TL;DR: the $518m "illicit funds" number is a 5 year total, under 0.06% of PSM volume, mostly routed there by aggregators. And USDS held 1:1 through $2B+ of redemptions on the same day.
So CoinDesk ran a story on NOV 19(based on Inca Digital's tracing) saying ~$518M tied to hackers, North Korea and sanctioned entities moved through Sky's Peg Stability Module. Block Analitica went through the flagged transactions one by one. Here's what they found:
1. The number has no denominator. $518M is spread over five years. The PSMs have processed $960B+ in that time, so it's under 0.06%
2. Most of it isn't even t he current PSM. About two-thirds went through the original MakerDAO PS between 2021 and mid-2024. On the LitePSM use today, it's under 0.03%
3.The "sanctioned entities" weren't sanctioned yet. In the data CoinDesk shared, they were a few wallets that traded before being sanctioned.
4. Sky didn't pick these trades. CoinDesk's onw report says most flagged transaction came through aggregators like linch, ParaSwap and MetaMask Swaps. The PSM does flat 1:1 swaps, so aggregators route through it constantly because i'ts cheap.
5. The "exit from freezable USDC" angel falls apart. Of the $91.5M tied to the Bybit hack, only ~$0.56M was a wallet swapping it's own USDC. The reset was ETH sales split across routes by aggregators.
Meanwhile, the stress test
-$2B+ of USDS redeemed for uSDC in one day, every swap at 1:1
PS USDC never dropped below $800M, back above $1.1B the next day
-~$9.3B collateral stayed above USDS + DAI supply the whole tine
-Trailing 12-month net revenue: $131M, up 48.5% YoY
A scary headline and whale exit on the same day, and peg didn't move. That's good above a result as a stablecoin can get.
What are your thoughts guys? Because to me, it definitely looks like a planned attack.