r/DungeonMasters • u/allusivepoet • 2h ago
Arabian Nights-style homebrew in Calimport for six first-time players. What do you think of the story? (Acts I and II, full spoilers) Spoiler
If you sail on a ship called La Rondine and drink tea at dawn with a merchant named Zahra, please stop reading here.
I'm running a homebrew 5e (2014) campaign for six players who had never played D&D before. It's called The Nights of Calimport, set in Calimport in 1490 DR, and the models are the Arabian Nights, the Decameron and the 90s Sinbad TV show. 5e says very little about Calimshan after the Sundering, so I lean on the 2e books (Empires of the Shining Sea, Calimport) and homebrew the rest. We've played a prologue at sea and the first two chapters, and the party is level 3. Acts I and II are written and Act III isn't, so there's still time to change things.
**The frame.** The PCs work for Zahra, a rich merchant. Every chapter opens at dawn in her courtyard, over tea. The party is just back from a job, she asks how it went, and we play the job as a flashback. At the tea she always asks the same three questions, and the third is "What did you keep to yourselves?"
**What's really going on.** An efreeti prince, Sahruq, has been chained under the city for thousands of years. Nine seals hold him: blood, lamp, pearl, song, key, flame, name, crown, door. Zahra is the blood seal. In her family the eldest daughter renews it with her own life, and she is sick and has no heir. Every night the prisoner tells her a story in her dreams. She strips out the temptation hidden in it and turns the rest into a job, so the party is following leads that come from the very thing they're guarding. The villain is the Grand Vizier, who wrote the city's anti-genasi laws under the slogan "never again slaves of the genies". He doesn't want to free the prince. He wants to break the seals and reforge them into a single leash, held by him. Through middlemen he funds a fire cult, the Ember Hand, whose members are sincere and have no idea who pays them.
**Act I (levels 1-5, five chapters).** Self-contained stories, one seal each, though the players don't know that yet. A brass lamp stolen on the docks that must never be lit. A lighthouse kept by monks of Ilmater on an island no chart shows. A tomb that sings under the dunes, with a sphinx inside. A midnight market where a dao holds a key in pawn. Meanwhile the city gets darker: new edicts, harbor fires that burn blue, arson blamed on the genasi. On the fifth night the cult attacks Zahra's house, and in the rubble she tells the party about the prince. They stop being mercenaries and become Keepers.
**Act II (levels 5-8, seven chapters).** The jobs get longer and start to connect. The party sails to a marid who has forgotten why he guards a pearl, and finds out the enemy already knew their route, so there's a spy in the house (Zahra's scribe, blackmailed over a brother in prison). They escort twelve genasi families out of a city that wants scapegoats. Then comes a two-chapter dungeon in the Muzad, the buried city under Calimport, home of the Qandil, descendants of runaway slaves who keep the lamps of the dead burning. Their law says that whoever comes down with a light in hand is a guest, and whoever comes down in the dark is a thief.
Down there a cult ritual makes a vein of black amber "sing" (it's the resin the prince's fire leaves when it seeps through rock), and the PCs' souls swap bodies until sunrise. At the table the players swap character sheets. Each one gets a card with three ready-made moves and a folded note with something that body knows. They fight like that, and they explore a flooded archive where the prince's true name is carved backwards and can only be read in the water's reflection. It can't be copied, so one PC has to carry it in memory. In the same archive they learn that Zahra is a seal and that the stories come from the prisoner. When the souls go back, there are seven shadows on the wall instead of six. The seventh is a qarin, the spirit double of Arab folklore, made of everything the party answered (or didn't) to "What did you keep to yourselves?" It looks like a threat at first, but it isn't an enemy. It says out loud what they keep quiet.
The act ends with a palace heist for the Crown of Ash, where the party finally sees the Vizier's face, and then with the fall. Zahra is publicly accused of genie sorcery and the pasha's elite guard comes for the house on flying carpets. The fight can't be won, only held long enough to get out. Zahra gives herself up to buy that time and the party escapes through the cistern into the Muzad. They end up outlaws with a bounty on their heads, guests of the Qandil, one month before the Vizier's ritual.
What I'd like to hear from you:
What do you think of the story? Plot holes, clichés, things you'd cut or change, anything goes.
I have two worries. One is that "the patron hands out the jobs" turns into a railroad. The other is that Act II puts too much on the plate for people in their first campaign. Are they justified?
Have you run or played a campaign in a similar setting (Calimshan, Al-Qadim, anything with an Arabian Nights flavor)? What worked at your table, and what would you avoid?
Thanks to anyone who made it this far.
