r/Edgic • u/McAulay_a • 4h ago
An Elimination-Based Approach to Edgic, S51E9 Spoiler
Let's get it over with!
This week, we said goodbye to Lewis, who we had not yet eliminated. We have gone through this season at an absolutely blistering pace. To this point, only one person has been voted out post-elimination. This is the second fastest we could've completed arrived at our winner, the fastest option would've resulted in me having only one contender left at the beginning of this writeup, rather than the end, which would've made my job a hell of a lot easier.
As a reminder, the players I have already eliminated are:
Cristian, Thien An, Alexis, Mike, Carter, Eric, Maggie, Devin
With that, let's get started
Jelly and Sharonda are my final two, and seemingly the final two of everyone else on the subreddit. Except for the one Mike, the one Maggie, and the one Thien An truther. I will be forgoing my typical Good Noodle/Bad Egg structure, and fittingly switching to a more "open-forum discussion" a la FTC.
Jelly and Sharonda have basically polar opposite edits, both of which, through episode 9, I think are valid winner trajectories. So having to make the call between the two of them at this juncture makes it feel like a total coin flip, no pun intended.
Jelly has been, in tandem with Devin, the main character of the season, which is by far her edit's biggest strength. Main characters don't always win, hence why this decision is not straightforward by any means, but they do win sometimes.
Sharonda has been more of a side character, but unlike the other side characters of the season, she has a direct narrative tie to the main characters via the Helicopter Alliance, and she has been shown time and time again to be an extremely savvy player.
Speaking to this episode specifically, Sharonda had nearly a picture perfect week. She pops in to take FULL credit for Jelly's idol play, and then is the first person to state that she wants Lewis to go home. If there were more than two contenders left, Sharonda would have absolutely no chance of being eliminated here. But there are only two contenders left, so we have to consider everything.
Jelly has a very high-vis episode this week, but it wasn't all great. As previously mentioned, Sharonda gets credit for HER idol play. Bad look. Other than that, I felt like the bulk of Jelly's content was great. She gets a deserved moment to celebrate having played her idol correctly, saving her and Devin. She gets a big character moment about the helicopter reward and how she felt about being left out of it, continuing her big character status. She states that she would prefer Maggie go home, but pivots when her alliance pushes to target Lewis, and this pivot plays in a way that makes her look like a reasonable ally, more than anything. I thought this was a solid episode for Jelly.
Looking at the season as a whole, I feel like I am constantly reminded of reasons I should not be pulling the trigger on either woman as a winner. Jelly's first confessional of the season is abysmal. Sharonda more or less gets called a coward by Lewis after the Linnea vote, which is about the worst thing you can be called, Edgically. Jelly has the big looming cloud of Devin, and her constant reminder to viewers that this relationship won't be good for her game are in total contradiction with every single action she has ever taken, except for that one time she told Patt about her idol and not Devin. Sharonda's content is strong, but it feels like it's missing that third gear. It's too clean, it's too polished, it's too one-note.
I feel like I am also constantly reminded of these things that seem to make it obvious that either of them are the winner. Jelly has been so strongly in the season's focus. Her relationship with Devin has so many shades of Yam Yam and Carolyn or Savannah and Rizo. Sharonda is one of many people left in the game with a quieter edit, but hers is SO much more fleshed out strategically, and created with so much care. Her presence is so reminiscent of Dee, or Kenzie, or Kyle, where we feel like this massive screentime hog in the center of everything is about to run away with the game, and the only layer of doubt is these seemingly unnecessary strategic check ins that give them so much credit.
These conflicting tidbits make the decision feel so impossible, that I question; have I already gotten it wrong? Is Thien An Erika? Is Mike the Alligabler? Is Maggie mother?
No. Well, except for that last one.
I am confident that one of Sharonda or Jelly is the winner, and I believe I can come to the right conclusion if I just stop overcomplicating it.
I think the answer is right in front of me.
The philosophy behind this experiment, since I started it back in Survivor 47, has been that it is possible to find the winner of the season by looking at who the edit is telling us is losing, rather than who it's telling us is winning. Every writeup, whether the decision on who to eliminate is glaringly obvious, or painfully obfuscated, the way I land on that decision has always been guided by that philosophy: Who is the edit telling us is losing Survivor?
To try to say that this episode has told us that Sharonda is losing would be completely disingenuous.
Am I completely 100% certain that we are being told Jelly is losing? No, and in a perfect world, I'd have a couple more weeks to make that call, but I don't. Being forced to make the call, I completely see the world that this episode has told us Jelly is losing.
Therefore:
The Winner of Survivor 51; Sharonda.




