r/FinalFantasy • u/UnculturedGames • 1h ago
Resonance Finished FF Resonance and it restored my faith in Final Fantasy (review from a 40-year-old hardcore FF nerd)
(Tried my best to avoid spoilers.)
First, FF Resonance was my most anticipated video game since FF12. I have enjoyed FF15 and Remake to some extent (Rebirth and FF16 were very mixed bags for me) but I have also been very frustrated with the direction of the franchise. Since announcement, Resonance seemed like a perfect doctor's precription to 20 years of frustration, and oh boy did it deliver!
For context, I haven't played Brave Exvius at all, but I've played through all mainline games aside from 13 and 14, a few of them up to 12+ times, I've finished games like FF Adventure on the GameBoy, FF Dimensions on mobile and most of Final Fantasy XI, so I would say I'm a pretty diehard FF guy. My favorite game is OG 7, but I also have a soft spot for many of the offbeat games like FF2, FF8 and FF12.
I've not enjoyed the direction of the franchise, but also not the completely unsustainable remake to new game ratio at Square Enix. (I'm aware that Resonance is a remake too, but it was rebuilt so thoroughly that it doesn't apply.) Seriously, I've bought FF6 like four times in my life already, and it shouldn't be too much to ask to just get more new original titles instead of these endless waves of remakes. The remake focus feels like Lego, which has become a millennial nostalgia machine that focuses on selling 1980s Star Wars memorabilia to people like me, forgetting its core purpose.
***
Anyway, FF Resonance was a 10/10 game for me.
THE POSITIVES:
* All in all, it was the most enjoyable FF game since at least FF12 for me, possibly the PS1 era.
* Fan service, love letter treatment. FF history is all there but it never feels artificial. Even the Visions, which I had huge doubts on, worked pretty well mechanically, lore-wise and aesthetically.
* The world map feeling is back! The thing I've been missing the most came back with a bang. The feeling of exploring, fighting random battles, riding on a chocobo, flying on an airship, discovering things on my own. After Chadley's cleaning to-do checklist in Rebirth and the MENU-BASED traversal blasphemy of FF16, this was just perfection.
* The battle system, customization and progression systems are very solid and fun. I'm probably a weird person in the sense that combat is not my #1 thing in an FF game, but it was mostly fun and hit the sweet spot in complexity without ever feeling overwhelming.
* The turn-based battle system healed my brain. I don't need to stay ultra alert every second, do frame perfect parrying and reactions, stay aware of projectiles and a 360 environment, spend huge amounts of time studying boss attack patterns, et cetera. Even in the toughest endgame bosses, my brain was resting and I frickin' loved it.
* The game has a huge amount of tiny quality of life features and for the most part, it always respects my time.
* The graphics are great, and the OST features some absolute standout tracks.
* Dialogue is well written and while the characters start off dull, they grow on you during the game.
* Great, compact amount of side content that feels curated and handcrafted compared to certain other games that give you 70 identical intel towers to light up and 249 VR battle challenges to complete in 12 different difficulty modes.
* I don't usually care about Platinum, but this time getting it was fun and accessible. The key thing is that I could achieve platinum by playing a JRPG. Many other FF games these days force me to complete and master segments and mini-games where the genre of the game changes entirely into some arcade party game. The recipe in Resonance was perfect: there's no reason why some of the most tedious or non-JRPG stuff can't just be kept out of the trophy systems.
THE NEGATIVES:
* The story is not that great, it feels a tad un-ambitious and cartoony compared to the mainline games. It definitely gets better towards the end, and it's not actively bad at all, but there is an element that makes it feel a bit, I don't know, juvenile, in your face, patronizing?
* Boss battles got incredibly repetitive by chapter 5. Massively tanky HP sponges with ridiculous HP and defense, maybe a gimmick or two and that's it. And it got much, much worse at endgame and while I mostly played on normal with some stretches on expert, I switched to casual for some endgame bosses because I simply didn't have the time to spend an hour or more on a single battle. This was the one element in the game that did not respect my time.
* Part of the problem was the stagger mechanic. I'm generally not a fan of games this mechanic, because whenever there is a stagger mechanic, it instantly and automatically becomes 100% of the battle system and the only meaningful battle mechanic in the entire game. Suddenly stagger becomes the only way to solve each boss battle in the game. Stagger also makes the battles feel even longer than they actually are, because during the staggering phase you're dealing very unsatisfying low damage for long periods of time. The system in Resonance could've used a bit more variance especially at endgame.
* Another thing I didn't like about the battles is how they handled different boss stages. I wasted a ridiculous amount of double bonus rounds and resonance attacks because the bosses went full immune during a phase shift just that they can give me a couple of lines of dialogue. It felt almost exactly like OG FF1 on NES where you miss your attack entirely if the enemy you targeted happened to die before your turn. That's NOT necessarily the retro feeling I'm looking for here. 😅
* While the Visions fit the game surprisingly well, as mentioned, I don't generally like the fact they had to milk Cloud & co to sell a game like this. I would've appreciated a game that dares to stand proudly on its own too legs.
* The OST is not all great and it features some tracks that are below FF standard in my opinion.
* While there are great QoL features, there are also some small annoyingly missing ones. Item sorting, swappable or saveable character builds, auto-equip come to mind, and some minor things like not being able to use a tent in the chamber of arms for some weird reason. The game is so polished that it's just surprising that some of this obvious stuff is missing. I don't personally care about a bestiary but my kid is already furious that the game doesn't have one. He loves browsing the pixel remaster bestiaries. Not including one is an incredibly weird decision for sure.
But yeah, I'm giving it a 10/10, and if there's no sequel (BE season 2 or a new standalone game) and if this doesn't become a long spin-off series that exists alongside the mainline games, I will be very disappointed and I will send huge amounts of angry emails to a Square Enix corporate email address that no one is reading. With a spin-off series like this, I wouldn't have to place all of my hopes and expectations on the mainline games only. It's a win-win-win scenario that Square Enix can't sleep on.
I'm almost still a bit blown away that this game even exists. I had almost lost hope and assumed that Square Enix simply does not care about catering to more old-school turn-based FF fans anymore. That they don't see us as a market worth pursuing, except by releasing a new FF1-FF9 remake wave every ten years or so. I have no idea how Resonance is doing financially, but the cultural impact seems overwhelmingly positive. I fully understand that Square Enix needs to seek out younger players too, which means various action/mobile/etc. approaches, but put together, I've spent probably 10 times more money on Final Fantasy in the last 5 or 6 years than I did before I was 35. I hope the positive reception of Resonance makes Square Enix see people like me again and realize that keeping us engaged and connected with the franchise is important too. And a pro tip: a spin-off series like this would be a pretty good way to achieve it.