I grew up in church, in your standard run-of-the-mill evangelical upbringing. As I'm sure for others raised in that denomination, you're familiar with demonic activity or demonic possession (DP because I hate typing). And I'll probably be using DP and DA interchangably. But hopefully you understand I mean demonic *gestures vaguely* things.
I've heard some weird stories. I'm trying to think of specific ones right now, but I can't seem to remember. But they were all told by teachers, elders, or pastors, and spoken with such conviction with little doubt that it had to be from hell, had to be true, they're too powerful for us humans to combat, and God is the only one who can handle demonic forces.
As a kid I wasn't necessarily scared. I certainly found them thrilling and intriguing. But there was always a little seed of skepticism that wouldn't go away.
Even so, how could you doubt it? There's clearly examples of Jesus casting out demons in the Gospels! And the Bible doesn't lie! If you questioned if demons existed and could possess people, you questioned whether God even existed! How dare you!
As I grew older and the Internet gained in popularity, DP started to lose its believability. The Internet did expose stories of "modern" DP, which I did take an interest in, but the credibility of the stories quickly fell apart...at least the story of them being "someone posessed by an evil spirit."
And most stories of DP or DA can be easily explained by natural phenomena--usually ones that should be dealt with immediately--and dealt with by a medical professional, not with p*ayer! (like epilepsy or carbon monoxide poisoning)
And you'd think that in the modern era, with smartphones and security cameras, we'd at least be able to see SOME form of DP in the wild. If some rando on the street in Jersalem having his demon cast out can be witnessed by hundreds of people, why can't Donna from marketing, recorded on CCTV with your buddy recording on his iPhone. Or are demons just so good at evading detection because they like the thrill of the chase?
So then I'm looking back at scripture again. And a few things I note:
- Nowhere in the old testament is DP or DA mentioned. Demons are mentioned as profane recipients of sacrifice, never as active participants.
- DP and DA is really only mentioned in the synoptic gospels. Besides that, there are mentions of demons and their interactions in the letters of the New Testament.
- The Gospels were 2nd or 3rd hand testimony. There are numerous stories in the Bible that convey a truth, but aren't "true" in the accuracy sense--they fall apart on investigation (i.e., the Creation account, the flood).
- I've read many papers that have suggeted that since Luke is a doctor, he would have medical knowledge, which he could have used to diagnose medical ailments that could have been erroneously described as DP. So since Jesus is characterized as literally interacting with the demon, the suggestion is that Luke can be a reliable source to conclude that demons actually do exist and inhabit peoples' bodies.
Most articles I read or videos I see don't have the perspective I'm looking for. They're either written by Christians trying to prove a point but then veer off into a spiritual lesson, or by non-Christians who just want to disprove the Bible.
But I think there's a way to critically discuss stories of DP/DA and come away with an understanding. I'd like to point out I'm not stressing about it or anything. It's just one of those thoughts rattling around in my head and I don't feel like there's anyone I can have a rational discussion about it with.
I'd love to hear peoples' thoughts on where you stand with DA or DP. Or if you found any articles that takes a deep dive. I have three theories bouncing around in my head:
- DP/DA is real, it's still happening, and either the evidence is being suppressed or it's just not gaining virality. I don't give much weight to this theory. Maybe in places like Russia or China this would be the case, but in America, something like DA would be marveled at by non-believers and you can bet spread like wildfire among Chrisitan groups on Facebook.
- DP/DA is not real, and what was happening in the 1st Century was something else. I think this one I trust the most, since it's the simplest. That's not to say that the early Christians that told these stories were trying to lie or deceive, but they were an oppressed people group living under a violent dictator. Even when the church was being martyred, there were fantastical (conflicting) stories of early Christians that were slain in glorious fashion. So it could also hold true for stories of Jesus as well. Maybe the DP man was really just someone alone and neglected, and Jesus took pity on him. Like early Christians thought. "Oh, how nice of Jesus, but what if instead...he cast out a legion of demons and sent them into a herd of pigs! Now that shows Nero that Jesus is the true king!" Again, not intentionally misleading, but easily mistold and exaggerated as a way of comping with the mass trauma I'm sure they all felt.
- DP/DA was real for the 1st Century, but not for today. This one is actually a close 2nd for me. We often forget that Jesus gave His Disciples (and only his disciples) specific instructions to heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse lepors, and cast out demons. These weren't commands for all Christians, only to his disciples. So God allowed these events to occur only in the 1st C, but not today, beause Jesus had people able to answer these needs. In addition to DP, we also don't see miracles recorded live (unless you'r Benny Hinn...calm down...I kid, I kid), or people raised from the dead. These were specifically 1st C events because of the specific instructions given to the disciples.