r/Firearms • u/TC0ch • 1h ago
Question Best deer caliber for reliable expansion, exit wounds, and blood trails? Considering 6.5 Creedmoor
I’m buying a new bolt-action deer rifle and leaning toward 6.5 Creedmoor, but one of my biggest priorities is having a reliable blood trail if a deer doesn’t drop immediately.
I hunt whitetails in South Georgia, generally around 70–150 yards, occasionally out to 200. Most deer are roughly 100–150 pounds, and I’m often hunting thick woods where tracking without blood can be extremely difficult.
I’m trying to understand how much blood-trail performance comes from caliber versus the specific bullet.
I’d like to hear firsthand experiences with 6.5 Creedmoor compared with .243, 7mm-08, .270, and .308.
Specifically:
Which caliber and factory ammunition are you using?
Are you consistently getting exit wounds?
How have your blood trails been, especially in thick woods?
Have you noticed major differences between bonded, copper, and traditional cup-and-core bullets?
At what distances have you seen reliable expansion and penetration?
I’m looking for a relatively low-recoil hunting rifle that produces quick, humane kills and dependable recoveries, not necessarily the biggest cartridge available.
I’d especially appreciate experiences from hunters who’ve taken multiple whitetails with different cartridges and can compare actual results.