rents giving way to supply-curve collapse via biotechnological scaling:
- The Scarcity & Veblen Phase (Pre-2021): With fewer than a dozen known wild plants and strict export bans, supply was virtually fixed (Q ≈ 0). Collectors treated it as a Veblen status good, pushing prices to $10,000–$20,000+ per cutting.
- The Biotech Supply Shock (2021–2023): High prices acted as a massive profit signal, incentivizing commercial labs in Thailand, Ecuador, and the U.S. to crack its tissue culture (micropropagation) protocol. Tissue culture shifts propagation from slow, linear vegetative division to exponential cloning.
- Price Collapse & Commoditization (2023–Present): Once labs flooded the market with thousands of genetically identical clones, the supply curve shifted violently right. The price floor collapsed by over 99%—turning a five-figure luxury trophy into a $30–$65 mass-market houseplant.
- Ex-Situ Conservation Externality: Crucially, market forces achieved what regulation alone couldn't—by crashing the price of cultivated clones, the profit incentive to poach the remaining wild plants in Brazil vanished overnight.
**************
any ai can quickly explain the straightforward economic process by which a luxury becomes a commodity. and it can provide endless examples, from oranges to books to refrigerators to smartphones. so what explains the widespread persistence of ignorance regarding basic economic concepts? obviously not enough people are aware of their economic ignorance.
moderators, please sticky this thread. ignore all the downvotes.