r/Fauxmoi • • 15h ago

FILM-MOI (MOVIES/TV) Home Alone's director, Chris Columbus, didn't know a new sequel written by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg was coming. He had just said there is no new film without Catherine O’Hara.

Post image
462 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

79

u/Nervous_Insect5976 15h ago

I can see why he would feel that way.

I’m keeping an open mind, but I won’t be surprised if I’m disappointed.

56

u/actionmarkers88 15h ago

I mean there was already a 3 and a 4?

20

u/OneUseHero 15h ago

5 and 6 even!

1

u/Foxy02016YT 14h ago

Correct, and none of them are worth watching

26

u/CakeSpade 15h ago

Yes, but Mac is returning in this one. He wasn't in 3 or 4.

1

u/Historical-Record227 9h ago

The character was in 4 though. As was hers.

536

u/woolfonmynoggin padre pascal 15h ago • Bravo

It’s ghoulish, in bad taste, and I don’t want it

121

u/michaelbchnn24 14h ago • Bravo

Ghoulish is so over the top. Catherine literally spent the last years of her life staring in Home alone themed credit card ads with Kevin Hart as the Kevin McAllister insert. I don't think she's rolling over in her grave.

267

u/Foxy02016YT 14h ago • Bravo

It’s not ghoulish. There have been like 4 sequels without her, or anyone from the original movies for that matter.

It’s only in bad taste because every single one of those movies sucked.

22

u/reluctantseahorse #whoremembers 10h ago

Weren't there two more just released over the past few years? I know there was the one with the kid from jojo rabbit. I thought there was another one after that too.

Why is this even being framed as a sequel? There are at least 3 movies in the series after the McAllister family ones. It's a franchise at this point and none of them have anything to do with Catherine O'Hara after the first two.

And I say this as a HUGE Catherine O'Hara fan.

5

u/Lopsided_Parfait7127 14h ago

Ebert and i agree - 3 was actually better than 2 or 1

28

u/vmachiel 14h ago

3 had those criminals looking for a microchip right?

I remember liking it as a kid, but that’s no guarantee it’s a good movie.

9

u/Foxy02016YT 14h ago

Okay I’ve heard that from a few people and, tis’ the season, so I may be putting that hypothesis to the test this year

1

u/TimeshareMachine 6h ago

It's the last one written by John Hughes.

1

u/montycuddles 12h ago

My grandmother thinks this too because "the kid in 3 is cuter"

62

u/itsgonevery 15h ago

Why is it "ghoulish"?

75

u/PaleontologistNo5420 15h ago edited 15h ago

Some pieces of art are tied to someone’s legacy. No one can speak for O’Hara (maybe she would have loved this idea!), but I think it’s understandable that fans of the original franchise find this to be a nostalgic cash grab  

27

u/Foxy02016YT 14h ago

Buddy, this would just be another nostalgic cash grab in a franchise full of them.

There are more than 2 movies, but there are only 2 good ones

52

u/NarrativeNode 14h ago

Seth Rogen and O’Hara were friends. I’m nearly certain they’d have spoken about this.

48

u/ConstantRefills 14h ago

Unless they’re putting a CGI version of O’Hara like they did Harold Ramis in Ghostbusters, which I doubt, I don’t really see a problem with making a sequel today.

-3

u/Courier12pt 15h ago

It’s just a movie… People who fixate their identity and self-worth to a piece of media are so ludicrous . Just don’t watch it if it doesn’t align with your moral barometer.

-7

u/PaleontologistNo5420 14h ago

I pity people who can’t see the soul and spirit in art. A movie isn’t always “just a movie” 

13

u/rednaxthecreature 14h ago

So every sequel needs to have a stamp of approval of the main caste to be made? Does Culkin's involvement not matter in this regard?

-4

u/Nilosyrtis PURE OUT OF CONTROL RAGE AND VIOLENCE  14h ago

5

u/ghostwiththeleast so kiss me and I might live más 14h ago

Different circumstances but this is how I feel about Princess Diaries 3 without Garry Marshall

9

u/dakilazical_253 14h ago • Heartwarming

Please, call me Garry

61

u/anythinganything18 15h ago

I just can't imagine the series having another good movie without her in it

16

u/Grimlocks_Ballsack 15h ago

So far it hasn’t.  But I like this idea, esp if they get Stern and Pesci back

16

u/rokthemonkey 14h ago

I really liked 3 personally and that didn’t have her

5

u/TCoMonteCristo 11h ago

I think it could work if part of the film's core pathos was partially around Catherine O'Hara not being there

8

u/Historical-Record227 10h ago

Well kind of a stupid sentiment considering there's been 4 Home Alone films already made without her involved.

I understand the sentiment but it's just at odds with reality.

17

u/bartelbyfloats 15h ago

I have no interest in seeing nostalgia bait anyway.

2

u/Newwavecybertiger 3h ago

It's very sad such an absolute icon died, but there is no movie reason they can't do a sequel to home alone. People in their 40s have dead parents all the time. Give a tribute to her with a funny gag and move on. It'll be a shitty movie anyway

1

u/Ifonliesandjusts 14h ago

Doing it without Catherine and without Chris is weird

32

u/Foxy02016YT 14h ago

Why? They did it 4 times already

Trust me, none of those 4 are good

0

u/PoliteQueef 8h ago

I think you’re essentially proving their point

0

u/Minglu07 12h ago

It thought that was Seth Mcfarlane for a second.

-6

u/TheNocturnalAngel 14h ago

I meant with her without her literally why make this

-7

u/ImaginationDoctor 13h ago

It's especially rich considering Seth just worked with Catherine. For him to write a sequel to a fun that arguably doesn't work without her is pretty stupid.

-2

u/Glum_Spot_465 13h ago

What gives them the right?!

27

u/PyramidicContainment too high to spell 'Amanda Seyfried' 15h ago

I actually just watched Catherine O' Hara in an episode of Outer Limits last night! s3e15.

Based on the Stephen King story "The Revelations of Becka Paulson", about a woman who accidentally shoots herself in the head and survives. She starts receiving info and hearing voices, including having convos with a guy from the generic background inside an 8x10 photograph that she bought.

This also enables her to take revenge on her cheating husband, but I don't wanna spoil the ending. She was fantastic!