Today I will be refuting the common Rhetoric that’s used to discard the satanic verses by claiming it’s ‘fabricated’
Surah 22:52
“Never did We send a Messenger or a Prophet before you but when he did recited revelation Satan threw into his recitation. But Allâh abolishes that which Satan throws in. Then Allâh establishes His Revelations. And Allâh is All-Knower, All-Wise”
Every Prophet And messenger According to this Ayah Had satanic verses
Some may say تمنى = wish, to Escape the issue which becomes apparent. However we quickly realise the Salaf Agreed that it means to recite
Meaning of تمنى (established)⬇️
Ibn Al-Qayyim(d.751 AH) [159/1]
السلف كلهم على أن المعنى: إذا تلا ألقى الشيطان في تلاوته
all of the Salaf held that the meaning is: when he recited, Satan cast into his recitation.”
Ibn Taymiyyah(d.728 Ah) [190/15]
وَلِلنَّاسِ فِيهَا قَوْلَانِ مَشْهُورَانِ؛ بَعْدَ اتِّفَاقِهِمْ عَلَى أَنَّ التَّمَنِّيَ هُوَ التِّلَاوَةُ وَالْقُرْآنُ كَمَا عَلَيْهِ الْمُفَسِّرُونَ مِنْ السَّلَفِ …وَهُوَ ظَاهِرُ الْقُرْآنِ وَمُرَادُ الْآيَةِ
People have two well-known views concerning this, after their agreement that tamannī means recitation and Qurʾān, as held by the exegetes from the Salaf*….* it is the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān and is certainly what is intended by the verse.
Now that it’s been established from the Ayah Alone that Every prophet Had satanic revelation. We will move on to the story.
Saʿīd ibn Jubayr, who said: “When this verse was revealed, ‘Have you considered al-Lāt and al-ʿUzzā?’ [Qurʾān 53:19], the Messenger of Allah ﷺ recited it and said: ‘Those are the exalted cranes, and indeed, their intercession is to be hoped for.’ Then the Messenger of Allah ﷺ prostrated.
Tafsīr al-Ṭabarī – Ibn Jarīr al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH) [Link]
We see that this mursal agrees with the apparent meaning of The Quran as established… we look at what ibn Tamiyyah says
Ibn taymiyah (d.728AH) [154/1]
if a mursal is transmitted through another route, or is supported by the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān or Sunnah ,it becomes a ḥujjah by agreement.”
It’s routes are mursal They come through:
Saʿīd ibn Jubayr (d. 95 AH) (Sahih)
Abū al-ʿĀliyah (d. 90 AH) [link] (Sahih)
Abū Bakr ibn ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn al-Ḥārith (d. 94 AH) [link] (Sahih)
Muḥammad ibn Kaʿb al-Quraẓī (d. 120 AH) [link] (Hasan)
Qatadah (d.177 AH)[link] (Sahih)
Marasil are a proof when corroborated According to the scholars of Hadith⬇️
Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ (d. 643 AH) [page 53]
Know that the ruling of a mursal is the ruling of a weak ḥadīth, unless its source is established as sound through its transmission by another route as previously explained in the category of ḥasan
If we go to check the hasan category⬇️
[Page 32–33]
Likewise, if another mursal agrees with it*, transmitted by someone who received knowledge from transmitters other than those of the first Tābiʿī.*
Al-ʿIrāqī (d. 806 AH) [208/1]
mursal is used as proof when it is supported by a connected report through another route, or when it is transmitted mursal by someone who received knowledge from transmitters other than those of the first mursal.
Ibn taymiyah (d.728AH) [154/1]
if a mursal is transmitted through another route, or is supported by the apparent meaning of the Qurʾān or Sunnah ,it becomes a ḥujjah by agreement.”
Story fulfils conditions for proof as mursal⬇️
Ibn Ḥajar (d. 852 AH)[439/8] [link]
“I have already mentioned that three of its isnāds are upon the conditions of the Ṣaḥīḥ ( Saʿīd b. Jubayr (d.95 AH) , Abū Bakr b. ʿAbd al-Raḥmān (d.95AH), Abū al-ʿĀliyah (d.90AH) They are mursal reports of the sort relied upon by those who accept the mursal as proof; and likewise [they are relied upon] by those who do not ordinarily accept the mursal, because they reinforce one another.”
Salaf Who affirmed it as Tafseer ⬇️** ( Additional to those I’ve already mentioned already**)
•Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH)
•al-Zuhrī (d. 124 AH)
•Muqātil ibn Sulaymān (d. 150 AH)
•ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH)
•Ibn Qutaybah (d. 276 AH)
•Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH)
•Al-Zajjāj (d. 311 AH)
•Ibn Abī Zamanīn (d.399AH)
Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH) [link]
Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH)
He says: When the deities whom they invoke besides Allah are mentioned alongside Allah, and it is said:“Those are the exalted gharānīq, and indeed their intercession is hoped for,”
As follows
Mujāhid ibn Jabr (d. 104 AH)
*concerning His statement:They recoiled in aversion” he said: “They contracted [in aversion].”He said:“*And that was on the day he recited Sūrat al-Najm to them at the door of the Kaʿbah.”
al-Zuhrī (d. 124 AH) [Link]
Uses it as Tafseer
that he was asked about Allah’s statement:
*“And We did not send before you any messenger or prophet…’ [Qurʾān 22:52].”*he said: ‘Indeed, their intercession is hoped for.’ And the Messenger of Allah ﷺ had made an inadvertent error.”
Muqātil ibn Sulayman (d.150 AH) [link]
“So Allah abolishes what Satan casts” onto the tongue of Muḥammad ﷺ, “then Allah establishes His verses” by removing the falsehood that Satan casts onto the tongue of Muḥammad ﷺ.
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH) [link]
tabari: “So some of them said: It refers to the statement of the Prophet ﷺ: ‘These are the exalted cranes, and indeed their intercession is hoped for.’”
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Zayd ibn Aslam (d. 182 AH)
concerning ‘Those who disbelieve will continue to be in doubt concerning it’: ‘[It refers to] what Iblīs brought. It does not depart from their hearts; it increased them in misguidance.’”
Ibn Qutaybah al-Dīnawarī (d. 276 AH) [link]
“If they deny this because they believe Allah would never allow Satan any means of affecting the Prophet or the other prophets, they have surely read Allah’s statement: ‘We never sent before you any messenger or prophet except that when he recited, Satan cast into his recitation…… when he recited in prayer: ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is hoped for.”
Al-Ṭabarī (d. 310 AH) [link]
“Allah, exalted is His remembrance, says: Allah abolishes what Satan casts and then establishes His verses, so that He may make the falsehood which Satan casts into His Prophet’s recitation such as the Prophet’s saying, ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is indeed hoped for’ a trial.”
And something similar to what we have said concerning this was stated by the scholars of interpretation.
Al-Zajjāj(d. 311 AH) [link]
Satan cast onto the Prophet’s tongue something describing the idols*, through which those characterised by opposition and hypocrisy, and those with disease in their hearts, were put to trial.”*
Ibn Abī Zamanīn (d.399AH) [link]
“His saying, ‘Or shall man have whatever he wishes?’ this was because of the polytheists’ rejoicing over what Satan cast upon the Prophet’s tongue concerning the mention of their gods.”
Ibn Hajar concedes the Dhahir supports my claim
Ibn Ḥajar (d. 852 AH) [link]
*“*Once that has been established (that it happened), it becomes necessary to reinterpret what is objectionable in these reports, namely the statement that Satan cast upon his tongue, ‘Those are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is indeed hoped for.’ For this cannot be understood according to its apparent meaning.”
There are so much from the khalaf who affirm it I will save the time and Show a few big athari/Ashari imams affirm it: Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728AH), Taj Al-Din Subki (d.771 AH), Sayf ad din Al-Āmidī (d. 631 AH)
We will begin with ibn Taymiyah ⬇️
Ibn taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [191–192/15]
since tamannī must necessarily include speech, then there are two views concerning it.
The first is that the casting occurred in the hearing of the listeners, while the Messenger did not himself utter it.This is the view of those who interpreted the verse in such a way as to deny the permissibility of anything being cast into his speech.[not His position]
The second and this is the position of the generality of the Salaf and those who followed them is that the casting occurred in the recitation itself, as is indicated by the verse and its context in more than one respect and as is reported in the multiple transmitted reports.[From salaf] There is nothing objectionable in this unless it is allowed to remain. But if Allah abrogates what Satan casts and then establishes His verses, there is nothing objectionable in it.”….[his position]
Those who denied that Satan’s insertion could occur during his conveying of revelation did so in order to escape this difficulty…. However, it is said to them: Satan cast something, and then Allah made His verses firm. Therefore, there is nothing objectionable about this.….. This resembles abrogation in certain respects, as experienced by those to whom commands and prohibitions have been conveyed….. This is a sound explanation, agreeing with the apparent meaning of the verse and with the other fundamental principles established by the Qurʾān and the Hadiths.
This should make his position very clear
Tāj al-Dīn al-Subkī (d. 771 AH) [278/6]
“A saint should not imagine that he will escape Satan’s deception while living in this world. Even prophets do not escape it, to the extent that the words ‘These are the exalted cranes, and their intercession is to be hoped for’ were caused to occur upon his tongue*. However, a prophet is not allowed to persist in error.”*
Sayf ad din Al-Āmidī (d. 631 AH) [4/200]
“The answer is that tamannī here means recitation, for three reasons:
First: The occasion for which the verse was revealed, namely what was heard of his statement*, ‘Those are with Allah among the exalted cranes.’ This occurred during recitation, not as an inward wish.”*
Refuting that Ibn Taymiyah claimed it was fabricated ⬇️
#Claim 1
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [409–410/2]
according to what is well known from the Salaf and the Khalaf, that this passed upon his tongue, after which Allah abrogated it and nullified it this is, according to the position of these people, among the greatest fabrications.”
Refutation ⬇️
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [403–410/2]
“Commentary on his(Ibn al-Muṭahhar) statement that “this destroys confidence and causes people to be repelled.”
This is clearly a response to Ibn al-Muṭahhar and the like who reject this. Not him saying that he himself believed it’s fabricated
⬆️ further proof he wasn’t saying the salaf “said it’s fabricated “
Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728 AH) [291/10]
“But can something occur which Allah then corrects so that Allah abrogates what Satan casts and then makes His verses firm? On this there are two views. And what is transmitted from the Salaf concerning this agrees with the Qurʾān.
Refuting ibn taymiyah Had doubt⬇️
Claim: ibn Taymiyah used إذَا كَانَ صَحِيحًا which indicates he didn’t know if it was authentic
Ibn Taymiyyah [link]
“As for what has been mentioned concerning the tamannī, if it is authentic*, then it was the reason they agreed to join him in prostrating to Allah.”*
Refutation ⬇️ the if (إذا) doesn’t necessitate doubt according to himself
“Conditionality does not necessarily entail doubt. Rather, this depends upon the speaker’s knowledge: sometimes he is doubtful, and sometimes he is not doubtful.”
[link]
Story isn’t baseless ⬇️
Jalāl al-Dīn al-Suyūṭī (d. 911 AH) [link]
“No consideration is given to the statement of Ibn al-ʿArabī and qadi ʿIyāḍ that these narrations are invalid and baseless.
Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī (d. 852 AH) [Fatḥ al-Bārī, 8/439]
“Abū Bakr ibn al-ʿArabī boldly stated, as was his habit, that al-Ṭabarī related numerous baseless and invalid reports concerning this. This sweeping assertion is rejected.”
Contemporary imam affirms it⬇️
Shaykh ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz ibn Rayyis al-Rayyis [link]
*“*Among the evidence for the authenticity of the story from the perspective of transmission is that it was narrated through mursal routes, and the Tābiʿūn who transmitted it as mursal were from different regions. Among those who transmitted the story as mursal were Abū al-ʿĀliyah and Qatādah, both from Basra; Saʿīd ibn Jubayr, from Kufa; and Abū Bakr ibn ʿAbd al-Raḥmān, from Medina.”… These mursal reports are numerous, their transmitters belonged to different regions, and their chains are authentic up to those who transmitted them as mursal. Therefore, the story is authentic and Allah knows best.
Khalaf who affirmed 2.0
Hibat Allāh ibn Salāmah (d. 410 AH) [link]
Al-Thaʿlabī (d. 427 AH) [link]
Makkī ibn Abī Ṭālib (d. 437 AH)[link]
Ibn Baṭṭāl al-Qurṭubī (d. 449 AH) [link]
al-Wāḥidī’ (d.468 AH) [link]
al-Samʿānī (d. 489 AH) [link]
Al-Zamakhsharī (d. 538 AH) [link]
Najm al-Dīn al-Ṭūfī (d. 716 AH) [link]
Al-Maḥallī and al-Suyūṭī (d. 864 AH and 911 AH) [link]
Muslims will run to the route of musa ibn uqbah To say “ the prophet never said it” but we will refute this too
Ibn Kathīr’s Tafsīr, [5/442 – 443]
ثم قال ابن أبي حاتم: حدثنا موسى بن أبي موسى الكوفي، حدثنا محمد بن إسحاق المُسَيَّبِي، حدثنا محمد بن فُلَيْح، عن موسى بن عقبة، عن ابن شهاب
Ibn Abī Ḥātim → Mūsā ibn Abī Mūsā al-Kūfī → Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq al-Musayyabī → Muḥammad ibn Fulayḥ → Mūsā ibn ʿUqbah → Ibn Shihāb al-Zuhrī
Response⬇️
Ibn ʿAbd al-Barr (d. 463 AH) – al-Istīʿāb fī Maʿrifat al-Aṣḥāb, [8/119]
“Mūsā ibn ʿUqbah is not an authority in his narrations from Ibn Shihāb when someone else contradicts him.”
Aḥmad ibn Ṣāliḥ al-Miṣrī (d. 248 AH)
Ibn Abī Ḥātim, al-Jarḥ wa-l-Taʿdīl, [9/249]
‘“We do not give anyone precedence over Yūnus concerning al-Zuhrī.’”
Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal (d. 241 AH) Al-Mizzī, Tahdhīb al-Kamāl, [1/343]
*“I asked Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal: ‘Who are the most knowledgeable people concerning the hadith of Ibn Shihāb al-Zuhrī?’ He replied: ‘*Aḥmad ibn Ṣāliḥ al-Miṣrī.”
Narration in Bayhaqi response⬇️*** (musa ibn uqbah***)
Dalāʾil al-Nubuwwah, [2/285 – 287]
Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways
Yaḥyā ibn Maʿīn (d.233 AH) [816/1]
He mixes things up, he lies, and he is nothing
Turning the table ⬇️
A Muslim might say not a authentic route from a companion came so we don’t have to accept it
Refutation
Surah 17:79
so your Lord may raise you to a station of praise
Mujāhid:
«يجلسه معه على عرشه»
“He seats him with Him upon His Throne.”
Ibn Taymiyyah Darʾ Taʿāruḍ al-ʿAql wa-l-Naql [237/5]
“Some transmitted it through numerous prophetic routes; all are fabricated.” What is established is only that it comes from Mujāhid and other early authorities. The early salaf used to narrate it without rejecting it and received it with acceptance.”
Clearly the salaf accepted narrations that are mursal
The clear Lie of Albani appealing to ibn taymiyah that The prophet didn’t say it
Al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) – Naṣb al-Majānīq li-Nasf Qiṣṣat al-Gharānīq, [p. 63, footnote 1]
“After writing the preceding discussion, I saw that Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah inclined towards affirming the story to the extent mentioned*…. **and that* the statement, ‘Those are the exalted gharānīq …’, was not pronounced by the Messenger of Allah, but rather Satan cast it into their hearing. Refer to his words in al-Fatāwā (2/282).”**
If we look at his majmu he brought two views and agreed with the second that it happened on Prophet tongue ⬆️(which I’ve already posted)
The second and this is the position of the generality of the Salaf and those who followed them is that the casting occurred in the recitation itself, as is indicated by the verse and its context in more than one respect and as is reported in the multiple transmitted reports.
Albani concedes That nobody preceded him in weakening the marasil because it was ‘possibly weak’
al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) [p. 44–45]
it is possible that each of the two or more intermediaries is weak. And with these possibilities present, using the mursal ḥadīth as authoritative evidence becomes invalid, even if its transmission routes are numerous. This is an analysis for which I have not found anyone who preceded me.
Ironic coming from Albani When he says We go off what’s more probable than ‘mere possibility’
al-Albani [link]
The door to raising objections, I mean to say, is wide open. However, scholarly investigation requires a person to follow what is most probable.
What other way to end it but with the Imam himself Albani tell you it falsifies Islam⬇️
al-Albānī (d. 1420 AH) [Link]
*وأوضح مثال وأقوى مثال على ما نقول هو حديث قصة الغرانيق، وكلُّكم يعلم قصة الغرانيق التي القول بها يؤدِّي إلى الشك بكل حديث رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم، بل وبقرآنه *الذي
“The clearest and strongest example of what we are saying is the narration of the gharānīq incident. All of you know the gharānīq story, belief in which leads to doubting every ḥadīth of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, and indeed even the Qurʾān that Allah revealed to him.”