r/Chase • u/scuba_steve410 • 19h ago
Best single card to add to my Chase Sapphire Preferred?
I'm looking to add one new card to go with my CSP, focused on getting more out of everyday spending without overcomplicating my wallet. I'm open to cash back, travel rewards, or a hybrid of the two, whichever gives the best long-term value.
Current cards: Chase Sapphire Preferred, Discover it
Credit profile: 810 FICO | 5-year oldest account | under 5/24
Annual spending:
- Groceries: $4,000
- Utilities: $4,000
- Costco: $3,000
- Insurance: $2,700
- Online retail: $2,100
- All other: $2,000
- Gas: $2,000
- Parking: $1,800
- Dining: $1,200
- Home improvement: $1,200
- Transit: $1,200
- Amazon: $1,000
- Internet/cable: $1,000
Travel/spending habits
- Hotels: Hilton,Hyatt, Marriott
- Airlines: American, sometimes Southwest and Delta
- Groceries: local supermarkets
- Other frequent spending: Costco, Amazon, Chipotle, Chick-fil-A
Cards I'm considering:
- Chase Freedom Unlimited: Easiest way to stay in Chase and pool points with my CSP but I'm not sure 1.5x is competitive anymore.
- Capital One Venture X: The 2x catch-all, lounge access, and credits are appealing, but the transfer partners don't line up well with American, Southwest, Hyatt, or Marriott.
- Robinhood Gold Card: 3% on everything (including Costco) is hard to beat but I've heard mixed things about their customer service and I'm worried they'll cut the 3% down the road.
- Amex Gold: I'd use some of the credits and 4x on groceries would be nice with but I'm not sure it's worth the $325 fee.
Given my spending and the fact that I already have the CSP, what one card would you add? Would you stay in Chase with something like the Freedom Unlimited, add a 2%/3% catch-all, or go with something like the Venture X or Amex Gold? Mainly looking for long-term value not chasing welcome bonuses or constantly rotating cards.