r/CompetitiveForHonor • • 22h ago

Discussion Why are shaman and gladiator considered throw picks in (ranked) dominion?

10 Upvotes

I understand why it’s the case for cent but nothing in their kits seems particularly awful for 4s. Shaman does have shit range but I feel like she’d be able to make up for that, no?


r/CompetitiveForHonor • • 14h ago

Discussion Role based balancing

4 Upvotes

So I’ve seen plenty of people express disdain in this sub for “generalists”, or characters who are good in every role, and have suggested or implied that characters should either be great in one role and shit in the rest, middling in all roles, or something in between. I agree with this sentiment to a degree, though I do think that all characters need to be at least competent at dueling since there’s an entire gamemode dedicated to it. Not every character needs to have excellent dueling tools and some level of imbalance is ok, but there shouldn’t be any heroes that are straight up incapable of using offense at the highest levels of play.

Personal opinions aside, I’m no expert in top level play, but it seems that some roles are more valuable than others. An S-tier duelist for instance is likely not as powerful as an S-tier staller. This difference in value is important to consider in character balancing.

My question:

What is the relationship between relative capability in each role to overall viability in dominion? What should be the ideal distribution of capabilities for each role? I think the easiest way to express this would be some sort of multi-axis scale for all roles, that way we can see just how many points in one role a hero should have to give up to gain a point in another role.

Example:

Hero: Nuxia (I don’t see a ton of complaints about her so she might be a good example)

Role: Duel Specialist

Dueling: 10/10 (best in the game with her T1, which is completely nullified in all other situations)
Ganking: 4/10 (has decent pressure but feeds too much revenge)
Teamfighting: 2/10 (very difficult to get a trap off in a teamfight, leading to low pressure; has decent hitboxes but no hyperarmor, dodge cancels, or other special defensive moves)
Stalling: 2/10 (impossible to get a trap off while stalling and no good defensive moves, saved from the very bottom only by infection and caltrops)

Overall viability: A-tier

I think Nuxia is a great example of a highly niche specialist, but these numbers shuffled to different roles might result in a character who is either too strong or too weak. Would love to hear examples of other characters who get the distribution right in your opinion.