Watched camp rock 3 and wanted to share some of my thoughts. Will give my pros, ‘pros but’ (i.e. it was good but…) and cons and address the fan reactions I’ve seen.
Pros:
•Every main character has their strength – Sage is talented and committed, Desi too and secretly loves the camp, Fletch is someone trying to find his own way, Rosie and Cliff show how important instrumentalists are in the world of music and have their own good moments.
•After the main characters, I like Lark the most. A good manager who gives advice and insight, is committed to her role and shows that not everyone is made out for camp life (the bee and bite marks show some humour).
•The movie was able to have both charm (Camp Rock 1) and a plot with stakes and competition (Camp Rock 2).
•I liked the nostalgic callbacks – the backflips off the vehicles, “whatever major loser” and “She’s really good” being the best / most nostalgic for me.
\^ Also when Sage says camp rock is “exactly where I’m supposed to be”.
•I liked the vast majority of the songs. My personal favourites are one beat away, play my music and work in progress. Brand new day, it’s on and we rock were also used well. Every single final jam song was amazing and fitted the character well.
•I liked the comedy – Cliff’s joke about Rosie being scared of “cliffs” being a sign she likes him, Maddie being frustrated with her backup dancers and Sage seemingly going to tell off Cliff for playing his drumsticks but wanting him to guard the portable toilet stand out for me.
•For challenge #1, I like how the song showed the different performers.
•I like that Lark eliminated Maddie, Daniel and Danielle for stopping their dancing during challenge #2 saying the show must go on. Realistic for Lark.
•I like that the antagonist was defeated halfway through and their goal became revenge, more unexpected than pure ‘sabotage’ or the antagonist winning.
•Challenge #3 was both a great test of the finalists and a great way for them to bond (and therefore for Sage and Desi to reconcile).
•Nice use of Rosie’s cello in her final jam, showing that Maddie didn’t get to her.
‘Pro but’:
•I like Connie being the camp director but there should’ve been a brief explanation as to how. A camp as big and prestigious as camp rock would almost certainly require a music background for their directors / senior staff and Connie had none.
•I like one beat away but should’ve had more singers than just Sage (and briefly Desi).
•I like bringing back Mitchie’s journal but it makes no sense she’d leave it in the cabin when she left (her last summer). If you want it in the plot, have it be in Connie’s office.
•I like Cliff’s final jam song but the beatboxing came out of nowhere. Should’ve mentioned it in the earlier ‘confessions’ scene with Calvin Rhodes.
•I like the idea of Desi giving a speech before her final jam song praising her friends, but it shouldn’t have been pick them “instead of” me, it should’ve been pick them “with” me. It would’ve also better explained why the other finalists were performing with her.
•I like Desi’s final jam and the message of “work in progress” but she walked up next to Rosie, Desi and Fletch during the song but not Cliff. I understand that Rosie, Desi and Fletch are her bunkmate, brother and crush respectively but I don’t think she’d ignore Cliff.
•I like Mitchie’s message of all five finalists being better together but it’s undermined by her complimenting Sage specifically (“she’s really good”) and Sage being the only finalist to make eye contact with her at the end. It’s clear Mitchie considers Sage the best.
Cons:
•Not being filmed in the original setting(s). I could tell the difference, it’s just not the same as the original.
•Camp Star not being mentioned. Camp Rock 2 ended with camp star being the bigger camp. I understand that Axel only opened Camp Star to close down Camp Rock and probably gave up when Camp Rock stayed open but there should’ve been a line to address this.
•Connect #3 should’ve been more involved with the plot, being on-site to do the challenges. Maddie and Callie were also underutilised (Sage should’ve had more ‘confession’ scenes with Callie, like talking to her not Desi about revealing Fletch’s phone).
•The crush / relationship between Sage and Fletch happens WAY too fast.
•For challenge #1, about 70 students enter and 50 pass. For a manager with as high standards as Lark and a competition as serious as finding an opening act for Connect 3, this is an unrealistically high pass rate for effectively the application stage.
•Fletch and Desi had a very weird first interaction, Fletch angrily telling Desi “You telling me what to do?!” but then they laugh it off.
•The plot point involving Fletch and keeping his eyes closed during performances was underdeveloped. I didn’t even notice it during his final jam song and had forgotten about it.
•I didn’t like the ‘joke’ about Rosie holding Cliff’s nose to stop him snoring / breathing a “little”. It’s actually quite messed up if you think about it.
•I didn’t like the rhythm’s only right song (the song where Sage and Desi reconcile). It feels too similar to wouldn’t change a thing from camp rock 2 but definitely isn’t as good.
•How did Connie and Lark not know who shared the video clip at first but then figured out it was Maddie within 24 hours? Should be one of two extremes, you know who it is immediately or it takes you time to figure out.
•Lots of unresolved / unaddressed relationships. Three main ones:
- Desi and Callie.
- Rosie and Cliff.
- Mitchie and Shane – are they still dating?
•Lots of ‘contradictory’ / ‘zig-zagging’ plot points. Three main ones:
- At least twice, it’s stated that Sage and Desi’s band broke up when she went to Anthem, but at least twice Desi refers to the band in the present tense (i.e. still active).
- Rosie smiles when Cliff throws the paste on Maddie, then in front of Lark says that Cliff started it and she didn’t ask him to defend her (honour), then says to Cliff they’re definitely friends because he did it.
- Sage doesn’t believe that Fletch shared the clip when Connie first accuses him of it, but then says to Desi that he might have, then says to Fletch that she knows he didn’t.
When I looked at the fan’s reactions to camp rock 3, I saw four main criticisms:
- The music being ‘overproduced’ – I personally disagree with this being a criticism. I understand why some might not like this but I don’t mind putting in the higher quality tuning and choreography.
- The main antagonist, Maddie, being not really relevant to the plot and overall not developed and underutilised. I agree, especially since she had potential to be different than Tess (she let her backup dancers be part of her challenge #1 performance showing she understood more than Tess about the importance of using the talent of your group) but she only had a few scenes, and her main ‘act’ of filming the bus challenge was undone after about 3 scenes when it was traced back to her account.
\^ Should there be a Camp Rock 4 with the same characters as Camp Rock 3 (which I think there could be), Maddie needs to be far more antagonistic or there needs to be another antagonist who comes and Maddie’s redemption arc can be her standing up to this new antagonist.
3. Sage throwing Fletch under the bus and his being ok with it. I’m 50:50 on Sage because I understand there’s pressure to win and not wanting to be punished for something you didn’t do, but the issue is with only one movie we don’t know how much her ‘motives’ really mean to her – with the originals we had Camp Rock 1 to show us how much Mitchie loved camp before Camp Rock 2 showed how desperate she was to save it.
I disagree with Fletch though. I get his reaction – he was shocked with Sage at first, forgave her after it was made clear he suffered no punishment as Maddie was caught and he lost his mother that year – losing someone makes you realise how valuable the people in your life really are and you don’t want to lose anyone else.
4. Not enough time to develop too many plot-points. Definitely agree. Maddie’s character especially suffers from this.
Overall, Camp Rock 3 isn’t a perfect movie but it is fun, has lot of good moments and I don’t think it deserves some of the criticism I’ve seen. In comparison to the first two films, it is unfortunately weaker – very good ideas and potential but has too many flaws in execution, mostly due to spreading too thin across too many plotlines.
What does everyone else think?