r/DebateReligion • • 6d ago

Meta Meta-Thread 11/16

3 Upvotes

This is a weekly thread for feedback on the new rules and general state of the sub.

What are your thoughts? How are we doing? What's working? What isn't?

Let us know.

And a friendly reminder to report bad content.

If you see something, say something.

This thread is posted every Monday. You may also be interested in our weekly Simple Questions thread (posted every Wednesday) or General Discussion thread (posted every Friday).


r/DebateReligion • • 2d ago

General Discussion 11/20

4 Upvotes

One recommendation from the mod summit was that we have our weekly posts actively encourage discussion that isn't centred around the content of the subreddit. So, here we invite you to talk about things in your life that aren't religion!

Got a new favourite book, or a personal achievement, or just want to chat? Do so here!

P.S. If you are interested in discussing/debating in real time, check out the related Discord servers in the sidebar.

This is not a debate thread. You can discuss things but debate is not the goal.

The subreddit rules are still in effect.

This thread is posted every Friday. You may also be interested in our weekly Meta-Thread (posted every Monday) or Simple Questions thread (posted every Wednesday).


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Other Slavery was acceptable under biblical law, but considered an injustice when the Israelites themselves became slaves

60 Upvotes

Hey guys, hope everyone is doing well!

In my opinion, the answer to this must be that: the Bible distinguished between regulated servitude and oppressive enslavement.

But on the other hand Consider the following:

\\- God hears the Israelites suffering as slaves in Egypt and intervenes to liberate them.

\\- God subsequently gives the Israelites laws permitting them to own foreigners as slaves.

\\- Leviticus 25:46 explicitly permits those foreign slaves to be inherited as property.

So does this give the Israelities higher value than others or is it simply that only specific people can become slaves.


r/DebateReligion • • 5h ago Bravo

Islam The Quran makes more sense when you realise God had nothing to do with it

29 Upvotes

I think the Quran is a human creation. Not because I can prove God doesn't exist, but because its content, historical fingerprint and practical purpose make far more sense as products of 7th century Arabia than as the final word of an eternal God.

Its theology borrows from the religious landscape around it. Its laws solve local 7th century problems. Its verses repeatedly emphasise Muhammad's authority, and its teachings helped forge a new religious and political order.

I don't believe in the supernatural, and I've yet to see convincing evidence that God speaks to humans. With that said, I’m reading the Quran the way I’d read any other ancient text by chucking out the divinity factor out the window.

I mean, if we took "God wrote it" off the table, what would be left in there that still needed a miracle to explain it?

1. It didn't drop out of the sky

7th century Arabia wasn't isolated from the wider religious world. Jewish, Christian and other monotheistic traditions had been circulating across the peninsula for generations.

So it's no surprise that the Quran is filled with stories that have predecessors in earlier religious literature. Jesus breathing life into clay birds appears in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas. Abraham smashing idols echoes Jewish midrash. The Seven Sleepers were already a staple of Christian lore and the tale of Dhul-Qarnayn mirrors late-antique legends about Alexander the Great.

Scholars debate the exact lines of transmission, but the overlap itself is undeniable. The Quran sits squarely inside an identifiable intellectual neighbourhood.

The standard Islamic response is that God was simply confirming and correcting earlier scriptures. Yeah, but that’s another claim that needs evidence. A human movement remixing the stories that were already floating around its culture explains the overlap without needing a single miracle. I mean, why bring God into the equation when history already accounts for the data???

2. Its laws are 7th century problem-solving

Pre-Islamic Arabia wasn't the lawless wasteland that later tradition often makes it out to be. It did have functioning trade networks, tribal diplomacy, established customs and religious communities.

When the Quran lays down laws concerning inheritance, marriage, charity, warfare and property, it reads like a reform package tailored specifically to that part of the world. Yes, some rules genuinely pushed things forward: women were guaranteed specific inheritance shares, charity became a formal duty and certain harsh customs were curbed. But other institutions like slavery, polygyny and unequal legal rights between men and women were kept on the books and regulated.

This is exactly what human reformers do. They look at the messy reality in front of them, improve what they can and compromise with the social structures they can't dismantle overnight.

But if these rules came straight from an all-knowing, timeless God, why are they so boxed in by 7th century norms? Why regulate slavery instead of banning it? Why hardcode unequal inheritance instead of equal rights? Practical compromises make total sense for human lawmakers working within historical limits. They make very little sense for the Creator of the universe.

3. The revelations are super convenient for Muhammad

This is one of the biggest red flags for me. The Quran doesn't just talk about God or lay out a moral code. It constantly works to cement Muhammad’s status as the ultimate authority on earth.

Obeying Muhammad is explicitly equated with obeying God (4:80). Even more tellingly, several verses step in to resolve Muhammad’s personal and domestic "issues":

  • 33:37 clears the way for him to marry Zaynab, the ex-wife of his adopted son
  • 33:50 grants him special marriage privileges denied to everyone else
  • 33:51 gives him total discretion over his domestic arrangements with his wives
  • 33:53 tells guests not to linger at his house, and forbids anyone from ever marrying his widows

We’re told this is the final, cosmic message from the maker of galaxies... yet a noticeable chunk of it reads like house rules for one dude's household.

Now, to be fair, the Quran does occasionally scold Muhammad which complicates the idea that every single verse was self-serving. Still, the broader pattern holds. The revelations built a wall of religious authority around him and consolidated a community under his command. Whether Muhammad sincerely believed he was hearing from God, or consciously crafted the messages is beside the point. Either way, the text's daily function needs zero divine help to explain.

4. It doesn’t reveal God. It projects human power onto him

The Quran describes God as infinite, incomparable and completely self-sufficient. Yet what does this cosmic being actually spend his time talking about? Obedience. Loyalty. Punishment. Social hierarchy. Conformity. And let's not forget... respecting his messenger.

He demands worship, rewards submission, threatens unbelievers with hell and micromanages family law and war spoils. These are awfully familiar human preoccupations, and they take on massive political weight the moment you attribute them to an unquestionable deity.

Think about the difference between a leader saying, "Follow my rules," and that same leader saying, "Follow God's rules… which also happen to be mine." The first is a human policy you can debate. The second is an absolute command you can't question without risking your soul. And that's a masterclass in social organisation.

Are we actually learning objective truths about the Creator of the cosmos here, or are we watching 7th century ideas about power and morality get projected onto the sky? Simply asserting that the text comes from God doesn't answer that question… because it is the question.

5. The "miracles" prove nothing

The Quran famously challenges skeptics to produce a chapter as good as its own (2:23). But literary brilliance is hardly proof of divine authorship. Who gets to be the impartial judge of whether the challenge is met? Even if the Quran were the greatest masterpiece in Arabic history, Hamlet doesn't prove Shakespeare was a god.

The modern "scientific miracle" claims fare even worse. Verses about the sky, creation or embryonic development are frequently retrofitted to match modern science. But these readings rely on vague phrasing, creative translation and hindsight. A real scientific prediction shows up before the discovery, not centuries afterward via linguistic gymnastics.

Then there’s textual preservation. Yes, early manuscripts do show a stable textual tradition, though discoveries like the Sana'a palimpsest, variant readings and the historical accounts of Uthman standardising the text complicate the claim that not a single letter ever changed. More importantly, preservation only proves that a community copied a book carefully. It tells you nothing about who wrote it in the first place.

6. The final word? Really???

Here’s where the theology collides with reality. The Quran was born in a specific place, solved local problems and codified 7th century social norms. Yet Islam insists this message is universal and FINAL… meant to govern every human society UNTIL THE END OF TIME.

Why should a legal framework built for 7th century Arabia dictate life in the 21st century? Look at where modern human rights collide with traditional Islamic jurisprudence: slavery, women's legal equality, freedom of conscience and the right to leave or criticise religion. Apostasy laws and gender inequalities are still actively defended using these texts today.

Of course, Muslims would interpret their scripture in different ways, and plenty would reject those hardline positions. But that does nothing for the underlying tension. When a 7th century rule clashes with modern human rights... which one gives way? If the rule is untouchable because God wrote it, we are permanently handcuffing humanity to the 7th century. If we reinterpret or ignore the rule because our morality has evolved, then human reason (and not the text) is actually in the driver's seat.

Maybe these verses were never meant to be timeless. Maybe they were never meant for the whole planet. Maybe the Quran is simply a product of its era, making the exact kind of grand, universal claims that religious movements always make. Claiming to be timeless doesn't make a book timeless.

7. The scripture can’t be separated from the empire

Islam didn't stay a quiet spiritual movement for long. Within Muhammad’s own lifetime, it became a political state with laws, taxes, diplomacy and an army. The Quran served as its founding constitution, defining who was in, who was out, who held power (4:59) and even how to split the booty after a battle (8:41).

After Muhammad died, the early caliphates exploded out of Arabia. Granted, you can't reduce a massive imperial expansion down to a single book as economics, military strategy and geopolitics all played huge roles.

But still, the outcome matters. A local Arabian movement turned into an empire and the Quran became the ultimate stamp of legitimacy for rulers governing millions of people far beyond Mecca and Medina. Religious authority and state power fused together. That’s a fascinating historical development and it deserves serious analysis.

8. Solving the puzzle

So let's step back now and look at the whole picture. We have a text that:

  • Absorbs the religious stories of its neighbourhood.
  • Solves local 7th century social problems.
  • Regulates existing institutions like slavery and patriarchy.
  • Repeatedly backs up the personal and political authority of its founder.
  • Lays the groundwork for a new state.
  • Declares itself universal, final and beyond question.

Every single piece of this fits comfortably inside human history. Muhammad didn't even have to be a cynical con artist; legit religious conviction has sparked movements like this throughout history.

Apologists often reply that God simply chose to speak in the language and culture of 7th century Arabia so people would understand him. But that creates a bit of a fatal trap. If every single human fingerprint on the text can be waved away as "God accommodating the locals," how could you ever tell the difference between a divine book and a human one? An explanation that can explain anything actually explains nothing.

The Quran makes vastly more sense as a human creation than as the final message from the Creator of the universe. Some of its ideas were progressive for the 7th century. Others froze inequalities in place that humanity has spent centuries trying to outgrow. That’s completely normal for an ancient movement, but it’s deeply awks for an all-knowing God.

And that puts the burden of proof squarely where it belongs. I don't need to disprove God to doubt that God wrote a specific book. Anyone claiming divine authorship has to show their work.

So I’ll leave it with three questions:

  1. What's actually inside the Quran that couldn't reasonably have come from a 7th century human mind?
  2. What independently proves that its time-bound laws should rule over modern humanity?
  3. If the Quran didn't constantly tell you God wrote it, would anything in its pages ever make you guess that he did?

From where I stand, the Quran looks entirely at home in 7th century Arabia, and I don't see any reason to look further than that for its author.


r/DebateReligion • • 4h ago

Islam Muhammad permit men to beat their wives after Umar requested it

12 Upvotes

Sunan Abi Dawud 2146
The narration reads:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Do not beat Allah's handmaidens."
Then Umar came to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and said: "Women have become emboldened towards their husbands."
So he (the Prophet) gave permission to beat them.
Then many women came to the family of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ), complaining about their husbands.
So the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Many women have gone round Muhammad's family complaining about their husbands. They are not the best among you."

It is classified as Sahih (authentic).
- Riyad as-Salihin 279 also reproduces it, describing its chain as authentic.

- Mishkat al-Masabih 3261 records the same incident.

- Ibn Majah 1985 contains the narration as well.

Muhammad basically allowed husbands to beat their wives, but when the wives came to Muhammad then he suddenly critized those men (for something he allowed) without pointing out that they were wrong.

Prophet's later criticism demonstrates disapproval of the consequences, but it does not erase the earlier permission.


r/DebateReligion • • 5h ago

Christianity Mark 13:32

9 Upvotes

Hey Christians. Help me out! Your so called god doesn't know the hour. Mark 13:32

New International Version

The Day and Hour Unknown

32 “But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father."


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Other Accuracy in scripture about the mundane is important if it wants us to believe the incredible

5 Upvotes

I tell you I have a chocolate bar with me and another chocolate bar at my house. I want to give you the first now, then have you follow me home and give you the other.

If it turns out I do not have a chocolate bar with me, you are highly unlikely to follow me home for the second chocolate bar.

.

If scripture fails to reliably report or describe things and events we can verify, it makes the unverifiable claims in scripture harder to believe.

For example, the Gospel of Matthew reports a census that required Mary and Joseph to return to Bethlehem. There is no other record of this census and Romans did not conduct any census by requiring people return to their hometown.

This indicates the census likely did not happen. If Matthew reports an event that did not happen, this challenges every other word in the Gospel. This intentional or unintentional error indicates there is a strong possibility of further errors.

I use Matthew as an example, but all scripture, from the Upanishads to the Book of Mormon, faces a similar issue: a provable error creates concern of further errors.


r/DebateReligion • • 48m ago

Islam Satanic verses proven

3 Upvotes

Today I will be refuting the common Rhetoric that’s used to discard the satanic verses by claiming it’s ‘fabricated’

Surah 22:52
“Never did We send a Messenger or a Prophet before you but when he did recited revelation Satan threw into his recitation. But Allâh abolishes that which Satan throws in. Then Allâh establishes His Revelations. And Allâh is All-Knower, All-Wise”
Every Prophet And messenger According to this Ayah Had satanic verses

Some may say تمنى = wish, to Escape the issue which becomes apparent. However we quickly realise the Salaf Agreed that it means to recite
Meaning of تمنى (established)⬇️
Ibn Al-Qayyim(d.751 AH) [159/1]
السلف كلهم على أن المعنى: إذا تلا ألقى الشيطان في تلاوته
all of the Salaf held that the meaning is: when he recited, Satan cast into his recitation.”

Ibn Taymiyyah(d.728 Ah) [190/15]
وَلِلنَّاسِ فِيهَا قَوْلَانِ مَشْهُورَانِ؛ بَعْدَ اتِّفَاقِهِمْ عَلَى أَنَّ التَّمَنِّيَ هُوَ التِّلَاوَةُ وَالْقُرْآنُ كَمَا عَلَيْهِ الْمُفَسِّرُونَ مِنْ السَّلَفِ …وَهُوَ ظَاهِرُ الْقُرْآنِ وَمُرَادُ الْآيَةِ
People have two well-known views concerning this, after their agreement that tamannī means recitation and Qurʾān, as held by the exegetes from the Salaf*….* it is the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān and is certainly what is intended by the verse.
Now that it’s been established from the Ayah Alone that Every prophet Had satanic revelation. We will move on to the story.

Saʿīd ibn Jubayr, who said: “When this verse was revealed, ‘Have you considered al-Lāt and al-ʿUzzā?’ [Qurʾān 53:19], the Messenger of Allah ﷺ recited it and said: ‘Those are the exalted cranes, and indeed, their intercession is to be hoped for.’ Then the Messenger of Allah ﷺ prostrated.
Tafsīr al-Ṭabarī – Ibn Jarīr al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH) [Link]

We see that this mursal agrees with the apparent meaning of The Quran as established… we look at what ibn Tamiyyah says

Ibn taymiyah (d.728AH) [154/1]
if a mursal is transmitted through another route, or is supported by the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān or Sunnah ,it becomes a ḥujjah by agreement.”

It’s routes are mursal They come through:
Saʿīd ibn Jubayr (d. 95 AH) (Sahih)
Abū al-ʿĀliyah (d. 90 AH) [link] (Sahih)
Abū Bakr ibn ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn al-Ḥārith (d. 94 AH) [link] (Sahih)
Muḥammad ibn Kaʿb al-Quraẓī (d. 120 AH) [link] (Hasan)
Qatadah (d.177 AH)[link] (Sahih)

Marasil are a proof when corroborated According to the scholars of Hadith⬇️
Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ (d. 643 AH) [page 53]
Know that the ruling of a mursal is the ruling of a weak ḥadīth, unless its source is established as sound through its transmission by another route as previously explained in the category of ḥasan
If we go to check the hasan category⬇️
[Page 32–33]
Likewise, if another mursal agrees with it*, transmitted by someone who received knowledge from transmitters other than those of the first Tābiʿī.*

Al-ʿIrāqī (d. 806 AH) [208/1]
mursal is used as proof when it is supported by a connected report through another route, or when it is transmitted mursal by someone who received knowledge from transmitters other than those of the first mursal.

Ibn taymiyah (d.728AH) [154/1]
if a mursal is transmitted through another route, or is supported by the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān or Sunnah ,it becomes a ḥujjah by agreement.”

Story fulfils conditions for proof as mursal⬇️
Ibn Ḥajar (d. 852 AH)[439/8] [link]
“I have already mentioned that three of its isnāds are upon the conditions of the Ṣaḥīḥ ( Saʿīd b. Jubayr (d.95 AH) , Abū Bakr b. ʿAbd al-Raḥmān (d.95AH), Abū al-ʿĀliyah (d.90AH) They are mursal reports of the sort relied upon by those who accept the mursal as proof; and likewise [they are relied upon] by those who do not ordinarily accept the mursal, because they reinforce one another.”

Salaf Who affirmed it as Tafseer ⬇️** ( Additional to those I’ve already mentioned already**)
•Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH)
•al-Zuhrī (d. 124 AH)
•Muqātil ibn Sulaymān (d. 150 AH)
•ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH)
•Ibn Qutaybah (d. 276 AH)
•Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH)
•Al-Zajjāj (d. 311 AH)
•Ibn Abī Zamanīn (d.399AH)

Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH) [link]
Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH)
He says: When the deities whom they invoke besides Allah are mentioned alongside Allah, and it is said:“Those are the exalted gharānīq, and indeed their intercession is hoped for,”
As follows
Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH)
*concerning His statement:They recoiled in aversion” he said: “They contracted [in aversion].”He said:“*And that was on the day he recited Sūrat al-Najm to them at the door of the Kaʿbah.”

al-Zuhrī (d. 124 AH) [Link]
Uses it as Tafseer
that he was asked about Allah’s statement:
*“And We did not send before you any messenger or prophet…’ [Qurʾān 22:52].”*he said: ‘Indeed, their intercession is hoped for.’ And the Messenger of Allah ﷺ had made an inadvertent error.”

Muqātil ibn Sulayman (d.150 AH) [link]
“So Allah abolishes what Satan casts” onto the tongue of Muḥammad ﷺ, “then Allah establishes His verses” by removing the falsehood that Satan casts onto the tongue of Muḥammad ﷺ.

ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH) [link]
tabari: “So some of them said: It refers to the statement of the Prophet ﷺ: ‘These are the exalted cranes, and indeed their intercession is hoped for.’”
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH)
concerning ‘Those who disbelieve will continue to be in doubt concerning it’: ‘[It refers to] what Iblīs brought. It does not depart from their hearts; it increased them in misguidance.’”

Ibn Qutaybah al-Dīnawarī (d. 276 AH) [link]
“If they deny this because they believe Allah would never allow Satan any means of affecting the Prophet or the other prophets, they have surely read Allah’s statement: ‘We never sent before you any messenger or prophet except that when he recited, Satan cast into his recitation…… when he recited in prayer: ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is hoped for.”

Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH) [link]
“Allah, exalted is His remembrance, says: Allah abolishes what Satan casts and then establishes His verses, so that He may make the falsehood which Satan casts into His Prophet’s recitation such as the Prophet’s saying, ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is indeed hoped for’ a trial.”
And something similar to what we have said concerning this was stated by the scholars of interpretation.

Al-Zajjāj(d. 311 AH) [link]
Satan cast onto the Prophet’s tongue something describing the idols*, through which those characterised by opposition and hypocrisy, and those with disease in their hearts, were put to trial.”*

Ibn Abī Zamanīn (d.399AH) [link]
“His saying, ‘Or shall man have whatever he wishes?’ this was because of the polytheists’ rejoicing over what Satan cast upon the Prophet’s tongue concerning the mention of their gods.”

Ibn Hajar concedes the Dhahir supports my claim
Ibn Ḥajar (d. 852 AH) [link]
*“*Once that has been established (that it happened), it becomes necessary to reinterpret what is objectionable in these reports, namely the statement that Satan cast upon his tongue, ‘Those are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is indeed hoped for.’ For this cannot be understood according to its apparent meaning.”

There are so much from the khalaf who affirm it I will save the time and Show a few big athari/Ashari imams affirm it: Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728AH), Taj Al-Din Subki (d.771 AH), Sayf ad din Al-Āmidī (d. 631 AH)

We will begin with ibn Taymiyah ⬇️
Ibn taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [191–192/15]
since tamannī must necessarily include speech, then there are two views concerning it.

The first is that the casting occurred in the hearing of the listeners, while the Messenger did not himself utter it.This is the view of those who interpreted the verse in such a way as to deny the permissibility of anything being cast into his speech.[not His position]

The second and this is the position of the generality of the Salaf and those who followed them is that the casting occurred in the recitation itself, as is indicated by the verse and its context in more than one respect and as is reported in the multiple transmitted reports.[From salaf] There is nothing objectionable in this unless it is allowed to remain. But if Allah abrogates what Satan casts and then establishes His verses, there is nothing objectionable in it.”….[his position]
Those who denied that Satan’s insertion could occur during his conveying of revelation did so in order to escape this difficulty…. However, it is said to them: Satan cast something, and then Allah made His verses firm. Therefore, there is nothing objectionable about this.….. This resembles abrogation in certain respects, as experienced by those to whom commands and prohibitions have been conveyed….. This is a sound explanation, agreeing with the apparent meaning of the verse and with the other fundamental principles established by the Qurʾān and the Hadiths.
This should make his position very clear

Tāj al-Dīn al-Subkī (d. 771 AH) [278/6]
“A saint should not imagine that he will escape Satan’s deception while living in this world. Even prophets do not escape it, to the extent that the words ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is to be hoped for’ were caused to occur upon his tongue*. However, a prophet is not allowed to persist in error.”*

Sayf ad din Al-Āmidī (d. 631 AH) [4/200]
“The answer is that tamannī here means recitation, for three reasons:
First: The occasion for which the verse was revealed, namely what was heard of his statement*, ‘Those are with Allah among the exalted cranes.’ This occurred during recitation, not as an inward wish.”*

Refuting that Ibn Taymiyah claimed it was fabricated ⬇️
#Claim 1
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [409–410/2]
according to what is well known from the Salaf and the Khalaf, that this passed upon his tongue, after which Allah abrogated it and nullified it this is, according to the position of these people, among the greatest fabrications.”
Refutation ⬇️
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [403–410/2]
“Commentary on his(Ibn al-Muṭahhar) statement that “this destroys confidence and causes people to be repelled.”
This is clearly a response to Ibn al-Muṭahhar and the like who reject this. Not him saying that he himself believed it’s fabricated
⬆️ further proof he wasn’t saying the salaf “said it’s fabricated “
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [291/10]
“But can something occur which Allah then corrects so that Allah abrogates what Satan casts and then makes His verses firm? On this there are two views. And what is transmitted from the Salaf concerning this agrees with the Qurʾān.

Refuting ibn taymiyah Had doubt⬇️
Claim: ibn Taymiyah used إذَا كَانَ صَحِيحًا which indicates he didn’t know if it was authentic
Ibn Taymiyyah [link]
“As for what has been mentioned concerning the tamannī, if it is authentic*, then it was the reason they agreed to join him in prostrating to Allah.”*
Refutation ⬇️ the if (إذا) doesn’t necessitate doubt according to himself
“Conditionality does not necessarily entail doubt. Rather, this depends upon the speaker’s knowledge: sometimes he is doubtful, and sometimes he is not doubtful.”
[link]

Story isn’t baseless ⬇️
Jalāl al-Dīn al-Suyūṭī (d. 911 AH) [link]
“No consideration is given to the statement of Ibn al-ʿArabī and qadi ʿIyāḍ that these narrations are invalid and baseless.

Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī (d. 852 AH) [Fatḥ al-Bārī, 8/439]
“Abū Bakr ibn al-ʿArabī boldly stated, as was his habit, that al-Ṭabarī related numerous baseless and invalid reports concerning this. This sweeping assertion is rejected.”

Contemporary imam affirms it⬇️
Shaykh ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz ibn Rayyis al-Rayyis [link]
*“*Among the evidence for the authenticity of the story from the perspective of transmission is that it was narrated through mursal routes, and the Tābiʿūn who transmitted it as mursal were from different regions. Among those who transmitted the story as mursal were Abū al-ʿĀliyah and Qatādah, both from Basra; Saʿīd ibn Jubayr, from Kufa; and Abū Bakr ibn ʿAbd al-Raḥmān, from Medina.”… These mursal reports are numerous, their transmitters belonged to different regions, and their chains are authentic up to those who transmitted them as mursal. Therefore, the story is authentic and Allah knows best.

Khalaf who affirmed 2.0
Hibat Allāh ibn Salāmah (d. 410 AH) [link]
Al-Thaʿlabī (d. 427 AH) [link]
Makkī ibn Abī Ṭālib (d. 437 AH)[link]
Ibn Baṭṭāl al-Qurṭubī (d. 449 AH) [link]
al-Wāḥidī’ (d.468 AH) [link]
al-Samʿānī (d. 489 AH) [link]
Al-Zamakhsharī (d. 538 AH) [link]
Najm al-Dīn al-Ṭūfī (d. 716 AH) [link]
Al-Maḥallī and al-Suyūṭī (d. 864 AH and 911 AH) [link]

Muslims will run to the route of musa ibn uqbah To say “ the prophet never said it” but we will refute this too
Ibn Kathīr’s Tafsīr, [5/442 – 443]
ثم قال ابن أبي حاتم: حدثنا موسى بن أبي موسى الكوفي، حدثنا محمد بن إسحاق المُسَيَّبِي، حدثنا محمد بن فُلَيْح، عن موسى بن عقبة، عن ابن شهاب
Ibn Abī Ḥātim → Mūsā ibn Abī Mūsā al-Kūfī → Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq al-Musayyabī → Muḥammad ibn Fulayḥ → Mūsā ibn ʿUqbah → Ibn Shihāb al-Zuhrī
Response⬇️
Ibn ʿAbd al-Barr (d. 463 AH) – al-Istīʿāb fī Maʿrifat al-Aṣḥāb, [8/119]
“Mūsā ibn ʿUqbah is not an authority in his narrations from Ibn Shihāb when someone else contradicts him.”
Aḥmad ibn Ṣāliḥ al-Miṣrī (d. 248 AH)
Ibn Abī Ḥātim, al-Jarḥ wa-l-Taʿdīl, [9/249]
‘“We do not give anyone precedence over Yūnus concerning al-Zuhrī.’”
Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal (d. 241 AH) Al-Mizzī, Tahdhīb al-Kamāl, [1/343]
*“I asked Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal: ‘Who are the most knowledgeable people concerning the hadith of Ibn Shihāb al-Zuhrī?’ He replied: ‘*Aḥmad ibn Ṣāliḥ al-Miṣrī.”

Narration in Bayhaqi response⬇️*** (musa ibn uqbah***)
Dalāʾil al-Nubuwwah, [2/285 – 287]
Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways
Yaḥyā ibn Maʿīn (d.233 AH) [816/1]
He mixes things up, he lies, and he is nothing

Turning the table ⬇️
A Muslim might say not a authentic route from a companion came so we don’t have to accept it
Refutation
Surah 17:79
so your Lord may raise you to a station of praise
Mujāhid:
«يجلسه معه على عرشه»
“He seats him with Him upon His Throne.”
Ibn Taymiyyah Darʾ Taʿāruḍ al-ʿAql wa-l-Naql⁠ [237/5]
“Some transmitted it through numerous prophetic routes; all are fabricated.” What is established is only that it comes from Mujāhid and other early authorities. The early salaf used to narrate it without rejecting it and received it with acceptance.”
Clearly the salaf accepted narrations that are mursal

The clear Lie of Albani appealing to ibn taymiyah that The prophet didn’t say it
Al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) – Naṣb al-Majānīq li-Nasf Qiṣṣat al-Gharānīq, [p. 63, footnote 1]
“After writing the preceding discussion, I saw that Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah inclined towards affirming the story to the extent mentioned*…. **and that* the statement, ‘Those are the exalted gharānīq …’, was not pronounced by the Messenger of Allah, but rather Satan cast it into their hearing. Refer to his words in al-Fatāwā (2/282).”**
If we look at his majmu he brought two views and agreed with the second that it happened on Prophet tongue ⬆️(which I’ve already posted)
The second and this is the position of the generality of the Salaf and those who followed them is that the casting occurred in the recitation itself, as is indicated by the verse and its context in more than one respect and as is reported in the multiple transmitted reports.

Albani concedes That nobody preceded him in weakening the marasil because it was ‘possibly weak’
al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) [p. 44–45]
it is possible that each of the two or more intermediaries is weak. And with these possibilities present, using the mursal ḥadīth as authoritative evidence becomes invalid, even if its transmission routes are numerous. This is an analysis for which I have not found anyone who preceded me.
Ironic coming from Albani When he says We go off what’s more probable than ‘mere possibility’
al-Albani [link]
The door to raising objections, I mean to say, is wide open. However, scholarly investigation requires a person to follow what is most probable.

What other way to end it but with the Imam himself Albani tell you it falsifies Islam⬇️
al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) [Link]
*وأوضح مثال وأقوى مثال على ما نقول هو حديث قصة الغرانيق، وكلُّكم يعلم قصة الغرانيق التي القول بها يؤدِّي إلى الشك بكل حديث رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم، بل وبقرآنه *الذي
“The clearest and strongest example of what we are saying is the narration of the gharānīq incident. All of you know the gharānīq story, belief in which leads to doubting every ḥadīth of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, and indeed even the Qurʾān that Allah revealed to him.”


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Other Religion should be banned from public life and kept out of every law, with private worship at home as the only exception

16 Upvotes

My thesis is that religion should be removed from public life completely. That means no law can pass if its only reason is religion, whether voters pass it or a legislature does, and churches, mosques, temples, and other religious property get turned into things the whole community can use, like schools, clinics, shelters, food banks, and housing. People can still believe whatever they want, tell anybody what religion they follow, and worship at home with their families every day. I know this would take a constitutional amendment and won't happen anytime soon. I'm arguing it should.

The reason is that religion doesn't stay private. It ends up in laws that everyone has to live under, including people who don't share it, and those laws rest on claims nobody can test. In Iran, a 22 year old woman named Mahsa Amini died in 2022 after the morality police arrested her for supposedly not wearing her hijab the way the government required, and this year Iran has executed dozens of people over the January protests on a charge that means waging war against God. In Afghanistan girls have been barred from school past sixth grade since 2021 and women from universities since 2022. Pew found 18 of the 20 countries in the Middle East and North Africa had laws making
blasphemy a crime, and 13 outlawed leaving your religion.

The US isn't immune. A federal appeals court cleared the way this year for Louisiana's law requiring the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms, even though the Supreme Court struck down a nearly identical Kentucky law in 1980. The Southern Baptist Convention, the country's largest Protestant denomination, passed a 2025 resolution calling for overturning the ruling that legalized same sex marriage, saying it defies God's design. The worst example is Idaho. Parents there who say their faith prohibits lifesaving medical care for their children can't be charged with neglect or manslaughter, and at least 15 babies and children from one faith healing sect died between 2015 and 2025 from illnesses doctors could have treated.

My standard is evidence. When a company wants to sell a new drug, it has to prove the drug works before anyone can use it. Laws should be held to the same kind of standard, with a reason based on measurable harm that doesn't depend on accepting any religion as true. Feeding the hungry doesn't need a god, hunger can be measured on its own. Questions where people disagree for real secular reasons, like abortion, would still be voted on. Questions that only come down to religious objections, like banning same sex marriage, wouldn't be allowed, and courts would strike down any law that slipped through.

Under my plan the buildings would go to public use because right now that land only serves one group when it could serve everyone. The 2020 U.S. Religion Census counted about 357,000 congregations in the country, and this kind of conversion is already happening on its own. Lifeway Research estimates about 4,000 Protestant churches closed in 2024, and empty churches are being redeveloped into affordable housing and community centers.

Nobody gets hurt for believing, praying, or worshipping at home, and nobody gets punished for peacefully disagreeing. People rioted over desegregation, and the law held anyway. If someone turns violent over this, they get arrested like anyone else who commits a violent crime, because the threat of violence shouldn't decide what's right.

I'd like to hear from religious people especially. If your faith shapes how you vote, why should a law based on that faith apply to someone who doesn't share it? If religious claims can't be tested, what makes them a fair basis for laws everyone has to follow?


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Islam Either Satan has divine power or Allah's will was to allow scripture to be corrupted

3 Upvotes

Firstly The Quran never actually declares the prior scriptures corrupted, it accuses a group of people that do attempt to distort the message.

It's an Islamic ruling invented because Muslims started reading the old and new testament and saw it contradicts the Quran, by apologist such as Al-Tabari and Fakhr al-Din al-Razi.

If we try and break this down, Moses lived 40 years after receiving revelation and at that time there were hundreds of thousands of jews that followed Moses and his law, It is just insane to think that the Torah could be permanently altered, when you had Jews at the time view Moses as the ultimate just as Muslims see Muhammed, and they learned the Torah by heart.

Same thing applies to Jesus, he didn't preach the injeel to a select amount of people in a quiet room, he preached to tens of thousands of people, Jews Gentiles, Romans etc. How is it possible for not on of those people preserve anything. Especially the part of Him being a mere prophet and God is father to no one.

The main point is how can Allah be called, the all powerful and the preserver but for 5000 - 5500 years allow the Jews and Christians to call him father.

So just as Muslims see Muhammed so did Jews see Moses and Jesus disciples see him in the same way.


r/DebateReligion • • 2h ago

Islam Romans prophecy debunked

3 Upvotes

Muslims When asked for a prophecy always use surah 30:2–5 today I will show that the prophecy is built on conjecture with no proof.
Let’s begin ⬇️
Surah 30: 2–5
The Byzantines have been defeated, In the nearest land. But they, after their defeat, will overcome. Within three to nine years.

What does بضع سنین ( in a few years mean) ⬇️ for the ayah according to early Muslims
Muqātil ibn Sulaymān (d. 150 AH), [link]
“Within a few years” meaning five years, or seven years up to nine years. ( 5 years/or 7–9 years)

Abū ʿUbaydah Maʿmar ibn al-Muthannā (d. 209 AH) [link]
biḍʿ means between three years and five years. (3–5 years)

Abū al-Layth al-Samarqandī (d. 373 AH) [link]
Within biḍʿ years’: meaning up to five years.
This shows early Muslims differed on what bid means when applied to this Ayah.. why should we take something as clear cut?

Linguist⬇️
al-Fīrūzābādī (d.817AH) [linguist] [link]
Between three and nine(3–9 years max ); or up to five (5 years max); or between one and four.” (1–4 years max)

Was it Badr or Hudaybiyyah?⬇️
Badr view⬇️
Yaḥyā b. Sallām (d. 200 AH) [link]
When the full seven years had passed, the Romans prevailed over Persia … the Romans prevailed over Persia and the believers over the polytheists on one and the same day the Day of Badr.”

al-Tabari (d. 310 AH) [link]
It was the believers’ victory over the polytheists at Badr.

Ibn Abī Zamanīn al-Mālikī (d. 399 AH) [link]
When seven years came, the Romans prevailed over Persia … Rome prevailed over Persia and the believers over the polytheists on the same day, the day of Badr.”

Al-Wāḥidī (d. 468 AH) [link]
Then Rome and Persia met in the seventh year after Persia had defeated them, and the Romans defeated them … and that coincided with the day of Badr*.”*

Ibn al-Jawzī (d. 597 AH)[link]
“When the Messenger of Allah ﷺ met the polytheists on the day of Badr and was granted victory over them, that same day coincided with the meeting of Persia and Rome, and Rome was victorious, so the Muslims rejoiced at the two victories.”

Sufyan Ath Thawri (d.161AH)[Implicit] [link]
“I heard that they defeated them on the day of Badr”
This one is more implicit as he says he heard it however ibn kathir Attributed it to him
Ibn Kathīr (d. 774 AH)[link]
The Romans’ victory over Persia occurred on the day of the Battle of Badr according to a large group of scholars, such as Ibn ʿAbbās[not clear], al-Thawrī*, al-Suddī [weak chain to him]and others.*

Hudaybiyyah view⬇️
ʿUbayd Allāh b. ʿAbd Allāh b. ʿUtbah (d. ~98 AH) [link]
Then Allah caused the Romans to prevail over Persia at the time of al-Hudaybiyyah*, and the Muslims rejoiced at the victory of the People of the Book.”*
[Sanad begins from page 332]

al-Shaʿbī (d. ~103 AH) [link]
“The Romans prevailed over Persia, and the believers rejoiced at the confirmation of Allah’s Book.” This is explicitly included among the events of Hudaybiyyah.

Qatādah (d. 117) [link]
“Allah caused the Romans to prevail over Persia at the completion of seven years from their first wager, and that was their return from Hudaybiyyah.”

Muqātil b. Sulaymān (d. 150 AH) [link]
“The news subsequently reached the Muslims, while the Prophet ﷺ and the believers were at al-Hudaybiyyah, that the Romans had defeated the Persians, so the Muslims rejoiced at that.

Ibn Qutaybah (d. 276 AH) [link]
The Romans defeated the Persians and expelled them from their lands on the day of al-Ḥudaybiyyah.”

Ibn Taymiyyah(d.728AH) [link]
A group of scholars held that the report concerning the Romans’ victory over Persia occurred on the Day of Badr, while others held that it occurred on the Day of al-Hudaybiyah, and this is the correct view.

Ibn al-Qayyim (d.751AH) [link]
“This victory of the Romans over Persia occurred in the year of al-Ḥudaybiyyah, without doubt. Whoever says it occurred in the year of Badr has erred,

Ibn Hajar al-ʿAsqalani (d. 852 AH) [link]
Heraclius came to Jerusalem when his armies had defeated and expelled the Persian forces, “and that was in the year in which the Prophet performed the ʿUmrah of al-Hudaybiyyah; news of the Romans’ victory over Persia reached the Muslims and they rejoiced.
For a “air tight prophecy” the classical scholars themself differed on when it happened

Contradictory narrations of ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Abī al-Zinād
Some places he will say Abu bakr, quraysh or prophet came up with the 3–9 years

1) Luwayn [Baghdad]→ Ibn Abī al-Zinād – [Abū Bakr] [link]
(Abu bakr says 3–9)
حَدَّثَنَا رَوْحُ بْنُ الْفَرَجِ قَالَ: حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سُلَيْمَانَ لُوَيْنٌ قَالَ: حَدَّثَنَا ابْنُ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ عَنْ نِيَارِ بْنِ مُكْرَمٍ
قال أبو بكر رضي الله عنه: البضع ما بين الثلاث إلى التسع
“Abū Bakr said: al-biḍʿ is between three and nine.”
Al-Dāraquṭnī 385 AH [link]
Abū al-Zinād alone narrated it from ʿUrwah,
Ibn Ḥibbān(d.354 aH) [link]
“His report may not be used as proof when he narrates alone”

2) Surayj b. al-Nuʿmān [Baghadad]→ Ibn Abī al-Zinād – [Quraysh say 3–9] [link]
حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى، قَالَ: ثنا سُرَيْحُ بْنُ النُّعْمَانِ صَاحِبُ اللُّؤْلُؤِ، عَنِ ابْنِ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ بْنِ الزُّبَيْرِ، عَنْ نِيَارِ بْنِ مُكْرَمٍ الْأَسْلَمِيِّ
ثم بكروا، فقالوا: يا أبا بكر: البضع ما بين الثلاث إلى التسع، فاقطع بيننا وبينك شيئًا ننتهي إليه
“Then they came early and said: O Abū Bakr, al-biḍʿ is between three and nine, so set something between us and you as the limit.”
Alī b. al-Madīnī(d.234 AH) [link]
Abd al-Raḥmān b. Abī al-Zinād:
ما حدث عبد الرحمن بن أبي الزناد بالمدينة فهو صحيح، وما حدث به ببغداد أفسده البغداديون
“What ʿAbd al-Raḥmān b. Abī al-Zinād narrated in Medina is sound; what he narrated in Baghdad was corrupted by the Baghdadis.- what he narrated in Iraq is disturbed (مُضْطَرِبٌ)

4) Ismāʿīl b. Abī Uways [Medina] → Ibn Abī al-Zinād – [link]
[Quraysh say “3 – 9”]
٣١٩٤ – حَدَّثَنَا ‌مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ إِسْمَاعِيلَ، قَالَ: حَدَّثَنَا ‌إِسْمَاعِيلُ بْنُ أَبِي أُوَيْسٍ، قَالَ: حَدَّثَنِي ‌ابْنُ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ ‌أَبِي الزِّنَادِ ، عَنْ ‌عُرْوَةَ بْنِ الزُّبَيْرِ ، عَنْ ‌نِيَارِ بْنِ مُكْرَمٍ الْأَسْلَمِيِّ
وقالوا لأبي بكر: كم تجعل البضع، ثلاث سنين إلى تسع سنين، فسم بيننا وبينك وسطًا تنتهي إليه
“They said to Abū Bakr: How much do you make al-biḍʿ? Three years to nine years; so appoint a middle point between us and you
Salamah b. Shabīb (d. 247 AH) [link]
I heard Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways saying: Sometimes I would fabricate ḥadīth for the people of Madīnah when they disagreed among themselves about something.”’

4).Abd al-Raḥmān ibn Abī al-Zinād → his father (Abū al-Zinād) → ʿUrwah → Niyār ibn Mukram → Prophet ﷺ [link]
The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
‘Biḍʿ is from three years to nine.’”
Al-Dāraquṭnī 385 AH [link]
Abū al-Zinād alone narrated it from ʿUrwah,

Someone might try use the route in Tirmidhi 3194 ( there two defects)
Tirmidhi 3194 [link]
حَدَّثَنَا إِسْمَاعِيلُ بْنُ أَبِي أُوَيْسٍ، حَدَّثَنِي ابْنُ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ أَبِي الزِّنَادِ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ بْنِ الزُّبَيْرِ
1). (Defect)Ismail ibn Uways ⬇️
Yaḥyā ibn Maʿīn (d.233 AH) [link]
‘He mixes things up, he lies, and he is nothing”
Salamah b. Shabīb (d. 247 AH) [link]
I heard Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways saying: Sometimes I would fabricate ḥadīth for the people of Madīnah when they disagreed among themselves about something.”’
This narration occured in medina so the defect is here⬆️

2). (Defect) Al-Dāraquṭnī 385 AH [link]
Abū al-Zinād alone narrated it from ʿUrwah,
Ibn Ḥibbān [link]
“His report may not be used as proof when he narrates alone,” due to his poor memory and frequent errors.

The narration in Tirmidhi 3191
Tirmidhi 3191 [link]
Prophet:
ألا احتطت يا أبا بكر، فإن البضع ما بين الثلاث إلى تسع
“Why did you not take precaution, Abū Bakr? For biḍʿ is between three and nine.”
Refutation ⬇️
al-Dāraquṭnī(d.385 AH)[link]
ʿAbd Allāh b. ʿAbd al-Raḥmān al-Jumaḥī narrates it from al-Zuhrī, from ʿUbayd Allāh, from Ibn ʿAbbās as connected. Others narrate it from al-Zuhrī as mursal. Abd Allāh al-Jumaḥī is not strong, and the mursal version is closer to what is correct.”

The route in Tirmidhi 3193 is the strongest proof for a Muslim even then theirs a defect in the matn⬇️
Tirmidhi 3193 [link]
[Saeed ibn jubayr]
the Prophet ﷺ, said:
‘Why did you not make it less than’
The narrator. said:
أُرَاهُ الْعَشْرِ
‘I think [he said]: ten.’”
Ibn Ḥajar(d.728AH) [link]
It appears that doubt occurred to the narrator, so he inserted the expression أراه; with ḍammah on the hamzah, meaning ‘I think/suppose.’”
Qāḍī ʿIyāḍ (d. 544 AH) [link]
For there is consensus among them [scholars of Hadith]all that he may narrate only that which he has verified. If he has doubt concerning something, then he has narrated something which he has not verified to be from the saying of the Prophet ﷺ…. His narration would then be based on conjecture, and conjecture is the most false of speech.

Someone might say but Tirmidhi authenticated these narrations
It is said ⬇️
al-Dhahabī (d. 748 AH)[Mīzān al-Iʿtidāl, 3/407](https://shamela.ws/book/1692/1758)
the scholars do not rely upon al-Tirmidhī’s authentication.”

The narration about the prophet saying it is fabricated ⬇️
1). Ibrāhīm ibn ʿAbd Allāh ibn Khālid al-Miṣṣīṣī → [Prophet ﷺ] [link]
قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: البضع ما بين الثلاث إلى التسع
“The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: al-biḍʿ is between three and nine.”
Refutation ⬇️
Ibrāhīm ibn ʿAbd Allāh ibn Khālid al-Miṣṣīṣī. [link] [fabricator]

Now that we have established there’s no evidence the prophet ever intended 3–9 years with the fact that al bid can differ on when .. ibn Taymiyah gives a warning ⬇️
Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 728 AH) [link]
*“*One may not state categorically which meaning the Messenger ﷺ intended except with evidence establishing his intent. If his wording admits this meaning and that meaning, one may not categorically assert either one without evidence.”
What further refutes this is if it was the common meaning you would expect Abu bakr to mention 3–9 years But he didn’t he understood it as max 5 years

If this was not enough to make you think, granting he said 3–9 years. When does the counting begin: from when they was defeated or when the verse was revealed? Which victory is it referring the first victory of the Persians over the Romans or another one? When was the verse revealed Before badr or after it?
Who decides?

Tommo tessi work [link]
He shows how people during his time was making similar prophecies about the Romans. Showing this was something expecting by those living in that era.


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Abrahamic God wouldn't want us to be going through our lives in fear of his wrath.

6 Upvotes

At this point I've read probably 70% of the Bible and I've read a little of the Quran. The main point of contention for me that blocks me from fully subscribing the Abrahamic religions is the constant use of "Fear God" and the contradiction between how God is supposedly loving and forgiving but at the same time will send you to hell for human cultural things. I can't understand why God would care about us not following petty cultural rules like the consumption of pork when he literally made whole planets and solar systems that we can observe.

It's much easier for me to believe that God wants us to be confident and trust in our own natural logic and instincts which he supposedly made in the image of himself, instead of going through our lives in fear.


r/DebateReligion • • 5h ago

Islam The simplest solution to the sura-like-it challenge

4 Upvotes

The simplest way to solve this question is by pointing out the obvious; that we already have someone who produced something like it, namely Muhammad himself! Muhammad composed the Quran all by himself, and since the Quran is “something like the Quran” by definition, then the challenge is met!

There is no non-question-begging way to go around this solution.


r/DebateReligion • • 2h ago

Other The opposition ideologies of buddhists and Janists to that of Christians and muslims show that blasphemy laws are not necessarily justified

2 Upvotes

I will use Muslims and Buddhists tho as I am more familiar. But this less about the groups and more that if the mentality of the Buddhists exist then it shows that blasphemy laws is not necessary.

often times people say that blasphemy is about preventing violence. this is the topic I'd like to discuss on why it is not necessarily a good defence of blasphemy laws

I say Muslims Christian etc. Because I'm not concerned with "that's not what god said" as a cop out when there are many Muslims and Christians that think blasphemy laws are fine.

Most Muslims, and some Christians, have the mentality that arresting people for blasphemy is justified because it hurts someone's ego. In some cases people will say if the Muslim is insulted he will attack and we don't want that in society so better to prevent it.

However, Buddhists have the mentality that if they are insulted, life is about letting things go. That the only change that can happen is internally..

I don't believe there is some sort of different genetic in Buddhists that allow them to not be violent when they are insulted.

I'm also not saying every Buddhist (janist) doesn't go violent. I'm saying their modern doctrine States to not be violent no matter the insults thrown at them

I also want to note I am aware of the examples of Mohammed being calm despite being insulted. Assuming its true, its not about him but about the Muslims And Christians.

conclusion, being insulted doesn't hold water that you are unable to restrain yourself from being violent


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Islam The circular logic of the “sura-like-it challenge” argument

6 Upvotes

(Version 2)
The argument that the Quran must be divine because no human has managed to produce anything like it is begging the question. It assumes what it is trying to prove.

The problem is simple: if Muhammad wrote the Quran himself, then a human has already produced something like the Quran. In fact, he produced the Quran itself. And surely the Quran is something like the Quran.

So how can someone claim that no human has ever produced anything like the Quran? They must first exclude Muhammad as a possible human author. But on what grounds? If the reason is that Muhammad could not have written the Quran because it is divine, then the argument is circular.

The reasoning becomes:

1. Why must the Quran be divine? Because no human could have written anything like it.

2. How do we know no human could have written anything like it? Because Muhammad, a human, did not write it.

3. How do we know Muhammad did not write it? Because the Quran is divine.

Notice the circle: The Quran is divine because Muhammad could not have written it, and Muhammad could not have written it because the Quran is divine.

The conclusion is being used to justify the very premise that is supposed to establish that conclusion.

Unless Muhammad’s human authorship can be ruled out independently, the claim that no human has produced anything like the Quran cannot establish its divine origin.


r/DebateReligion • • 42m ago

Abrahamic Infinite regression cannot be proved to be a logical contradiction

1 Upvotes

No religious believer or apologist has been able to prove infinite regression as a logical contradiction to date. Yet, religious beliefs like Kalam's Cosmological Argument (KCA) vehemently rules out infinite regression as being impossible.

Core Structure of KCA:

  • Premise 1: Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
  • Premise 2: The universe began to exist.
  • Conclusion: Therefore, the universe has a cause

Infinite regression directly opposes premise 2 of Kalam's cosmological argument and denying infinite regression without giving proof is simply wishful thinking.

Once infinite regression has been kicked out of the picture forcefully without proof, it is then shown that everything has a cause and so God exists (even though the conclusion of KCA that God exists is erroneous, still accepting for argument's sake).

Proponents of KCA should not arrogantly dismiss infinite regression without providing any proof that it is a contradiction. Until infinite regression is proven to be a contradiction, the premises of KCA stands invalid and believers should not hinge on it to prove God's existence.


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Christianity Specific creatures invalidates Noah's ark completely.

31 Upvotes

To the believers of Noah's ark story, Noah's ark could not have happened because of these 3 animals.

  1. Termites - they literally would have eaten the ark. Termites can't survive as pair. They need a colony.
  2. Blue Whale/aquatic animal - cannot survive in flood from salinity change. No idea how Noah would accommodate Blue whale or any aquatic animal in the ark
  3. Giant Pandas - 15 metric tons of bamboo would be required. How will bamboo be preserved for ark's voyage?
  4. Vampire bats/Mosquitoes/Leeches- Blood clots within minutes outside body without specialized modern anti-coagulants. Blood cannot be stored. Noah would have to let the vampire bats feed on other animals leading to blood loss and obligate dangerous disease transmission across ark animals.

The existence of these animals on the planet invalidates Noah's ark story.

More importantly, how did Noah save termites? Until someone can answer that, Noah's ark cannot exist because of mainly these creatures.


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Islam Questions for muslims about islam being an abrahamic religion

0 Upvotes

Hello guys, i have a questions for muslims:

Prove me that islam is an abrahamic religion and that Allah is the God of abraham without using the quran.

Now some muslims will asking me:

"What do you mean by not using the quran?"

Because if you use the quran, thats circular reasoning.

Using the quran to prove the quran is from thw God of abraham is fallacious. And specifically, Muslims must use the zabur(psalm),tawrat(torah) and the injil(the gospels). Because those religious scripture historically traces back to the abrahamic prophets. And here is my argument for islam:

P1:Islam claims to be an abrahamic religion(according to the quran and the hadith)

P2:In order for muslims to prove that islam is an abrahamic religion and that allah is the god of abraham,they have to use outside independent sources without using the quran(otherwise,using the quran is fallacious and circular)

P3:There is no outside independent source for islam being an abrahamic religion.

Conclusion:therefore islam is false.

Now i want to add the important note about the p3: the muslim is in the burden of proof to show that there is an outside independent source to prove islam being an abrahamic religion.

God bless.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Abrahamic If God were truly just, he'd give us the choice of non-existence after death

32 Upvotes

Nobody chooses or asks to be born, so why should anyone be forced to exist forever? If God is perfectly just and loving, why isn’t non-existence an option for those who don’t want eternity in heaven or hell?

Forcing someone into an eternity that they never asked for doesn’t seem like an act of love.


r/DebateReligion • • 19h ago

Islam The Quran Erases the Historical Jesus and Replaces Him With a 7th-Century Islamic Version

11 Upvotes

Muslims often point out that they believe in Jesus, unlike Judaism which rejects him. The fundamental issue with Islam's view of Jesus is that it retains his name while completely rewriting his historical context.

Compare how the Quran treats Moses versus Jesus. Moses is the most mentioned prophet in the Quran, complete with named adversaries like Pharaoh, Haman, and Qarun, and storylines that directly mirror Muhammad’s conflicts with the Quraysh. By contrast, Jesus's real historical setting is largely erased. The Quran never once mentions Judea, Galilee, Nazareth, Bethlehem, Roman rule, Pontius Pilate, or Judas.

Instead, the Quran claims the Injeel (Gospel) was a message revealed directly to Jesus, and commands Christians to judge by what Allah revealed in it (Surah 5:47). Furthermore, it claims the Prophet is foretold in the previous scriptures (Surah 7:157), and specifically claims Jesus predicted a messenger named "Ahmad" (Surah 61:6).

Yet there is zero independently verifiable historical evidence that Jesus ever received or wrote a book called the Injeel. Ironically, the word Injeel ultimately derives from the Greek euangelion ("good news"), likely transmitted through Syriac, a Semitic language. Historically, the Gospel referred to Jesus's proclaimed message, not a distinct book revealed to him. The New Testament consists of Gospels and letters written in Greek decades after Jesus's death. Unlike the Quran, which is presented as the direct dictation of Allah, the Gospels are anonymous human biographies. Furthermore, they contain no explicit prediction of a future prophet named "Ahmad." Instead, John 14:26 identifies the Paraclete as the Holy Spirit, and the New Testament repeatedly warns against false prophets.

The Crucifixion Problem
Even worse, the Quran rejects the single most historically established fact of Jesus's life: his crucifixion under Pontius Pilate. This event is confirmed not only by early Christian sources but also by independent, non-Christian historians like Tacitus and Josephus.

Six hundred years after the fact, Surah An-Nisa 4:157 replaces established history with an ambiguous half-sentence. First, it claims Jesus's Jewish opponents boasted: "We killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of Allah."

The people who rejected Jesus's messianic claims allegedly boast about killing him while calling him the Messiah and messenger of Allah. Unless this is sarcasm or the Quran inserting its own terminology, why would the very people who rejected his claims suddenly affirm them?

Second, it asserts: "But they neither killed nor crucified him, it was only made to appear so." Without offering any concrete alternative account, a vague statement written six centuries later overturns a well-documented Roman execution. Under the traditional Islamic interpretation, this effectively makes God responsible for an apparent crucifixion that could have misled even Jesus's own mother and disciples. Yet the Quran will explicitly outline the rules for visiting Muhammad's home (33:53). Apparently, Allah doesn't prioritize clarifying the historical fate of the Messiah, but Muhammad's household visitation rules require explicit divine instructions.

The Apocryphal Problem
On top of erasing his real biography, the Quran fills the gaps with stories lifted straight from non-canonical Christian apocrypha such as breathing life into clay birds (from the 2nd-century Infancy Gospel of Thomas) and speaking as a newborn in the cradle (from the Arabic/Syriac Infancy Gospel).

An all-knowing God apparently omitted Pontius Pilate, Nazareth, and Jesus's actual teachings, yet included 2nd-century Christian folklore. Divine revelation is hardly a convincing explanation when the circulation of Christian oral traditions and apocryphal stories throughout Late Antiquity offers a far more historically defensible one.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Classical Theism animal suffering is at such a high scale for god to be omnibeevolent

20 Upvotes

Survival of the fittest is brutal. For millions of years before humans even existed, sentient creatures were experiencing fear, pain and premature death through predation, starvation, disease, parasites and natural disasters. Animals were being hunted, sometimes surviving prolonged suffering before eventually dying, entirely independently of human decisions or wrongdoing. Animal suffering demonstrably predates humanity by millions of years. Furthermore, animals aren't morally responsible for their circumstances, nor does their suffering necessarily contribute to any greater good for the individual experiencing it. I accept that some pain serves a biological purpose, but that doesn't explain why suffering needs to exist on such an enormous scale or with such severity. An omnipotent creator could presumably have designed a world in which animals could survive, reproduce and maintain functioning ecosystems without requiring conscious creatures to experience such extensive suffering. If God is omniscient, he knows about every instance of suffering; if he is omnipotent, he has the power to prevent it; and if he is omnibenevolent, we would expect him to have a compelling reason to prevent suffering that serves no necessary greater purpose. Yet the natural world contains extraordinary amounts of apparently pointless suffering.


r/DebateReligion • • 21h ago

Christianity The existence of a historical Jesus is of little importance

12 Upvotes

Why does it matter whether
there was a historical Jesus or not?

If there was, 
we know next to nothing about them.

The only thing we really have 
are a parade of imagined Jesuses. 

People seem so proud and righteous 
about the entries they make 
to the Jesus parade.

And to that, I have to ask: to what end?

What is the purpose of telling people 
about your imagined Jesus? 

Do you actually think that everyone 
is going to get on board 
with your conceptualization, 
and it will lead to some greater good?

If you have an idea that you want to share, 
why isn't it good enough to stand on its own? 

Why do you have to attach it 
to an authoritative figure 
to give it credibility?

No idea or action is good or worthy 
simply because Jesus or any other figure 
- whether they be real or imaginary - 
supposedly supported it.

An idea's worth 
comes from its evidence, reasoning, and outcomes 
- not from who endorses it.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Islam If there is no compulsion in islam, then all the islamic countries should be condemned on the basis of the religious laws compelling people.

15 Upvotes

I'm not saying you can't have a religion that has compulsion. I'm saying its a useless phrase to say "no compulsion in Islam" unless there's a free for all then Islam is not "no compulsion in islam.

many Islamic countries arrest apostates (thus compelling someone to not apostate) atheists (compelling people to believe, and in before but they let Christians. Yes but an atheist would still have to pretend to be Christian) blasphemers (compelling people to not speak about their thoughts about Islam, regardless if its likeable or not) gays (compelling people to conform to the religious morals) and so on.

My point is "no compulsion in islam" has no meaningful use unless you condemn the countries and mentalities that believe apostates, blasphemers, atheists, other non believers with a jizya be arrested or punished for who they are or how they behave.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Islam A kind, honest person who leaves Islam shouldn't end up in hell for that alone

13 Upvotes

Picture someone born Muslim who later leaves Islam. They don't join another religion and they don't become an atheist. They just aren't sure whether God exists.
This person still helps others, respects everyone, takes care of their parents, never harms anyone and treats people kindly. They do it because they want to, not out of fear or for a reward. They were a good person before leaving, and they still are.
My position is that a just and merciful God wouldn't send someone like this to hell just because they left the religion. Their sincerity and character should count for more than a label.
Muslims who disagree: please respond with Quran verses (and authentic Hadith if needed), not personal opinion. Does the Quran support my position or go against it?


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Christianity The bible shouldn't be used to decide what is sin and what is not.

1 Upvotes

Im a Christian who happens to be bi and as i have been raised ive been taught to love one another as jesus loved us by my christian mother and my athiest and poly father told me as long as people are happy and consenting (if they have the knowledge of the world to consent) then to accept them. Ive talked about my faith to my friends before and ive realized i know some stories of the bible from my confirmation class, but i never use that in my relationship with god. And if in my opinion if you base your faith off of the bible being the first thing you resort to when you need help then you are looking in the wrong place. I think people need to know that the christian god is a god of love and if you dont acknowledge that God loves everyone equally regardless of their actions then you are mistaken. (Side note i think hell is just eternity away from god not punishment) if people want to commit horrid acts then they look inward and try to connect with god then they are redeemed. Especially with homosexuality i see people quoting the bible a lot and others trying to supply context but if a person is not harming others by living a lifestyle why would you be against that. If a gay dude wants to be married to a guy let him. That act doesn't even affect the population because he doesn't want to have a similar relationship with a female, so that possibility is already gone. I never realized this but the "love one another as I have loved you" is (in my opinion) the only commandment that is truly worth living by because by following this you wont commit other sins. Why would you murder out of love, or be greedy out of love. I find people trying to find all of these quotes from the bible to determine if a person is sinning but God is the one who decides that and God loves everyone if God wants a person to not do an action God will pave a way for them to follow. Also trans people are often criticized for "changing how god made them" but what if being trans is how God made them so that they can become closer to God by going on that journey. Or God made them that way so that others can love them for being "abnormal" (which is a dumb way to say what im trying to communicate) or even just so that they can show that even a person who "sins" or lives a life away from God can still be a kind and loving person and how you should not use God as a reason to be kind but that you should be kind and its an added bonus that you get closer to God. And transphobes bring up so many bible quotes to push a hateful agenda even though that is not what God intended that to be used for. Overall, i feel as if people often dont realize that as followers of christ their stories hold the same value to their faith if not more value than the bible. Like God is a being of love why would you "love the sinner hate the sin" when you could just love the PERSON who sinned instead of trying to find a bible quote to use to hate their identity.