I think religion should be banned from public life in this country. That means churches, mosques, temples, public worship services, preaching in public, and religious displays on public property. Every building and piece of land outside of a private home that gets used for religion would be turned into something that serves the whole community instead of one congregation. Nobody gets hurt in this. No violence of any kind, nobody gets locked up, nobody loses food, shelter, or medical care, and anyone can believe whatever they want and pray in their own home as much as they want. I know this would take a constitutional amendment and isn't legal right now. My question is whether it should be.
My reasoning is pretty simple. Religion doesn't stay in people's homes. It goes into the voting booth, into the statehouse, and into laws that everybody has to live under, including people who don't share that religion, and those laws rest on claims that can't be tested or proven.
The clearest examples are places where religion runs the law. In Iran, a 22 year old woman named Mahsa Amini died in 2022 after the morality police arrested her for supposedly not wearing her hijab the way the government required. This year Iran has executed dozens of people over the January protests, often on a charge called moharebeh, which means waging war against God. In Saudi Arabia blogger Raif Badawi was sentenced to 10 years in prison and 1,000 lashes for insulting Islam on a website he created. In Afghanistan girls have been barred from school past sixth grade since 2021 and women from universities since 2022, and the Taliban justify it with their interpretation of Islamic law. Pew found 18 of the 20 countries in the Middle East and North Africa had laws making blasphemy a crime, and 13 outlawed leaving your religion.
9/11 is the most extreme case. In 1998 bin Laden issued a fatwa declaring it was God's decree that every Muslim should kill Americans, military or civilian, anywhere in the world. Three years later the attacks killed 2,977 people and kicked off a war on terror that lasted decades. The vast majority of Muslims reject that completely, but it shows what happens when a small group believes God has given them orders.
This happens in the US as well, in a milder form. Texas passed a law in 2025 requiring a state selected version of the Ten Commandments, drawn from the King James Bible, in every public school classroom, and a federal appeals court upheld it 9 to 8 in April. The posters have been going up in classrooms across a state with about 5.5 million students, and families challenging it have asked the Supreme Court to take the case. Texas also required every school board to vote on adding a daily period of prayer and Bible reading, and the senator who wrote that bill said there's no such thing as separation of church and state in the Constitution. Louisiana's Ten Commandments law was cleared to take effect this year.
The same thing is happening nationally. Trump signed an executive order in February 2025 creating a task force focused specifically on bias against Christians, and the White House Faith Office is led by televangelist Paula White. In 2025 the IRS said in a court filing that churches should be able to endorse candidates and keep their tax exemption (a judge rejected that deal this year, though the IRS has rarely enforced the rule anyway). The Southern Baptist Convention, the largest Protestant denomination in the country, passed a 2025 resolution calling for overturning the ruling that legalized same sex marriage, saying it goes against God's design for marriage. PRRI found about 3 in 10 Americans qualify as Christian nationalism adherents or sympathizers, and among Republicans it's 56 percent.
The example that bothers me most is in Idaho. Parents there who say their faith forbids lifesaving medical care for their children can't be charged with neglect or manslaughter. At least 15 babies and children from one faith healing sect died between 2015 and 2025 from illnesses doctors could have treated, like pneumonia and infections that turned into sepsis. In that case the law treats prayer as a substitute for medicine, and children have died because of it.
My main principle is about evidence. When a company wants to sell a new drug, it has to prove the drug works before anyone is allowed to use it. I think laws should be held to a similar standard. A law should need a reason that can be tested and that doesn't depend on accepting a particular religion as true. Religious claims can't meet that standard, so they shouldn't be shaping laws for people who don't believe them.
People say you can't ban something like this in a free society. A free society already limits plenty of things once they start affecting other people, though. You can smoke in your own house as much as you want, because it's your house and your lungs. Smoke in a restaurant and it ends up in everybody else's lungs, so a lot of cities and states banned smoking in public places, and nobody thinks that ended freedom. I see religion the same way. Practice it at home however you want, but once it moves into public life it ends up in other people's laws, their kids' classrooms, and their marriages.
The 2020 U.S. Religion Census counted about 357,000 congregations in the country. Under my plan, each of those buildings and the land under it would go to the local community and be used for something that serves everyone: schools, clinics, shelters, food banks, libraries, daycares, rec centers, affordable housing, or addiction recovery centers, depending on what the area needs. Places already running food pantries or shelters would keep running them without the religious part. Big buildings would be easy to convert. Lakewood Church in Houston is the old Compaq Center, the arena where the Rockets won two championships in the 90s, it seats 16,800 people, and the city sold it to the church for $7.5 million in 2010. It could go back to being a public arena or convention center. This kind of thing is already happening on its own. Lifeway Research estimates about 4,000 Protestant churches closed in 2024, and closed churches are being turned into affordable housing, community centers, and libraries.
On lawmaking, every law would need a basis in evidence and a reason that doesn't depend on religion. Questions that only come down to religious objections, like banning same sex marriage, wouldn't be allowed on a ballot. Questions where people disagree for secular reasons, like abortion, would still be voted on like normal.
On enforcement, I want nothing to do with what the Soviet Union did. Nobody gets arrested for praying, and everybody keeps their food, home, and medical care. If a group keeps holding public services anyway, they lose extra benefits like tax breaks and government grants, and that's the full extent of it.
The evidence I've seen points the same way. In the 2026 World Happiness Report, Finland ranked happiest for the ninth year in a row, and Nordic countries took five of the top six spots. In Gallup's 2009 world poll, only 17 percent of Swedes and 19 percent of Danes said religion was important in their daily lives. Gallup also found a median of 95 percent in the poorest countries said religion was important, compared to 47 percent in the richest. I know correlation isn't causation, but less religion keeps lining up with better lives.
So here's what I want to debate. Is there a way to keep religion out of the law that actually works, when a 9 to 8 court decision can put the Ten Commandments in every classroom in Texas? Would a ban like this do more harm than the problems I've described? Where do you draw the line between freedom of religion and freedom from it?