r/Exvangelical • u/uncut_macaroni • 4h ago
My Fundie friend made an interesting observation.
I have a fundie friend who recently made an interesting observation about the evangelical church. He is your fairly standard KJV only, women should be silent kind of fundamentalist, but we respect each other's boundaries, so somehow it works.
We were discussing the intersection of religion and politics. He is, interestingly enough, very anti-Trump. During the conversation, he made the observation that part of the problem with the evangelical church is how it approaches teaching. In his view, much of what happens in church isn't really teaching at all.
A teacher doesn't simply stand in front of a classroom and deliver a monologue. Legitimate teaching involves questions and answers. The teacher asks students questions to gauge their understanding, while students are given the opportunity to ask questions of their own to clarify what they don't understand. This process serves another important purpose. It holds the teacher accountable for actually knowing and understanding the subject being taught.
The church, however, often operates very differently. The preacher delivers a monologue, the congregation listens, and questions are rarely encouraged or welcomed. There is little opportunity to challenge an interpretation, seek clarification, or explore the complexities of what is being presented.
This has been the model for generations, and I think his observation raises an important point. It creates an environment where preachers can become intellectually lazy because they aren't regularly challenged to defend or explain what they teach, while congregations can become intellectually passive because they aren't expected to question, investigate, or develop their own understanding.
Eventually, the preacher becomes accustomed to speaking without being challenged, and the congregation becomes accustomed to listening without questioning. That's not education. That's the cultivation of an echo chamber.