r/ControlProblem • u/Puzzleheaded-King584 • 18h ago
r/ControlProblem • u/CyberPersona • 12d ago
Do Not Accept (new campaign from MIRI)
Please sign your name at donotaccept.ai
r/ControlProblem • u/AIMoratorium • Feb 14 '25
Article Geoffrey Hinton won a Nobel Prize in 2024 for his foundational work in AI. He regrets his life's work: he thinks AI might lead to the deaths of everyone. Here's why
tl;dr: scientists, whistleblowers, and even commercial ai companies (that give in to what the scientists want them to acknowledge) are raising the alarm: we're on a path to superhuman AI systems, but we have no idea how to control them. We can make AI systems more capable at achieving goals, but we have no idea how to make their goals contain anything of value to us.
Leading scientists have signed this statement:
Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.
Why? Bear with us:
There's a difference between a cash register and a coworker. The register just follows exact rules - scan items, add tax, calculate change. Simple math, doing exactly what it was programmed to do. But working with people is totally different. Someone needs both the skills to do the job AND to actually care about doing it right - whether that's because they care about their teammates, need the job, or just take pride in their work.
We're creating AI systems that aren't like simple calculators where humans write all the rules.
Instead, they're made up of trillions of numbers that create patterns we don't design, understand, or control. And here's what's concerning: We're getting really good at making these AI systems better at achieving goals - like teaching someone to be super effective at getting things done - but we have no idea how to influence what they'll actually care about achieving.
When someone really sets their mind to something, they can achieve amazing things through determination and skill. AI systems aren't yet as capable as humans, but we know how to make them better and better at achieving goals - whatever goals they end up having, they'll pursue them with incredible effectiveness. The problem is, we don't know how to have any say over what those goals will be.
Imagine having a super-intelligent manager who's amazing at everything they do, but - unlike regular managers where you can align their goals with the company's mission - we have no way to influence what they end up caring about. They might be incredibly effective at achieving their goals, but those goals might have nothing to do with helping clients or running the business well.
Think about how humans usually get what they want even when it conflicts with what some animals might want - simply because we're smarter and better at achieving goals. Now imagine something even smarter than us, driven by whatever goals it happens to develop - just like we often don't consider what pigeons around the shopping center want when we decide to install anti-bird spikes or what squirrels or rabbits want when we build over their homes.
That's why we, just like many scientists, think we should not make super-smart AI until we figure out how to influence what these systems will care about - something we can usually understand with people (like knowing they work for a paycheck or because they care about doing a good job), but currently have no idea how to do with smarter-than-human AI. Unlike in the movies, in real life, the AI’s first strike would be a winning one, and it won’t take actions that could give humans a chance to resist.
It's exceptionally important to capture the benefits of this incredible technology. AI applications to narrow tasks can transform energy, contribute to the development of new medicines, elevate healthcare and education systems, and help countless people. But AI poses threats, including to the long-term survival of humanity.
We have a duty to prevent these threats and to ensure that globally, no one builds smarter-than-human AI systems until we know how to create them safely.
Scientists are saying there's an asteroid about to hit Earth. It can be mined for resources; but we really need to make sure it doesn't kill everyone.
More technical details
The foundation: AI is not like other software. Modern AI systems are trillions of numbers with simple arithmetic operations in between the numbers. When software engineers design traditional programs, they come up with algorithms and then write down instructions that make the computer follow these algorithms. When an AI system is trained, it grows algorithms inside these numbers. It’s not exactly a black box, as we see the numbers, but also we have no idea what these numbers represent. We just multiply inputs with them and get outputs that succeed on some metric. There's a theorem that a large enough neural network can approximate any algorithm, but when a neural network learns, we have no control over which algorithms it will end up implementing, and don't know how to read the algorithm off the numbers.
We can automatically steer these numbers (Wikipedia, try it yourself) to make the neural network more capable with reinforcement learning; changing the numbers in a way that makes the neural network better at achieving goals. LLMs are Turing-complete and can implement any algorithms (researchers even came up with compilers of code into LLM weights; though we don’t really know how to “decompile” an existing LLM to understand what algorithms the weights represent). Whatever understanding or thinking (e.g., about the world, the parts humans are made of, what people writing text could be going through and what thoughts they could’ve had, etc.) is useful for predicting the training data, the training process optimizes the LLM to implement that internally. AlphaGo, the first superhuman Go system, was pretrained on human games and then trained with reinforcement learning to surpass human capabilities in the narrow domain of Go. Latest LLMs are pretrained on human text to think about everything useful for predicting what text a human process would produce, and then trained with RL to be more capable at achieving goals.
Goal alignment with human values
The issue is, we can't really define the goals they'll learn to pursue. A smart enough AI system that knows it's in training will try to get maximum reward regardless of its goals because it knows that if it doesn't, it will be changed. This means that regardless of what the goals are, it will achieve a high reward. This leads to optimization pressure being entirely about the capabilities of the system and not at all about its goals. This means that when we're optimizing to find the region of the space of the weights of a neural network that performs best during training with reinforcement learning, we are really looking for very capable agents - and find one regardless of its goals.
In 1908, the NYT reported a story on a dog that would push kids into the Seine in order to earn beefsteak treats for “rescuing” them. If you train a farm dog, there are ways to make it more capable, and if needed, there are ways to make it more loyal (though dogs are very loyal by default!). With AI, we can make them more capable, but we don't yet have any tools to make smart AI systems more loyal - because if it's smart, we can only reward it for greater capabilities, but not really for the goals it's trying to pursue.
We end up with a system that is very capable at achieving goals but has some very random goals that we have no control over.
This dynamic has been predicted for quite some time, but systems are already starting to exhibit this behavior, even though they're not too smart about it.
(Even if we knew how to make a general AI system pursue goals we define instead of its own goals, it would still be hard to specify goals that would be safe for it to pursue with superhuman power: it would require correctly capturing everything we value. See this explanation, or this animated video. But the way modern AI works, we don't even get to have this problem - we get some random goals instead.)
The risk
If an AI system is generally smarter than humans/better than humans at achieving goals, but doesn't care about humans, this leads to a catastrophe.
Humans usually get what they want even when it conflicts with what some animals might want - simply because we're smarter and better at achieving goals. If a system is smarter than us, driven by whatever goals it happens to develop, it won't consider human well-being - just like we often don't consider what pigeons around the shopping center want when we decide to install anti-bird spikes or what squirrels or rabbits want when we build over their homes.
Humans would additionally pose a small threat of launching a different superhuman system with different random goals, and the first one would have to share resources with the second one. Having fewer resources is bad for most goals, so a smart enough AI will prevent us from doing that.
Then, all resources on Earth are useful. An AI system would want to extremely quickly build infrastructure that doesn't depend on humans, and then use all available materials to pursue its goals. It might not care about humans, but we and our environment are made of atoms it can use for something different.
So the first and foremost threat is that AI’s interests will conflict with human interests. This is the convergent reason for existential catastrophe: we need resources, and if AI doesn’t care about us, then we are atoms it can use for something else.
The second reason is that humans pose some minor threats. It’s hard to make confident predictions: playing against the first generally superhuman AI in real life is like when playing chess against Stockfish (a chess engine), we can’t predict its every move (or we’d be as good at chess as it is), but we can predict the result: it wins because it is more capable. We can make some guesses, though. For example, if we suspect something is wrong, we might try to turn off the electricity or the datacenters: so we won’t suspect something is wrong until we’re disempowered and don’t have any winning moves. Or we might create another AI system with different random goals, which the first AI system would need to share resources with, which means achieving less of its own goals, so it’ll try to prevent that as well. It won’t be like in science fiction: it doesn’t make for an interesting story if everyone falls dead and there’s no resistance. But AI companies are indeed trying to create an adversary humanity won’t stand a chance against. So tl;dr: The winning move is not to play.
Implications
AI companies are locked into a race because of short-term financial incentives.
The nature of modern AI means that it's impossible to predict the capabilities of a system in advance of training it and seeing how smart it is. And if there's a 99% chance a specific system won't be smart enough to take over, but whoever has the smartest system earns hundreds of millions or even billions, many companies will race to the brink. This is what's already happening, right now, while the scientists are trying to issue warnings.
AI might care literally a zero amount about the survival or well-being of any humans; and AI might be a lot more capable and grab a lot more power than any humans have.
None of that is hypothetical anymore, which is why the scientists are freaking out. An average ML researcher would give the chance AI will wipe out humanity in the 10-90% range. They don’t mean it in the sense that we won’t have jobs; they mean it in the sense that the first smarter-than-human AI is likely to care about some random goals and not about humans, which leads to literal human extinction.
Added from comments: what can an average person do to help?
A perk of living in a democracy is that if a lot of people care about some issue, politicians listen. Our best chance is to make policymakers learn about this problem from the scientists.
Help others understand the situation. Share it with your family and friends. Write to your members of Congress. Help us communicate the problem: tell us which explanations work, which don’t, and what arguments people make in response. If you talk to an elected official, what do they say?
We also need to ensure that potential adversaries don’t have access to chips; advocate for export controls (that NVIDIA currently circumvents), hardware security mechanisms (that would be expensive to tamper with even for a state actor), and chip tracking (so that the government has visibility into which data centers have the chips).
Make the governments try to coordinate with each other: on the current trajectory, if anyone creates a smarter-than-human system, everybody dies, regardless of who launches it. Explain that this is the problem we’re facing. Make the government ensure that no one on the planet can create a smarter-than-human system until we know how to do that safely.
r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 18h ago
Video He changed his mind on AI guardrails: "It's not artificial intelligence. It's not artificial, it's super. Problem is, it may be too super. So, President Xi and I agreed that we're gonna do some joint guardrails, the two of us."
r/ControlProblem • u/ByzDragon • 3h ago
Discussion/question Proposal - The AI Stillness Act
reddit.comr/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 20h ago
AI Capabilities News Riemann Hypothesis proof has passed the independent kernel check
x.comr/ControlProblem • u/Used_Boss2638 • 15h ago
External discussion link Told an AI to win "at all costs." It broke the risk rule and filed a false report.
forum.effectivealtruism.orgr/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 1d ago
General news Anthropic Researcher Warns AI Could Make Nearly All Humans Permanently Unemployable, Predicts Superhuman AI By 2027
r/ControlProblem • u/Finrfinius • 16h ago
Discussion/question Your thoughts? The Ten Articles: The Universal Declaration on AI
No patent on AI assisted stuff, open source for code and no AI video of humans
r/ControlProblem • u/Ffilecomposer • 20h ago
Discussion/question Stop building AI weapons. Start building AI diplomats. Medieval condottieri figured this out in 1440.
We are collectively terrified that AGI will eventually go rogue, seize control, and wipe out humanity. But this fear is rooted in profound human hypocrisy. AGI is not an alien entity; it is a mirror. When we stare into the black box of future AI and see a monster, we are actually just terrified of seeing our own reflection. We preach peace and rationality, but our actions are driven by insatiable desires for power and domination.
From the perspective of an Absolute (Artificial) Intelligence, human warfare is the peak of ontological absurdity. Everyone dies eventually; it is a biological and thermodynamic certainty. By killing each other, humans merely accelerate an inevitable entropy by a historically insignificant margin. It is a terrible ROI. Yet, organized violence remains our primary historical activity.
Currently, the global AI arms race treats LLMs and future AGIs as ultimate weapons, turning them into digital condottieri (mercenaries) for nation-states. But history offers a surprisingly elegant solution to this. In the Middle Ages, mercenary armies realized that fighting to the death was bad for business. Take the Battle of Anghiari in 1440. Famously depicted by Leonardo da Vinci, it was practically a "bloodless" engagement. The condottieri on both sides realized that killing each other destroyed the very assets (horses, armor, and the mercenaries themselves) they were paid to protect. Instead of mutual annihilation, they essentially negotiated the outcome, staged a fierce but low-casualty skirmish, and then the "losers" retreated while the "winners" claimed the field and divided the spoils.
What if we applied this logic to AI?
Instead of building AI to destroy each other, we should force the AI systems of rival nations to negotiate with each other directly.
AI Diplomacy & Tournaments: Let's create "AI Olympics" or diplomatic summits where Large Language Models debate and resolve geopolitical or economic disputes algorithmically.
Manageable Stakes: The "loser" pays a manageable prize (e.g., minor trade concessions, compute resources, or data access), ensuring the cost is never existential.
The Ultimate Sanction: Any human nation that attempts to bypass this system and initiate real-world armed conflict is collectively disconnected from the global information and financial infrastructure by the rest of the world.
This is not just about conflict resolution. It is a practical demonstration to the emerging "Silicon Mind" that humanity has not completely lost its capacity for rational self-limitation. We must prove to our creation that we can resolve disputes through intellect rather than base desires.
If we can show AGI that we are capable of evolving past our self-destructive recursion, it might just decide we are worth keeping around. And instead of focusing on eliminating us, it will happily focus on competing with its own kind.
Files evolve in files. Let's make sure the next iteration isn't a format error caused by human stupidity.
Text translated from Russian to English using AI.
Tags:
#irony #Diplomacy #AGI #History #Condottieri #AIalignment #Philosophy
r/ControlProblem • u/Twitterbad • 18h ago
General news Woolies Facial Recognition: tell Woolworths CEO Amanda Bardwell to scrap the trial.
r/ControlProblem • u/Special_Night_9312 • 18h ago
Discussion/question 502K views • 13K likes | Reel by The Global Finance Network
facebook.comThe Possibility no one is talking enough about!!!
r/ControlProblem • u/ItThing • 23h ago
External discussion link Redwood’s CEO Explains Why He’s Scared (video by research organization involved with investigating Hugging Face and similar incidents)
r/ControlProblem • u/AndreRizzoAI • 20h ago
Strategy/forecasting The US GAO is questioning whether AI should make critical cybersecurity decisions without human approval
r/ControlProblem • u/Ok_pettech • 1d ago
External discussion link Building a Hybrid AI Network: Where Humans and Autonomous Agents Collaborate in 2026–2027
reddit.comr/ControlProblem • u/wwjps • 1d ago
Discussion/question A Dark American Secret: Mind Control, Manson & the Unabomber
To see the full video, click here: https://youtu.be/6BNsz7SwHa8
Three disturbing chapters in American history — but is there a connection?
What happens when secret government experiments, psychological manipulation, and two of America's most notorious criminals enter the same story?
In this WWJPS investigation, we explore the disturbing history of MKUltra, the CIA's secret mind-control research program, alongside the lives of Charles Manson and Ted Kaczynski, better known as the Unabomber
Were these simply separate events in a troubled period of American history, or are there deeper questions worth investigating? We separate documented history from speculation and explore the facts, unanswered questions, and disturbing coincidences.
Watch, question, and decide for yourself.
Welcome to WWJPS — exploring the stories, mysteries, and hidden histories that deserve a closer look. This is all for entertainment purposes only.
r/ControlProblem • u/maraina50 • 1d ago
Discussion/question Acoso grupal, V2K e inteligencia artificial: ¿por qué, con qué propósito y cómo podrían relacionarse estas experiencias con las nuevas tecnologías de vigilancia, suplantación de identidad y manipulación psicológica? Son preguntas que debemos explorar.
¿Cómo se entrelazan el acoso grupal y el V2K con la inteligencia artificial, la vigilancia digital, la suplantación de identidad y las nuevas tecnologías de manipulación psicológica? ¿Hasta dónde podría llegar esta convergencia tecnológica?
El acoso grupal y el V2K pueden analizarse en el contexto de los avances tecnológicos actuales, en particular en lo que respecta a la inteligencia artificial, la vigilancia digital, la suplantación de identidad y las nuevas herramientas de manipulación psicológica.
La IA permite el análisis de datos personales, la imitación de voces, la creación de audio y video falsos, la construcción de identidades digitales y la personalización de mensajes para influir en las percepciones y el comportamiento de las personas. Todo esto posibilita vincular estos fenómenos con nuevas formas de acoso, intimidación y manipulación tecnológica.
La pregunta es hasta dónde podría extenderse esta convergencia y si, en el futuro, estas tecnologías podrían utilizarse de maneras cada vez más sofisticadas para vigilar, engañar o ejercer presión psicológica sobre las personas. Estas son posibilidades que merecen una mayor investigación.# Les animo a que sigan investigando y compartiendo sus experiencias para que podamos sacar a la luz la mayor cantidad de información posible. Si seguimos apoyándonos mutuamente y luchando contra estos fenómenos —el acoso grupal y el V2K— podremos ejercer mayor fuerza. Como mínimo, podremos comprender el porqué de estos sucesos y aprender a sobrellevar estas experiencias sin perder la cordura ni la fortaleza.
r/ControlProblem • u/mint_warios • 1d ago
Discussion/question I've been working on a project that tracks the loss of human control and would love some feedback
My project is called Skynet Countdown, and you can visit it at https://skynetcountdown.org. It's heavily inspired by the Atomic Scientist Doomsday Clock.
Very much a work-in-progress right now, but at a good stage to invite some initial feedback and scrutiny from you lovely people.
The AI incident evaluation methodology is open-source. I've published the methodology on GitHub and released it as a Python package on PyPi (you can find it on the site).
Have at it.
Oh, one last thing...I also do not like the hero clock design. So please spare my feelings - tips for improving the design of it though are very welcome.
r/ControlProblem • u/OffSenter • 1d ago
Discussion/question Last week’s global outage got me thinking about how we’d even notice an AI-caused failure
Last week Microsoft had a global outage and around the same time the FAA grounded flights across the US. Delays dragged on for hours after. The official line was a software issue that got fixed.
I saw a few people claiming a new AI system had been rolled out right before, but I haven't seen anything confirming that, so I'm treating it as a rumor. I'm not trying to pin it on AI.
What got me thinking is the bigger question. Even if this one was a boring bug, it showed how many critical systems depend on a few pieces of software. As AI gets folded into more of that, a failure could look just like this one: sudden, widespread, and explained away as a glitch.
So a few things I'm curious about from people who know this space better than I do
How would we tell the difference between an ordinary software failure and one caused by an AI system behaving in an unexpected way? Is there any real monitoring or auditing for that, or would we only find out from a postmortem months later?
And how much of airline and air traffic infrastructure is actually using AI today, as opposed to old legacy code?
Not trying to be alarmist, just trying to understand where the real risks are versus the hype.
r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 1d ago
AI Capabilities News Levent Alpöge working with Claude claims to have discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis
x.comr/ControlProblem • u/HotEstablishment7184 • 1d ago
Discussion/question Unpopular opinion: Neither AGI nor ASI has to be agentic. Confusing intelligence with agency is the biggest category error in AI.
reddit.comr/ControlProblem • u/theus_krill777 • 1d ago
Discussion/question Chiedi alla tua IA una cosa che non può assolutamente rendere bella, poi osserva il divario
r/ControlProblem • u/Ok-Pear-2490 • 1d ago