I know people have been complaining about this for years, but with Season 7 approaching, I wanted to raise the topic again. Are there any plans to actually address the balance between Gemini, MKII, Defender and Hawkeye?
I love Engineer, but it seems ridiculous that one of his most iconic abilities has such an overwhelmingly dominant build after all these years.
I've been running some sandbox tests on Haz 5, spawning enemies at fixed distances and letting them charge through a line defended by the turrets. I wanted to look at actual ammunition efficiency and the ability to stop enemies, rather than just comparing theoretical total damage.
Some results:
Against a single Haz 5 Grunt Guard, four trials per configuration, all targets killed:
ConfigurationAverage ammo usedMKII Defender + Armor Breaking22Gemini Defender + Armor Breaking28.25MKII Defender + Stun28.25Gemini Defender + Stun35
That's combined ammunition consumption for BOTH Gemini turrets.
So MKII is indeed more ammunition-efficient, using roughly 20–22% fewer bullets. Sounds pretty good, right?
Except Gemini gets 90 additional rounds of ammunition, largely compensating for that advantage. And here's the much bigger problem:
Gemini has almost twice the damage output against a single target, because both guns can fire simultaneously.
Both configurations use the same seven-shot burst mechanics. Gemini can send 14 rounds downrange while MKII fires seven, and MKII's pathetic +2 damage per shot doesn't come close to making up for that.
MKII gets an additional five meters of range with Defender. Against a charging Guard, that's approximately 1.6 seconds of additional engagement time. Meanwhile, Gemini can finish a Guard substantially faster, even though it spends more ammunition doing so.
And that's before considering actual target acquisition. In my tests, Defender sometimes seemed surprisingly slow to start shooting, so the extra range didn't always translate into much additional firing time.
I also tested waves of five ordinary Grunts. Across my runs with different approach distances:
Gemini Defender + Armor Breaking stopped 36/40 Grunts.
MKII Defender + Armor Breaking stopped 34/45.
Gemini Defender + Stun stopped 39/40.
MKII Defender + Stun stopped 27/45.
Obviously these aren't laboratory-grade tests, and positioning and targeting RNG matter. But the difference is pretty striking.
And Hawkeye? God, I want to love Hawkeye.
The concept is fantastic. MKII Hawkeye in huge open caves is genuinely useful. It automatically clears Cave Leeches, shoots ceiling threats you haven't even noticed, picks off distant enemies, and effectively serves as an early-warning system.
I absolutely love that utility.
But as actual point defence on Haz 5? It's fucking awful. Watching five ordinary Grunts chew through almost half a turret's loaded ammunition is just ridiculous, lmao.
You sacrifice an enormous amount of damage for range and targeting capabilities. It can be a fantastic ceiling-cleaning utility, but it struggles to perform the turret's primary job.
And before someone says "but MKII is easier to manage":
Yes, obviously deploying and maintaining two turrets takes more effort.
But why should the alternative be deliberately underpowered?
This game is full of weapons, upgrades and overclocks that can be used effectively at high difficulty. We don't need a noob-friendly crutch that starts biting you in the ass when you play Haz 5.
Accessibility and ease of use are perfectly legitimate design goals. But they aren't excuses for having an upgrade that's just worse in most meaningful combat situations.
MKII is physically bigger, supposedly more powerful, and yet it only gets a tiny damage increase over ONE of the two Gemini turrets. It should feel like a genuinely powerful alternative, not just Gemini with one gun missing.
I'm not asking to nerf Gemini. I'm asking to make the alternatives worth choosing.
And it doesn't even have to be more damage!
If Ghost Ship is worried about raw damage or ammo efficiency, there are plenty of other possibilities:
Give MKII blowthrough rounds.
Let MKII fire continuously instead of using short bursts with long pauses.
Give it substantially better firing mechanics or target acquisition.
Rework Hawkeye so its utility doesn't come at such an enormous cost to combat effectiveness.
These are just ideas, not carefully balanced proposals. I'm sure the developers can come up with something better.
But please, give these upgrades distinct, useful identities.
Engineer is one of only four classes, and his turrets are arguably his most recognizable class-defining ability. Having so little meaningful build diversity for them is disappointing, especially considering how many years the game has been around.
I understand that Gemini is supposed to reward additional setup and maintenance. But those considerations shouldn't automatically outweigh nearly every combat advantage MKII could have.
Has Ghost Ship ever discussed revisiting this balance, or testing these options against actual Haz 5 enemy compositions? Is anything planned for Season 7 or beyond?
I'd genuinely like to hear from people who regularly run MKII or Hawkeye on Haz 5, particularly if you've found advantages I'm overlooking.
Rock and Stone.