r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

Mega Player Problem Megathread

2 Upvotes

This thread is for DMs who have an out-of-game problem with a PLAYER (not a CHARACTER) to ask for help and opinions. Any player-related issues are welcome to be discussed, but do remember that we're DMs, not counselors.

Off-topic comments including rules questions and player character questions do not go here and will be removed. This is not a place for players to ask questions.


r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

"First Time DM" and Short Questions Megathread

4 Upvotes

Most of the posts at DMA are discussions of some issue within the context of a person's campaign or DMing more generally. But, sometimes a DM has a question that is very small and doesn't really require an extensive discussion so much as it requires one good answer. In other cases, the question has been asked so many times that having the sub rehash the discussion over and over is not very useful for subscribers. Sometimes the answer to a short question is very long or the answer is also short but very important.

Short questions can look like this:

  • Where do you find good maps?
  • Can multi-classed Warlocks use Warlock slots for non-Warlock spells?
  • Help - how do I prep a one-shot for tomorrow!?
  • First time DM, any tips?

Many short questions (and especially First Time DM inquiries) can be answered with a quick browse through the DMAcademy wiki, which has an extensive list of resources as well as some tips for new DMs to get started.


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics The player and I both forgot about their ability which was important

66 Upvotes

My player is playing a drow. In one of the battles, she was the last one still standing and able to fight. The enemy tried to put her to sleep, and succeeded — so they all got taken prisoner.

Yes, both she and I forgot about the immunity to magical sleep. We only remembered that ability half an hour later, when the whole party was already sitting in cells.

Is it my fault for forgetting about the player's ability? What could we have done in that situation? Go back and replay it? Or move on and ignore that the impossible happened?


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Need Advice: Other DMs that handwrite their campaigns, how to stay organize?

15 Upvotes

My focus and creativity is so much better when writing ideas by hand, but without a digital tool it's impossible to go back into older notes and find what I need.

How are you personally keeping handwritten campaign notes organized?


r/DMAcademy • • 9h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures My Players are going to court, any advice?

16 Upvotes

This is a Medieval Fantasy Campaign, where the players are foreigners entering this city for the first time.

TL;DR: They're accused of crimes and told to go to court but i don't know how to handle the actual court part

Now I don't plan most of the campaign, and come up with things on the fly, It just so happens that the players were caught by a cop:

  • Breaking and entering (the cops ancestral home)
  • Stealing
  • Carrying illegal drugs
  • and in another scene, in an active crime scene, with a mutilated corpse

So, said cop confiscated the drugs and told them to go to court so that they can discuss their crimes.

I gave them a later date so that i had time to think about it.

but since then (within a span of 5 in-game hours of meeting the cop and getting the summons) the players have been witnessed committing more crimes (trying to find a lawyer), such as:

  • Attacking a civilian with a weapon
  • Murder (they had to mercy kill someone suffering a curse who asked them for death, with a noisy chainsaw blade.)
  • Murder (they panicked when the cleaning lady passed by the room and killed her too)
  • Arson (to hide the body they set a popular pub, frequented by nobles, on fire)

In a few in-game hours, they will be arriving to court.

Any suggestions on how I should handle things?


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Need Advice: Other Is this weapon too strong?

6 Upvotes

Players are about to enter the next chapter and receive their first major item reward. Items are going to be Rare and become stronger with subsequent chapters.

One of the characters is a Hexblade Warlock very martial focused. My idea is to give them a weapon where the main gimmick is that when they crit against a target affected by Hex/Hexblades Curse, they restore a spell slot after the attack & damage resolves. Essentially siphoning life force to replenish their magical reserves.

Would that gimmick be too strong or does it seem okay?


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures My party is convinced two seperate side quests are connected

6 Upvotes

My party have made it to the Big Trade City of my homebrew world, and they have come across some troubles (side quests)

So theres a Serial Killer loose in the city killing people for a devil and doing strange rituals

And theres also a street gang commiting kidnappings and the gang are weird and slightly ethereal and resistant to non magical damage.

Now ORIGINALLY I planned for these to be seperate side quests, the killer made a deal woth a devil and is sacrificing people for crafting skills, and the Gang were kidnapping to sacrifice to their aberrant elder evil god (not that the party knows that)

But my party are convinced the gang and serial killer are connected somehow

Im thinking do I divert cause and change my plan so my party is right or keep these sidequests as seperate little adventures in the city

Also if I do make them connected I gotta think of how and im not sure yet how to...but tbf Ill just get bored at work and think of a connection

What do you guys think, connect them or keep them seperate?


r/DMAcademy • • 57m ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures A one shot with a set outcome.

2 Upvotes

Before I start let me elaborate.
I already ran a similar one shot that was set in my world that also had a „set outcome” where it ended with a pcs death and basically just gave context to the rest of the campaign.

I have spoken with the players and they are okay with playing something like this.

If you are on of my players please don’t read.

The one shot is set in my campaign world and I wanted the players to expiriance a massacre that is going to occur in the hq of a cult of fire and rebirth. During the events of this massacre the pcs are attending a party in a different part of the world and trying to uncover the identity of the high cultist who is attending this party.

During the one shot the pcs will play lower level cultists that were called for help as the cults hq got attacked by a demon (patron of one of the players) who will steal one of two macguffins from the cult.

During this raid 2 of the 3 pillars - decision makers in the cult are going to die, leading to the high cultist basically having full control of the cult.

What I’m strugelling with is how can I give the players at least some agency? I still want them to be able to succeed (at least with a smaller task) so it doesn’t feel like a glorified cutscene. Like mabey saving one of the pillars, or preventing one of the macguffins from being stolen. The idea that speaks to me the most is probably that the pcs arrive to the cults order and are sent by a pillar to take down a magical barrier the demons spawn put up that is preventing teleportation to the hq, but idk if that is the greatest idea.

Also building the encounter itself is gonna be a chellange. The patron is overpowered but it is under a contract to not harm anyone unless it’s defending itself (it uses its own cultists and summoned demons to fight, and if it itself is attacked it can kill) so running that will be tricky.

Are there any suggestions on how I should run this/any questions I could answer to help clarify the premise?

Thanks in advance!

Edit: The set outcome isn’t the death of the party - it’s that the demon steals one macguffin and kills one/two of the pillars.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Trying to find an adventure

2 Upvotes

I read an adventure in the last year, and now I want to run it, but I can't find it. The rough idea was:

  • The players wake up after having a big party in a hunting lodge that belonged to a dead relative and was recently inherited.
  • They discover they're coughing up coal or something similar and will die if not treated. Also, they're snowed in to the lodge.
  • A dear like herald appears and warns them they've offended the spirit.
  • The group must explore the lodge, eventually finding caverns underneath that lead to a sacred spring whose spirit used to be appeased by the dead relative, but now feels neglected.
  • The party placates the spirit, and the curse is lifted.

If you can identify it, that would be sooooo helpful, thaaanks!


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics How do you handle player resources spanning multiple sessions?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

I'm relatively new to DMing and my two games almost strictly play over roll20. It's been great for managing character sheets and pulling tokens out.

My question is, some of my players feel a bit... Very strong, and I think they might be mismanaging their respective resources.

For instance, it feels like the paladin feels like he has an unlimited number of divine smites, and my monk always seems to have focus points available.

So, I guess in two parts, do you just trust the players to manage their own resources and be honest about what they did or didn't use, or do you track it in any way on your end. And, if you do, do you have a tool that helps?

Thanks!


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Getting stuck while writing adventures because "Everything needs to make sense"

3 Upvotes

So like the title suggests I tend to find myself stuck when writing adventures, oneshots or really most things. I can have a idea or premise I like but when it comes to the details I find myself thinking it over for several hours over days.

For example: I’m going to make a "mini" adventure that should last roughly 5-6 sessions and the idea is that the players find themselves walking into a village to rest, but they quickly discover they can't actually leave this lil run down village as every time they try, they eventually walk into a mist and find themselves walking back into town. (Almost exactly like the mist in Curse of Strahd) The main antagonist is supposed to be a druid that wants to keep people there and slowly turn them into Myconoid slaves as he is building an army(not sure about the army part)

But when it comes to the more intricate details (Like connecting the ideas and actually making it a playable adventure) I find myself thinking of ideas and scrapping them over and over because I want everything to make sense (even though we are playing make believe with DND)

Would you as a player be disappointed if you asked a question about the world or lore and got the response "Because it just is that way" from the DM?

I find myself thinking about why the mist is there, why and how the druid got to this place, what he would do with the Myconoid slaves etc and I don't really want to just say "The mist is just there because it is, the druid is there because he is and he wants to make Myconoid slaves because he can. I'd be a bit disappointed as a player if my DM didn't have any answers to why things are happening.


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Other Advice and suggestions requested

2 Upvotes

I've been DMing a single game for a year. I have all of my sessions as handwritten notes with what my party did during the session.

I would like to learn how to write so others could run the same scenario. (several players at my table suggested I publish my campaign as a campain sourcebook)

I have no idea how to organize my materials for others. Or if it's worth it to do so.

Please help!?

Edited to add that my "original source material" does contain images generated by AI based off my written prompts and stick figure sketches, because I can't draw.


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Other I Don't Think I'm the Right Fit for my Group.

10 Upvotes

Hi all. I hope this isn't in violation of the rules of this sub. Just thought this was a good place to vent.

I just finished up a game with a group I've played with periodically for about 2 years. We started with a variation on the missions from a mostly thieving series of modules, so high RP very low combat. This ended in a death trap puzzle that TPKd the party for the first time in my experience.

I then went on to develope a narrative driven game based on more action and conflict (I don't want to give a lot of details here, I think my players are on and I don't want to call them out). What I found right away was that they started acting way more like murder-hobos than previously.

So I upped the combat, giving them meaty encounters that were challenging but not impossible to a crew who'd been playing since at least 3rd ed. And they almost got wiped walking nearly single file into a charge of monsters while ignoring the recruitment NPC meat shields and seemingly forgetting how to use the powerful spells they'd dumped on a room of zero level NPCs that had inconvenienced them in a previous session.

Needless to say after that, I gave them a "canned lion", an encounter crippled to be almost no challenge down a Slug's T intersection maze funneling all progress to eventual success. That, they seemed to like. And if you can't tell by the words I used to describe it, I did not enjoy the experience.

Fine then, I set up some more stuff, tried to craft some lore, then got cocky throwing in a higher concept dungeon. Due to some more hands off design on my part to avoid railroading, it seemed like every time they encountered a puzzle or a way forward, they'd poke at it once then wander in the wrong direction. When finally they reached the end, they were unsatisfied with how it turned out (again, no details, not trying to call anyone out).

Long story short, I don't think I'm the right DM for my group. I get the impression my group wants a straight line to victory with few if any challenges, no puzzles, more or less a power fantasy writ large across a linear path. And there's nothing wrong with that inherently, it's just not the games I want to run.

I know I'm being vague, and I'm sure there's design notes from the game I ran that can be improved on (it was done on a time crunch). I just wanted to share with people who could understand. I'm not going to stop playing with these people, I'm probably just going to step back and let them run a game or two, try to get a feel for what I'm doing wrong to reach them.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other First session gone awry: I need advice on DMing

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’m a second-time DM, but after the first session I held yesterday, I noticed a lot of problems regarding my form of DMing. (I’m more used to being a player, so I still struggle as a DM)

One thing I want to note is that I have NINE players, which might be the cause and is already a huge indicator of the problems going on, but it is a campaign I’m running in a school club (high player count were due to the issue of DM shortages before anyone asks why), so I can’t just quit/kick a huge chunk of people out.

I’ve never ran a campaign with NINE players, and there was already an issue of players splitting up/only 3 out of the 9 people mostly participating (One of them was a murder hobo that took down 3 NPCs already, and then they tried killing an important NPC).

I couldn’t figure how the story pacing should be (it went terrible), and I realized how underprepared I was. My players were left behind, and I couldn’t find an efficient way to handle it.

I attempted a different game system from 5e too, but I returned to 5e after the first session due to how bad it went. This is mostly a roleplay campaign too.

I’m stressed out because if the first session is like this, then future sessions might be even worse. I was thinking if there is a system I can use to make sure each players can have a chance to roleplay, but I don’t know how much I need to prep, and I got the plot idea down already.

I need some advice, because I already dug myself a hole with this.

Are there any resources I should look into for big campaigns? Or is there anything I should tone down (like combat)? Or should I discuss this with my players instead (I’m intending to)?

Thank you, all suggestions will be appreciated!

TLDR; first session bad pacing, NINE players, three npcs already dead cus of one guy, messy storyline and lack of preparation— I need advice on how to DM properly


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Plague themed camaign where a Vampire Family is the bbeg! I need opinions!

1 Upvotes

Hiii! I dmed once before and Im so excited for the second one, but I have a few problems at gathering the pieces. Vampires are cool, plague is a cool concept, they should work together well... right? I thought it would be interesting if a vampire family decided to cause a sickness that causes people to die slowly, which helps them to hunt down weak people and feeds their sadistic nature. And if you read the spider-verse comics before, you would know where the family idea comes from. I think it would be more enjoyable if there was a few different vampire with different kinds of tastes, weaknesses and powers. But I have 2 different problem, and I would love some help!

Tying everything each other. Even though I think these ideas are cool serperately, Im not sure how to direct the party toward vampires. I dont wanna tell "its a vampire made sickness, beware!" and I dont want it to be too obvious or too hidden. Maybe a wise mage can identify the tiny vampiric spell remmanter on a patient or a cleric can sense something about undeads but Im still working on it. İm also planing to give them creative ways to defeat vampire family members but it can wait for now (though Im open for advices!!!!)

I must confesss, Im not really good at playing the monsters. I usually get too afraid to kill my players and it ends up them winning easily. I have been 3 campaigns till now, I was the dm on one of them, and no ones character died in those games. Once I lost my character in a oneshot and that felt terrible. I dont want them to feel the same, but I want them to take the enemies serious. İs there a way to get rid of this situation? Should I stop pulling myself back and maybe giving them ways to revive their characters with maybe a sidequest or is there better ways to do that?

Thank you very very much for all replies! I hope my English didnt ruined your day :P Have a nice day!!!


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other Trying to figure out how to end a Campaign

1 Upvotes

So ive got the end of a campaign in mind, however I'm trying to figure out if it's worth making a tie in to continue the campaign if the party enjoy it. It's my first time making a Homebrew and first time being a DM. Any advice on how to handle it or make it work?

Cheers in advance 😄

Edit: I'm trying to decide if the boss they defeat at the end of this campaign (Kraken) should be part of a larger plot to release somwthing worse and the krakens death was the first lock to be broken. Or should the kraken die and that be then of it


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Need help tightening the mechanics of my encounter

4 Upvotes

Hi all, so I'm building an encounter for the first big bit of storytelling in my world, but I'm not sure if it will play out how I think it will. My players are 3 level 4 character.

So players enter a cave system, and once they get to the end room, they will see a "gem" naga chained up over a pool. She will have 4 wires coming out of her head, connected to 4 gems surrounded by scientific equipment around the room. As well as this, there will be a number of mind controlled commoners and one Knight around her and the gems.

As the players enter, they will feel a pulse of energy rip through the Gem naga, and one of the gems around the room light up. Each gem has its own ability:

Red Gem: All mind control creatures stop what they're doing

Green Gem: All mind control creatures attack

Blue Gem: Gem naga screams and non-mind controlled creatures must make a wis saving throw or take 2d4 psychic damage

Yellow Gem: The Gem Naga casts Dominate Person.

I was thinking each round a different Gem lights up on the Gem nagas turn.

Whilst this was happening, the commoners could be continuously emerging from the pool beneath the Gem Naga so that the party can't just kill everything. They will have to deystroy the Gems around the room to end the encounter.

A few things I'm not sure on is:

Should I roll for which Gem gets lit up each round or have it in a set order?

Should I give the Gems a DC and Hit points, or should there be a different mechanic for destroying them?

Although I can control the flow of how many commoners appear, is it unfun to have them constantly spawning? I do have a Monk In the party so thought it might be nice for him to just punch a bunch of things.

Is there anything I've just not thought about? I'm still a very new DM and I'm not always the best at seeing problems in my encounters.

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/DMAcademy • • 16h ago

Need Advice: Other Funny magical items

7 Upvotes

Hello hope everyone is doing well. Recently started off a new campaign and created an NPC called Sindarim. He’s a powerful drunken wizard who specializes in enchanting gear but due to his drunkenness and level of power often doesn’t listen to instructions and somewhat extorts the party.

A good example of this is the paladin asking for “enchanted armor”. Sindarim took his armor and enchanted it so that when he takes damage there’s a 50% chance a mug of beer pops out. The original agreed upon price was 50gp but Sindarim bumped it to 60gp. He then enchanted to the artificers musket. The artificer wanted burning damage and instead of fire Sindarim gave him a little bit of acid damage.

Basically the end result of this is I’m trying to figure out similar magic items that have unintended consequences or don’t work exactly as intended. So far in his two appearances Sindarim is a popular character so I’d like to bring him back now and then for the party and keep him engaging for them.

Thank you to everyone for any ideas yall bring to the table.


r/DMAcademy • • 23h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How can I reward this players build in a boss fight without devaluing the rest of the party?

25 Upvotes

I’ve got a really big boss fight coming up, and I’m a pretty experienced dm. The next session will hopefully be one big lethal end of arc battle that we’ve been building to for a while, so I want it to last at least, like, 5 or more rounds for it to be suitably epic. One sorcerer has built basically his entire kit around save or suck charm/frighten effects and mental manipulation shenanigans. It’s been a really cool build, suggestion has come in clutch a couple encounters for life saving moments, and balancing hasn’t been too hard since they’re normally fighting multiple enemies, meaning that if he gets a few, combat can continue. But, this fight will inevitably be all of them vs 1 guy.

Hence the dilemma - he has no real damage spells, and one weak heal spell. The rest are save or sucks. If he gets a successful suggestion off on the boss, which could happen turn 1, that could end the encounter, as the boss might be forced to just sit peacefully for hours. If this happens on later turns - none of the damage the rest of the party did would matter at all, it all just came down to a Wis save. If I make the boss immune to charm, I’m kind of screwing him over specifically and giving him very little to do. I could give legendary saves, but I’ve always hated legendary saves for feeling cheap, and sort of giving a boss two unrelated health bars, and whichever one runs out first again invalidates the progress done to the other one.

So- I’m trying to find a way to make charm effects contribute to progressing towards victory for the party if the boss fails a save, without ending the encounter immediately so that the rest of the players can have fun in a big combat session.

Im open to literally anything, homebrew is fine. To provide flavor, simply put, the boss is a crazy old wizard in his tower. He has no shortage of ancient magical mumbo jumbo that he’ll be throwing at the players, but is rather squishy and is more trying to avoid getting hit with magical defenses than soaking hits. My goal is for the fight to feel like fighting someone cheating with random bullshit hax abilities. So literally any idea y’all have mechanically or lore wise I can probably justify very easily.

If anyone takes the time to read through this and help me out, thanks a bunch! I think I’m just stuck in my own head about it and need another perspective.

Edit: thanks for all the ideas everybody! These are wonderful


r/DMAcademy • • 18h ago

Need Advice: Other Opinion on homebrew item for two specific characters

9 Upvotes

I'm running a 2014 5e campaign. Party is level 8, soon to be level 9; the campaign will run through level 12. We have a dao warlock (melee), land druid (mountain), twilight cleric, fighter/barbarian, gloomstalker ranger, and watchers paladin. The paladin and the ranger are the two specific characters this item is intended for. The paladin is intentionally built as a damage sponge - 21 AC, max CON, only 12 STR/CHA. He likes to throw out Warding Bond, but generally only uses his spell slots for smites. The ranger has max DEX, 14 WIS. She almost never uses any spell slots, the one exception being the very occasional Hunter's Mark.

The paladin and ranger are essentially oathsworn platonic companions - they traveled together before meeting the party, and they roleplay their relationship consistently. Given the chance between saving her friend or saving the world, I'm 100% confident the ranger would let the world burn.

I want to give the ranger a reason to use her spell slots, and building on her connection to the paladin seemed like a good way to do it. This is the item I came up with for the two of them:

Rings of the Unbroken Bond

Ring, Rare (requires attunement by two characters)

This pair of platinum rings is engraved, one with a bow and arrow and the other with a mountain. When two characters are each attuned to one of these rings, they are aware of each other's general direction and overall state of physical well-being while within 1 mile of each other.

In addition, while within 30 feet of each other and can see each other, they also receive these benefits:

Bolstered Will. Each attuned character receives a +1 bonus to their armor class and saving throws.

Bond of Support. When one attuned character takes damage, the other can use their reaction to intercept part of the damage by expending a spell slot of 1st level or higher. Roll 1d8 plus the reacting character's spellcasting ability modifier, plus 1d8 for each slot level above 1st. The triggering damage is reduced by that total (minimum of 0), and the reacting character takes the prevented amount of damage. The damage reallocation occurs before the ally takes damage. This transferred damage is the same damage type as the damage prevented and cannot be reduced by resistance or immunity.

I'm already used to dealing with Twilight Sanctuary most combats, and I'm not terribly concerned about the interaction between these rings and that feature. I feel like it's reasonably positioned as a Rare item, given that it's a slightly nerfed Cloak of Protection with an additional feature, plus a ribbon, but I could accept it as a Very Rare item; either way, the loot budget has room for it.

Does this item seem reasonable for the party level? Overpowered? Underpowered? Just dumb? I think I've found a balance between utility and resource cost. The party has recognized and distributed character-themed items before and everyone really enjoys them, so they're unlikely to end up with the warlock and druid or whatever. I'd appreciate any opinions or suggestions anyone wants to offer.


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Arabian Nights-style homebrew in Calimport for six first-time players. What do you think of the story? (Acts I and II, full spoilers) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

If you sail on a ship called La Rondine and drink tea at dawn with a merchant named Zahra, please stop reading here.
I'm running a homebrew 5e (2014) campaign for six players who had never played D&D before. It's called The Nights of Calimport, set in Calimport in 1490 DR, and the models are the Arabian Nights, the Decameron and the 90s Sinbad TV show. 5e says very little about Calimshan after the Sundering, so I lean on the 2e books (Empires of the Shining Sea, Calimport) and homebrew the rest. We've played a prologue at sea and the first two chapters, and the party is level 3. Acts I and II are written and Act III isn't, so there's still time to change things.

The frame. The PCs work for Zahra, a rich merchant. Every chapter opens at dawn in her courtyard, over tea. The party is just back from a job, she asks how it went, and we play the job as a flashback. At the tea she always asks the same three questions, and the third is "What did you keep to yourselves?"

What's really going on. An efreeti prince, Sahruq, has been chained under the city for thousands of years. Nine seals hold him: blood, lamp, pearl, song, key, flame, name, crown, door. Zahra is the blood seal. In her family the eldest daughter renews it with her own life, and she is sick and has no heir. Every night the prisoner tells her a story in her dreams. She strips out the temptation hidden in it and turns the rest into a job, so the party is following leads that come from the very thing they're guarding. The villain is the Grand Vizier, who wrote the city's anti-genasi laws under the slogan "never again slaves of the genies". He doesn't want to free the prince. He wants to break the seals and reforge them into a single leash, held by him. Through middlemen he funds a fire cult, the Ember Hand, whose members are sincere and have no idea who pays them.

Act I (levels 1-5, five chapters). Self-contained stories, one seal each, though the players don't know that yet. A brass lamp stolen on the docks that must never be lit. A lighthouse kept by monks of Ilmater on an island no chart shows. A tomb that sings under the dunes, with a sphinx inside. A midnight market where a dao holds a key in pawn. Meanwhile the city gets darker: new edicts, harbor fires that burn blue, arson blamed on the genasi. On the fifth night the cult attacks Zahra's house, and in the rubble she tells the party about the prince. They stop being mercenaries and become Keepers.

Act II (levels 5-8, seven chapters). The jobs get longer and start to connect. The party sails to a marid who has forgotten why he guards a pearl, and finds out the enemy already knew their route, so there's a spy in the house (Zahra's scribe, blackmailed over a brother in prison). They escort twelve genasi families out of a city that wants scapegoats. Then comes a two-chapter dungeon in the Muzad, the buried city under Calimport, home of the Qandil, descendants of runaway slaves who keep the lamps of the dead burning. Their law says that whoever comes down with a light in hand is a guest, and whoever comes down in the dark is a thief.

Down there a cult ritual makes a vein of black amber "sing" (it's the resin the prince's fire leaves when it seeps through rock), and the PCs' souls swap bodies until sunrise. At the table the players swap character sheets. Each one gets a card with three ready-made moves and a folded note with something that body knows. They fight like that, and they explore a flooded archive where the prince's true name is carved backwards and can only be read in the water's reflection. It can't be copied, so one PC has to carry it in memory. In the same archive they learn that Zahra is a seal and that the stories come from the prisoner. When the souls go back, there are seven shadows on the wall instead of six. The seventh is a qarin, the spirit double of Arab folklore, made of everything the party answered (or didn't) to "What did you keep to yourselves?" It looks like a threat at first, but it isn't an enemy. It says out loud what they keep quiet.

The act ends with a palace heist for the Crown of Ash, where the party finally sees the Vizier's face, and then with the fall. Zahra is publicly accused of genie sorcery and the pasha's elite guard comes for the house on flying carpets. The fight can't be won, only held long enough to get out. Zahra gives herself up to buy that time and the party escapes through the cistern into the Muzad. They end up outlaws with a bounty on their heads, guests of the Qandil, one month before the Vizier's ritual.

What I'd like to hear from you:
What do you think of the story? Plot holes, clichés, things you'd cut or change, anything goes.

I have two worries. One is that "the patron hands out the jobs" turns into a railroad. The other is that Act II puts too much on the plate for people in their first campaign. Are they justified?

Have you run or played a campaign in a similar setting (Calimshan, Al-Qadim, anything with an Arabian Nights flavor)? What worked at your table, and what would you avoid?

Thanks to anyone who made it this far.


r/DMAcademy • • 15h ago

Need Advice: Other I made a feat for my 5e game would love some feedback.

3 Upvotes

Feat
Ranged Combatant
Requirements: Proficiency with at least on ranged weapon that doesnt possess the thrown property

You have honed your skills with ranged weapons to be able to fight in close quarters.

Being within 5 feet of an enemy no longer imposes disadvantage on your ranged attacks.

You can use a ranged weapon in place of a melee weapon for oportunity attacks.

Your ranged weapons gain the Melee & Finesse properties, allowing you to use them to make melee attacks.

Range: 5ft.

Damage: 1d6 Bludgeoning

When you make an attack with a ranged weapon you can use your bonus action to make a melee attack with the same weapon.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other My player refuses to use the pantheon of the setting I chose for the Campaign

0 Upvotes

Heya, I think the title sums it up quite decently to be honest, but here's some context just to be safe.

Me and my group all pretty new to the game, I'm probably the most experienced one of the bunch, which is why they FORCED me to play the DM (no real grudge held for that lol), my relative inexperience is why I'm using the Forgotten Realms setting, it's popular, supported by WotC and a bunch of other shit, which overall saves me a good chunk of time with world-building.

This being said, I also do want to integrate my players' characters into the story as possible, and, considering we're most certainly gonna have a paladin and a cleric, and that I personally really like that concept, I know that the gods of Faerun are gonna play a decent role in tying them into the world, say with quests related to temples and other stuff like that.

Now here's the issue: the paladin player absolutely refuses to choose one of the gods in the pantheon listed for the Forgotten Realms as his, and no matter what I tell him he won't budge...

He insists i can just not tie his faith into the story, but as I said... I do want to do that. I know I should let my players do what they want, but since he expects me to have stuff ready for the adv., is impatient as hell with game scheduling etc. etc., I feel like he could at the very least help me by making my job easier following the ONE thing I'm asking of him, instead of making joke deities which I won't even be getting into cuz that's a whole other can of worms...

Who's in the wrong here? Am i too controlling like he says, or is this a reasonable expectation on my side? How do i handle this?? Please help me

EDIT:

Thank you for your replies everybody, truly enlightening lol.

Imma set my foot down with this guy, y'all have made me think back on some of the stuff he did in a one shot we played a short while back, and realise he really is a bit of a trouble-player.

I don't want to kick him out so I'll try to find a solution that's good for everyone with him, I'll edit once we do.


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Other struggling with steampunk, pirate campaign

1 Upvotes

So I'm really new to DMing and I want to do a longer term campaign with steampunk pirate elements (as the title suggests)

My idea is that something horrible happened in what people now call "The Old World", in which the Gods decided to seperate almost every town across Toril into their own little pieces of land just floating through space, but a highly powerful wizard sacrificed themself in order to connect all the pieces through magical pathways from one place to the next, and people now use these cool airships to travel from place to place using these magical pathways.

I'm planning on starting the game when the party is already captured and is being held captive on one of these airships, and obviously they'll need to escape together and all that, and probably crash land on one of these settlements blah blah.

My problem is that I have no ideas for cool A plots once they crash land (aka the most important thing), and I also don't know how to pull in the pirate theme and airships into importance past the opener without them being sidelined immediately.

Please help me I barely know what I'm doing. 😭🙏