r/Fauxmoi • • 10h ago • Popcorn 1

STAN / ANTI SHIELD Journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin asks Hailey Bieber why she thought she could sell Rhode for a $1 billion

416 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

1.9k

u/elloitsmeadele before we get married i gotta go fuck this guy 10h ago edited 8h ago • This Bravo Mindblown

if you watch the full interview, he’d ask about the business side of things and she didn’t really answer those questions

she’s one of the founders and (former) business owners and she can’t even explain the reasoning behind the company’s evaluation. she couldn’t even directly answer other business questions, even the most basic ones. the interview confirmed what people always say about these celeb-owned brands - they’re simply a company mascot. they don’t talk about finances, strategies, or business practices because they’re not involved with that and there are experts who make the brand what it is

ETA: hailey stans, replying to this comment by sending me chat requests isn’t going to change how this interview was received

619

u/International_Ant953 9h ago • Popcorn Bravo

I saw someone say that these brands are essentially celebrity merch.

194

u/Famoslastwords 8h ago

Celebrity grift.

47

u/Brave-Primary319 7h ago

There was a Rhode ad that kept popping up for me on YouTube a few years ago where she was walking through her skincare routine with the brand. Seemed unscripted, but she was fumbling the talking points hard and it was obvious she didn’t understand the benefits or science of the products at all. I wasn’t expecting her to be a genius but was shocked her team greenlit the ad. She truly sounded like she had no idea what she was talking about.

61

u/uterusturd 10h ago

Yeah I would assume so, you don't just figure out business out of sheer will, it makes sense they hire qualified people to handle the specifics. But she can't just sell being beautiful, girlboss is also part of the visual they're selling women now so she has to try and fake that

21

u/mulderitsme 8h ago

Yeah I kind of see the celebrities personal brand as representing the ethos of the makeup brand, but I doubt they are as hands on as people would like to think. Hailey was basically a celebrity they could shape into anything they needed since, as she said, the idea of the brand came before deciding how to market herself in order to sell the brand. Honestly, kind of genius from the actual minds behind Rhode— who would have thought a generally disliked nepowife could actually build such a following?

10

u/CustardApple- 7h ago

They knew they could garner support from people who are ok with plantation weddings and ‘racism is a phase everyone goes through’-types.

42

u/CustardApple- 5h ago

The fact that he didn’t even broach the topic about how the products faced so many quality complaints about mold even after the sale, was pretty soft already. I don’t believe these questions were not screened. She and her team are just ill-prepared and egoistic enough to think they can wing it like all the softball influencer podcasts they usually go to.

Eat the rich. I’m really not here for nepos and their parasocial stans crying about how they’re sad that the general public sees through the entitled behaviour, as though they are ‘harmless’. Reminder that this lady pulled the rug from an established clothing women-led brand with the same name. And her fans basically went all “it should be promised to her because of her name”-bs. They swore up and down she’s not doing a clothing line. And here we are, she’s releasing clothes. 

358

u/thatgirlzhao 9h ago • Bravo

Respectfully, I’m not saying you can’t self learn, but she didn’t even graduate high school. She likely is unable to do math more advance than high school algebra (if that). I am not saying this to put her down or say she’s incapable of running a successful business, but of course she needs to bring in experts for things like finance.

431

u/Walking_the_dead 9h ago • Bravo

You're not saying she's  incapable, but i sure am. She is and this interview clearly shows she didnt run shit. 

There's plenty of sucessful self taught people within degrees actually runnin businesses out there, she's not one of them.

167

u/elloitsmeadele before we get married i gotta go fuck this guy 8h ago edited 8h ago • Bravo

i’m not saying she should be working every single position at the company, obviously she’s not going down to the third floor to do accounting. but, she was asked simple business questions and she couldn’t even answer them as the founder and one of the owners of the brand. as we see in the clip above.

39

u/thatgirlzhao 8h ago

I think maybe I didn’t articulate myself clearly, I am agreeing with you! I am just adding, I think the lack of even a complete high school education is an obvious blocker for why she couldn’t be the complete brains behind this business

37

u/BookQueen13 8h ago

It's crazy to me that someone who didn't even graduate high school was handed a billion dollar business because of her name and face.

7

u/abhasatin 3h ago

She wasn't. She was part owner. I think 1/3rd

22

u/Decent-Statistician8 4h ago

I am not standing up for her I’m just saying I did graduate HS and I couldn’t do an algebra problem now if you held me at gunpoint.

I am not a business person or in any field that requires math 😅

12

u/seven-blue 9h ago

I just assume, in most cases, they are the one financing the brand. I think, Hailey was the main funder of Rhode initially (although the public info is very limited). So, it is like you building a company with your money and hiring actual professionals who know how to run the company while you hold the equity and control. In the past, celebrities would just sign deals with big companies to advertise their products. Now it pays more to build your own.

38

u/OneTwoKiwi very parasocial for Ms. Rachel 9h ago

Were any of us under the impression that celebs “built” their brands/products? I would never expect Hailey to know any of the nitty gritty of the business.  Her (or perhaps her team’s) fault for agreeing to this interview and being ill-prepared. 

The only exception I can think of is Jessica Alba. I feel like she actually worked the C-suite of her company. 

6

u/SlipperyWinds 7h ago

Genuinely, what else would you expect from a celebrity brand?

-5

u/brianlefebvrejr Fauxmarxist 7h ago

You’re correct. I don’t even see this as being insulting towards Hailey.

If you go back and look at interviews with Bezos early, he’d said the same thing about Amazon. Even Ashton out her didn’t think he’d make billions of Anthropic.

It’s a fair question to ask and Hailey had the appropriate answer. “You need to have this delusional optimism”

Nobody dreams their company sells for a million dollars (not a celebrity anyway). You have to think big.

“You know what’s cool, a billion dollars”

-7

u/alittlebitblue39 6h ago

Fascinating. Thank you for your work.

-24

u/xNyxx 7h ago

Respectfully, why does it matter that she can't? I am not a Hailey Beiber Stan one way or the other. But why are we tearing her down for what she is struggling with? She used what advantages she had to help bring the brand success (e.g. influence, beauty, reach, etc.) and it worked.

3

u/bluegreenie99 1h ago

Bc she's was nothing more than a marketing mascot in her own brand

915

u/Different_Prior_517 9h ago • This Bravo

This was a really good interview and she was wholly underprepared. When questioned about the more business-oriented aspects of her company she was quite lost and didn’t answer well.

It ended up showing how bad podcasters and internet “journalists” have become because Hailey’s obviously never been outright asked some of these things before. She’s done a lot of puff piece interviews that skirt everything about Rhode, their practices and her involvement, but she’d clearly never been confronted with questions you’d expect a founder/brand owner to be able to answer easily.

313

u/ConstantKooky3329 9h ago

This is a fail on the part of her and Rhode's comms team. My former flatmate worked in corporate comms- she always prepared a list of questions and rehearsed responses with execs attending these events. Since Hailey was at an investor's event and being interviewed by Andrew Ross Sorkin, her team should have prepped her accordingly.

144

u/Attorneyatlau 8h ago

It’s laughable to think how unprepared she was. Even lower level directors prepare more for interviews with far less at stake.

70

u/DogsDucks 7h ago

I am a writer and was in charge of the writing dept. for a multibillion dollar corporation, and one of the many things I did was . . . This.

For interviews, for long speeches at corporate conventions, for promotional shoots. I’ve also done a lot of scripts for various celebrity endorsements.

Something I’ve noticed that happens with basically every super rich person who wants power and spotlight, is that they don’t know how much they don’t know when it comes to like, just how people see them.

And they always get really fixated on some niche aspect of the brand, but it’s usually not the part that people are gonna care about most.

Sometimes I have been given drafts of what they want to say initially and those drafts are always the most myopic, bloviated things ever, like:

“Yes of course, so the other day I was on my way to the Ferrari dealership, well my assistant was, and I thought about how stupid traffic is, so I just took out my lipgloss and it jiggled too much in the exhaust so then the anti-jiggle-tray was born in between my Ferrari kissing event and my gold bar fort building, scorpion-venom-wasting party . . . “

And the ones who do a good job are the nice ones who just let people like me redline and slash and burn their drafts, laugh and are like “cool!” but then the others that go back and forth a thousand times and keep trying to change the changes? Those ones are the least good at understanding and marketing their ware, I get the impression that this HB likes to give a lot of feedback but no substance.

Fun fact: most professional athletes I’ve worked with on endorsements, and on their own brands, have been lovely. Easy going and smart.

12

u/helame 2h ago

Athletes have had to work really hard to be where they are at by the time they’re working with you! Your job sounds cool

71

u/dont_be_all_uncool__ 8h ago

She likely can't even articulate what a profit & loss statement is.

620

u/-this_bitch- we don't even know if selling feet pics is her final form 9h ago edited 9h ago • Bravo

I’m over the stans crying “he was so mean!” Give me a break. These nepo baby “founders” love to cosplay being girl bosses and copy outfits of icons in hopes that it makes them iconic too and then can’t answer simple valuation questions. She should feel embarassed.

Do you know the real answer for why selling for one billion is important to someone like Hailey Bieber? Status. Literally that’s it. So she can call herself a billionaire and be on a magazine cover. It’s fucking soulless.

114

u/SandSpecialist2523 9h ago

They say money don't grow on trees, but some people get to be under a waterfall of money for no particular reason.

171

u/disappointingnews 9h ago • Popcorn

“optimistical delusion” really just says it all (someone make that their flair)

14

u/katieb1300 optimistical delusion 8h ago

I am once again asking the moderators to make this a flair. (Pweeze.)

357

u/tabxssum 9h ago edited 7h ago

She was probably expecting “easy” questions like she gets with podcasters…

people are so used to alex cooper’s version of journalism that they’ve forgotten what actual journalism looks like - I mean what do you expect from a girl who dropped out of HOME school. He asked why she thought Rhode was valued for $1B and she couldn’t even answer that…

Edit - she’s too busy cosplaying Carol Bassette Kennedy yet doesn’t have an inch of Carol’s intelligence

109

u/ClumsyZebra80 8h ago

How do you drop out of home school? You just stop showing up to the kitchen table?

48

u/smorio_sem shiv roy apologist 8h ago

But they shouldn’t expect that from the NYT and Andrew Ross Sorkin. That’s just irresponsible

-3

u/bomilk19 7h ago

But didn’t the company sell for a billion?

58

u/thebetterbad 8h ago

I prefer interviews with interesting people.

141

u/Beepboop5698 locked, loaded, and kind of cunty 9h ago

she was one of three founders for rhode. i wouldn't be surprised if they were the ones making the actual business decisions, while she was just the face who could sell it. unfortunately, she should've brought one of the other founders with her to answer the business questions, and then they could've thrown her more softball questions about the vision and the vibes.

13

u/smorio_sem shiv roy apologist 8h ago

Well she clearly wasn’t, this video made that clear. And her team also didn’t prep her which was irresponsible

4

u/triggereddumbass 4h ago

tbf, her other cofounder (lauren ratner) is also someone who answers questions similarly to how hailey does. i think they’re used to the podcast way of questions and answers, so it’s quite jarring to actually be questioned about the inner workings of actually running a company and everything associated with it

-1

u/athsrva 8h ago

i mean definitely what it was i think. but even if she didnt do anything business wise, i dont think anyone would argue she didnt contribute a lot to growth

45

u/mydreamstheyplagueme 6h ago

Couldn't make it past, "optimistical"

40

u/SlimReaper85 6h ago

Optimistic not Optimystical….

23

u/HipsterSlimeMold 6h ago

whyyyy would she do this interview 🥹

19

u/tangerime 9h ago

teams orchestrated an entire persona for HB, including stylist pap walks and copy and pasted glossier’s entire brand and lineup. scooter orchestrated the sale. we should all be so lucky.

8

u/One_Page_4633 7h ago

So basically a (well presenting) idiot with money and a stellar team 👌

5

u/GlassPomoerium controversies: girl 9h ago

She just rolled up to the Dealbook summit thinking wearing CBK’s jacket would be enough to be taken seriously lol. Her team did her a real disservice by not prepping her better.

(from the RealReal subreddit)

16

u/SandSpecialist2523 9h ago

So... is she free or she has to work for whoever bought her company?

14

u/q_eyeroll 8h ago

Elf cosmetics owns it

74

u/aybsavestheworld Sylvia Plath did not stick her head in an oven for this 9h ago

Andrew woke up that day yelling “CHAOS”

I love seeing REAL journalists. It’s always refreshing to see people doing something they’re good at, showing how they have mastered their profession. For journalism, not only we lack true journalists who are not afraid to ask THE questions, but we are also bombarded with influencer interviewers who are only about the money, have no desire to get better at their job and no ability to create a story through an interview.

185

u/ClumsyZebra80 8h ago • Bravo

He wasn’t yelling chaos. He was a reporter doing his job. Nothing chaotic about it. That word has lost all meaning.

44

u/midwestwhackadoo 6h ago

Completely agree. Too many people are giving her a free pass because of all the stuff with her personal life or because she's a woman. Nothing he asked was unfair. If she wants to be the founder and the face of this company, she can learn how to answer these basic ass questions. It's her and her team's fault for not preparing better. People are way too easy on millionaires.

8

u/23notsavage 2h ago

more and more hailey bieber is trying to cosplay as some smart and cunning businesswoman - it’s embarrassing that she was the one showing up to a BUSINESS summit pretending she knew anything at all about business. it is not cute, it is embarrassing and i guarantee everyone in the audience were rolling their eyes listening to her.

i’m exhausted listening to all the hype around this brand and can’t wait for it to it’s inevitable fade into the background as the next thing comes up

4

u/No-Huckleberry-7633 1h ago

She had a hand in product development and branding, which are crucial parts of the business. A founder doesn't have to be business savvy, they just need money and traction, which she had thanks to who she is.

She could have been more prepared, but we all know that neither Haley or Selena or Ariana or Gaga (the list goes on) are actually business-oriented people. Their real talent is in influence, modelling, singing... They just invested their money and fame into an idea/a product and their team does the heavy lifting. Let's not pretend we're discovering a shocking truth here, or that there's actually anything wrong with that. Rhode is a great brand, I'm a bit of a skincare addict and the glazing milk is one of my favourite products of all time (and at 46 I'm not even in the target audience, I think).

15

u/Baeomyces 6h ago

Okay but isn’t this the same reporter who didn’t push back at all when Elon said he doesn’t have extreme views ?

28

u/Aznable-Char 4h ago edited 2h ago

If Andrew was trying to confront and point out the hypocrisy in everything his guests said, then nobody would want to be on his show. In that spirit, I think he does a pretty good of job of allowing these people to make a fool of themselves uninterrupted and letting the audience throw the stones.

3

u/Ecstatic-Hunt7332 9h ago

Dealbook, the Page Six for Wall Street.

1

u/MissLychee10120 16m ago edited 12m ago

Optimistical!

But honestly sounds like this journalist just can’t believe she was able to build such a valuable company. Women, particularly beautiful women, are often underestimated. And the power of young female consumers too!

-12

u/thegreatabysss 5h ago

This guy was tougher on Hailey Bieber than he was to Elon Musk. Tells you everything.

14

u/Aznable-Char 4h ago

I think he’s equally tough with all of his guests. It’s just a bit unusual for the founder of a billion dollar brand to know nothing about the financials of their own business.

-5

u/SlimReaper85 6h ago

Is a Billion not a big deal anymore?

7

u/_ryuujin_ 5h ago

apparently we must of open the gates to the unicorn universe. seems like every company is worth a bill

-73

u/SwimmingPathology 9h ago

This guy fucking sucks