Have you ever been given a batch of chocolate chip cookies that had too much salt?
Have you ever been given chocolate chip cookies, and one cookie just did not hav
enough chocolate chips? Well, that's what happened with my first batch of chocolate chip cookies. Did I give up making cookies? No, I didn't. I tried again. I found joy in measuring the ingredients, forming the chocolate chip dough into balls, even though
they didn't always come out perfect. Baking was a happy place for the chaos that permeated throughout
my home.
In the span of seven years, I lost four people I loved dearly: my aunt, my uncle, my grandfather, and my grandmother. They were each an important ingredient that filled my heart. My grandmother always said, Khylah, you are a star! There is such a void without them here. But once a week, I took out my mixing bowl, flour, sugar, butter, eggs, and chocolate chips as I tried to remind myself that life could still be sweet.
What's very interesting is that within my world, I have been one of the only chocolate
chips on my dance team. I still remember walking into the studio and asking myself, "Where are the other chocolate chips?" I immediately saw a difference in my appearance. One of my dance mates asked me how I was going to slick back my hair because I had a puffy curly texture. I was viewed differently because I had a very muscular physique. There were always lots of stares during dance competitions and lessons that made me feel out of place. Individual's words would intimidate me.
Now that I look back on how they treated me, I used to let that bring me down and made me believe that I was not good enough. I was placed at the back of the group routines, so sugar cookies with less dance skills could shine. It didn't stop me: It gave me more motivation to practice more at home, so I would be better than was the last time I did the dances. If my leaps weren't good enough, I would do it again. I didn't stop when skills were close to okay; I stopped when skills were close to perfection.
Feeling less than coming home from dance class one evening, my mom sat me down as she did my hair and told me how amazing I danced. I expressed to my mom that I would have to work ten times harder than sugar cookies because chocolate chips are often looked at as less than.
As I continued to practice and attend competitions, it became more of an opportunity to prove to myself that I have improved and mastered difficult dance skils. There was a feeling of anxiousness that radiated over me every time I was about to hit the stage.
Even after many years of hitting the stage, I always had moments where I questioned whether I was good enough to grace the stage. I'd look backstage and notice how all these other dancers looked so confident, and they presented themselves like they were the top dancers. Overtime, I learned that confidence does not mean you never feel nervous. It means you continue to be driven even when you are nervous.
As I prepared for another competition, I was going over my choreography multiple times. I reflected on times I would stay after to practice, stay up past my bedtime, and do skills repeatedly until I knew they were right. I remember times feeling frustrated when the skill wasn't coming out right and thinking why I couldn't get it on the first try.
After I snapped out of the daydream, I teared up because I still felt nowhere near as good even after being fully prepared as the rest of the dancers there. Then it clicked, I said to myself, "stop this" my biggest competition wasn't the other dancers; it was the dancer I looked at when I looked in a mirror. That person was me.
Just at that moment my number was called Number #261: Smoke and Mirrors. I took a deep breath and started to walk onto the stage. With step I felt my heart beating throughout my chest. Thump...Thump....
As I took my starting pose, I stopped thinking, I didn't care who was watching, what place I was going to come in, what line I was for my group dance, or whether the people's backstage were anyone was judging me. My only focus was on one thing. dancing for myself, remembering the real reason I chose to dance, in the first place and why I loved it. I wanted others to see my love for dancing through my movements. At this comp I decided to only dance for me. I still thought at times I was not good enough, but I still chose to give it all I had.
When it was time for awards, the host presented an X Factor award (best dancer among 200 dancers). I was chosen. She stated to the audience, No matter where this dancer is, whether it's the front, middle, or back of the line, she always gave 100% She saw this chocolate chip in a sea of sugar cookies, shining. My light could not be dimmed.
As a student teacher over the last five years, I'm very mindful to be sure that I inspire
younger students to always feel good about themselves, no matter what the differences are within them. Reflecting over the years, life is about the ingredients one uses to stand out: leadership, resilience, work ethic, and empathy.
I have often wondered why people have prejudices, discriminated against, or stereotyped others. This has motivated me to pursue a degree in psychology. As a psychologist, I would help people face uncomfortable situations and help them grow
from them. The most important part of this joumey is that now I embrace being the
only chocolate chip. People's words still affect me, but they're also what makes me
stronger. In everything I do, I now show up as myself, never trying to blend in.
EDIT: I think some of you are overlooking the underlying metaphor of the essay. The cookies weren’t simply an introduction about baking that I randomly abandoned halfway through. They were a representation of my experiences with identity, belonging, loss, and navigating environments where I often felt different.
The chocolate chip cookie versus the sugar cookie comparison was intentional. I was describing what it felt like to be the only Black girl in a predominantly white dance environment without immediately spelling out the racial differences. Baking was also something that brought me comfort during a period when I experienced significant family losses.
Could the transitions have been stronger? Absolutely. I’m not arguing that my essay is flawless. But I don’t think it’s fair to dismiss the entire narrative without considering what I was actually trying to communicate.
I shared this because it was my personal college application experience, not because I was presenting it as a universal template for writing successful admissions essays. You don’t have to like my writing, but I would appreciate criticism that engages with the actual message rather than assuming the experiences were thrown together without purpose.