r/Environmentalism • u/Alternative_Try1933 • 3h ago
People say they want "balance/nuance" in environmental stories, but really just want "Humans=Good, Nature=Bad."
Anytime you have a story that's "nature=good, humans=bad," people hate it. Yet, when it's the exact inverse, people love it. Princess Mononoke is a prime example. The movie conveys that, no matter how flawed humans are, that they're just misunderstood and the people who destroy nature are "just trying to make lives better for humanity." Meanwhile, nature is portrayed as just straight-up violent and horrible with almost no redeeming factors beyond "it's pretty," along with absolutely no good reason to care about nature besides some hamfisted "humans need nature" BS. Don't show the struggles animals go through unless you can ALSO show those animals as bloodthirsty monsters who need to be killed. And that's a big reason people LOVE this movie. They LOVE that it demonizes nature.
Most "good" environmental media seems to follow this. Hoppers also kind of did this. Nature is "cute," and beyond King George, is portrayed as inherantly horrible and violent and wanting to kill humans and blah blah blah. And speaking of which...
God forbid humanity ever be held accountable for environmental destruction. This also seems to be a rule: humans are never allowed to take the fall. They're never allowed to learn a lesson or actually recieve a consequence for their actions. One of the most beloved 3DS games of all time, Kid Icarus Uprising, does exactly this. It portrays blind worship of humanity as a goodthing and an animal lover who is corrupt and horrible UNTILL she learns to turn her back on nature and condemn it to an existance of suffering at the hands of humanity. And the game wants to convince me that it's a good thing. Like, whatever. Genociding the entire species is wrong, I get that. But that doesn't mean I want NOTHING to happen. That doesn't mean I just want humans to get NOTHING in the form of a consequence for everything they did. Because I sure as fuck do NOT want the continued suffering of nature, but the game seems to think I should want that.
Not to mention animal lovers and vegans in media are almost UNIVERSIALLY portrayed as no-nuance horrible people in media, yet no one cares. People love King Of The Hill DESPITE having zero-nuance takes on these people. They had the chance to change this with Willow, but even she ended up getting the "Fuck You!" from the show writers. No one but Bobby Hill respected her, and once she pooped on that man's chair (or whatever) she was written out of the show and it just comes off as infuriating to see pretty much every vegan character except Aang portrayed as an inherantly unlikable person. ...and I'm not even vegan. I'm just sick of these stereotypes.