We have two female cats, Whimsy (almost 2) and Solstice (almost 1), and today we adopted a 4 month old male kitten, Nyx.
Whimsy and Solstice have lived together since April. Their initial introduction was rocky, with Whimsy hissing at Solstice during their short supervised interactions, and Whimsy playing a little too rough which scared Solstice, but after a slow introduction they became very close. They play, groom each other, and frequently sleep cuddled up together. The photo is actually from the night before everything happened, when they were both curled up on my lap.
We’re now doing a slow introduction with Nyx, using separate spaces, scent swapping, room swapping, and supervised interactions.
Surprisingly, Whimsy has been very accepting of Nyx. She’s curious, sniffs him, watches him play, and generally seems comfortable around him. Solstice, however, has been more apprehensive (despite being our sweeter and more confident kitty, so this has come at a bit of a surprise). She hissed the few times she briefly saw him, although she’s also curious and frequently tries to get in.
We fed all the kitties on opposite sides of the door, which went well. Both girls seemed really curious about him and Whimsy especially was chirping and seemed to want to play. We decided to try a short supervised interaction between Whimsy and Nyx, which went super well and we were excited! Solstice was waiting outside, and was trying to get in, and we thought seeing Whimsy interact positively with him might help…. However, when we briefly let her into the room, she immediately hissed and ran away.
Looking back, I think we got too excited because things seemed to be going well and rushed that step. I really regret bringing her in before she was ready because it’s clearly caused some issues…
Later, Whimsy and Solstice got into a pretty significant fight involving yowling, hissing, puffed-up tails, and physical wrestling. We separated them, and although they initially seemed okay after calming down (even ate treats near each other and played a bit) Solstice has since been hiding, growling, and hissing at Whimsy. Whimsy seems interested in approaching her, but Solstice keeps retreating and hissing.
It’s upsetting because they were so affectionate with each other. Even last night they were both curled up on my lap. I’m assuming Nyx’s scent or presence may have caused redirected aggression.
We eventually got Solstice to calm down and she even curled up on my lap and asked for pets and kisses and purred. We’ve currently separated all three cats to give everyone space.
So my questions are, should we essentially restart the introduction between Whimsy and Solstice? Or is there something else we should be doing to help ease the tension? And should we pause Nyx’s introduction until the girls are comfortable with each other again?
We really don’t want to rush things again or make the situation worse, so any advice or similar experiences would be appreciated! I’m just super worried that bringing in a third kitty ruined the other two permanently, but I have hope it will get better since they are all still pretty young.
TLDR: introducing a third kitten has seemingly wrecked the relationship between our other two kitties, and we’re not sure how to move forward
Edit:: I forgot to mention that they are all fixed and up to date on vaccines