r/Edgic • • 3d ago

Survey Survivor 51 Episode 9 Edgic Survey

Thumbnail
forms.gle
1 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Oct 21 '26

There are no spoilers this season

95 Upvotes

there's a couple people running around in this sub claiming to have spoilers and then spoiling them. just putting this post up to confirm that there are actually no spoilers this season (one person confirmed pre-merge from social media activity, that's it.) so do not fret if you see a "spoiler" in the comments! it's not real.


r/Edgic • • 4h ago

An Elimination-Based Approach to Edgic, S51E9 Spoiler

51 Upvotes

Let's get it over with!

This week, we said goodbye to Lewis, who we had not yet eliminated. We have gone through this season at an absolutely blistering pace. To this point, only one person has been voted out post-elimination. This is the second fastest we could've completed arrived at our winner, the fastest option would've resulted in me having only one contender left at the beginning of this writeup, rather than the end, which would've made my job a hell of a lot easier.

As a reminder, the players I have already eliminated are:

Cristian, Thien An, Alexis, Mike, Carter, Eric, Maggie, Devin

With that, let's get started

Jelly and Sharonda are my final two, and seemingly the final two of everyone else on the subreddit. Except for the one Mike, the one Maggie, and the one Thien An truther. I will be forgoing my typical Good Noodle/Bad Egg structure, and fittingly switching to a more "open-forum discussion" a la FTC.

Jelly and Sharonda have basically polar opposite edits, both of which, through episode 9, I think are valid winner trajectories. So having to make the call between the two of them at this juncture makes it feel like a total coin flip, no pun intended.

Jelly has been, in tandem with Devin, the main character of the season, which is by far her edit's biggest strength. Main characters don't always win, hence why this decision is not straightforward by any means, but they do win sometimes.

Sharonda has been more of a side character, but unlike the other side characters of the season, she has a direct narrative tie to the main characters via the Helicopter Alliance, and she has been shown time and time again to be an extremely savvy player.

Speaking to this episode specifically, Sharonda had nearly a picture perfect week. She pops in to take FULL credit for Jelly's idol play, and then is the first person to state that she wants Lewis to go home. If there were more than two contenders left, Sharonda would have absolutely no chance of being eliminated here. But there are only two contenders left, so we have to consider everything.

Jelly has a very high-vis episode this week, but it wasn't all great. As previously mentioned, Sharonda gets credit for HER idol play. Bad look. Other than that, I felt like the bulk of Jelly's content was great. She gets a deserved moment to celebrate having played her idol correctly, saving her and Devin. She gets a big character moment about the helicopter reward and how she felt about being left out of it, continuing her big character status. She states that she would prefer Maggie go home, but pivots when her alliance pushes to target Lewis, and this pivot plays in a way that makes her look like a reasonable ally, more than anything. I thought this was a solid episode for Jelly.

Looking at the season as a whole, I feel like I am constantly reminded of reasons I should not be pulling the trigger on either woman as a winner. Jelly's first confessional of the season is abysmal. Sharonda more or less gets called a coward by Lewis after the Linnea vote, which is about the worst thing you can be called, Edgically. Jelly has the big looming cloud of Devin, and her constant reminder to viewers that this relationship won't be good for her game are in total contradiction with every single action she has ever taken, except for that one time she told Patt about her idol and not Devin. Sharonda's content is strong, but it feels like it's missing that third gear. It's too clean, it's too polished, it's too one-note.

I feel like I am also constantly reminded of these things that seem to make it obvious that either of them are the winner. Jelly has been so strongly in the season's focus. Her relationship with Devin has so many shades of Yam Yam and Carolyn or Savannah and Rizo. Sharonda is one of many people left in the game with a quieter edit, but hers is SO much more fleshed out strategically, and created with so much care. Her presence is so reminiscent of Dee, or Kenzie, or Kyle, where we feel like this massive screentime hog in the center of everything is about to run away with the game, and the only layer of doubt is these seemingly unnecessary strategic check ins that give them so much credit.

These conflicting tidbits make the decision feel so impossible, that I question; have I already gotten it wrong? Is Thien An Erika? Is Mike the Alligabler? Is Maggie mother?

No. Well, except for that last one.

I am confident that one of Sharonda or Jelly is the winner, and I believe I can come to the right conclusion if I just stop overcomplicating it.

I think the answer is right in front of me.

The philosophy behind this experiment, since I started it back in Survivor 47, has been that it is possible to find the winner of the season by looking at who the edit is telling us is losing, rather than who it's telling us is winning. Every writeup, whether the decision on who to eliminate is glaringly obvious, or painfully obfuscated, the way I land on that decision has always been guided by that philosophy: Who is the edit telling us is losing Survivor?

To try to say that this episode has told us that Sharonda is losing would be completely disingenuous.

Am I completely 100% certain that we are being told Jelly is losing? No, and in a perfect world, I'd have a couple more weeks to make that call, but I don't. Being forced to make the call, I completely see the world that this episode has told us Jelly is losing.

Therefore:

The Winner of Survivor 51; Sharonda.


r/Edgic • • 2h ago

[51] First Confessionals for the F9

17 Upvotes

Devin 6:18

Oh, my God. We just jumped off a boat, grabbed supplies we fought for. I’m like, “What’s going on? Are we marooning? Is this classic Survivor? There’s only two words you remember from Jeff’s speech -

Carter 6:29

When my feet hit the sand, that’s when it felt like, “this is real.”

Eric 9:24

What the hell? There’s another Rhode Islander in the game? This is serendipity. As long as I’m around this guy, I’m gonna feel at least a bit comfortable, ‘cause now I got a, like, slice of home here.

Sharonda 10:14

In this chaos, the first person I saw was somebody with braids like me. And I’m like, okay, we can relate at some point. All of a sudden, we got a guy named Ori, who looks like he’s this big athlete. And Aaliyah.

Thien An 11:45

No way will that person that goes is me.

Jelly 12:03

Irish bro is like, “I’ll go.”

Mike 18:44

We have to pick someone. I do negotiations as part of my job. I’m the assistant director of baseball operations for the New York Yankees. I negotiate multimillion-dollar contracts for players, but I’m not telling people that. I don’t want to be a negotiator on Survivor, or at least I don’t want people to know that I am. And, fortunately, Kilby says…

Kilby said he’s a good negotiator. And man, that is music to my ears.

Maggie 40:06

Devin is starting to question what Jenna’s profession is. Honestly, she’d be the first person I’d vote out.

Cristian 43:04

Eric tried so hard (laughing) for this little fish, he was gone for two hours. And I think he is just overly excited for the experience. I mean, I am too, who wouldn’t be? But he is genuinely a little wonky.

~~~

🎶 One of these these kids is doing his own thing… 🎶


r/Edgic • • 5h ago

Results Survivor 51 - Meta-analysis of the different Edgic ranks after Episode 9

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Nobody changed his placement from the previous week.

This time, however, unlike previous week, nobody's ranking matches the average.


r/Edgic • • 2h ago

Boot Order Prediction

5 Upvotes

Working backwards and reverse engineering from my Winner pick, this is how I predict the boot order to go:

9th - Maggie

8th - Carter

7th - Mike

6th - Thien An

5th - Jelly

4th - Devin/Kristian

3rd - Eric

2nd - Christian/Devin

1st - Sharonda

Summary

Next few boots - Salt members

Sharonda targets Mike (a number for Dev/Jelly, removing that option for them).

Last of core salt - easy boot

Dragon (Jelly) slayed - Sharonda uses her numbers in Eric/Kristian to blindside her

One of Dev/Kristian lose in firemaking, Eric is brought to the end as a goat.

Sharonda wins in 9-0-0 or 8-1-0 final vote

What do y'all think, would love to see everyone else's predictions aswell!


r/Edgic • • 16h ago

Could this be a "Why _____ lost" edit? Spoiler

28 Upvotes

Why Jelly lost

This has been a very weird season to get a read on the edit, huh.

With the two true frontrunners that most of the community has come to, I have seen a lot of talk on Jelly and Sharonda's individual edits.

While most of the discourse has been on how Sharonda's edit is too clean while Jelly's edit is super tied to Devin, I want to focus on how their relationships are framed.

The edit for Jelly almost entirely gravitates on her one game relationship-her's with Devin. We never really see too much of Jelly playing with others. It is more so how she operates in the gravity of the biggest presence on the island.

Comparatively, Sharonda is constantly seen as being looped in by and connected to others-Thien An, Lewis in most recent episodes-and how those connections directly allow her to control the game.

Perhaps, in the era of permanent uncertainty, the person who has been connected to everyone across the game is the person who wins. And the edit is demonstrating how playing the New Era "Ride or Die" game isn't viable anymore. Like a reverse-49.

So we get all of this Devin-based visibility and presence to show that this is why Jelly loses-her ties to just one person, her ties to certainty.


r/Edgic • • 22h ago

Traitors US NB S1 Final Edgic + Contenders Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Of all the 30+ seasons of shows I've done Edgic for, this is statistically one of my worst performances ever. I believe my three worst are Survivor 43, Survivor 50, and now this. Oops! I do blame the wacky editing this season (42 minute episodes, constant cliffhangers, etc), but I still did quite poorly compared to how I usually do. Credit to people who did catch on to Shane earlier though! I know a YouTuber (Survivor Gumball) who was high on Shane pretty much all season, and the whole time I was sort of confused by that. Clearly he was on to something I wasn't.

I'm not a big fan of this season in general due to the reasons outlined above. You'll see my ranking shortly. Here's to hoping NB2 is better, and here's to hoping they CAST ME BRO PLEASE 🙏

Season Ranking

  1. AU3
  2. UK4
  3. UK2
  4. CAN 3
  5. UK1
  6. US3
  7. CAN 2
  8. AU1
  9. Celeb UK2
  10. NZ1
  11. IRE1
  12. UK3
  13. US2
  14. CAN 1
  15. US1
  16. Celeb UK1
  17. NZ3
  18. NZ2
  19. US4
  20. US NB S1
  21. AU2

Winner Ranking

Perfect Games

  1. Cirie (US1, T)
  2. Harry (UK2, T)
  3. Rob R (US4, T)
  4. Alex (AU1, RT)
  5. Hollywood (CAN 3, F)

Very Strong

6. Stephen (UK4, T)

7. Rachel (UK4, T)

8. Kirby (AU3, T)

9. Neda (CAN 2, T)

10. Sebastian (Celeb UK2, F)

11. Shane (US NB S1, RT)

12. Bailey (NZ2, RT)

13. Mike (CAN 1, T)

14. Sam (NZ1, F)

15. Dylan (US3, F)

16. Oyin (IRE1, F)

17. Jake (UK3, F)

18. Anna (NZ1, F)

19. Alan (Celeb UK1, T)

20. Romesh (Celeb UK2, F)

Good Enough

21. Chloe (NZ3, RT)

22. Vanessa (IRE1, F)

23. Kelley (IRE1, F)

24. CT (US2, F)

25. Dom (CAN 3, F)

26. Gabby (US3, F)

27. Hannah (UK1, F)

28. Trishelle (US2, F)

29. Leanne (UK3, F)

30. Aaron (UK1, F)

Bad Wins*

31. Sam (AU2, T)*

32. Blake (AU2, T)*

33. Camille (AU2, RT)*

34. Ivar (US3, F)

35. Dolores (US3, F)

36. Meryl (UK1, F)


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Truther Edgic 51 Episode 9 Rankings

4 Upvotes

1. Mike 🐊

Mike has officially entered his AlliGabler Era! Although this seems like a nothing burger of an episode for Mike, we get visual confirmation that he has indeed integrated into what is now a majority alliance of five with Sharonda, Eric, Devin and Jelly. We also see him in the background bro’ing down with Carter and Christian.

To the not insignificant portion of Edgic who seemed convinced Mike would go out on the coin flip. I have a message for you:

I told you so!

I told you Mike was unlikely to flip the coin, primarily because Mike was unlikely to be viewed as a target by either side at this point. And he wasn’t. I predicted he had integrated into Heli + Eric. And indeed he had.

Even Mike’s donkey haters have stopped braying their Mike hating hee haws.

2. Sharonda 🐉

Although I am still firmly Team Dragon for Sharonda’s edit, this was a really great episode for Sharonda. She gets the lion share of the credit in the previouslies and post tribal strategy talk for what should have been a Jelly/Devin move.

I like that Sharonda recognizes she gets to take credit for Jelly playing the idol in confessional (and potentially at FTC), while Jelly and Devin have to take the fall in the game and suffer the consequences for the move. I like that Sharonda is the main driver of the hypothetical Lewis vote and gets her way over Jelly, who wants Maggie to be the target.

As for the Salt side, they have tunnel vision for Jelly. Great episode for Sharonda, terrible episode for Jelly.

Why don’t I have Sharonda back at number one? In a word, Cristian.

Sharonda and Cristian have been together the entire game, and we STILL don’t have a firm grasp on their relationship, despite him telling her about the idol. Cristian appears to be rat floating between Salt and Old Savu. Cristian does not appear to be in The Merge Majority Five.

Sharonda mentions in passing to Jelly that Cristian is dangerous in episode 8, but I believe that if Sharonda were winning, we would have had some confessionals from Sharonda explaining her distrust of Cristian and their general orientation towards one another in the game. Cristian would not be a blank space in her game.

3. Devin 😈

Yeah, the episode was THAT BAD for Jelly.

For me, this episode felt like the start of Devin’s journey to the end, and his Why Devin Lost losing finalist edit. For the first time, Devin’s story felt more important than Jelly’s.

However, I still don’t think he’s winning. It has just become crystal clear he will outlast Jelly and indeed be her downfall. The fake idol scene with Maggie was terrible for Devin, especially this late in the season.

Mike is AlliGablering, while Devin is goating out.

4. Jelly 😇🪽

Oof, Sharonda got the most edit credit for Jelly’s idol play. Sharonda gets credit for the hypothetical Lewis vote when Jelly wanted Maggie out. Devin gets most of the post idol move celebration content.

Jelly is the Fallen Angel. We have been beat over the head with foreshadowing that Devin will be her downfall.

This episode was the nail in the coffin, for me, for Jelly.

5. Eric 🐐

Although we get some decent strategic content from Eric, he’s almost certainly a losing finalist.

With this majority of five, I think the boys are going to realize Sharonda and Jelly have a lot more win equity than they do. I predict a final 3 of Eric, Mike, Dev.

6. Maggie 💅🏼

Although I think Maggie has a lot of win equity, I don’t think she has a winning edit. This episode, she does not appear to have a whole lot of agency. The majority clocks her as a threat, Devin tries to trick her into finding a fake idol (to her credit, she sniffs it out in the NTOS).

Bottom line, this is not what Maggie’s edit looks like if she wins. Late intro in the premiere, not enough credit for the Linnea move, way too much Mike focus.

Carter/Cristian/Thien An 🦨🦨

nope


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 9 - SUTRAL

16 Upvotes

OMG I've got so much to say about this week's episode!!

I wanna start with an unpopular opinion and annihilate my social capital in this subreddit: I didn't dislike the coin flip at all. 🫠 I mean okay, it's not classic Survivor, but to be honest we would be clamoring just as much if the show stayed the same for 51 seasons. Also, I feel like it kinda WAS a unanimous vote and no one was really forced to do it, all things considered. I LOVED Lewis (returnee right now pls) and I'm bummed he went out but he literally took his fate in his own hands.

So, now, let's start with this week's SUTRAL!

Episode 9 - Data Table

I need to put a little asterisk on the EDGIC column because I don't agree with a couple of those choices lol. Anyways, the EDGIC that I put into the model is for all intents and purposes an "average" of the EDGIC charts I've seen around after this episode, so it's more like a "community consensus" EDGIC.

Episode 9 - Win Equity

There's a little addition that I've made to correct the fact that the more we go into the season, the less people the total win equity has to be split between, and that caused everyone to have a positive trend. So I created a new metric, the "adjusted trend", that takes out of the equation the free boost everyone gets when someone is eliminated. It compares each player's actual equity with what they would have had if only the field had shrunk (if nothing else happened in the episode and Lewis was just removed): positive means a real gain, negative means they lost ground despite the raw number rising. Across the players, the adjusted trends sum to zero.

In this case, we can see that Sharonda, despite her total win equity went up by 1.2%, hasn't gone up as much as it would have if the only changing parameter was the number of players. That means that actually in this episode something happened that impacted her growth and slowed down her rise. Hope I explained it in a good way, in my head it makes sense 😂

Episode 9 - Season Graph & Analysis

ANYWAYS! Let's get to work and analyze our surviving fellas:

9. Eric

This is like the first time we see Eric speak normally, like a real human being, and not as a Disney character. That tells us that the editors chose to keep in his most cringey moments, and purposefully left out the "normal person" moments. I mean, we saw that the guy CAN be serious for a second. Anyway, this just further confirms that he won't win. At least I hope the editors made the rest of his stay a little less painfully uncomfortable to watch.

8. Cristian

I'm very conflicted cause half of me hated, hated, HATED his weird hippie "energy" moment at Tribal Council, and half of it found it so stupid and funny - his dead father told him that Devin had to flip the coin LMFAO All of me, though, was so confused at the "explain as if it was a poem" (????????) moment. He was more visibly on the rise in the last couple episodes, now we see him positioned in a pretty solid way. All of this can't be enough for a win edit, and if it is, it will be VERY controversial.

7. Devin

OMG THE IDOL AUTO-FIND. That was H-Y-S-T-E-R-I-C-A-L!! Also, go listen to the last Know-It-Alls episode on RHAP, it is SO funny how much it shows that Rob Cesternino can't stand Devin 😂Anyways, Devin was finally enjoyable (for me) after an overexposed first half and a dull second half of the premerge. Another thing that I'd like to say is that Devin is the only one I can still see having a path to the win: they seeded the start of the season with Devin content so hard, then put him aside, checked on him once in a while and took him out of the oven for the merge. A spike in visibility now and a victory at the end wouldn't be too bad or unsatisfying. Last thing: sir, please don't try to sell to us that you're a superfan 😂

6. Thien An

FINALLY we found out that... "Thien An sleeps through everything". 😑 But seriously, idk, sometimes I happen to notice little details in players' personality, and the fact that she laughed when Jeff commented her pose during the challenge makes me think that we've been wronged so much by the editors not showing enough of her bubbly self! She just seems so chill and fun to be around and I wish we saw more of that. If we look at the numbers, she gets the second highest rise in win equity for this episode, but I'm still convinced she won't win.

5. Mike

Last player that I categorically rule out as a winner is Mike. Mike('s few) fans got excited for a moment there lol but he just isn't getting what he needs to win. Best case scenario: 0-vote finalist. That's it. I lost a lung for laughing so hard at the "???" subtitle while he was eating chicken LMFAOOOO

4. Carter

Hey, Carter is still very much alive for me, and it makes sense that statistically he's here and not higher up: at the moment, it looks like he's stuck in an alliance division that doesn't bode well for him, as the most immediate challenge threat from the minority alliance. But if production decided that they wanted a "weird" or "anti-EDGIC" edit to throw everyone off for the first Open Era season, I can see Carter as the most viable candidate for it. Oh, and... what's going on with his obsession for big balls/nuts? Reminds me of myself on a Saturday night. 😂

3. Jelly

I don't know, I'm still pretty agnostic on whether she will win or not, and it's the same thing that is happening with Sharonda. It's like: it's TOO obvious for it to just be a matter of who will sit at the final Tribal between Jelly and Sharonda. Maybe I'm just overcomplicating things or giving the production too much credit here, but something just tells me they wouldn't go for an obvious winner edit this time. Wishful thinking probably, cause she is the one who benefited the most from this episode in terms of Win Equity so her star is back to her original brightness after last week. But something tells me she's not winning.

2. Maggie

I'm seeing so many people start to consider her and I just wanna say I TOLD YOU SO BEFORE IT WAS MAINSTREAM 😂 We literally had a whole segment with everyone agreeing Maggie would win and also WTF THE WHOLE REFUSING THE IDOL WAS PURE STRATEGIC GENIUS. She is so quick-witted when it comes to making strategic decisions on the spot. Once Jelly is gone, I think Maggie will have even more of a grip on her position in the game.

1. Sharonda

Well, everything boils down to whether the winner has an openly positive edit, 'cause in that case Sharonda is undoubtedly winning. Her Win Equity is by far the best right now and 1 out of 4 times she wins, which doesn't sound like much but it is a lot when there's still 9 people in the game. The problem I see with her, though, is that we're getting closer and closer to the moment she will eventually have to choose "publicly" who to be with between the Helicopters and the counter-helicopters: she's very good at stealth mode, but what will happen once she's forced to reveal her real allegiances?

And that's it for this week! See you next week with a new SUTRAL! <3


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

The Traitors: New Blood Final Edgic Spoiler

Post image
14 Upvotes

Given Shane's late recruitment, it makes sense that they seemed to go more for a 'Why Victor/the other traitors lost' edit than a 'Why Shane won' edit. He may have only been a traitor for around 2 days, but he played those two days well.

But also, this season was rough. I enjoyed Victor and Joe, but not really anyone else. Michael was fine, I guess. Plus, the pacing was horrible, largely because this show isn't made for such short episodes. 4/10, solely because of Victor.


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Traitors US New Blood 1 Edgic Spoiler

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

F4 Prediction

18 Upvotes

Haven't posted on Edgic in a hot minute but I still follow it a bit. I've slowly been coming towards a mental picture of what I think the final 4 will be. I wanted to share my quick thoughts before next week proves me wrong by having one of them be voted out.

Final 4 - Sharonda, Jelly, Devin, Mike

I think the helicopter alliance has the winner at this point and Mike seems both aligned with them and able to win a few immunities.

I think they will be able to work with Eric along the way as well but I think he gets voted out some time before the finale.

Mike will win final immunity in this scenario since he seems to be pretty decent at challenges while the others have all struggled. Mike will then see Jelly as the biggest jury threat (that idea has started to build this episode) and put her into fire against Devin. Devin will beat Jelly and fulfill the build up of him being her downfall.

Unrelated but we're going to need a jury removal in here since it'll be a final 3 with 9 jurors.

I then think that Sharonda will ultimately win 8-0-0 or 7-1-0 with Jelly potentially throwing a vote towards Devin. Mike feels like he's being built up to be a 0 vote finalist to me. Devin has not shown to be too respected by the rest of the cast either.

I can't wait to be proven completely wrong


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Permanent Uncertainty = Reduced Player Agency

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 9 - EDGIC

6 Upvotes

Hi y'all!

Here's my EDGIC for this episode (which, to be honest, I loved):

And yeah, I was wrong on my Mike coinflip theory, but so was almost everyone else on the internet lol

See you soon for the new SUTRAL!

Byyeeee <3


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Confessionals proving ________ will not win. (Survivor 51 Episode 9) Spoiler

87 Upvotes

Jelly

  • Episode 2

    • I'm very close to Devin at this point in the game. We were the only ones on the wrong side of the vote at Tribal. But my boy Devin, as much as I love him, Devin's approach is blatant honesty, and I can't risk him blowing up my spot.
    • Jelly to Devin: My only concern with that is, like, if I'm telling you something and it goes to someone else or comes up at Tribal, it ends... it's bad for me.
    • Right now I'm thinking about how I want to proceed in this game. And Patt feels solid and loyal. And that is what you want in an ally.
  • Episode 4

    • The core five... it's completely obliterated. But what stings more about this Tribal Council is I had the power to change it. Going back, I would have played my idol on Patt. And now I have regret, but the silver lining is. Patt was the only one who knew about my idol. So I'm holding more power than these people think. They made a mistake keeping me, because I'll throw every single one of them, with the exception of Devin, under the bus, in a heartbeat.
    • No, but for me it was weighing the devil you know versus the devil you don't know, right?
    • Devin is not good for my game.
  • Episode 5

    • When we come back from Tribal Council, I was trying to contain my excitement, but it's pretty hard to do that when my guy Devin is out here acting like we just won the Super Bowl.
    • And, to be honest, Alexis is right. Devin is not good for my game. He's not connected to anyone that I need moving forward. And I could always lean on the fact that I wasn't okay voting out another woman to kind of make it make sense why I had to let go of Devin.
  • Episode 6

    •  Last night was tough. Sadly, we had to get rid of Alexis, who was with me since day one. But I was willing to sacrifice her in the hopes of this day 11 three going far in this game. If this could be the day 25 or day 26 three, it would be amazing.
    • It was just Devin and Jelly in Fiji, not Devin and Jelly trying to survive in Survivor. Today, with us two frolicking around the jungle and the beach, it's gonna go down as probably one of my top memories of life,
    • Ori: I've been trying to talk to Jelly, trying to plead my case, but she was steadfast about it. She said they're emotionally and honor bound to each other, which makes me sick.
    • Devin: Ori telling me, "When are you gonna start playing this game for you?" Flipped a switch from my emotional brain to my logical brain. This is Survivor. You're here to play. There can only be one winner of, potentially, $2 million. And now I'm like, "Oh, Jelly looks secure." She doesn't seem very worried because she believes that we will never, at this point in the game, write each other's name down. So she won't play her immunity idol. And I'm sitting here with an extra vote in my pocket.
  • Episode 7

    • We're not losing anymore, and they're gonna see a completely different Devin and Jelly. - I just made a promise to myself at that Tribal Council. - No, we love Ori. I was like, "He will be my final heartbreak."
    • You know, I love Devin, but our work together is a struggle bus. You know, we love each other, but I need to get on a new bus. Pretty ASAP. And hopefully this Buff is that new bus for me.
  • Episode 8

    • Devin is just a part of me. He is my Survivor husband. Not the one I expected. I genuinely thought I might get one out of this experience. But that's what I got. I cannot escape that man. For better or worse. I've chosen this life.
    • I'm worried about, while I'm here, what Devin's doing.
    • It is incredibly difficult to know when to play your idol, but at the same time, if I could get through this Tribal Council, maintaining my hidden immunity idol and Devin's extra vote, our power goes up exponentially throughout this game.
  • Episode 9

    • Me and Devin... we're locked and loaded.
    • It was, like, triple wins tonight. We got out probably the biggest threats in this game at the moment, built a résumé, saved my number one ally. And I've never felt better. All these people now have to grovel to me.

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Devin vs Jelly’s Edit

18 Upvotes

There are a lot of Devin truthers out there now and I’m not totally opposed to his edit but I just don’t see it right now and I have a few big reasons why that I’d like to know how the people who do think he wins can see past it.

My main issue with Devin’s edit is why is Jelly always prioritised over him when it comes to narration if he is supposedly the one who wins that battle? She always gets to talk at every point of the game and tell us where her mind is at while I feel like Devin is only shown when he needs to because of things that the editors can’t edit out. For example, Jelly is the one to have her connection with Patt shown and not only gets that emotional scene and confessional post tribal but also the confessional when she’s getting on the boat for the swap where she says she’s gonna make it work no matter what and her game is gonna turn around. Devin on the other hand doesn’t even get to narrate being blindsided and an ally of his going not to mention the fact that Jelly got completely shielded in Episode 3 while he was made to look like an idiot (Aside from the vote there’s even just small things like Thien An saying he tried to mansplain me survivor being shown and captioned).

Another issue I have is he has no connections other than Jelly. Jelly got setup with Sharonda and also got setup with Mike and arguably Eric too. Meanwhile the only connection Devin did have aside from her was Brady and there was no proper resolution. I find it weird how we never got anything from Devin about the Brady boot when that duo was such a big thing early on and we instead get to hear from Jelly about him which once again demonstrates how the edit prioritises her over him every time even when his perspective is objectively more relevant.

Jelly gets to defend herself and is shown as self aware much more than Devin as well. Just this episode she gets a segment about not hiding her emotions and knowing that people can see when she doesn’t like something and then when Thien An talks about why she’s targeting Jelly she mentions that she is a closed door which makes the previous scene feel very intentional to me.


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Thien An content top-heavy in the episodes

28 Upvotes

Ok so what is with Thien An getting a couple confessionals right when the episode starts then going dark the rest of the episode?? lol every episode I get excited thinking this could be her big breakthrough episode then literally nothing else after. Thankfully she was at least shown saying something at tribal this last time.
But it’s very odd. Reminds me of Aubry for a lot of S50 too. Although by now, even Aubry’s edit began to pick up some steam.


r/Edgic • • 3d ago

The Elimination Game - S51E09 Spoiler

56 Upvotes

This season is killing me. Every time I narrow it down, the game gets to one of my contenders before I can. Kristin and Kilby went home on a single vote, Lewis went home on a coin, and somehow every single person I cut is still in the game except Alexis. So I’m left with Jelly and Sharonda, two of the strongest characters of the season with very different edits, and I have to pick my winner right here. After watching Lewis lose everything on a coin last week, I’ll admit this feels a bit like my own coin flip.

I’ll start with Jelly, since her story starts louder. She had one of the best premieres of the whole cast, excited about permanent uncertainty before most people even knew what Jeff meant. She connected with half the beach on day one. Then came the losing streak, first Aaliyah and then Patt, both gone with Jelly and Devin on the wrong side. The edit put the blame on Devin and Brady and kept Jelly out of it. I remember being nervous about her quiet Episode 3, but looking back it was protection that didn’t cost her anything. After the swap she became the season’s decision maker for a few episodes in a row. Jenna, Alexis and Ori all went home after we watched Jelly wrestle with the choice, and along the way we got great personal content with Ori and Devin, and a real sense of who she is as a player. At the merge she promised us a new Jelly, she and Devin were loaded with advantages, and she got the merge boot Brady out. Last week she played her idol at exactly the right moment (a triple win!).

That’s a winner’s resume, right? Well, hold on.

Jelly also has the darkest clouds hanging over her of anyone left. Since the swap Devin has been telling us he plans to cut her eventually, and the edit hasn’t shown us a single hint that she suspects it. Then there’s the idol she told us over and over she wanted to save, which she had to burn anyway last week, and now her name came up everywhere. If Jelly went home in the next couple of episodes, the edit has already laid out every piece of that story and it would make complete sense.

Sharonda has none of those clouds. Her premiere was quiet, but it was about the right things, bonding with Jelly over braids and clicking with Devin and Ori right away. From there she pretty much always got her way. The only exception was being forced to flip on Linnea at the deadlock, which was also the only week I really called out her strategy focused edit. Since then she’s only gone up. At the tethered idol summit she got Kristin, the season’s resident strategist, to do exactly what she wanted without saying a word. People come to her with information and trust her with their idols and secrets. At the merge all the connections she had built came together, and she’s been the best connected player in the game while staying completely under the radar. Then we finally got her personal story about being underestimated her whole life, and this week my favorite line of the episode, where she takes full credit for the last Tribal, “just not out loud right now.” She’s already working on her FTC speech.

The edit has also never proven her wrong. Her SPV is the best in the cast, her relationships are clearly edited in her favor, and she’s in the driver’s seat of this tribe. If you just look at the board, Sharonda is winning this game. She hasn’t made an obvious mistake, nobody is coming for her, and everything is going her way.

So why am I hesitating?

This season has never really been about the player who keeps everything under control. She’s always shown as calm and level-headed, and never as someone enjoying the chaos this season keeps selling us. Her personal content came so late that for most of the game she came across as a strategist without much of a story behind her. Her relationships are useful, but they mostly look like working relationships. Everyone tells Sharonda their secrets, but Jelly is the one we actually got to know as a player.

I keep coming back to that. Jelly has been through a lot this season. She lost, she struggled, she doubted herself and she kept finding her way back. She’s part of the most visible duo of the season, and even if she isn’t as well connected as Sharonda, every relationship she has was actually fleshed out on screen. Her obstacles are obvious, but that’s also what would make her win feel earned. Looking at the winning edits of the last few seasons, the complex player who has been through everything fits the mold better than someone who never put a foot wrong.

Last season I learned the hard way that strong visibility and fleshed out storylines (Aubry) matter more than a clean edit (Cirie, my winner pick), so this time I’m trusting that lesson.

I am cutting Sharonda.

Jelly is the winner of my elimination game, and hopefully of Survivor 51!


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

My thoughts on why _____ doesn't win Spoiler

24 Upvotes

I've lurked on this sub a lot, and as a Jelly truther since the swap, I have been convinced that Jelly is going to win.

Of course, for that to happen, she needs to beat out Sharonda.

Why won't Sharonda win?

On paper, Sharonda's edit is perfect. She has had great SPV from her cast members, she has had virtually zero hiccups outside of the Linnea vote, and she has been making great behind the scenes moves and holding control while building up zero of the target. Once her personal content came in a few episodes ago, there should be no reason for her to win. She's the perfect option. Too perfect.

This season has bashed us over the head time and time again with permanent uncertainty. It's the theme every single week. Call me crazy, but I don't see the winner of the uncertain season of Survivor to be the person who kept a level head, had strong control, and rarely faced adversity (of course, there is still more season to watch so we will have to see).

Turning it over to Jelly, she had an extremely strong premiere and, being apart of the main duo of the season, has gotten a lot of good content on her game. The biggest worry people are having with Jelly's edit is her constant repetition of Devin being the one to ruin her game, which admittedly has worried me too. However, I really don't think that this is going to happen. We saw Devin 1.0 return in the last episode. Jelly 2.0 is still pushing forward and I think will virtually drag Devin towards the end of the game, if he doesn't get out due to his old shenanigans first.

Survivor 50 had me on a (slightly biased) Cirie train, because her edit compared to Aubry's was so clean. While not every season needs a dragon, I don't think Sharonda is going to win a game with such obvious control considering how much Jeff has to remind us that the game is uncertain.


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 9 Edgic

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Survivor 51 Edgic: Episode 9 Spoiler

Post image
9 Upvotes

Tough episode. Hopefully they do away with the coin flip once it flips successfully. Interesting to discuss from an Edgic perspective, though! Spoiler alert, my ranking order stays completely the same (-Lewis), but there are some wrinkles to think about.

True contenders

(1) Sharonda

I had my eyes peeled for a Sharonda confessional explaining why she voted against Jelly and Devin, and we got it. AND she explained how the pros of her positioning outweighed the cons of losing Kristin and the tethered idol. Anytime Sharonda speaks, her content is so incredibly positive. The main downside is that she doesn’t feel like a main character, and this felt especially prominent this episode to me for some reason. If Sharonda wins, we’re getting a why Devin/Jelly lost story, and Sharonda’s complete and utter competence is the main focus of her winning game. Absolutely no disrespect to Sharonda, she’s my favorite on the beach right now, but she reads to me as very business-first in her confessionals. This edit fits her personality and a winning game from her well, I think. 

Other stray thoughts about Sharonda: 

  • With S51 as the inaugural season of the Open Era, I’d wager some money (maybe not a million dollars, but at least 20 bucks) that the editors are doing their best to separate this era from the New Era. What better way to do this than take Jelly, a player with a very “new-era winner” coded edit, and Sharonda, a player with a very “old-school winner” edit, and flip the narrative on its head with a Sharonda win?
  • I have been seeing a S50 Cirie/Sharonda comparison floating about and I don’t quite agree. Cirie was going to get a glowing edit no matter what she did or how far she went (rightfully so). That Sharonda hasn’t been skunked like Cirie was and has no legacy to factor in but is STILL getting the mastermind edit puts her edit head and shoulders above Cirie’s in my opinion.
  • Love her.

(2) Jelly

If it isn’t Sharonda, it’s likely Jelly. Jelly is the main character of the season, we have double the content from her compared to Sharonda, and I still cannot shake the losing finalist vibes that have plagued her for most of this game. I felt like this episode was mixed for her. We get a lot of Jelly content, and that visibility is important to keeping her in the audience’s mind, but the edit went out of its way to show her calling herself a hater. Was that negative or just humorous? Idk. What’s worse, we see Jelly’s preference to target Maggie get absolutely and thoroughly bulldozed by Sharonda and the rest of her alliance. Lacking agency within her alliance is a theme for Jelly and it’s not a good one. If Jelly were winning, I don’t think the editors would have shown these kinds of moments over and over again.

What sticks out in my head the most is that we STILL don’t have a resolution to her needing to separate her game from Devin. As the numbers whittle down, this becomes worse and worse. At this point, she needs to distinguish herself from Devin AND cut Sharonda to have a clear path to win (maybe cutting Sharonda is how she separates herself from Devin ...). Maybe it will happen, but I don’t think her path is as locked down as some on Edgic seem to believe.

Jelly’s clearest winning FTC is against Mike and Eric, which is very, very, possible. Mike’s and Eric’s edits being so bad in their own ways would also make sense should Jelly win in this scenario.

Dark Horse

(3) Devin

Devin’s path to win involves betraying Jelly. If Sharonda goes at 6 or 5 and he cuts Jelly, I think he could genuinely win. We’ve had glimmers of him talking about playing the game for himself, but most of his content has been about staying loyal and sticking with the Helicopter alliance. It seems Devin 2.0 will never fully emerge, as he fell back on his radical honesty approach this episode. It worked, mostly by luck.

I think a FTC with all the remaining helicopter alliance members is the likeliest option at this point, with Devin in 3rd, Jelly in 2nd, and Sharonda winning.

Everyone else

(4) Maggie

She continues to surprise and delight me. The fake idol segment is one of the highlights of the season so far for me, and based on the NTOS, it seems like she’s caught on to what was happening. Still, she’s in the minority and seen as a threat, so she’s likely gone soon, but every time she’s on my screen I’m having a great time. 

(5) Mike

Kind of a nothing-burger episode from him.

(6) Carter

Wins immunity, loses a number in Lewis. Good episode with strategic insights from him, but much like everyone else in this category, it’s too little too late.

(7) Cristian

The energy moment with the coin at tribal was nails on a chalkboard for me. Good lord. He’s getting content, but this is Yellow Sophie reincarnated.

(8) Thien An

Biggest Thien An episode yet, but still underdeveloped as a presence on the season.

(9) Eric

One of his better episodes! Lewis still dunks on him, but Lewis is no more.

Out

(10) Lewis

Many people on Edgic hypothesized a Lewis coin flip, and we got it. It’s a shame to see him go, I really enjoyed him on this season. The editors need to revamp how the coin flip is placed in the episode because when I saw how much time was left in the episode, I instantly knew he was cooked. Lessons for future coin flip seasons: a big character with circumstantial content, content focused on chaos, and MOR strategy segments is high up on my “coin victim” radar. His “I need this idol” quote from the premiere was foreshadowing for his elimination this episode.

Also, his “Sharonda is a massive threat” confessional that was a little out of place in the pre-merge now makes total sense if she wins, kind of like S44 when Frannie clocked Carolyn/Yam Yam/Carson and was promptly booted.


r/Edgic • • 3d ago

Editing Clues

24 Upvotes

There have been several instances of editing clues/camera panning indicating a Jelly win.

- In the intro, everyone’s name moves sideways while hers moves upwards.
- Just this episode, when Lewis says he is excited to vote for the winner of the season the camera shows Jelly.
- Also in this episode, when Devin says “only one of us can win” the camera shows Lewis who just went home and then Jelly.
- In Episode 8, when Carter says “money” it shows Jelly smiling for a split second.
- She is also shown right after the 51 logo in the opening credits.


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 9 Contender Ranking Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Welp … this was a really fun episode until it ended on such a bummer. I think, as most of us knew, the coin flip is a bad twist if the flipper goes home. But this episode proved that the coin flip is also not a good twist because it creates bad TV if the flipper goes home. If this episode ended with Lewis being voted out unanimously it would have still kept its momentum. The coin flip renders the scramble before mostly pointless and makes tribal feel like its own separate segment of the show. It’s a shame the chaos of Devin’s fake idol and the Jelly vs Lewis numbers war were overshadowed by this.

Let’s talk about Lewis then, and his edit very much makes sense in retrospect. Mostly circumstantial, really tied to the chaos theme, very positive all around, and completely fell off after the merge because you can’t tell a Point A to Point B story when someone’s game ends with a coin flip. I fully expect to see him back on the next returnee season and I think he’s earned his spot as someone willing to play aggressively and not necessarily optimally.

Jeff asking Cristian to describe the storm as a POEM has made me bloodthirsty enough to cut a couple more contenders this week. So I now only have three people remaining in contention. Is this a mistake? Probably, but only time will tell.

So, without further ado …

 

Who is my Top Contender? …

  1. Sharonda. (-) As the merge goes on, my confidence in a Sharonda win is only growing. I won’t go into as much detail this week, as I’d only be repeating myself. This was another perfect episode for her. She got to address Kristen going home while also still having the result presented as a win for her as she saved Devin and Jelly. She foreshadows using this information as a big reveal at final tribal. She has a new connection established with Cristian, which was one of the relationships I was concerned about last week. She set up wanting Lewis to go home, and ultimately, even though she had nothing to do with it, he did. She got a hero moment at the challenge despite not winning yet again, and finally at tribal she got so much camera time surrounding the coin flip, as if it was setting up her prize money amount. I’m up to 90% on Sharonda being the sole Survivor, and I’m mad that I didn’t have her as my number one contender in the premiere when I picked up on her name being subtitled in her introduction as being significant.

 

Who else is a Contender? …

  • Jelly. (-) This wasn’t a great episode for Jelly to be honest. She had her threat level escalated leaving me less confident that she will make it to the final tribal council. Devin continued to play her up and that’s troubling considering the pre-merge set up of Devin being really bad for her game. The fake idol is most likely going to get a vote split between them. And most unfortunately, Eric called her desperate in a segment that I don’t really think we were meant to disagree with him on. What I will say is that Jelly continues to be an extremely complex character, so much so that if she doesn’t make final tribal, I would have her locked in as a returnee on the next all-star season. Also, I warmed a lot to Jelly on a personal level this episode and really loved her hater segment. I still think she is probably the Runner-Up, but now I’m not as confident that she will even make the endgame.

 

Who is an Unlikely Contender? …

  • Maggie. (+1) I’m leaving Maggie in contention to have a third option just in case, but I don’t think Maggie is winning. Her narrative precedence in this episode was basically dead last, and she didn’t get much screentime until the back half of the episode. That said, she got mid-merge threat SPV from Jelly about her sweeping the jury if she gets to the end which was very reminiscent of Dee for me. I also just love her and thought her not falling into Devin’s trap was hysterical. Also, in the NTOS she called him on his bluff!? She’s iconic, but I can’t see her making final tribal.

 

Who is Eliminated? …

  • Mike. (+2) As promised, Mike stays at the top of my eliminated tier. Although, I thought this episode was a nothing-burger for him and these Aubry turn around edits rely on steadily increasing visibility at the merge. I totally get why people are truthing for him though, and a Mike win at this point would be one of the least surprising outcomes somehow.
  • Carter. (+2) Carter also floats to the top of the eliminated tier. I’m not entirely sure why. He hasn’t really got a story and has very inconsistent visibility when compared to the rest of the cast. I just think his content is generally stronger than the other low visibility players and so I feel he is more likely to win than them.
  • Devin. (-3) Devin is eliminated this week for having a great merge mission statement about changing his game and being more devious, then doing nothing for two episodes, then out of nowhere returning to his dreadful weaponised honesty strategy that he incorrectly continues to praise. Oh, there’s also the fake idol hide fail and trying to coin flip himself out of the game. Jelly might see Devin as a bad omen, but he’s actually just a bad player. He’s out there for the vibes, but vibes don’t write cheques.
  • Eric. (-2) I’ve also decided to chop Eric. I thought this was actually a decent episode for him, and edit-wise there’s at least the foundations for a shock turn around there. But logically he is not winning a jury vote so I’m not sure why he was even still in contention to begin with. I’m 75% confident on Eric as the zero vote finalist.
  • Thien An. (-) Thien An is getting consistent content, but it’s all narrational and she doesn’t have a story. She’s not returned to her underestimated motif, and all her relationships are mentioned once until they are voted out and then Thien An gets to eulogise them. Something about her edit is giving endgamer, maybe she’s even meant to be Sharonda’s dragon (or at least the Toka collective is), but she’s certainly not the winner.
  • Cristian. (-) I think it’s becoming clear that production just didn’t like Cristian, and I will say I was rooting for him to coin flip himself out of the game by the end of the episode. Your deceased father was whispering Devin’s name? Wild thing to say to back out of taking a big risk. Also, at the start he claimed playing his shot in the dark was the biggest move of the game, which makes me feel like this guy has zero clue about what is going on, because that’s not even a move my friend.