TL;DR – my deleted L5P smokes and stinks and nobody can seem to figure out why.
I’ve posted in a few other subs with no luck so far, so here goes.
The truck: 2021 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali, 6.6L L5P.
Pre-delete: After the warranty ran out I put a shift on the fly tuner from Calibrated Power on it. I ran that on an otherwise stock truck from about 75K to 180K miles without any issues. I later learned that tune wasn’t letting the truck regen like it should, so that could be part of the puzzle.
The delete: Around 180K I did a full delete: cats, EGR, downpipe, the works, with a 4" exhaust. The ECM was flashed and tuned by DieselR. My first mistake was letting a friend’s son do it. he has a professional shop, but he’s young and a little inexperienced. he had enough history that i figured i’d let him do it.
First sign of trouble: About 2 hours into the drive home I stopped for fuel. i usually leave it running while i pump, and i saw big plumes of blue/white smoke coming out of the exhaust. I texted him and he said that was just soot burning off because the truck hadn’t regen’d in so long (see the Calibrated Power issue above). I didn’t love that answer, but I drive a lot so I figured it would clear up. it never did.
Shop #1 (the installer): A couple weeks later I took it back to him. after three weeks he still couldn’t fix it, and he blamed a turbo leaking oil. i didn’t buy that, so i picked it up.
Shop #2 (bona fide diesel mechanic): He had it for almost a month, mostly because DieselR is spread too thin in my area and kept missing appointments at the shop. Great mechanic. He also thought it was the turbo, and even though I didn’t agree I told him to go for it. He put in a refurb turbo, and lo and behold, it didn’t fix anything. Next he wanted to do a compression test for the head gasket. i passed on that. He was pissed he couldn't figure it out and didn't charge me a dime because "[I] didn't fix anything."
Shop #3 (mechanic I’ve known for ages): He scoped everything and said there’s no way it’s a head gasket because none of the symptoms point that way.
Shop #4 (local delete guy with great reviews): He got me in within a week and found:
+ NOx sensor that still had power going to it and hadn’t been deleted
+ DEF injector that also still had power and hadn’t been deleted
+ low DEF warning on the cluster that nobody else, including DieselR, had been able to clear. he cleared it.
He also floated turbo/head gasket at first, but after I gave him the full history he suggested putting his own tune on in case DieselR had left some glitch behind. that’s installed now, and I still have the smoke and the noxious smell. it’s not black and it’s not white, more of a blue/grey. he’s scratching his head too and thinks it might be a bad muffler (no idea what the first guy put on, could’ve been used) or back pressure from the 4" pipe.
Here’s the kicker: if i’m idling in park with my foot OFF the brake, it smokes like a freight train. when i put my foot on the brake, the engine audibly changes pitch and the smoke stops. take my foot off and it starts smoking again.
My theory: something got missed in the tune, or in how the TCU talks to the ECU. i’m no mechanic and i’m no tuner, but it really feels like it’s running way too rich at idle.
Hoping someone here has seen this before and knows the fix, or can point me somewhere besides the usual turbo/head gasket diagnosis.