Honestly, I'm having a hard time rating this mod. It had the potential to be something genuinely interesting, and that's probably what makes it so-so disappointing.
The premise is at first pretty cool. It introduces several concepts that could have made for a really compelling story, but unfortunately, I feel like the mod hardly does anything with them. I'm gonna address a bunch of them down here, spoilers are guaranted:
- The wasted potential of MC's powers
We're introduced to MC's ability to view people's memories, which is presented as something INCREDIBLY important. We're also told that this ability, along with his awkwardness towards love, have something to do with a traumatic experience.
However, the ability is barely explored throughout the story. MC tells Monika and Alex about it, they believe him, and eventually he tells his chosen romantic interest. That's pretty much it.
Even more disappointing is the explanation behind his trauma. After all the buildup, it turns out that he was cheated on.
Now, obviously, being cheated on is bad and in some cases it will lead to the person becoming wary about love. However, my issue isn't with the subject itself, but with how disproportionately it is presented compared to its eventual role in the story. The buildup makes you expect something much more significant or psychologically complex.
Like say, maybe someone close to him killed themselves and he saw their memories of how much they suffered and yet he blames himself for having done so little...
Something like that.
But no, it's just cause a random nobody cheated on him.
2. The Literature Club's supposedly massive conflict
The entire premise revolves around MC being chosen to rebuild the Literature Club after it fell apart the previous year.
This sounds like a good setup. A group of friends have fallen out, their relationships being deteriorated, and someone has to bring them back together.
Except... that's not really what happened?
Apparently, Sayori's old friend joined the club, left, and never spoke to anyone again. This somehow caused enough arguments and disagreements to COMPLETELY destroy the club.
I found this incredibly underwhelming. The conflict is presented as something enormous, but its actual explanation doesn't justify the amount of importance the story places on it.
And after the first couple of days, the club essentially acts as though nothing ever happened. Because bow that they've apologized there's zero tension and no arguments at all.
3. The romance routes feel pointless
This is probably one of my biggest issues with the mod.
Why are there romantic routes if the story barely explores the relationships?
You can choose between Sayori, Natsuki and Yuri, but the actual romantic development feels rather limited. And whenever the story reaches its more serious moments, the routes become practically irrelevant.
For example, when Alex dies and MC falls into depression, we barely see anything from the perspective of the girls.
Then two years pass, MC falls into a coma, and once again, we don't really get to see Sayori, Yuri or Natsuki.
This is particularly frustrating because at least one of these three are supposed to be the people MC has developed romantic relationships with. You would expect those relationships to matter during some of the most important moments of his life.
Instead, Monika often ends up explaining what happened, while the other characters are sidelined.
It becomes difficult to feel emotionally invested in your choices when the story repeatedly removes that person from the narrative.
4. The time skips and missed emotional development
The story eventually puts MC through several major events, including Alex's death, his subsequent depression, a coma, and ultimately becoming unconscious for an entire decade because his powers backfire.
These are enormous developments.
But instead of allowing us to experience their consequences, the story skips over substantial portions of them.
I don't need every single day to be depicted, but I do want to see HOW the characters react, how their relationships change, and how they cope with everything that's happened.
The mod repeatedly tells us that something tragic has happened without giving us enough time to actually experience its emotional consequences.
Final thoughts:
I genuinely wanted to like this mod.
It has an interesting protagonist, an unusual supernatural ability, a Literature Club that needs rebuilding, and multiple romantic routes. There are so many possibilities here.
But I feel like almost every major concept is introduced, briefly explored, and then abandoned or underdeveloped.
The biggest problem is that the mod constantly promises something much more substantial than what it eventually delivers.
I also think the story suffers from not allowing its characters to remain relevant throughout its major events. The relationships and friendships should have been the emotional backbone of the narrative, but they're repeatedly pushed aside.
I just wish those ideas had been explored properly.
Final rating: 5/10.
Good premise, disappointing execution.