r/FanFiction • • 1d ago

Subreddit Meta Concrit Commune - November 21

5 Upvotes

Welcome to the Concrit Commune, where you can get bits of your fic looked at... for a small "price."

For the purposes of this thread, concrit is defined as - pointing out things that could use improvement and also giving suggestions on how to do so. Compliments are always welcome, of course but these do not count towards your concrit requirement.

The rules:

  • State your Fandom | Title | Rating | Any Applicable Content Warnings | Link - AO3, FFN, etc. at the top of the comment.
  • Post a few paragraphs (copy and paste to a comment, please) of your fic, or your plot premise, or your character bio, or your world building, whatever you need help with.
  • There is a soft limit of 500 words. Not your whole fic.
  • Please post an outside link to underage and extreme-explicit violence/rape content. Try Just Paste Me which includes rich text options.
  • If you, the author, are looking for something specific - the phrasing of a particular part or if a character's reaction is believable - please ask!
  • If you just want to hand out advice without throwing your own fic in, you're quite welcome to.
  • If you post part of your fic you must give concrit to someone else in the thread within 24 hours of posting your excerpt!

Since we're all here to give and receive help from other people, a certain level of respect for the author and the work they've put into their fic is expected as a baseline courtesy and should be reciprocated.

Tearing into a fic or author without regard for their effort isn't constructive even if there is decent criticism attached. Moreover, it discourages people from participating if they know that insults await them.

You aren't expected to treat this thread like the Comment Cooperative, advice and honesty and pointing out flaws is what we're here for.

Some helpful tips to keep things running smoothly:

  • Keep your comments helpful to the author, not just smashing out your opinion.
  • Be polite and civil.
  • Be kind. At a minimum, showing your peers professional courtesy is expected.
  • Phrases like "I think" or "I believe" can lighten your tone.
  • Elaborating on why you think something could be changed is not only more useful to the author but keeps statements from being abrupt.

Timezone Changes

As you can see, the post time will shift by 6 hours every month. If there are any inconsistencies in the times, please let us know in modmail so we can fix it up!

MonthsPSTEDTGMTCESTJSTAESTNZT
February, June, OctoberSaturday: 8:30amSaturday: 11:30amSaturday: 3:30pmSaturday: 5:30pmSunday: 12:30amSunday: 1:30amSunday: 3:30am
March, July, NovemberSaturday: 2:30amSaturday: 5:30amSaturday: 9:30amSaturday: 11:30amSaturday: 6:30pmSaturday: 7:30pmSaturday: 9:30pm
April, August, DecemberFriday: 8:30pmFriday: 11:30pmSaturday: 3:30amSaturday: 5:30amSaturday: 12:30pmSaturday: 1:30pmSaturday: 3:30pm
May, January, SeptemberSaturday: 2:30pmSaturday: 5:30pmSaturday: 9:30pmSaturday: 11:30pmSunday: 6:30amSunday: 7:30amSunday: 9:30am

Please note that there may be a difference of an hour during parts of the year due to daylight savings in various timezones.


r/FanFiction • • 8h ago

Subreddit Meta Brainstorming Bureau - November 22

4 Upvotes

Find the current Daily Discussion*

Welcome to our weekly thread, Brainstorming Bureau! This is an idea we've trialled previously and, based on feedback and observation, it feels like something the sub has been crying out for, and we're hoping as the weeks go by it'll turn into a lively, community-oriented way to cap off the weekend. We'd love to hear your feedback and suggestions on how to make the best of this idea, so feel free to reach out via modmail if you have any ideas. And without further ado...

What's this about?

Do you have an issue that's too specific to your own fic to make a post about, but too small to seek out a long-term beta or writing partner for? Well, you've come to the right place!

This is where you can drop those plot points you're stuck on ("How would this scenario play out realistically? What should happen next?"), workshop your worldbuilding and concepts ("What should I name this character? What power should I give them? Which fandom would work well as a crossover with this other fandom?"), or get a second opinion on an approach to character development ("Is this a good central conflict? What would have to happen to make a character realise this?"). It's your space to talk through any issue that can't be solved through more generalised writing advice.

How to play:

To participate, comment with any aspect of your fic you've been mulling over or hitting a wall with. Other users will then respond with suggestions and questions to help you get to where you need to be. No idea is too big or too small, provided your comment fits within the parameters below. Feel free to be as fandom blind or specific as you like!

Rules:

  • Please state your fandom at the top of your comment, along with any common and pertinent content warnings
  • NSFW text should be placed behind a spoiler tag or linked to, as per site content restrictions
  • Summarise the issue you'd like feedback on in 500 words or less. More information may be given in follow-up comments if requested
  • Links to polls or to any previous installments of the fic will be permitted for context
  • Please specify in your comment what level of critical feedback you're open to
  • When responding to someone's ideas, please keep your feedback constructive and keep their specified level of criticism in mind. If their premise is not to your taste, please choose another
  • If you make a submission to this thread, much like the other weekly events, please comment on at least one other user's request with the best suggestions you have
  • When submitting an idea for brainstorming, please provide adequate context for others to be able to follow along. Remember that this is a multi-fandom subreddit, and not everyone will be familiar with your fandom.

Have fun! And remember, all suggestions are just that and are to be taken with a grain of salt; we're here to help and consider our works from angles we haven't before.


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Discussion My friend told me I was on fire while I was writing fanfiction. Turns out, my house actually was.

57 Upvotes

I genuinely cannot make this up.

For reference, I and my friend mentioned here are both mods of the SquidgeWorld subreddit.

Last night, I was working on my Harry Potter Fanfiction — something I’d written already five years ago but I’m trying to revive. Anyway, I’d just finished polishing and posting two chapters, so naturally, I hopped into our Reddit Mod Discord to share my little accomplishment. Because that’s why we do what we do… dopamine and praise.

Anywho… At exactly 8:41 PM, my moderator friend responded:
“Fuck yeah, look at you go, you’re on fire!”

Well.

Well, well, well…

At approximately 9:00 PM, we discovered that MY HOUSE WAS LITERALLY ON FIRE.

By the time we noticed, the flames had already climbed up the exterior of the building from the bottom story to the top. Judging by how far the fire had spread… there’s a very real possibility that the house was already BURNING when my friend sent that message.

Which means I was sitting there, happily discussing my fanfiction, while my house was potentially ON FIRE.

The timing… The wording… The sheer INSANITY of it all.

Guys, be careful when you tell your writing friends that they’re, “on fire”. THEY MAY ACTUALLY BE ON FIRE.

And please use caution when posting more than one chapter at a time.

Anyway, I guess that’s one way to celebrate updating your fic.


r/FanFiction • • 3h ago

Discussion Now that it’s been a week, what was the first comment you got post ao3 coming back?

38 Upvotes

Or what was the first comment you left?


r/FanFiction • • 4h ago

Resources Looking for a smaller, genuinely welcoming Discord community for fanfiction writers (30+)

33 Upvotes

Hi everyone! 

I’m wondering whether anyone knows of a friendly, relatively small Discord server for older fanfiction writers, preferably 30+?

I’ve tried quite a few servers over the years, but haven’t really found one where I’ve managed to settle in. Everyone is usually very welcoming at first, which is lovely, but I’ve often found it difficult to get beyond those initial introductions. People often have their established friendships and little groups, and it can be hard to find your footing and become part of the conversation as a newcomer.

I’m hoping to find somewhere a little more close-knit and inclusive, where people genuinely enjoy getting to know one another, chatting about writing, sharing ideas and occasionally reading each other’s work.

I also write for two absolutely microscopic fandoms (population: me), so I’m certainly not expecting to find anyone who shares my particular interests. I’d just love to meet some like-minded writers who are at least open to unfamiliar fandoms and enjoy a good conversation.

I’m not looking for a huge, bustling server where it’s impossible to keep up, just a friendly, reasonably active little community where newcomers can gradually feel like part of the furniture.

If anyone has any recommendations, I’d be very grateful! 


r/FanFiction • • 3h ago

Venting Quality of writing having gone down

15 Upvotes

I only started writing back in January, but I feel like the quality of my writing has gone down tremendously instead of improved. While reading back, I do notice mistakes I made earlier this year, but I also notice the fact that I used to effortlessly string sentences together and just come up with scene ideas in general.

My friend tells me it's just writers block, which also factors into it, I guess, but it also just feels like I lost a bit of spark. I used to be able to write 10-15k each week--I even wrote a 17k oneshot in twenty-four hours--and now I'm happy if I can write even 1k. It's honestly driving me crazy.

I tried everything I could think of: reading back my own works and dissecting it to see how I wrote the way I did, reading other fics and books, forcing myself to write just to get something on paper, switching between different projects at once to see if any of them stick, writing with a timer where your fingers can't leave your keyboard, etc. It still doesn't help. The quality has gone down, and I'm actually quite sad/mad about it, because why can't I do the one thing I love anymore?


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Activities and Events Word Game Excerpt Challenge

8 Upvotes

Hello all! The excerpt games keep me writing and I hope it motivates with your writing as well.  You can post any type of story (use NSFW for spicier scenes).  

I will be posting this challenge on Sunday Mornings / Pacific Time… because that day I need the most help to not think about Monday.

If you have stumbled into my game and are looking for more, remember to check out the Activities and Events flair for other writing challenges and story swaps.

Here are the rules:

 The first word starts the game.  Use ANY letter from the word that is posted in the last comment as the starting letter of your word.  Post your word in the top level comment.   Your word drives the next word to be posted… and so on.  

**Example:  LOVE  >>>>  VILE. (If the word Love is in the comment line you could make the word Vile and post the next comment.)**

Reply to any of the words in the top level with an excerpt from any work you might want to share.  I don’t generally like word limits, so use your best judgment.  Enough to get the scene across but not so long that you lose your reader.  

Please use spoiler tags and/or provide a trigger warning for content that may be NSFW or sensitive. IF IN DOUBT - Give a warning!

If you are going to leave excerpts, I ask that you leave at least one top-level word and try to give at minimum an upvote to commenters.

Upvote your favorite words or excerpts.  We are all here to share and know how it feels to get a comment, so spread the love.  

Ganbatte!!  Do your best and I look forward to everyone’s excerpts!


r/FanFiction • • 14h ago

Celebrate I did it! 🥹

Thumbnail reddit.com
51 Upvotes

r/FanFiction • • 23h ago

Discussion What fandoms are there that have no canon source material?

139 Upvotes

Hello, I'm making a video and I need some more fandoms that have little to no actual "canon" source material. The only ones I've got are vocaloid and the marauders.

I would need like 2 more, please.

Even better if those fandoms are now basically dead, but any will suffice :D


r/FanFiction • • 55m ago

Writing Questions How to improve my english (fast)

1 Upvotes

I have already started writing a fic and everytime i update I don't feel like i improved. At all.

I know it takes a lot of reading and writing to improve, but i feel like i am able to write in my brain better than how i deliver it on keyboard. It's basically feels like all of my english just disappears whatever i try to write, and I don't want to underpreform. I feel like i have so much more potential, but i am stuck with the same words over and over.

And my chapters relay heavily on this words:

But/And/So/Plus/He knows/He wants.

Yes i checked those are the most used words

And my dialogue is lacking too. Maybe because i am an introvert, and i barley speak as it is... But still!!

I still haven't tried to write smut cause i am scared of that too, and i REALLY want to get better, at least a little bit before i update my next chapter!!

Any advice??


r/FanFiction • • 59m ago

Recs Wanted Looking for jjk fic recs

0 Upvotes

Really obsessed with jjk rn, just wondering if anyone has any REALLY long gen fics, preferably focused around yuji or all three of the first years. I also love time travel fics, andd crack fics


r/FanFiction • • 1d ago

Discussion There's nothing sadder than a story randomly being deleted

112 Upvotes

I think this is something we can all agree about. For me, there's is nothing sadder than reading a story - or wanting to read specific one later - only to then find out that the author deleted it inexplicably some time after it was uploaded.

This has happened to me multiple times, where I would read a story in progress and patiently wait for a new chapter to drop, only to go check on it and discover that the story is no longer there. But sometimes, I wouldn't even get to read the story in the first place before it got deleted.

I was recently reading some Peanuts fanfics when I stumbled onto one posted a few days ago with the ship tags "Sally/Linus" - I thought they were a relatively cute dynamic that doesn't really get that much attention in fanfics, so I thought I'd read it later. So I try to look it up the next day and come to discover it was no longer there.

I felt a little demoralized, but I think the most unfortunate thing about it is the fact that it was up for just a handful of days max. There's an odd feeling in having a story disappear just as quickly as it came, especially when they are supposed to be multi-chaptered too but the writer drops the towel first moment in.

Anyone agree?


r/FanFiction • • 1h ago

Lost Fic Looking for a Bedrock Bros (Tommyinnit & Technoblade) story

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Discussion Whumpy stuck updated stuff

2 Upvotes

I have made a updated post regarding the whumpy version of characters getting stuck in a wall or something but to also discuss the other kinds of whump that can go along with it.

- Environmental whump. If the wall the whumpee is stuck in has no protection from above, then they're out of luck while stuck. Cold, freezing snow falling all around them, rain falling on them and making them wet and cold and possibly making their being stuck situation even worse, the hot blazing sun shining down on them, etc. Alternatively a wild animal that's a predator could eventually spot whumpee and see an easy meal and the whumpee has nowhere to run or any hope of escape.

- A whumper eventually coming by and seeing the whumpee stuck in the wall but they decide to just give whumpee false hope in saving them and either makes the whumpee get even more stuck somehow or keeps leaving to go and 'get some tools or friends to help' but always comes back with inefficient tools or their friends 'couldn't come'.

- Alternatively a whumper could have shoved whumpee into the hole and leave them there as punishment, making sure to make the hole as small as possible so whumpee has no way to get out.

- Emotional whump in that whumpee thinks they're going to die stuck in a wall when no one has come to save them.

- Just pure, desperate struggling to get free, twisting their body, using their hands and feet for leverage, anything to break free from their predicament. Nothing works.

- The fear that comes with realizing they're truly stuck with no way to free themselves, especially effective if they find that they're really, really stuck that they need people to help them get unstuck.

- Getting stuck in a hole in a cave wall, the darkness, the oppressive atmosphere of the cave, the claustrophobia from the cave and being stuck in such a compromising position.


r/FanFiction • • 9h ago

Subreddit Meta Share Your Progress Sunday - November 22

4 Upvotes

Here at Share Your Progress Sunday, please share what you are currently working on and what you’ve posted in the past week!

Please label as:

Summary - This may include a brief summary of your last posted chapter and how close you are to finishing the new chapter. Feel free to use this opportunity to tell us a bit about your fic.

If you would like to leave a link to the posted chapter, please use the format below.

Fic Posting

Fandom -

Title of fic (and chapter #/title if desired) -

Rating -

Genre -

Links to AO3/FFN/other sites -

Small description or summary -

Anything else you'd like to share about this fic -


r/FanFiction • • 16h ago

Recs Wanted Underutilized characters in Time Travel and Crossover fics

15 Upvotes

I have a special place in my heart for both time travel and crossover fics in any fandom, but I have noticed that often times it’s the same 2 or 3 characters that end up being used in most of the stories (looking at you Obi-Wan). Does anyone have any high-quality time travel or crossover fics focusing on side characters? Any fandom welcome


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Lost Fic Help searching for a Naruto alt. Universe fanfiction

1 Upvotes

So a few years ago i read a sasunaru alt. Universe, i think it was a famtasy setting, on ao3 i think.

I can only remember that kurama was some sort of dragon horse and that the plot was that they were both princes in an arranged mariage but i think naruto blew it off? And then there was a sort of War where they met again and fell in love.

I dont know when or where i read it exactly or of its deleted. But if anyone knows anything more please tell.


r/FanFiction • • 9h ago

Subreddit Meta Daily Discussion - Sunday, November 22 | r/FanFiction Rules, FAQs, Weekly Schedule, & Current Event Threads

3 Upvotes

Welcome to r/FanFiction, I love you!

New to this subreddit? Here are links to get you started: Rules & Overview | Wiki | FAQs

Sunday is Brainstorming Bureau for your brainstorming and idea exchange needs.

Got a fic to promote? Click HERE to find the current Weekly Fic Showcase thread

Current Events

  • An AO3 downtime which may last 2-4 weeks has been in place since the end of October. We will be informing you as there are updates. Please check the pinned threads.
  • For the time being, we will have a weekly fic request/offer thread for users to swap downloaded fics. These will be pinned as well. Please check the pinned threads.
  • Until the downtime is over, you can link your own fics as an archive in the Weekly Showcase. This will be pinned as well.
  • No AO3 doesn't mean no fun! There will be mod and user-organized activities. Please keep an eye on the "Activities and Events" flair.

Don't forget to participate in our special events:

Got a question or concern? Feel free to message the mod team.


r/FanFiction • • 16h ago

Writing Questions How do you get ideas for fanfiction?

9 Upvotes

Hello all.

I haven't been writing for a long time, my skill has been lacking in that department. Recently, i've found that i've lost all ideas for anything i like.

It's hard for me to picture things that characters (in any fandom i'm in) are doing out of canon. It hasn't ALWAYS been like this, and i don't know what's happening.

Any advice to get the plot bunnies moving in my head would be nice!


r/FanFiction • • 14h ago

Recs Wanted Looking for a very flawed relationship, preferably modern stetting.

6 Upvotes

" I like relationships that are like, this is the best these two people (any sexuality or preference) could do under the circumstances and it's pretty bad sometimes love doesn't heal you or fix all your problems. sometimes love is an end unto itself. the love was there and it mostly made things weirder" saw this somewhere. Hopefully, theres a book out there that captures its essence. I don't mind darker books as long as the parties involved are adults. Smut is not a requirement.


r/FanFiction • • 17h ago

Writing Questions What’s your process for writing a oneshot?

10 Upvotes

I’ve seen people talking about sitting down and writing a few thousand words and completing a oneshot from start to finish.

For whatever reason, I get an idea, write a few notes in my phone, then I fill in scraps of dialogue, then I add actions to the dialogue and write the in-between bits, and there are still some unfinished gaps with “blah blah blah” or “they go to bed.” Finally I go over it and edit and tweak everything. I’m working on a series of oneshots that are like 1000-2000 words and it always takes me multiple days to get it to a point where it’s good enough to post.

I wish the entire work would just flow onto the page all at once, but for some reason it doesn’t!


r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Lost Fic Nightwing Fic

1 Upvotes

There is this nightwing fic where he takes revenge on joker for killing jason and many other reasons. but he did it in a way where he crossdresses by wearing heels and even slade wilson was so impressed he got scared.

that's all I remember from that fic please help me 😭🥺


r/FanFiction • • 15h ago

Writing Questions When you're doing a crossover.

5 Upvotes

Apologies if this sounds dumb but. For those who make crossover fics. Do you re-read or research the series you're less knowledgeable about?

I currently make lots of those and I'm nervous of making a mistake involving certain characters. Hope I explained this well, I just wanted a bit of advice


r/FanFiction • • 59m ago

Writing Questions Оцените концепт фанфика: попаданец с Системой, гачей и 100 мирами (старт в «Ходячих мертвецах»). Нужны советы по балансу и предложите миры

0 Upvotes

Всем привет! Пишу фанфик про героя с Системой и хочу посоветоваться насчет баланса способностей и сюжета. Буду рад любой критике и идеям.

Суть сюжета:

Герою нужно пройти 100 миров. В каждом мире у него есть 25 лет, чтобы стать там самым сильным. Первый мир для старта — «Ходячие мертвецы».

Как устроена Система:

Гача: завязана на текущем мире (можно выбить предметы, навыки или «куртки» из лора этого мира).

Задания: стандартные квесты для прогресса.

Вкладка «Формы»: открывается позже, когда герой поглотит достаточно существ. Позволит принимать облик Дракона, Демона, Бога и Космической сущности и другие.

Три главные способности героя:

  1. Путешествие между мирами (с таймером в 25 лет и условием стать сильнейшим).
  2. Поглощение генов и самих существ.

Ограничения: нельзя поглотить того, кто сильнее героя (либо ген усвоиться неполноценным и сильно ослабленным). Если существо равное по силе — внутри сознания/тела начинается битва за главенство.

3. Поглощение энергии. Работает по тем же жестким правилам, что и поглощение генов (только равные или слабые, иначе риск или штраф).

Не слишком ли имбовым (слишком сильным) получается герой к 3–4 миру?

Какие интересные гены можно забрать в первом мире («Ходячие мертвецы»), кроме банального иммунитета к вирусу и регенерации?

Как лучше удержать интерес читателя, если миров целых 100? Думаю, часть из них потом придется описывать коротко, иначе книга станет бесконечной.

Ещё хочу добавить один момент: я стараюсь ставить себя на место главного героя и думать, как бы я сам поступил в его ситуации. Например, какие меры предосторожности я бы выбрал, как распределял бы силы, какие способности развивал в первую очередь и как использовал бы свои знания лора, чтобы получить преимущество в каждом мире.

Мне интересно, насколько такой подход будет интересен читателям и не приведёт ли он к тому, что герой станет слишком сильным слишком быстро. Хочется сохранить баланс между знаниями героя, его решениями и уровнем силы, чтобы он не превращался в непобедимого персонажа.

Заранее спасибо за ответы!


r/FanFiction • • 12h ago

Writing Questions How to change between languages in a fic?

2 Upvotes

I'm planning on writing a fanfic which is somewhat a "foreigner x local" trope. The fic is being written in English but the setting is in a different country. How should I distinguish between English and different languages when the characters are speaking? Thanks in advance!