I have a league member who is 2-8 and was trying to run 8 Bears players. I told him he was throwing and so he played Johnathan Taylor and now he's blaming me for controling his lineup.
To be clear, this is a 6 man league and you need to score a lot of points to win. 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 Flex, K, DST. (I know many of you think 6 man leagues are a joke, but it's really fun and meaningful for us)
His original lineup had Caleb Williams, D'Andre Swift, Kyle Monangai, Luther Burden, Kalif Raymond, Colston Loveland, Cairo Santos, and the Bears DST.
I just told him he needs to figure out a better lineup and that 8 is too much from the same team, especially in our league. I never told him to do anything specific, only that he has too many Bears. I might have called out Raymond and Monangai as the obvious bad ones.
So he started JT on Thursday and only got 5.2 pts in our league. Now he is saying I controlled his lineup and would have ran Monangai had I not interfeared and is giving me a hard time about it. I'm honeslty pretty bitter, because in my mind this was a joke and if I just didn't say anything he probably would have played JT anyway, but now that JT did bad; he gets to act like I'm the jerk.
Looking for honest feedback here. Was I out of line when I told him 8 is too many Bears players? I feel like it would be irresponsible to let him run that lineup when others are competing for playoff spots.
Also, what's the number on how many players from the same team is too much? In my mind, 3 is a lot, 4 you are over invested, 5 is soft throwing, 8 is definitely throwing. But, apparently, I need a reality check.
Edit: $175 Buy-in Re-Draft