r/CryptoMarkets • u/MaksimBacktests • 16h ago
A trader asked me to test his 20 EMA short on BTC. The entries beat random 100% of the time and it still lost money.
Someone on X shared a 20 EMA short setup on BTC and was happy for me to run it through a full backtest. I tested it three ways.
The setup: BTC trending down, price bounces up into the 20 EMA, the bounce fails, you short. Stop above the bounce, target 2R. Jan 2021 to Nov 2026, spread, fees, slippage and funding all counted, 1% risk per trade.
| Version | Trades | Beat random entries | Costs per trade | Result per trade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4h, plain rule | 234 | 73% | 0.02R | -0.05R |
| 1h, plain rule | 1,115 | 100% | 0.06R | -0.11R |
| 1h + daily trend filter | 552 | 100% | 0.06R | -0.07R |
What surprised me:
- On 1h the entries beat 100% of random entries using the same stop and target. The timing is real.
- It still lost money. On 1h costs took about 0.06R per trade, three times more than on 4h (0.02R).
- Adding a filter (only short when BTC is below its daily 50 SMA) halved the trades and cut the loss from -0.11R to -0.07R per trade. Better, but not enough.
- On 4h costs were small, but it only won 32.5% of trades. At 2R you need about 34% to break even.
Limits: one market, one period, and the stop rule was approximated (1% minimum distance). This doesn't prove the idea is bad, only that this exact version doesn't pay after costs.
Would you keep a setup with good timing that loses to costs, or move it up a timeframe?