r/EU5 • • 19h ago

Discussion In order for EU5 to be great (it is a very good game now, but not yet great), frustrating things must be resolved

1 Upvotes

I just had a frustrating situation when I declared war on Tunisia, but was unexpectedly blocked from doing anything. I had a border with them (their vassal to be correct), we were only bordering in 1 location, since the south of that location was dessert, so impassable terrain. I had a parliament approved CB, so I declared war on them. But, their vassal, who I was directly bordering, didn't join, despite me believing vassals joined automatically. I tried getting or buying access, but since they were vassals of my enemy, they absolutely refused. My fleet was much weaker, I couldn't invade from the sea, so my army just sat there, 1 location away from my enemy, but not being able to cross. I then had an idea, to build a spy network and declare war on the vassal. I had to build a spy network on Tunisians, since they were the overlord, so I did that. And then I created a CB on the vassal. And when I tried declaring war on them, I was blocked because I was already at war with the overlord! Meanwhile, warscore was ticking in the enemy's favor, and I couldn't do anything about it. Luckily, that vassal had its capital far away, so when I threatened the war for that location, they just gave it to me, allowing me to continue a war I considered easy but had a nasty surprise instead.

Some time later, when I got a new CB on them, I tried declaring a war, but couldn't, because some rebels had more than 95% progress. The rebellion couldn't start because I was already in another insignificant war that I couldn't end instantly, so I had to wait for my ally to end that war, so that the rebellion could start, so I could declare war, but by that time my parliament CB just expired.

I know Paradox resolved COUNTLESS frustrating issues in the last 12 months, and I salute it, but there are other things like this that just ruin the fun, since we as players don't have control over these frustrating things. There was the issue with rebellions in vassal lands that the vassals lost, and the players couldn't do anything despite being more than able to stop it. It was very frustrating, but thankfully, it is now resolved, so thank you, Paradox. State and country disaster was very annoying, now it is A LOT more manageable, and even fun to some extent. A lot was solved and improved, and the game needs to continue improving, since there are still many posts of angry players who had a frustrating situation happen to them. I am certain that in a couple of years EU5 will be considered a great game without stupid frustrations.


r/EU5 • • 1h ago

Discussion I'm so glad the hourly ticks are back again and with a game rule!!

12 Upvotes

So players who like hourly can switch to that or they can switch to daily whatever they want to play with. It's good that we have choices now. So what will you choose??


r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Image The balkanization of France by PDX

Post image
46 Upvotes

It's only 1344, and France has already basically ceased to exist, having turned into a 1344 version of Ex-Yugoslavia. They attacked me (England), and I easily beat them, destroying 70% of their army and creating vassals. Then, France went through 3 independence wars, and 2 more wars, all between 1340 and 1344. Why have the devs destroyed France so much? Why are other countries such as Bohemia or Kiev so strong when they shouldn't be historically?


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Discussion Market Access Buildings not working due to no market access is very annoying

5 Upvotes

Had a recent run where I managed to establish a giant market in North America (Forming Pubelo), doing my own thing spamming out market access buildings. Only to note in the 1800's that vast swaths of my territory was just not doing anything because despite having upwards of 7-8 Market Villages or Market places their buildings just weren't operating because they had no market access. For context this market spanned the entire Western border of the USA, so pretty damn huge.

It really feels like Market Access just falls off a cliff way too fast despite the infrastructure you build, punishing huge markets way too much. It was really annoying when I looked around and notices that nearly half my empire was running on < 10% access or just being completely shut out of the market despite being linked by railroads.


r/EU5 • • 23h ago

Suggestion Region, Ruling Culture, and National Idea Modifiers to Add Flavour

0 Upvotes

The current game struggles a little bit, because most countries feel the same and have a very similar gameplay loop. This could be remedied by adding modifiers based on geographical regions, the ruling culture, and a national ideas system.

Region Modifiers
Like in Victoria 3, each region has a set of small buffs and debuffs to production outputs for certain goods. In some cases there could also be a small effect on other metrics like population growth, artist ability, literacy, or conditions in combat.

Elite Culture Modifiers
Each culture would have a balanced set of small modifiers based on what the culture was known for historically. I would only have these modifiers apply for the official primary culture, and then maybe also the culture of the nobility and merchants.

I don't think this is too outlandish. It was common sense for most of history to assume that a French king and court would rule an area a little differently than if they were Italian or Russian. Also, many European countries had merchant classes that were a different culture and people noted that this had an effect.

National Ideas
The last part would be to add a sort of National Ideas system. This is how the educated classes consciously understand themselves and what they view to be the purpose/goals of the country. These would also add modifiers.

We already have the reform and privilege system. This is good, but it is not the same as an abstract national identity or mission. It's a different layer.

Thus, the output of a country would depend on its geography, the culture of the ruling classes, and the system of ideas they use to understand themselves and the purpose of their state. Then also of course, it's buildings and technology.

I think this is very realistic.

The modifiers alone would be small, but they would add up. By the end of the game each country would have a distinct character with unique strengths and weaknesses.


r/EU5 • • 47m ago

Discussion what even is this

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

How am I suposed to fight 1 milion of troops in god damn 1500s?! not only bohemia can easily spam tons of alliances, but also additional half of Europe decides they have to join this fucking war. And I don't care if this is historicaly accurate, this is just unfun.


r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Suggestion Improved non-primary supported culture interaction

4 Upvotes

I've been playing Connaught into Ireland into Celtica, which has been a very fun playthrough, but having just taken Cornwall, Wales, and parts of Scotland, I have discovered that it is impossible for me to push those cultures in their home regions, not via the cabinet action or releasing as subjects. I can't even use console commands to mass convert the pops.

I figure that mechanics designed to improve the interactions with non-primary cultures in this region could be applied generically to all playables to have the opportunity for more interesting interaction.

I suppose I can use console commands to merge or create a "Celtic" culture which I push, but it's just a big disappointment, and there's no guarantee it'll have the evocative and painstaking language names (I noticed tiles in Wales have different English, Irish, and welsh names for example). Really hoping this can get a pass with the Auld Alliance update, even simple additions like being able to pick which of your accepted cultures you're enforcing on a subject, boost cultural influence or tradition of non-primary cultures, or to direct subjects to take particular action (such as converting culture, religion, or annexing their own subjects as would be great for Wales).


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Question Is there a way to kill my bastard son so that i can impregnate his wife and steal the naples crown?

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 14h ago

Image Well this is an odd timeline

Post image
7 Upvotes

im not even sure how this happend


r/EU5 • • 16h ago

Discussion Why does Spain transport hundreds of thousands in gold via "Gold Fleet" expeditions, yet experience zero inflation?

76 Upvotes

By the year 1600, I already have over a million gold, and I literally have nowhere to spend it. This is just way too overpowered.

Every 5 years, I get about ~180k gold delivered to me.


r/EU5 • • 10h ago

Image Why does France have holdings in Russia in 1497?

Post image
88 Upvotes

This is my first playthrough.


r/EU5 • • 20h ago

Image Accidentally found the best Granada strategy

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

I initially was attacked multiple times by Castile and won each time, but only expanding by a few locations or just getting white peaces. Morocco never attacked me, but every time Castile was weak they invaded and started expanding.

Thing is, due to weak control Morocco keeps releasing their new Iberian possessions as vassals. Those vassals keep rebelling, and when a rebellion happens, I no-cb declare war on them and rush to full annex the rebellion before Morocco has time to react. Most of my expansion so far has happened like this.


r/EU5 • • 23h ago

Image Just came back to 1.4

Post image
117 Upvotes

This is my first playthrough in 1.4. What the fuck happened here, why is there Castile in Anatolia?


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Image The 'Grand Alliance' feature against Spain is a bit, uhhhhhhhh..... Intense?

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 18h ago

Question EU5 - Road Builder proximity source

2 Upvotes

Hey,
Is there a way in the Road Builder menu to calculate and build roads based on a specific local proximity source instead of the capital?

For example, say my capital is Constantinople, and I also have a Seljuk Mint in Sivas acting as a local proximity source. I want to plan and build roads using Sivas as the proximity source rather than calculating everything from Constantinople.

Right now, the sorting options in the Road Builder don't really work for this:

  • Sorting by proximity to the capital ignores Sivas as an origin.
  • Sorting by distance to location doesn't solve it either, because it only measures raw location distance from the target rather than actual proximity steps/pathing along existing roads from my local source. For example, if I already have a road from Sivas to Mosul, sorting by location distance just treats a province next to Mosul as "1 location away" from my target instead of calculating the real proximity path starting from Sivas.

Is there any setting or way to make the Road Builder calculate from a selected local proximity source, or do you have to work around it manually (e.g. using the proximity map mode and building segment by segment)?


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Question Aragon achievement help

3 Upvotes

I just tried to get the very hard achievement that Aragon got in the 1.4 patch. At first it was extremely easy. You get Sicily for free and Corsica and Sardinia were easily conquered as well. Naples was no problem as well as they focused their entire army in Epirus and I got them as well. Now I’m missing 0,42 % of land needed. How can I complete it? I don’t understand I even conquered Andorra??? I checked everywhere but I don’t have a single location which misses. I’m pretty lost please help me.


r/EU5 • • 20h ago

Suggestion Can we fix HRE Emperor policy AI?

8 Upvotes

In my games the AI emperor constantly tries (and succeeds) in passing policies such as figurehead emperor and rotating emperorship that kneecap its own power and imperial authority.

I’m astonished that this hasn’t been fixed yet. There should be a massive penalty to AI willingness to enact policies that are bad for itself.


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Question Can't get Gilt-Edged achivment. The game tells me I went bankrupt, even though I definitely didn't. Is this a bug? [1.4.9]

2 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Question What to do with disloyal vassals?

3 Upvotes

R5: so, doing a run as Castile. Fairing better than i have done before, but I conquered a small slither of Morocco and Tlemcen and I cannot keep them loyal. I released them as soon as I could due to zero control, but they keep rebelling


r/EU5 • • 23h ago

Question Should I max out food RGOs first?

18 Upvotes

I was wondering whether starting out it is worth building food RGOs first regardless of control now the pop growth mechanics are based on food surpluses in provinces. Depending on the starting market I think sometimes you have to invest in some food regardless (e.g. Barcelona always seems to run out of food). However, considering I generally invest in RGOs at the start anyway as they have no cost I wondered if it also makes sense to invest in food for the long-term pop growth. I'd assume the compound growth from the start would mean a far larger population by the Age of Discovery and later.

Asking out of interest btw, I will probably do this anyway depending on the country because I like the flavour.


r/EU5 • • 13m ago

Question EU5 1.4 – Sweden: Should I create a market in Copenhagen or stick with Lübeck?

2 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I've decided to play Sweden. And yes, despite the food supply issues in version 1.4!

I've just conquered most of Sjælland (Zealand), including Copenhagen. A real breadbasket, exactly what my Swedish kingdom needs!

The problem is that Stockholm's market doesn't reach the island. Instead, the whole area is connected to Lübeck's market, which I don't control.

And we all know how powerful Lübeck can be, especially with the Hanseatic League behind it!

Now I have two options:

  • Take advantage of Lübeck's existing market, which is already powerful and well established.
  • Create a new market in Copenhagen, bringing Danish agricultural production into a market under my own control.

I'm also currently in the process of annexing Norway, which means that eventually I'll have the Oslo market to consider as well.

My long-term goal is to unite Scandinavia and develop a strong economy, with food security being one of my main priorities.

So, with Stockholm, Copenhagen, and eventually Oslo in the picture, what would you guys do? Is Copenhagen worth its own market, or am I better off sticking with Lübeck?

I'm curious to hear your experiences with markets in EU5 1.4!


r/EU5 • • 53m ago

Advice Wanted Byzantium help

2 Upvotes

Ive decided to play Byzantium for my 4th game ever (i don’t have the dlc) and Ive been doing okay after struggling early on I now control all of the starting cores and have a Bulgarian vasal and a vasal in sicily and i have a local govenor In Athen. i have also been getting rid of the corruption privileges, the only one missing is The clergy one.

now my problem, i don’t make money even though i have 10-15 control minimum everywhere i only have a positive income of +5 at max, sometimes it dips below -20. iv gone bankrupt once but currently i have zero lones and that’s all I make, Ive been building buildings that are the most profitable in the best locations for them and Ive been trying to reduce building expenses by building stuff that makes the needed goods cheaper, i really don’t know why i don’t make money. I have a professional army but that only costs me 4 bucks when not fully funded and i own 5 ships (starting stuff) to increase naval presence, Ive even cut and reorganized my forts so i have logical cover but as few forts as possible.

can anyone help me?

PS: it’s 1387