I feel the need to discuss the distribution of strangers' nudes in NSFW accounts or communities on X, reddit, former tumblr etc.
Long story short:
If you don't have someone's consent, you don't slap their butt just cause they were slutty in public.
So, if you don't have someone's consent, you don't share their nudes just cause they were slutty in public plattforms, right?
Long story long:
Next to revenge porn and deepfakes, image-based sexual abuse (IBSA) also lists a rather new definition of consent violation: The consent to an image being created (1), posted (2) and shared outside the original community or account (3) are divided in three different stages. Each stage requires seperate consent by the subject. And consent can be withdrawn later.
My question is: Does this include the following case?
If an adult industry content creator creates an intimate image (1, with consent) and posts it via his or an authorized account or publisher (2, with consent) - and this account or plattform being public - did they automatically give limitless consent to redistribute their content somewhere else (3)? Especially when they are not informed or credited?
I know there are concerns about copyrights and money. But I want to focus on the person's bodily autonomy, personal rights and consent.
Why? There are lot's of NSFW communities and accounts on Reddit, X and other media based social networks, where trading nudes of other people is encouraged. Usually the subjects or artists aren't credited. With the source being untraceable, the consent of each stage is unknown. In my opinion you can never assume consent to all three stages just by the media itself. But even if the source can be reconstructed, amateur accounts dominating these communities probably rarely check with the subject's consent.
If consent is affirmative (only yes means yes), does that mean a relevant amount of NSFW media reshares is problematic?
Current guidelines usually focus on the prohibition of non consensual intimate media. But if the consent is unknown, it indicates it's the victims job to call out violations of their consent (no means no). But shouldn't it be the other way around? If you can't prove consent of the subject, simply don't distribute their nudes?
As I already stated, I am especially interested in what this means for NSFW communities and social media accounts built around sharing others' intimate media.