r/DID • u/ConfidentMachine • 16h ago
Discussion thoughts on "repressed memories"?
just something thats been weighing on my mind. ive been seeing psychologists say repressed memories are complete BS and there are zero circumstances anyone would ever not remember something truly traumatic, that trauma makes you remember more and anyone claiming they dont remember is lying. people with more qualifications than me linking dense studies saying that they prove what theyre saying without any room for doubt. saying its "obvious" that its all lies, even in the most extreme cases everyone has perfect recall of their trauma.
and yet, everything surrounding DID completely contradicts this. i know many of them dont even believe DID is real, and a phd is just some expensive classes anyone can take and not proof of truth or infallibility. amnesia is obviously a criteria for DID. even in systems with no idea about their trauma pre-discovery, it effects their life every day. predators can even tell youve been through trauma before you have a clue and use that to hunt prey. therapy for DID is often focused on memory recovery and processing. its just a common part of life on our side that youve lost or repressed memories of the worst things that can happen to a kid.
so which is the truth? maybe im just spiraling and trying to find a reason to deny the obvious. its not exactly a good time of year for anyone here im sure, myself included. but i still cant shake the idea that we should remember more than we do. maybe itd be a blessing if less happened than we think, maybe its pure coping considering all the external proof. is there something im missing?