r/DoctorsIreland • u/LabourUnited • 5h ago
Damning new literature review exposes the patient safety risks and false economy of replacing doctors with mid-levels
A scathing new literature review in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine has challenged the international drive to replace doctors with mid-level practitioners, exposing serious concerns about patient safety, diagnostic competence and the supposed financial savings.
Authored by Dr Jatinder Hayre, medical doctor and public health researcher at the University of Leicester, the review examines international evidence on doctor substitution. In the UK, these roles are discussed under the term Advanced Clinical Practitioners (ACPs), alongside comparable mid-level roles internationally.
The findings are damning:
- 56.2% of mid-level referrals were deemed unnecessary in one study, compared with 30.1% from doctors.
- Opioid overprescribing indicators were more than twice as prevalent among nurse practitioners than physicians in another study.
- Doctor-led teams cost approximately $617 less per discharge in one American hospital comparison.
- Robust evidence of equivalent patient safety and cost-effectiveness remains conspicuously inadequate.
The University of Leicester's accompanying press release goes further, highlighting Dr Hayre's call for an immediate halt to ACP recruitment and an urgent reassessment of their expansion.
How much does a cheaper clinician really save when unnecessary investigations, referrals and missed diagnoses enter the equation?
The implications extend far beyond Britain's NHS.
Patients should not be guinea pigs in an inadequately evidenced international experiment in cheapening medical care.
Literature review: https://doi.org/10.1177/01410768261501746
University press release: https://le.ac.uk/news/2026/november/advanced-practitioners-doctors-replacement-study