r/DreamWorks • u/Crescentbrush • 14h ago
Discussion I continue to consider what if Dreamworks did more films like "The Prince of Egypt"
i.pinimg.comI don't mean purely biblical stories, but what if their filmography was mostly made of dramatic, emotional epics (maybe more original musicals, because Disney doesn't need to be the only one). I enjoy hypotheticals like this. Of course, this comes with pros and cons:
- Dreamworks probably would've struggled. Creatives (notably Roger Allers pertaining to Sony and Michael Reece pertaining to Disney) have mentioned how the 2000s leaned more into comedy, thus why animation generally veered that way, especially when more dramatic films didn't do as well. If Disney kept pushing, they'd likely have gone into the red for a while, maybe even being acquired, but perhaps bouncing back in the 2010s as people get tired of more comedic films.
- Fairy tales/fantasy would've been adapted differently. While the late 20th century started the whole cynicism/self-awareness of magical concepts, "Shrek" created a legacy (both good and bad) for fairy tales to now be more referential, more cynical, and less immersive as a result. Like I said, these tropes existed before "Shrek," but if it hadn't been made (or if it was less humorous), films like "Happily N'ever After," "Hoodwinked," "Enchanted," "Tangled," and "Steps" would've likely approached fairy tales differently, possibly without subversion. This is good or bad, depending on how you view meta fairy tale films.
- Maybe more male-led musicals? Given that Disney is the only primary female-led studio, it's quite possible that if Dreamworks made more original musicals, they'd still want to keep a male focus. Perhaps this would send the idea that male leads for musicals is profitable (in film).
- We'd have stronger competition--MAYBE. If point #1 doesn't happen and Dreamworks epics are successful, they'd probably be very LAIKA-esque, perhaps spurring Sony to get serious earlier, keeping Pixar on their toes (with Pete Doctor never making that "we don't make millions of dollars of therapy" quote), and Disney management viewing their products differently during the revival era.
- Creative brain drain (for other companies)--In the events that other companies still work as they do in the OTL, I could see Roger Allers going there with his "Tam Lin" idea and Brenda Chapman (who was a director for TPOE) going to them with "Brave" since it felt too foreign to Pixar (assuming the Dreamworks epics are more medieval). Stephen Schwartz would probably work on more projects, and maybe Alan Menken goes over as well. Maybe this pushes Disney to make "Aida" an animated film instead of a Broadway film--specifically to compete with/spite "The Prince of Egypt" (unlikely given the production for both films was around the same time anyway, but I can dream).
- Disney 2.0--It's extremely likely that if Dreamworks keeps making films like TPOE, they'd be seen as a second Disney or the superior Disney (depending on the commenter), and likely their fanbases intersect. However, this may mean their styles are also more similar, perhaps with less modern stories from Dreamworks--which I guess COULD be seen as unique since LAIKA, Illumination, and Pixar all do modern films while Disney jumps back and forth. Though Dreamworks may have some original films simply to keep with the setting (a lot of people forget a lot of Dreamworks films are based on a property), and may be more creative. For example, if they keep the high fantasy stuff, "Forgotten Island" may feel like a 90s Disney film set in pre-colonial Philippines (this isn't a dig at the movie; just a hypothetical).
