r/CharacterRant • • 16h ago

Civil war would not work in DC because a majority of DC heroes would be anti registration

247 Upvotes

I saw a post that asked what if dc had civil war, and speculated which hero would be anti/pro registration. It was an interesting idea, but the more I thought about it, I realized that a lot of DC heroes would be against it.

Starting off with the big three, even batman wouldn't support it. I know he has those contingencies in place to avoid the JL going rogue, but that's him in control. He wouldn't want those plans in the hands of the government because he's too paranoid to let anyone other than him be in charge of those plans (well sometimes the batfamily, but they're y'know his family). By letting the government have oversight on him, he loses the ability to perform his more shady activities. He could be a backer behind it, but eventually he'd realizes that by putting the heroes on such a tight leash, this lets even shadier people than him, like waller and luthor have leverage on those heroes.

Superman wouldn't support it for similar reasons, but he also believes in freedom of expression. There's also the numerous super heroes that he himself sanctioned, like super girl, power girl, shazam, etc. He's much more a fan of "policing his own" for better or worse. Diana is similar, she's stern, but she also distrusts authority thanks to zeus being a creep toward her and attempting to rape her. She also comes from an island of diplomats (aside from a handful of shitty comics), who believe in non violence first; which isn't an option when you have government agenda holding the reigns.

There's also the green lanterns who answer to a higher power, wally west who was friends with castro and aided in the cuban revolution (somehow?), various aliens (matrians, thangarians, tamaranians, etc).

There's also the fact that dc heroes are of one mind. They make decisions with each other, and anyone who's a hero in dc either ends up in the JL or titans so they'd just defer to what the heads of those groups would say.

The only heroes I could imagine being pro registration are barry allen (a cop), Mr. Terrific (someone who'd find the idea of registration reasonable), and captain atom (who's a bit of a government stooge). But those characters would not agree with registration because Amanada waller is entrenched in the government.

Now there are parts in DC where registration, or ideas similar to registration are introduced. Injustice is the biggest culprit, but there have been more than enough rants done on this sub on why that story sucked, and how everyone was OOC. Another example is Kingdom come, but that comes with a huge asterisk because it wasn't the government enforcing the heroes, it was the main Justice League.

The most prominent example I could think of is Kurt Busiek's trinity, where half way through the story; history changes so that superman, wonder woman, and batman never existed. It goes off the walls quick, but a notable part of this new universe is how the JSA (the ww2 era super heroes) stuck around and created an industry based on indoctrinating heroes. But again they're a private industry, not government backed; and characters like wally west lead a non registered super team that doesn't get much flak from the main team.

In the main universe, an example of super heroes teaming up with the government that comes to mind is during that one batman/superman story. The one with the kryptonite meteor and shit. But even this has caveats. Most of the heroes ended up siding with batman and superman in the end, and the duo had to be framed for them to even be considered a threat in the first place.

So to surmise, registration in dc would not catch on because

  1. the government is too shady. Amanda Waller is just one of the many many reasons none of the heroes would sign on with the government, but even disregarding that a lot of the heroes in dc are distrustful of authority.
  2. Their heroes have too much of a one track mind. If supes says something, half the super heroes follow him. If batman says something the other half follow him. You'd be hard pressed to find anyone who'd go against both of them. And they'd both want super hero registration out of the governments hands.
  3. Even in universes with registration, or registration adjacent concepts; things usually fall apart or the registration ends up getting cancelled.
  4. Mark millar isn't writing for dc at the moment (thank god)

r/CharacterRant • • 22h ago

Films & TV Why does Hollywood make the past look so aesthetically drab and soulless as possible, even outright cheap/rummage-like, despite the lavish budget and talent attached?

131 Upvotes

(Rant made after viewing The Odyssey and The Uprising)

Seriously, is it their way of telling how the past sucked? Which fine, compared to modern civilization and its amenities, I suppose it did, but is this the way to convey that?

If anything, aesthetic and fashion-wise, it's the modern world that's quite minimalistic and "utilitarian", with emphasis on functionality, in regards to fashion, especially men's, it's quite monochromatic when it comes to their formal and ceremonial wear,

The past was FAR from colorless and drab, and if anything, was the polar opposite of the modern world, in how colorful and vibrant it was to the point of coming across as potentially "flamboyant" to modern sensibilities, even,

By now, with so many memes and awareness online pointing this out, I feel Hollywood might take a note or two and make some necessary corrections, but nope....

Is it because making new props and costumes out of scratch isn't as easy, no matter how much lavish budget they might allocate for a period piece? I mean, it does require hiring and consultation of professional and skilled craftsmen, artisans, designers, historians, etc, etc.....maybe more so than monetary issues, it's simply more of a time constraint? Because no matter the creative vision and freedom, they still need to satisfy producer/distributor mandate and get completed on time?

All that budget, with the most prolific names attached to them, and they look ugly/hideous to look at, ugh....imagine how gorgeous the Odyssey could've been with Nolan's oft-praised cinematography, if it tried to be faithful historically with the aesthetics, instead....it was downright gross at times, to see the mismatched and anachronistic aesthetic at full display,

The Uprising wasn't as bad, despite being a smaller movie, compared to the Odyssey, but it was also guilty. It did have some color in it (that prince/bad guy's armor in the climax was quite visually remarkable, but that's about it, it too was a drab and bland movie to look at, otherwise)


r/CharacterRant • • 4h ago

General I hate when people ask for “consequences” without explaining what they mean (mostly digital circus)

114 Upvotes

What i am talking about is that i engage with the discourse about Jax and among the more rancid takes his haters usually have is that Jax suffered no consequences

My big issue is that no one explains what “consequences” means??

Do they want Jax to go to jail? How exactly?

Do they want Jax to know everyone hates his ass? He already does and is actively surprised Pomni cares for him at the finale

Literally the only thing i can imagine is that they want Jax to have the most painful death by all the other characters who then proceed to throw a party about it

I dont think i need to explain how that’s overkill and sounds immature at best, Jax is nowhere near as bad to warrant this reaction, i think getting so depressed you die is enough


r/CharacterRant • • 16h ago

Games [LES] It's always a little funny getting to the part of every single videogame retrospective where they talk about how the franchise has some of the best music in all of gaming history.

94 Upvotes

Hey guys, did you that that Zelda/Final Fantasy/Castlevania/Halo/Sonic/Mass Effect/Mega Man/Doom/Mario/Witcher/Fire Emblem/Command and Conquer/Xenoblade/Dragon Quest/Pikmin/Elder Scrolls/Persona/Harvest Moon/Dues Ex/Nier/Metal Gear Solid/Every Supergiant Game/Kingdom Hearts/Metroid/Pokemon/Heroes of Might and Magic/Ace Combat/Guilty Gear/Blazblue/Splatoon/Jet Set Radio/Katamari Damacy/[A billion other series] has an amazing soundtrack led by a gifted composer that's easily among the best in all of gaming?

If I was being glib, this is where I'd put an Incredibles "If everyone's Super, no-one is" meme, but honestly, I don't really disagree.

I think Videogames truly have been blessed with some exceptionally good soundtracks over the years and anytime someone assures me that their favourite franchise has some of the best music gaming, chances are I'll find something I like out of it.

Partially, it's probably nostalgia, especially since you're also associating that music with what's very likely some good gameplay. You'll note almost without exception that the games held up as having amazing music are also popular and beloved games; I can't think of many games that're considered poor games but remembered for an amazing soundtrack. Still, even beyond that, I just think that in general, there really is a lot of very good stuff out there.

EDIT: Funnily enough, gatcha might be the example where people agree that the gameplay probably sucks but the music is still fantastic. Nikke, Girls' Frontline and Umamusume all have highly praised soundtracks, while 2/3 of those get regular complaints about the gameplay (GFL1 is an acquired taste, to be fair). I haven't played Ruina, how's that fit into this spectrum?


r/CharacterRant • • 10h ago

(Low effort) Dear Wonder Woman writers, stop rehashing the moment she meets Steve Trevor. I promise you, I get it.

88 Upvotes

I finished reading Tom King’s Wonder War Part 1 and in addition to being deeply confused by a lot of story elements that weren’t explained what annoyed me is that after Diana sacrifices herself so Steve and her daughter Trinity can escape the under world. Steve sits down with Trinity and explains yet again how he met Diana and how she ended up going to Man’s world.

And it made me audibly groan because we have done this so many times. It’s a trap I notice Wonder Woman fall into over and over again. Every run, every adaptation it constantly needs to remind me how Diana met Steve and went to Man’s World even if the story itself is about an already established Wonder Woman who has lived in Man’s World for decades.

Greg Rucka’s Wonder Woman Year One did this, the animated movie Wonder Woman Bloodlines did this, Earth One did this and now Tom King is doing this.

Look I get it, Steve Trevor crashing on Paradise Island is a pivotal moment for Diana. It’s her equivalent of Krypton blowing up or Bruce’s parents getting shot but also I get it we don’t need to keep being reminded how she met Steve. We don’t need to be constantly reintroduced to her. You can trust that the people reading her books probably know her backstory and don’t need to be told. Imagine if the plot of Batman stopped dead in its tracks to remind us that Batman is sad because he misses his parents.

Sometimes it’s acceptable. I like it in Absolute Wonder Woman because obviously that entire line serves as a reintroduction to the characters. So it’s different, narratively, to how it usually plays out.

But at a certain point can we just get past the origin and just let her be herself? It’s why my pitch for a Wonder Woman movie in the DCU (assuming Skydance doesn’t reduce her to a depowered piece of eye candy sidelined for the men) would have her already be an established hero with an established history, maybe having served in WW2 so we can get that out of the way and just let her be a modern character.

Because so many writers seem to get how to do the “fish out of water” part of Diana’s story but struggle with how to write her as an established hero so we just get reheated leftovers in the form of rehashing her backstory over and over again.

I know how she met Steve Trevor, I am humbly begging you guys to please tell the story you are telling.


r/CharacterRant • • 5h ago

Anime & Manga (LES) The Buu saga reads as if Akira Toriyama couldn’t make up his mind of who the hero should be

60 Upvotes

First off, hope you’re resting easy, Toriyama

Continuing on

I re-read the Buu saga earlier this year and it’s so jarring upon retrospect. Yes, I’m aware of the fact the fact that Gohan was supposed to be the main character, but then fan backlash wanted Goku, but apparently that’s just a rumor so I’m not going into further detail with that

Anyway, it’s like Toriyama couldn’t decide who’d beat Buu

“Okay, I’m gonna make Gohan the main character for this arc! No wait, I think I’ll bring back Goku and make him the MC! Actually, wait, I’m gonna shift it back to Gohan! Wait wait, I think I’m gonna make the new generation, Goten and Trunks the focus and beat Buu! Actually, maybe Vege-no that’s dumb I’m gonna make Goku the focus with SS3! Actually wait I think I should make it Gotenks and have him with SS3! No wait actually I’m gonna make it Mystic Gohan and have him beat Buu! Never mind, maybe I should make it Vegito! Actually, no maybe I shou-aah fuck it I’ll just make Goku the MC with the spirit bomb.”

Edit: So many of you guys are missing the point. This isn’t about the Gohan rumor, it’s about how Toriyama couldn’t make up his mind.


r/CharacterRant • • 17h ago

Films & TV Do people… actually like the DCEU?

44 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing an uproar of Zack Snyder / DCEU fans since the whole James Gunn situation and like… I legitimately forgot all about Zack Snyder and that people actually enjoy those movies.

I remember Man of Steel was okay as a kid. Pretty much forgot all about it so I didn’t have a strong opinion on it. But I was 10-11 years old when Batman vs. Superman came out and I remember that was the first movie to make me realize that some movies can be bad. And funnily enough, when I brought this up to my dad, he remembered it too.

I could go on about every movie that released within that universe but it’s all the same old story. They pretty much all sucked besides maybe Wonder Woman? The Suicide Squad is a fun ride as well but the universe lost all of its connection tissue and care by that point in time and is now retconned into another universe.

It was extremely exciting for fans of Zack Snyder to get his Justice League cut and it was pretty solid but heavily dragged out. But to my surprise, PEOPLE STILL TALK ABOUT HIM? I thought that was the closure and messy bow wrapped out this whole thing.

Why do people still like those movies? A 50 year old Batman, a boring ass Superman. A universe that was interfered and fucked up by its third movie. The movies are masterpieces but it needs to be the Ultimate Cut, Director’s Cut, a cut that has been banished to the vault (Suicide Squad), and a cut that people are confused on if it exists or not (WW’s sloppy third act).

After that none of the movies might as well be connected at all. There was no Batfamily at all, killing off Dick Grayson instead of the obvious choice of Jason Todd. A fuck ton of miscast and wrong choice for directors. Batman didn’t have a movie. No Catwoman, Robin, Oracle, Nightwing. Aquaman was the only one to make a billion. It boggles my mind that people enjoyed this universe. That run from 2018-2021 was so fucking bad and pathetic from DC and we’re just throwing shit at a fan dude.

I legit haven’t thought about Zack Snyder in YEARS and people like him. Wild.


r/CharacterRant • • 13h ago

Games (Mild RDR2 and GTA 6 spoilers) Jason can’t be antagonistic to people like Arthur was Spoiler

31 Upvotes

Warning: I do not think Jason is cuck or simp, just bland.

When people justifiably criticise Jason personality as being more bland, dull, not out there than Lucia he gets defended of being like Arthur Morgan type of personality which I do not get. Arthur despite being man with heart of gold with high Honor or bitter man clinging for a former glory and salvation in low Honor was not a 100% bland or dull, he wasn’t as introverted as Jason. He could read the room, be sarcastic, witty or outright cruel. Arthur got teeth when he wants to. It can be easily seen if you played RDR2, when Arthur in free roam antagonise people be it strangers or own comrades. There is so much venom in his lines, saying to Uncle that maybe Micah was right about him, calling Molly Dutch plaything, insulting Grimshaw about her age, for fucks sake insulting Bill for his old name, insulting Jack about John being shit father, the list can go on. Arthur in surface may be seen like a typical muscle man but he is very outspoken and witty whether it in his personality or trauma cope. But playing the GTA 6 and trying to insult pedestrians is such a disappointment. His lines feels lazy, forced and dull. “Man fuck you”, “Get out of here”, “Better watch out”. God it feels like he is in the B tier movie and director told him to be really really mean. Arthur insulting someone’s horse is more creative than all Jason’s insults. Even Lucia have some fire in her insults.

So yeah, maybe feels like nitpick but Jason is what people thought Arthur is without playing RDR2. Even in realistic setting character can be interesting and not overly extroverted.


r/CharacterRant • • 1h ago

General [LES] You don’t know how weird the fans’ limitations on how Superman can be depicted in media until you use that logic on other famous Superheroes

24 Upvotes

By their logic…

Every Spider-Man piece of media where Spidey gets hit by something is bad because spider-senses should mean he can never ever get hit

And I guess we could never ever get a Spider-Man game, because Spidey is just too overpowered. He literally has webs and can swings across buildings— he would never die from a fall. There wouldn’t be any challenge because he has the strength to lift entire trains and whole buildings— not only that, he can also think faster than any human and has LITERALLY SPIDER SENSE PRECOGNITIVE ABILITIES! How would you make a game where you’re playing a guy who can dodge bullets? Literally every thug would be an instant win!

“Oh but they could just use stronger foes from Spider-Man’s gargantuan rogues gallery that actually can match the wall crawler”

But then it wouldn’t be Spider-Man! The whole amazing fantasy is that he’s strong and can swing with webs dude! If it’s just a boss rush game, then it would feel like regular man- not Spider-Man

Oh, and there’s just NO WAY we could EVER get a Wolverine game ever. Wolverine is literally impossible to kill with conventional weapons— what would even be the challenge? He would always regenerate anyways! And no, you can’t use his stronger foes from the comics, it has to be regular thugs/PMCs and nothing else!

Oh? You really think they could make a Batman game? My guy, Batman is literally a super genius who’s always one step ahead of whoever he’s going against. That would be impossible. And not only that, he has a Batmobile, Batwing, bulletproof suits, etc etc. He is simply too powerful. And also, Batman doesn’t kill, so how would they make a game where the player can go absolutely ham on thugs and launch them off buildings? It would completely go against the character and break immersion! The game would be unplayable!


r/CharacterRant • • 20h ago

Games Halo 4-6 should have had Arbiter as the protagonist | The Metal Gear Rising approach to the 343 sequels

12 Upvotes

I was partially inspired by Tony Vuong's pitch in Quora, though I have not seen anyone suggesting this idea before, so I decided to do this little write-up.

Looking back to the "Reclaimer Trilogy" whatever that meant, people debate where it went wrong. I'd argue the original sin was bringing back Master Chief in the first place. When I first beat Halo 3, I kind of accepted it as the series' ending. Chief sacrificed himself, accomplished his mission, and drifted into the endless darkness of space, and might be picked up... I don't know, a million years later? That is, if he gets picked up. I always thought that that was the end of him, remaining as a legend for humans, who hold a funeral. Halo 3 was the perfect send-off point.

So when I saw the E3 2011 teaser of Halo 4, I was completely befuddled. Wait, Master Chief is back? Halo 3 came out only 4 years ago! And indeed, the game does say that only 4 years have passed from the events of Halo 3. Really? Didn't literally 2/3 of humanity get extinct in the last war? Didn't Earth get glassed? The Holy Roman Empire lost 20%-40% of its population in the Thirty Years' War, and it took 50 to 100 years to recover its pre-war demographic and economic levels. I know that was pre-industrial society, but we are talking about that on the galactic scale. Do they not have a civilization to rebuild? They are in an end-time apocalypse, and the UNSC bounced back somehow, pumping out a bigger fleet and Spartans like a factory... for what, exactly?

Instead, the story is about the Forerunners doing evolutionary planning and implanting instructions for humanity’s technology to do a "chosen one" bullshit. It delves into the ""lore"" that you have to read a book, some audio logs, and a PHD in Halo Mythology to understand. That is, if you read them, you will know that the Prometheans spit in the face of everything that used to be established about the Forerunners. And you have Chief going through an emotional arc, but the appeal of Master Chief is that he is an empty vessel, who shares more similarities with the classic silent FPS protagonists than someone like Harry Potter or Luke Skywalker. In fact, the whole destiny and fate nonsense is directly criticized in Bungie's trilogy, with the Covenant being obsessed with it. Ultimately, what wins the war is the human force of will. Halo 4 didn't look like, sound like, play like, or feel like Halo.

The less said about Halo 5 and Infinite, the better. 343 couldn't make up their mind about what kind of story they wanted to tell for the new trilogy. Not that Halo ever had a good story. While there may be good stories in the Halo EU, it’s not in the games and never has been. The story ranged from decent enough to embarrassing. However, it had a direction and worked as a power fantasy. With Halo 1-3, it was about fighting the alien race that wages a religious war against humanity. Aura and vibe. It works. With Halo 4-6... what is it about? Is it about Chief's personal arc of grieving and going AWOL, or Cortana becoming the Skynet, or the Didact, or the Covenant civil war, or whatever Infinite's story was? They didn't even figure out if Chief was the last Spartan. Telling us that Chief is no longer special in the age when the Spartan program is back, only to unceremoniously kill them off in the next game just to say Chief is the last of his kind... all over again... What is this, The Force Awakens?

I thought about what the 343 trilogy should have been if they inevitably had to exist. When I read any rewrite of Halo 4-6 that doesn't remove Master Chief, I stop caring because the ending of Master Chief will always be escaping from the exploding station and him staying asleep. It ended on such a definite note. There didn’t need to be anything after for him. I choose to believe Chief is still floating around space, and anything that pulls him out of his sleep is a fanfic. Write anew back to that point. Scrap everything after.


So if Chief is not the center of the new trilogy, who should be? Surely, Chief is the face of Halo. Well, Halo 3 ODST and Halo Reach exist, which tells me that Bungie saw the appeal of Halo was more about the universe and not an individual character. If you insist that they are spin-offs, okay. I will say that Master Chief is not the sole protagonist of Bungie's mainline Halo games. There was another...

Remember how playing as a Covenant in Halo 2 was a shock? Because I was when I first played it. I wonder if Halo 2 was inspired by Metal Gear Solid 2. Up to that point, you were playing as Master Chief, defending Earth from the Covenant, until there was a sudden bait and switch to put you in the eyes of the enemy commander who was fighting against you on the first Halo. We are suddenly thrown into the Covenant's internal politics and religion. Arbiter? He was not in the advertisement, took time away from Master Chief, and generated a fan backlash. What am I even doing? Fighting some random Covenant rebels? I want to play as Chief! Arbiter's arc is even similar to Raiden's arc, as he gradually turns against his masters, who have been manipulating him all along, and eventually joins Master Chief. Looking at his progression from Halo 2 to 3, I wonder if Arbiter was supposed to be the new Chief. He has the same moveset, becomes Chief's sidekick, and was even a coop partner by the time of Halo 3.

Arguably, there is a wealth of materials to explore after Halo 3 on the side of the Covenant. Halo Evolutions published a series of short stories, and one of them, The Return, gave an insight into what the situation was after the Human-Covenant War. The Elites were disenfranchised with the Covenant, though many of them still search for spiritual guidance, and they were at war with the Brutes. After the religious order that has been putting them together collapsed in Halo 3, how did the Covenant society react? It wouldn't be a peaceful transition. It would be a complete shitshow--revolution, rebellion, rebuilding, ethnic conflict...

I imagine Halo 4 taking this direction, similar to Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, in which Raiden fights the villains who seek to revive the war economy from MGS4. Now, we have one coherent direction. We mostly saw the point of view from the human fighting the Covenant in Halo 1-3, and the next trilogy should have been Arbiter, trying to rebuild a new society, while the remnants of the old cult would wage a civil war. Halo 5 hinted at this, and... why is this not the whole game in the first place? The UNSC-Sangheili Coalition is formed, so the player could use the human weaponry, AI companions, and vehicles, and they are fighting the Brutes (not Jul ‘Mdama’s Covenant nor the Banished) in the civil war. If you want to bring the Forerunner stuff into the narrative, have the Brutes searching for the Janus Key, which provides the location of Forerunner technology in the galaxy.

This way, it can still retain desperation, which is the core idea of the Bungie games. In those games, humanity is always pushed to the corner, and only you have the power to save humanity. You could still generate a similar kind of power fantasy with Arbiter by emphasizing how desperate their situation is in building the new society. At the same time, you could still add a more emotional arc that would work better with Arbiter because he is the dynamic character.

With this reimagined Halo 5, this is the perfect opportunity to have "a new Spartan protagonist hunts down the old protagonist" plotline by tying it with the conflict between humanity and Elites. Maybe the UNSC doesn't trust the Elites since, obviously, the Elites were on the side of the Covenant and slaughtering humans. The UNSC creates a new Spartan team and orders it to chase Arbiter's Elite team. As the plot progresses, it is revealed that the Brutes are behind the AI revolt (not Cortana), leading the UNSC Fireteam and Arbiter's team to work together. The theme is to bring the two species together for the greater good.

With Halo Infinite, again, remove the Banished--the space pirates who randomly get introduced in Infinite and never gets properly explained. Apparently, they were introduced in Halo Wars 2, which most players didn't play. We replace that faction with the Brutes, who now have the power of AI on their side, seizing control of the galaxy. Arbiter learns the Brutes plan to take control of another Halo and use it as a weapon. It is sort of a role reversal since Arbiter was ordered to protect the Halo in CE, and now, he is put in the situation to destroy it. The player should have been a part of the massive conflict at the start of the game, where the protagonist lost, which would have been reminiscent of Halo 1. We should have seen what was stored within the Ring, besides the boss, and at least defeated a portion of it and sealed it away again instead of just being teased with hints of what it might be. No "Endless" sequel tease. Make it a definite conclusion of the trilogy.


r/CharacterRant • • 2h ago

How "Manhunter" Explained the Psychology of a Killer

8 Upvotes

Michael Mann's crime-drama masterpiece, "Manhunter," celebrates its 40th anniversary this year. Even all these decades later, "Manhunter" remains at the top of its genre. In spite of its deceptively simple setup, the film ascends its superficial trappings, becoming a psychological study just as much as it is a thriller. The film by no means explains every last trauma that Francis Dollarhyde experienced in childhood--in fact, those details are left out, and we're forced to speculate what kind of harm was done to him as a kid. However, certain scenes, such as Francis snuggling up against Reba in bed, clue us in to the fact that Francis' wounds are, largely, related to abandonment. A feeling of rejection. Thus his fantasies of being wanted, loved, and accepted. It all stems from a painful rejection as a child, and now as an adult, Francis seeks to fill the void in his heart by creating fantasies which satisfy his desires.

Francis gains infamy for stalking and then murdering families, all the while pretending to be a loving member among them who is loved and accepted. When the fantasy becomes too much to contain in his head, and he needs a physical element to make it seem realer, Francis pays a visit to the family in question, and murders them, then engages in sexual activities with the mother's corpse. On the surface, he could be mistaken for an aimless killer. However, these are not just crimes of passion, they are plotted over an extended period, and serve an overarching fantasy. Francis, in his killings, isn't just letting off steam, rather he's collecting a debt. He's stealing affection from families because of his own lack of affection during youth. Abandonment and abuse from a young age taught Francis a harsh lesson, that love does not come voluntarily from others, and at the first chance, the people around you will hurt or leave you.

Thus, love, as he sees it, must be taken. Stolen before it can be revoked or denied to you. This of course is not real love, but Francis has come to accept this as a form of substitution. In a sense, he can get what he's always wanted, but not in a complete form. Not in its purest form. In fact it's in a ruined form, but ruined is what Francis has learned to accept. Anything other than ruined might very well overwhelm Francis, who is used to settling for heinous alternatives. Thus, when Francis is finally given voluntary affection from Reba, this is confusing and scary to him. And lovely. But as a man controlled by his traumas, Francis is seemingly incapable of letting a good thing go untainted, and thus he finds a way to ruin this love too. If only to continue the tragic pattern of his life.

I've got a great video on this topic that everyone who loves "Manhunter" should definitely check out! Click here to watch it!

Thanks for reading!


r/CharacterRant • • 13m ago

General (LES) Stories should not be obligated to be perfectly satisfying to everyone

3 Upvotes

It feels like a good 75% of all criticisms leveled at whatever is popular these days is that the story isn't satisfying enough: that the good guys suffer too much, the bad guys are too sympathetic to mindlessly hate, the setting is too bleak, the setting is too hopeful, the plot is too simple, the plot is too complex, etc. etc. and that the story would become goldilocks' perfect porridge if it was changed to fit the viewers taste. At the core I'm just viscerally repulsed by any idea that can be summed up as "art today is degenerate and rude, so what if the REAL subversive narratives are the ones that dare to be comfortable to me". It requires a solipsistic view of the world where art is conjured up and presented to you, to make you feel things, to harvest your opinion of it and correct the mistakes of individual voice. People write responses to the world they live in.

Fundamentally, it is an urge to believe that everything which is written was written for you by people who share your inner world, speaking back like desynched reflections of you with their own mouths, who ought to be set on the course of making what you need, because it's what you all need I stole this from Tumblr


r/CharacterRant • • 2h ago

Comics & Literature The Kite Runner is mediocre

3 Upvotes

For many of us, The Kite Runner is a familiar title, one that likely triggers flashbacks to torturous essays. While praised as a heart-wrenching story of guilt and redemption, the novel loses its gleam when revisited without skimming for quotes.

Published in 2003, less than two years after 9/11 and the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan, the novel capitalized on the confusion of Americans by offering an "enlightening" look into a country they knew nothing about. Desperate to translate the Afghan experience into a language understood by his audience, the author inadvertently dilutes it. A complex geopolitical conflict rooted in broken institutions, ethnic tensions, and foreign proxy wars is portrayed with the nuance of a fairy tale.

This is embodied in Assef, the antagonist and representation of the Taliban, who is granted a familiar brand of evil. When we first meet him as a boy, Assef expresses a profound admiration for Hitler, wishing that he "finished what he had started." This is a lazy crutch to cater to readers and one that is entirely unnecessary, considering that he soon rapes the protagonist's best friend and later sexually abuses the victim's child. The following passage between Assef and our protagonist, Amir, best captures the absurdity of it all:

“That’s what you were doing in Mazar, going door-to-door? Taking out the garbage?”

“Precisely.”

“In the west, they have an expression for that,” I said. “They call it ethnic cleansing.”

“Do they?” Assef’s face brightened. “Ethnic cleansing. I like it. I like the sound of it.”

The careful omission of America's influence on Afghanistan's political instability is the most glaring part of the novel. The CIA armed and financed the Mujahideen, a coalition of Afghan militias, to fight against the Soviet Union. After the Soviet Union withdrew its troops, the Mujahideen fractured, plunging the country into a brutal civil war. This chaos allowed the Taliban to rise up and present themselves as liberators promising a new age. After 9/11, the U.S. invaded to topple the Taliban, utilizing and reinstating many of those same disgraced warlords. This cemented a government that many Afghans viewed as corrupt and a puppet regime. Yet in the novel, America exists purely as a peaceful sanctuary and a "brash savior," completely detached from her role in the devastation.

The novel briefly touches upon the layers behind it with mentions of citizens dancing in the street after the Taliban evicted the Alliance from Kabul, but it is subsequently discarded. Readers are never prompted to wonder why anyone would support the Taliban, outside of rapists, pedophiles, psychopaths, and Nazis.

Hassan, Amir's best friend and servant, is a member of a marginalized ethnic group, the Hazaras, and arguably the most important character in the novel. This narrative significance only highlights how he is more shallow than Assef, characterized by a singular trait, loyalty, and no further. Hassan is a servant who delights in his servitude, expressing no resentment toward his masters, even years later. He is written as a saintly, all-forgiving martyr who accepts betrayal without any grievances.

This is necessary for his role as a catalyst for the protagonist's descent and redemption. Hassan must be pure and untainted to maximize Amir’s guilt, while remaining an empty vessel for Amir’s conscience. The tragedy that befalls him is written to compel readers to fixate on the protagonist's reaction rather than dwell on the victim's suffering. His voice is silenced in favour of Amir's agonizing conscience. Even his most powerful moments, such as taking the blame for the stolen watch, are framed around Amir's assumption that Hassan knows Amir passively witnessed the assault. At the time, there is little reason to believe that Hassan actually knows, distorting the moment into a mere projection of his guilt.

At times, the novel reads like an annoying travel guide, forcing unnatural exposition into both dialogue and Amir's internal monologue. As an example, I point to a strange introduction from a nurse: She says her name is "Aisha, like the prophet’s wife.” Nobody named Mary would introduce themselves as “Mary, like the mother of Jesus”; it is that common of a name. Odd details like this are inserted across the novel and gradually become more and more annoying.

In short, The Kite Runner succeeded through precise timing and a refusal to demand any real inquiry from the audience. The third portion of the novel feels painfully contrived and has all the melodrama of a cheap Bollywood film. The story ends with a climactic fistfight against Assef, graceless parallels to Hassan, and a jarring shift from an endless barrage of misery to uneasy hope.


r/CharacterRant • • 9m ago

Films & TV Why do people act as if Jax never faced consequences?

1 Upvotes

Why do people act Jax never faced consequences for his behavior, or that the cast was entirely helpless while being tormented by Jax, or that the cast was wrong for sympathizing with her death?

Edit: Jax is a character from a show called the amazing digital circus (TADC)

People talk about how the cast needed to establish more consequences but… like… Zooble choked him (in the pilot), Gangle & Ragatha tied up & gagged him (episode 3), Gangle tried psychological torture / imprisonment (episode 4), Zooble took advantage of his phobia multiple times (episode 5), Gangle & Zooble tried forcing him into a dress without context (episode 5), half of the cast constantly speaks about how much they hate Jax (whole series), Pomni beats him up (episode 6). Zooble dumps water on him (episode 7) & later on (after Jax helps get the key from Caine) throws a indirect jab at how he likely has no one in the real world to return too & makes it clear that no one in the circus trusts him (which honestly doesn’t make much sense since Zooble can see he got the key & isn’t lying) (episode 7), not long afterwards Caine puts Jax in a electric chair & runs him over with a train episode 8), Jax offers to distract Caine alone despite potentially being on abstraction watch & the cast doesn’t offer any support or worry until Pomni suggests for them to also help Jax (episode 8), when Caine crashes out he rips her skin in front of shadows of her former friends to laugh at him (episode 8) & the cast even had the freedom to just ignore Jax if they wished (episodes 2, 5, 8 & 9).

The whole series even makes it clear that Jax planned to abstract from the start while pushing everyone away with the belief she was incapable of being loved (“you’re not supposed to miss me, you’re not supposed to love me, this isn’t how it was supposed to go!”) over the guilt of Ribbit & Kaufmo’s abstractions (although the series makes it clear that there was other factors at play with their abstractions & Jax likely didn’t even know about abstractions beforehand). I feel like containing so much self-hatred & guilt over the years to the point where you develop 3 masks inside your mindscape that you’re afraid of & slowly losing the ability to be human is the most horrid consequence in itself. Jax doesn’t get babied, he/she’s not irredeemable monster that’s on the same level as the average villain in media. I wouldn’t even say he’s anywhere near the same level as Chris from Carrie (whichever version of Carrie, even 2026) like most make her out to be.

What’s crazy is that to anyone else who’s not a fan or is just a casual watcher, these consequences including the specific circumstances of Jax’s abstraction (being trapped in a void, your happiest self locked in a closet, seeing your memories as they corrupted, finally allowing yourself to be human only to hyperventilate & get flashbanged in your last moments) in a full list clearly convey he does face consequences (& are over the top), yet people wanted more suffering out of him. Why?


r/CharacterRant • • 30m ago

Films & TV OK, I know everyone's over it by now, but please, TADC people...

0 Upvotes

Stop calling the final episode a "redemption" for Jax. What Episode 9 is for Jax is an EXPLANATION, showing why Jax was the way she was (basically, an abusive childhood that instilled in her the belief that any attempt to be vulnerable or authentic would be punished via emotional blackmail, and getting close to people will result in them dying and it being her fault, and so trying to push people away so they never get close to her), and it shows that Jax had the potential to find redemption and companionship here...But it also shows very clearly, how Jax, throughout her time in the Circus, rejected every attempt by other people to reach out, every chance to be better, every chance to be vulnerable for once, she turned it down. It's not a redemption arc, it's the arc of someone pointedly refusing redemption, and only realizing that all their problems were solvable after it's too late to do anything. If TADC has any message, it's that "being like Jax is toxic, to everyone around you and to you, and, if you don't stop being that way, it will destroy you". Jax had the potential for redemption, and that very fact is what makes her constant REFUSAL to take any of the chances given to her all the more tragic. It is not a story of redemption, it's a story of someone who was hurt hurting others and only realizing how badly they've screwed everything up when their toxicity destroys them. Jax was not redeemed, Jax was simply...Explained.


r/CharacterRant • • 2h ago

An hour of your time is the maximum ask for any piece of entertainment

0 Upvotes

So I dont care about GTA 6, havent played it, dont know if its good, and dont care if its good. But ive been considering this for a long time now, and with the controversy around the slow opening, this seems like a culturally relevent time to say this.

When you start a new game, movie, tv show, book, whatever, there is always going to have to be a give and take between a reader and a writer. In order to do something meaningful, the writer needs time for setup. Characters need introduced, setting needs to be shown, narrative and themes need to be established, and if you are a game the gameplay loop needs to be explained.

In this give and take, it is fair to ask for patience from the audiance. If they cant wait 5 minutes for you to introduce a character properly, there is a problem with the viewer, not you. However, the opposite is also true. If it takes 40 episodes to get good, thats a problem with the writer.

The macimum amount of time you can expect from an audiance, from what I can tell, is about an hour of their time. That is three episodes of anime, or a big pilot for a big budget live action show. It is a chunk of free time that is expendable and continuous in most people's lives, that can be between getting home from work and starting dinner, it could be your unwind before bed, it is a reasonable time frame to fit into someone's day. If we are being realistic, busy people with kids or a lot of responsibilities will probably only be able to manage 30 minutes. If you go over that chunk of time, you are now asking for potentially multiple days of free time investment.

One piece is obviously the best example of this from a fandom, but arguably a more relevant example is Final Fantasy 13 having this exact same controversy. Despite being a super hyped game, it had a start that just face planted you in the middle of a jargon filled world where you had no fucking idea what was going on, but it supposedly got amazing 20 hours in. I wouldnt know, because like most people I gave it somewhere between 30 minutes and 2 hours and dropped it. Thats not a problem with the audiance, that is a problem with the writer not pacing their story properly.

Now, im mot saying it cant be worth pushing through a slow start. Some of the best and most iconic pieces of fiction do have one, just consider the lord of the ring books. But thats despite the massive writing flaw, not because of it. And it is a flaw that can and will push people away at no fault of the audiance. I dont think less of someone who tries persona 4 and drops it before the opening sequence is over, becuase it has a super long multi hour opening. It is a decision they made to ask that much from the audiance, and if the audiance decides not to play along that is the creator's fault.


r/CharacterRant • • 5h ago

Films & TV I doubt Hollywood can ever make a truly great Godzilla movie

0 Upvotes

Please note that I am merely doubting it, rather than thinking it's outright impossible. Of course, there can one day be a filmmaker, who understands what makes the character so compelling, has a sufficiently ambitious vision for what an American adaptation could be and possesses enough influence to convince a major studio to give them the creative freedom to execute it. Is just that in a general sense, looking at the way Hollywood operates and they have tackled Godzilla so far, I find it difficult to imagine that happening anytime soon.

To be clear, I don't believe Godzilla movies necessarily have to be all grim and politically charged to be worthwhile. Yes, for the sake of honesty, I freely admit that my favorites have been the movies that play the premise mostly as straight drama (the 1954 original, Shin Godzilla, and Godzilla Minus One) and I have also never been particularly fond of any of the Hollywood-produced Godzilla movies (2014 comes closest and I suppose, gun to my head, I'd have to admit that the Kong team-ups are harmless enough). However, this isn’t a question of the tone of the films, but of their worldview.

While some incarnations differ (Shin, for instance, being a stand-in for a natural disaster, or GMK embodying Japan's shame over its war crimes) or at least emphasize different aspects of the character, Godzilla is at his core very much an anti-nuclear bomb franchise. Godzilla is a monster born from radiation, who brings death and destruction wherever he goes and represents a threat that could at any moment wipe out the entire human race. The 1954 original even reinforces this theme through a second, parallel threat: the Oxygen Destroyer, a device so destructive that the only responsible thing its inventor could do was ensure that nobody would ever be able to use or recreate it after it was used just once.

And this is where I think Hollywood has a fundamental problem, when it comes to transferring Godzilla from Japan to America. American blockbusters love portraying the US military unambiguously as the good guys and are, to a large extent, encouraged to do so if they want access to actual military equipment. Godzilla is fundamentally incompatible to that kind of worldview. In fact, his very existence raises questions that American blockbuster cinema has historically been reluctant to explore. What happens when military power is itself part of the problem? What does it mean when the greatest threat to humanity is a consequence of its own weapons? And how do you tell a story about the horrors of nuclear destruction, without confronting the historical circumstances in which those weapons were actually used?

That last question is particularly important. In mainstream American culture, the use of atomic bombs against Japan during WWII is still commonly framed through the argument that, however terrible it was, it ultimately was necessary to end the war. There is comparatively little appetite for treating the bombings as an enduring moral failing that deserves serious examination.

Godzilla, however, is a franchise whose very premise challenges that kind of thinking. He's simply not a character Hollywood can tackle honestly without confronting some deeply uncomfortable ideas about its own country's history and military. Hell, as much as G-fans love to gush over Godzilla: King of the Monsters, nothing illustrates this problem better than the way that movie reduces the Oxygen Destroyer to a blink-and-you'll-miss-it piece of shallow fanservice, while also presenting the detonation of a nuclear bomb (by a Japanese character, no less) as a big heroic moment.

A drama aimed at adults, like Oppenheimer, might be allowed to genuinely make audiences uncomfortable about nuclear weapons and the military institutions that possess them. A big-budget blockbuster, on the other hand, is a different beast. Those typically aren’t allowed to make their audience think about anything “too uncomfortable” and a Godzilla movie almost inherently needs to be a big budget production, if only because of the sheer spectacle and visual effects involved.

Again, I'm not saying I'll never be proven wrong. But I suspect it will take a long time, and that it will probably require an entirely new reboot, separate from the MonsterVerse.


r/CharacterRant • • 22h ago

GTA 6 not having prostitutes is probably the best example of it's philosophy [LES]

0 Upvotes

Dawg I can't even cheat on Jason or Lucia , the possible endings and storylines would be so funny

The fuckass karma metre also sucks due to it contributing to the ending

Same as whatever tf is going on in Jason's empty skull , there might be themes and shit but bro is boring af even in just npc interactions

Lucia is nice, although I'm not sure if it's because of how uneventful Jason is that she seems much better.

All this to say is that while these changes and focus on the story and morality can be a good story it's so incredibly off-putting in GTA , again I can't pay for pussy and in other games you only see a shaking car but the fact that I can't is so strange to me

Outside of that I'm saying this now , BEST OPEN WORLD OF ALL TIME, everything is so fun to do and I get easily distracted by nonsense, like if you ignore the story it's the greatest game ever made and I like the missions a lot they're so fun

The story is like an 8 due to how you feel like the main character suddenly care about your morals , it's odd it feels like your cool friend suddenly started taking meds and calmed down or that you can't behave like an edgy teenager in the game anymore , it's like the game forcing you to grow up . I can't really call the story bad because it's sweet what J and L are trying to do and I wouldn't have complaints if it wasn't GTA and even in GTA it's still good just kinda worse than the previous ones.

Ignore the chuds because they're chuds

But overall would recommend just wish I could pay for pussy and go on more killing sprees that didn't really matter for the story.